Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are expensive clothes worth it?

115 replies

strawberrydonuts · 03/09/2021 06:18

On the back of another thread, I've been browsing some online clothes stores.

I tend to like places like FatFace, Weird Fish, Sea Salt, Boden occasionally... just decent quality, casual stuff. I usually buy stuff in the sale but I might splurge £40-50 for a really good quality top or shirt which will last me years. I have some clothes from these places that have lasted me 10 years.

But looking at some of the online stores people suggested on another thread, I am seeing cotton tops/ shirts costing £100+ that look no different in quality to what you can get at FatFace for half the price.

Things like:
www.toa.st/collections/womens-tops-tees/products/seed-check-boxy-shirt-french-blue

AIBU to ask what's the difference? Are they really worth it? If you would pay £100+ for a casual top/ shirt, why? (Not in a judgemental way... I'm just genuinely wondering if I'm missing something!)

It can't be just about quality because the clothes I buy are good quality. Is it design/ fit? Is it about the materials and where they are sourced?

OP posts:
Divebar2021 · 03/09/2021 10:12

I don’t know why this debate has become about cheap versus designer. There’s a lot of ranges in-between those two. This is really about quality & durability and pleasure I guess. Overall I think there’s a benefit in spending more - better weight fabrics, better cuts / fit and in some cases better ethical standards. I think these are the clothes that have longevity in your wardrobe. I have fast fashion items and without exception they don’t last as well. My linen shirt from H&M is much more lightweight than a Jaeger one I bought on eBay. My Monki blazer is not as well made as my Arket blazer or the Daks one I bought from a charity shop. The clothes from Toast will have ethically sourced fabric and will not be manufactured in sweat shops. It doesn’t mean that’s true for all higher end brands.

We have a problem with fast fashion, disposable items that don’t even last a year before they end up in landfill and horrific conditions for the people who make them and we don’t even care about it. Chains on Primark et al are built on the premise that you will get bored of an item and be onto the next trend. They turn over huge numbers so even if you have an individual item that lasts well you’ve bought into the whole business model. We have to change how we view fashion and our wardrobes - it’s a big problem. I think the answer is to consume less overall, buy better quality & second hand.

HeronLanyon · 03/09/2021 10:06

I also make sure wardrobe is not crushed/use clothes covers for some things including just shoulder covers for some jackets and renew my hanging moths things on a schedule rather than when I see a moth. It may be the most organised aspect of my domestic set up now I think about it !

user1471554720 · 03/09/2021 10:03

frumpety

Would there be a way of washing and drying to make clothes last a bit longer and would fit in with busy lifestyles of today?

I wash all at 40c with Persil and fabric conditioner ot dettol machine. I either line dry or dry on a clothes rack. Jumpers are done on a delicate wash, bras are washed by hand. I find the m&s jumpers bobble after a winter of wear, even though I don't overwash. It is not too bas as they cost 20 but I don't like shopping.

I like cotton tops for summer. A lot of the 'good quality' brands have a heavier material which can be sweaty. For tops I get debenhans, m&s and pay 15 to 25. These last 2 or 3 summers. I mix these with supermarket tops for wfh which only last 2 summers.

frumpety · 03/09/2021 09:52

A lot depends on how you wash and dry clothes.

VoyageInTheDark · 03/09/2021 09:49

@DappledThings

All the shops you mention are expensive to me. I have plenty of items from Primark and supermarkets that have lasted 10 years+ as well.
Same!
LindaEllen · 03/09/2021 09:48

I honestly don't know what people do to their Primark clothes to make them fall apart so quickly. If you look after clothes, they will usually last. I've got things from Primark now that I've been wearing for 12 years!!

I think with designer clothes, you're paying for the brand mostly. You can get better quality high street brands (such as Next etc) without having to go as cheap as Primark or anywhere near as expensive as designer.

BabyLeaf · 03/09/2021 09:41

I don’t believe they are for a second.

I have clothes from primark, Tesco, new look etc. that have lasted for literally a decade or more, worn frequently, washed often, and look as good as new. Some of the best fitting and nicest quality items I own cost less than £15. It’s all emperor’s new clothes imo until you get into stuff like really, really high end luxury shoes and bags.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 03/09/2021 09:33

I actively dislike anything that has focussed on their "brand" - signs of this are websites with lots of "storytelling",a section called "our story", or anything about lifestyle and values.

I don't need my clothing to have a lifestyle or values, I've got my own.

I do think there are higher quality items, ime supermarkets especially tend to have thinner fabric, more man made fibres etc.

But not exclusively. DS has had a few great pairs of jeans from supermarkets that were lovely and lasted better than boden cords which were crap, however I had some lovely leggings for DD from boden which were great

I dont assume something from a particular shop will be good or worse quality - I look at the item, feel how thick the fabric is, see how tight the weave looks, check what it's made of on the washing label, and look at the cut (eg bias?) to consider how it might stretch or shrink on washing.

