Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be really upset that DH complains we are overspending on my birthday

60 replies

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:09

Brief background : DH earns more than me. My family business went into voluntary liquidation 2 years ago and I am now self employed. Covid and my 14yo sons poor MH (he hasn't been able to be left alone sometimes) have meant that my business hasn't been as profitable as I hoped but it is now improving.

DH has always encouraged me in my work.

DH is not DS' dad.

We are comfortably off. I am very conscious that I'm not bringing in as much money as I should and I try not to spend more than necessary. Just for context, and not for a pity party as examples I cut my own hair, keep social spending to a minimum, no new clothes and absolutely no unnecessary spending on myself.

DH is a kind, caring, generous man usually.

Today is my birthday. He had insisted that we go out with some friends for dinner. He knew I wasn't too bothered but kept mentioning it so I asked a friend, her DH and DD and we are going out for some Tapas.

My friends are going away for a catch up overnight this weekend. When they invited me I declined because I didn't want to spend the money and also my sons MH is very tricky atm so it's hard it's hard to leave him. When DH found this out he arranged for me to join my friends and paid for my share of hotel. He also organised for my mum to have my son as he will be working. I was really pleased but already felt guilty.

Fast forward to my birthday today and he asks me if my friend's DH paid for everyone's food when we went out for my friends birthday. I said that he did and that I would put the meal on my credit card.

He snapped at me that "we are spending money like water". I feel really upset, he acknowledges that it was a thoughtless thing to say but he's cross with me as he feels I'm totally overacting and I've blown things out of proportion.

I am very tearful. I feel guilty and frustrated. I work outside and he was going to join me as he's off work today but I just want to be alone because I can't seem to pull myself together. He's now angry at my overreaction.

Am I being unreasonable to be so upset? And if I am how am I supposed to be 'less upset' and not 'overreact'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
billy1966 · 04/09/2021 15:53

@InthearmyN0W21

Went to birthday meal recently We all put in £5 & one person bought the presents & cake Then we all paid a little more, to pay for the birthday persons meal
This would be the norm for me too.
frazzledasarock · 04/09/2021 13:02

The relationship dynamics are seriously off here.

You feel you need to save and go without despite your H having a good job and your household being comfortably off.

So oyu feel as you have a child from a previous relationship that you need to be grateful and not spend any of your ‘husbands’ money for either yourself or your son.

Do you ever spend money, time resources on things of benefit to your husband?

From reading your post it sounds like your H enjoys playing lord bountiful then gets angry if you try and take control of your expenditure and work a way of paying for luxuries without his input.
Are you forever grovelling and thanking him for ‘his money’?

InthearmyN0W21 · 04/09/2021 12:38

If you are earning you should be able to spend on what you want, without getting into debt

Yes, you should spend time with your friends

Yes, you should enjoy your birthday

Do you pay into a pension ?

Do you have savings ?

Personally, I don't spend money on some things, so that I can spend on things that I prefer, that is good practice

Perhaps, you need to sit down & work out an entertainment/ hobby/holiday/birthday budget

InthearmyN0W21 · 04/09/2021 12:32

Went to birthday meal recently
We all put in £5 & one person bought the presents & cake
Then we all paid a little more, to pay for the birthday persons meal

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 04/09/2021 07:52

@CharlotteRose90

In my group of friends the birthday boy or girl doesn’t pay for their meal at all and certainly doesn’t pay for everyone’s. That’s a completely weird thing to do and I’m not surprised he’s pissed ff . I would be.
It's not completely weird. Some people pay when they are inviting others to celebrate.
OverTheRubicon · 03/09/2021 21:13

How long have you been together? It stood out to me that for you to go away, he had to organise for your 14 year old to stay with your mum. Is that because they're really not close, or it's a relatively new marriage?

If it's been a long time and they're still not able to be in the same place overnight, I'd wonder a bit about dynamics - and whether your DS's mental health issues are partly caused by this distance, or whether they are causing a distance. I say this with sympathy for both you and DS, I also have a child with physical and mental issues and that's part of the reason I'm planning to stay single, because even as a parent it can be so hard to cope with it all, and even strong relationships can buckle under the strain. If it's these cases, open discussion or family counselling can really help, or if he really is a dick then you need to get out for your child's sake.

Or is it a relatively new relationship? Because if so, and without wanting to make you feel any more guilty, I'd also be tetchy and stressed about money if I'd been a reluctant sole earner for over 2 years, supporting a non working partner and their teenage child.

Back to earlier though, what are you doing about your financial situation now? Is your teenager going back to school and can your mum help, or his father? Is your business really going to turn around? Can you claim benefits as a carer or extra support for your DS? Because it sounds like you really need to make more.money, for your own mental health and to either take some stress of your DH if he's decent, or be able to get out if he's not.

Auroreforet · 03/09/2021 20:22

@freckles20 people treat you like you treat yourself.
If the situation was reversed would you mind your dh having nice things occasionally?
Be kinder to yourself, get your hair done at a salon, buy yourself clothes and don't be afraid to use some of your dh money. You're a family.

And stop with the guilty martyr stuff, my dsis does this it's really irritating!

CharlotteRose90 · 03/09/2021 20:18

In my group of friends the birthday boy or girl doesn’t pay for their meal at all and certainly doesn’t pay for everyone’s. That’s a completely weird thing to do and I’m not surprised he’s pissed ff . I would be.

VioletVesper · 03/09/2021 20:13

Maybe I’m reading it wrongly but it sounds like your friends were already going to the hotel/meal and he paid for you to join them as a birthday treat. If that’s what happened, I don’t think it’s unreasonable that he would then be frustrated if he found he was then going to expected to foot everyone’s meal bill, although I agree he could have phrased it better.