Generally speaking I'm going to expect more from a thick, more tightly woven pure cotton jersey teeshirt, than a thinner, looser weave teeshirt in a polyester or viscose. The latter is probably going to stretch on wearing then shrink on washing and drying, so the shape is going to go.

mynameiscalypso · 03/09/2021 09:16

There are a couple of threads in S&B at the moment about brands which you would imagine to be ethical - Boden being a prime example - but actually score very low in terms of what they actually do. Cheap brands are not necessarily less ethical / sustainable

NothingEverChangesButTheShoes · 03/09/2021 09:13

I am a stupid size. I will buy what fits. I find sometimes cheaper or teens (jeans) brands come up better. I am also gothish in my style. I only wear black or band tees. They're bloody expensive, but last forever.
I used to buy a lot from Boden for DD, but her winter coat fell apart after 3 months of school. I did get a refund, but I didn't expect it. I replaced it with a coat from Matalan which was just as warm inside and DD loved the style. It was 75% cheaper.

PurpleOkapi · 03/09/2021 09:09

It depends on a lot of things, many of which are unknowable at the time of purchase. Just because something is expensive doesn't mean it's well-constructed or of higher-quality fabric. If a cheaper item is poorly constructed, that may just mean that you'll have to fix a seam or reattach a button. Whether a higher price is worth it depends on how easily you can do those things. Fashions change, jobs change, and sizes change. It's true that a high-quality (and correspondingly expensive) suit can last years even with weekly wear. But if you change jobs or gain/lose weight in that time, the fact that it has several years of life left in it won't do you much good as it hangs in the back of your closet.

I would consider paying that sort of money for an item I truly loved, as a rare splurge. But I wouldn't pretend it was a good investment, or "worth it" by any quantifiable measure. It would be worth it to me if wearing it made me happy enough to justify the price, and that would be the end of the analysis.

I totally agree with @GrandmasCat about getting a color consultation. You'll look better in cheap clothes suited to your figure and coloring than you will in expensive clothes that are more flattering on someone with different coloring or proportions. This is true even if they're the right size. Two garments can have identical measurements but flatter completely different figures because of design details.

girlmom21 · 03/09/2021 09:09

The clothes you're talking about are expensive to most people. Are they worth it?
Is the quality much better than say Matalan or New Look?

TableNiner · 03/09/2021 09:04

For me it's not so much does a garment seem expensive as the fact we've slightly lost sight of the true cost of clothing.

The supermarkets/Primark/Boohoo etc make a £40-50 top seem very dear but that's because the former is not producing clothes in an ethical and realistic way.

The shops that get me are those where they charge more but actually have no better ethical practices so then you are just paying for the brand name.

I appreciate not everyone has a budget to spend £50 on a t-shirt, although I also think we are now conditioned to buy lots of cheap clothes which we then treat as disposable. Some people might find they could actually spend £50 on a t-shirt if they changed their shopping habits. (three tops a year instead of thirty) But this wouldn't be as exciting.

I also appreciate what pps said about lifestyle, weight change etc. But more expensive garments tend to resell well so at least you can put it back into a clothing cycle for someone else to get wear out of. For fast fashion items people feel they might as well just go and buy new.

I'm glad there is a movement towards ethical fashion and more mindful consumerism as buying lots of cheap clothes - way more than we actually need and often via being manipulated by influencers and the like - is destroying the planet.

Finally I think it's all relative in that if you have a salary of £150k a £100 t-shirt is like a £20 t-shirt if you have a salary of £30k.

HeronLanyon · 03/09/2021 09:03

I’ve bought a few more expensive t- shirts and they’ve been great. There’s one from I think Chanel - was on sale - people have asked me where it’s from. The quality of the cloth is different. No branding.

TTCAbroad · 03/09/2021 09:01

For some things there is absolutely a difference, other items are just ridiculous. A t-shirt from Celine costs £300 because it says Celine on it; not because it is higher quality than Uniqlo.

A button-down shirt might be worth paying £200 for if it has interesting or unique tailoring. You can probably count on the fact that it is constructed out of quality materials.

I find the biggest difference is in the tailoring of more ‘complex’ items - trousers, coats, blazers/suits and dresses. For example I have a wool dress from Alexander McQueen and the tailoring is stunning and it looks stunning on. The bodice is beautifully made: boning, lining, interlining and padding. It’s made of silk and wool and has held up beautifully - I expect to have it for many years to come and to (hopefully) pass it on someday. Needless to say I don’t feel the same about some of my dresses from Banana Rebublic.

GrandmasCat · 03/09/2021 08:55

I have come to find out that what works cheaper is to pay for a colour and style consultation. With the right clothes for your body and the right colours you will look wonderful even if you are in Primark clothes.

Personally, I would throw the money into getting a nicely cut coat and good quality shoes than in expensive knitted stuff or t-shirts, which last as much as a middle range brand.

Dogmum40 · 03/09/2021 08:54

I always used to buy designer but as I’ve got older I’m more aware of the planet and ethics as sadly just because they charge more doesn’t mean the items are sustainable, ethical sourced or better quality!

I once bought a £300 wool jumper and it be bobbled in the wash after just the second wash, I followed the care label as it was wool and even ended up hand washing but it did just get worse, whereas I have other wool and cashmere from mid priced retailers that have been regularly washed and I’ve had for a few years now

I no longer buy expensive branded items but I do still buy expensive shoes/boots as I prefer leather but some are and some aren’t an expensive brand

Tarcietiger · 03/09/2021 08:50

There is a type of jersey made by some high end retailers that is a cut above (literally). It’s a bit heavier in weight and just sits more nicely/ washes better etc. I’m thinking Baukjen/ Pure Collection/DKNY. I wouldn’t spend £100 on a tshirt like this but I would spend up to £50 in a sale for something I’d get a lot of use out of.

Shirleyphallus · 03/09/2021 08:46

You could buy an expensive going out black dress, £300 boots, perfectly fitting work trousers, a burberry trench as a pp posted upthread, etc in your late twenties - all great quality 'classic' items....then 3 years later you're working from home so never wear smart workwear, lovely heeled boots have been replaced by wellies for walks in the countryside, the classic lbd no longer fits and you're too scared to get babysick on the trenchcoat!

@thevassal the more expensive stuff I buy I do so and wear like normal clothes. I wore the Burberry trench a lot on mat leave! Didn’t worry about baby vom but it was very practical to put on with jeans and white trainers.

I don’t see the point of buying expensive clothes if you then treat them like museum pieces and never actually wear them

Newmumatlast · 03/09/2021 08:44

@strawberrydonuts

On the back of another thread, I've been browsing some online clothes stores.

I tend to like places like FatFace, Weird Fish, Sea Salt, Boden occasionally... just decent quality, casual stuff. I usually buy stuff in the sale but I might splurge £40-50 for a really good quality top or shirt which will last me years. I have some clothes from these places that have lasted me 10 years.

But looking at some of the online stores people suggested on another thread, I am seeing cotton tops/ shirts costing £100+ that look no different in quality to what you can get at FatFace for half the price.

Things like:
www.toa.st/collections/womens-tops-tees/products/seed-check-boxy-shirt-french-blue

AIBU to ask what's the difference? Are they really worth it? If you would pay £100+ for a casual top/ shirt, why? (Not in a judgemental way... I'm just genuinely wondering if I'm missing something!)

It can't be just about quality because the clothes I buy are good quality. Is it design/ fit? Is it about the materials and where they are sourced?

Lol whereas I am always questioning if expensive clothes like Boden, Fat Face etc are. I have some Boden bits. Had one Fat Face top. No, they often arent.
thevassal · 03/09/2021 08:42

I think people exaggerate how long cheap items don't last for. I've got shoes from primark, tesco etc I've had for years and are going fine. Things like a pair of winter boots might only last a season or two if you wear them every day...but twenty or thirty pounds every year is still cheaper than 150 for a good quality "classic" pair that you feel you have to keep wearing forever even though two years into buying them knee high black leather you can only wear with skinny jeans is completely out and everyone else is wearing brightly coloured ankle boots with their mom jeans!

Basically the ethos of buying something to last years assumes fashions, tastes, lifestyles and your weight all stay the same for a decade or more. But how many people does that really apply to? You could buy an expensive going out black dress, £300 boots, perfectly fitting work trousers, a burberry trench as a pp posted upthread, etc in your late twenties - all great quality 'classic' items....then 3 years later you're working from home so never wear smart workwear, lovely heeled boots have been replaced by wellies for walks in the countryside, the classic lbd no longer fits and you're too scared to get babysick on the trenchcoat!

sub453 · 03/09/2021 08:39

I wouldn't spend £100 on a t shirt. I have bought True Religion jeans (at an outlet in the US but I think have an rrp of £200) because I like the low rise fit. I've worn them pretty much every day for 6 years and they're still going strong. As cheaper jeans might be too in fairness.

I really dislike it when t-shirts/jumpers/sweatshirts bobble, but that's not necessarily related to price. Jack Wills (now, used to be good), J Crew and GAP have been poor in this department, Uniqlo (not expensive) and Ralph Lauren are very good. I don't think good quality needs to cost the earth but generally I think the quality has declined in the last 10 years.

HeronLanyon · 03/09/2021 08:38

In my life I have had various expensive items of clothing. I’d say around 5% of my clothing items. Partic jackets and coats.
What I’ve found -
They last longer
They look/hang/fit better (also I take more time about choosing and trying on due to cost)
They are a pleasure to wear in small unexpected ways - a great well thought through feature or a lovely trim somewhere (often hidden) or just features that work eg fastenings or proportions etc. Good quality materials which wear and last well. I always feel good wearing something special (and pretty much without exception the ‘special’ have also been expensive).
So I do think they are worth the money if you can afford it. If not then no sense getting into debt. I’ve also given up wearing expensive things only eg when going out etc. Day to day I’ll wear things as I feel in the mood.

Standrewsschool · 03/09/2021 08:31

I would splash out on coats and shoes. I wouldn’t splash out over £100 ob that shirt, when you can get similar things in high street stores for under half the price.

MattyGroves · 03/09/2021 08:28

So I think it’s material more than label eg cotton, cashmere, wool, silk look better and last better.

Partly depends on if you iron! I don't and so cotton looks awful on me!