GreenTeaPingPong · 03/09/2021 19:51

When they invited me I declined because I didn't want to spend the money and also my sons MH is very tricky atm so it's hard it's hard to leave him. When DH found this out he arranged for me to join my friends and paid for my share of hotel. He also organised for my mum to have my son as he will be working. I was really pleased but already felt guilty.

It sounds like he did a really lovely thing, not just the paying, but the arranging. I get the impression that it's you that has the issues about money. You feel constantly guilty about any spending, so much so that you cut your own hair. He made just one fairly innocuous comment and your reaction has been quite out of proportion. I think you need to examine where your own issues have come from. And then have an honest talk with your DH about money. It sounds like you're both stressed (you about your son), so you need to be on the same team here. Good luck.

Josette77 · 03/09/2021 19:47

It's not normal to pay for everyone in my friends. He probably wasn't expecting to either.

NailsNeedDoing · 03/09/2021 19:44

You haven’t said how you actually reacted other than saying how you felt, so it’s impossible to say whether you over reacted.

It sounds like he only had a momentary snap where he stated the truth in a more harsh tone of voice than he should have done. You may well have overreacted, even if you’re justified in feeling a bit sad about it.

IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 03/09/2021 19:39

@Thatsplentyjack

If this is a one off, maybe he wasn't expecting to have to pay for everyone, just thought it would be nice for everyone to go out together when he arranged it and now feels he has to pay because your friends dh did for her birthday and he's panicking. Are you sure there's no financial worries? How much do you know or rake to do with the finances?
This is what I thought. He asked if the friend paid last time and then OP offered to put it on the credit card but he was trying to find out because he was hoping not to be expected to pay for that.
FlumpsAreShit · 03/09/2021 19:38

Who manages the finances? Are you very involved with them or not?

I occasionally snap at DH about spending (and he earns 3x my salary) because it isn't him who has to balance the budget and my stress manifests in snapping at him. Are you sure you're as comfortable as you think if you're putting things on credit?

HeartvsBrain · 03/09/2021 19:18

@MyBadHabitsLeadToYou

There’s a lot of presumption and projection on this thread.
This.
MyBadHabitsLeadToYou · 03/09/2021 14:00

There’s a lot of presumption and projection on this thread.

rolyisntittimefor · 03/09/2021 13:57

He is not a kind and generous man if you are comfortably off and you find yourself cutting your own hair over the bathroom sink tbh.....

The emotions you feel around guilt etc are very sad to see. "I should be bringing in more" - why? You're married and things will ebb and flow and your circumstances have made you have a little dip. Why is he the only one that can decide when it's ok to be frivolous (hotel etc) but then ensure you don't even have fun by making horrible comments! X

LegendaryReady · 03/09/2021 13:50

I'd be shocked to learn I was expected to pay for the whole group at my partner's birthday meal too. I know some MNetters think it's normal but it's unheard of in my world.

He's worried, it was a bit of a shock, something slipped out that he didn't mean in the context you've taken it, he's apologised and wants to spend the day with you. Move on and have a good day.

Thatsplentyjack · 03/09/2021 13:46

And if you not buying things or getting your hair done is from your own guilt about not working like you say, then I think maybe you just both over reacted on this occasion.

Thatsplentyjack · 03/09/2021 13:44

If this is a one off, maybe he wasn't expecting to have to pay for everyone, just thought it would be nice for everyone to go out together when he arranged it and now feels he has to pay because your friends dh did for her birthday and he's panicking. Are you sure there's no financial worries? How much do you know or rake to do with the finances?

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 03/09/2021 13:41

He didn't express himself very well but he may be stressed about money if his covering everything including a child that is not his.

You say you don't get your hair cut, new clothes etc. Does your DH? What about DS?

cheeseisnice · 03/09/2021 13:31

I couldn't get upset about this. Everyone snaps sometimes, and he said 'WE are spending money like water' not 'YOU'. There's no way this would ruin my birthday, I'd just put him straight and move on. Crying all day or considering LTB is a MASSIVE over reaction.

Holweighthelp · 03/09/2021 13:31

YABU.

Your taking your own person self created guilt and somehow blaming your husband. It’s entirely a you problem that you feel guilty. You have not insinuated that your DH has an issue usually. He has been kind and thoughtful with your birthday.

He made a comment that he probably felt - realising spending is a bit OTT at the moment. Maybe insensitive but doesn’t need your reaction which is entirely down to your own personal insecurities and guilt.

billy1966 · 03/09/2021 13:11

@teaorwine

I can’t imagine not noticing that my dw is not earning very much- cutting her own hair and buying all the bits for her son and that I wouldn’t say, do you need some money? So there might be something on your part about feeling solely responsible for yourself and your son, but why hasn’t he noticed and said “we’re in this together. “ I dont think he’s as kind as you think and agree with the poster about your gut trying to tell you and that’s why you’re so upset. Hugs on your birthday
He is obviously financially aware. There is no way that he isn't aware that his wife spends NOTHING on herself or HER child.

The ONE time he does something, that she NEVER asked for, he spoils it.

He's an arse.

teaorwine · 03/09/2021 13:03

I can’t imagine not noticing that my dw is not earning very much- cutting her own hair and buying all the bits for her son and that I wouldn’t say, do you need some money?
So there might be something on your part about feeling solely responsible for yourself and your son, but why hasn’t he noticed and said “we’re in this together. “
I dont think he’s as kind as you think and agree with the poster about your gut trying to tell you and that’s why you’re so upset. Hugs on your birthday