Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are expensive clothes worth it?

115 replies

strawberrydonuts · 03/09/2021 06:18

On the back of another thread, I've been browsing some online clothes stores.

I tend to like places like FatFace, Weird Fish, Sea Salt, Boden occasionally... just decent quality, casual stuff. I usually buy stuff in the sale but I might splurge £40-50 for a really good quality top or shirt which will last me years. I have some clothes from these places that have lasted me 10 years.

But looking at some of the online stores people suggested on another thread, I am seeing cotton tops/ shirts costing £100+ that look no different in quality to what you can get at FatFace for half the price.

Things like:
www.toa.st/collections/womens-tops-tees/products/seed-check-boxy-shirt-french-blue

AIBU to ask what's the difference? Are they really worth it? If you would pay £100+ for a casual top/ shirt, why? (Not in a judgemental way... I'm just genuinely wondering if I'm missing something!)

It can't be just about quality because the clothes I buy are good quality. Is it design/ fit? Is it about the materials and where they are sourced?

OP posts:
Draineddraineddrained · 04/09/2021 06:30

@RichPetunia

I have wondered about this!! Like Aldi brand biscuits 😂 just makes brand loyalty feel incredibly futile.

RichPetunia · 04/09/2021 06:25

A relative of mine worked in a factory making leisure wear. Regardless, of the brand, everything was made to the same design and standards. The only difference?- the logos applied at the end.

DorisFlies · 04/09/2021 06:11

I have two Toast shirts (sale buys). They have been with me for years and are such lovely cut and fabric. Jeans on the other hand - tried a couple of posher brands but found M & S fit me best.

Draineddraineddrained · 04/09/2021 06:11

I'd never buy shoes made of anything except leather or cotton canvas though because nothing else ages well. I expect to get years out of a pair of shoes. A pair of Clarks sandals finally gave up the ghost recently and I was gutted until I remembered I'd had them almost 10 years. Likewise I reheeled and soled some Joules ankle boots recently and was vexed at the additionl cost - then remembered I'd worn them about 70% of the time year round for 2.5 years because they're AMAZING. I work shoes bloody hard and expect a lot back from them.

Draineddraineddrained · 04/09/2021 06:02

I watched Shop Well For Less the other night and the bloke on there was into his designer. My head just about exploded when he said he'd paid £350 for a pair of foam sliders just because they were designer. Fucking flip flops. £350. There is not a power on earth that would induce me to spend that much on a pair of shoes, never mind flip flops. There is no way the quality could be THAT much better.

Have to say though I find quality from pretty much all retailers highly variable. Sainsbury's Tu is a good example - some lovely things in great fabrics I'll love forever, some utterly horrible cheap-feeling rubbish. Even if both are "100% cotton", which bewilders me. Boden is another one, slightly higher end. My sister shops there loads for her kids so mine have ended up with some great hand-me-downs from them; then this year they had a jersey dress with a pattern I really coveted, I ummed and aahed then eventually coughed up close to £30 for a jersey dress for a 4yo... And in the flesh so disappointing - the print seemed really cheaply printed, fabric felt slippery and thin, and the hem was thready after about 1 wash! Took a while to come as well so I wonder if they have a consistent supplier or just shop around for the cheapest factory/producer this sometimes good and sometimes bad.

Seasalt Cornwall is consistently very good quality but have got quite conservative and mumsy design-wise of late which is a shame. But they're a brand I'd spend money on.

Fat Face and White Stuff REALLY lost their way about 5/10 years ago I fear - in my teens and twenties they were my "I can't afford it but I'll ask for it for my birthday or hunt it down on eBay" aspirational brands, really solid good quality stuff that lasted incredibly well and looked better the longer you wore it, some interesting prints but good basic styles you could build and combine . You knew for example you could go in there and find s good corduroy skirt in a range of colours, a really nice thick cotton sweatshirt. At some point they went completely weird and the styles and prints became this sort of mad ever-changing panoply, sizing went MAD (I am not a size 10 at this almost 12 stone phase of my life, but I fit a FF size 10 sometimes!), and consistency of quality really deteriorated.

I think the rise of online shopping really plays a part.

I'd pay more to know from looking online how the fabric was going to FEEL when it arrives.

TTCAbroad · 04/09/2021 05:26

@Champersandchocolate he may well have done all that but he was also was a cutter on Savile Row. The pieces he put out reflected that - imagine being able to turn a bin bag into a tailored work of art. Many of the pieces at AM still demonstrate commitment to high quality construction. Are people who buy from luxury brands ‘lining the pockets of the business’; obviously. But so is someone who buys clothes at Primark. That’s literally what being a business is about.

DogsandCatsB4u · 04/09/2021 00:17

Bags and shoes yes
River island clothes are okay and other high street I have brought designer jumpers, dresses etc and no better than others

beansprout55 · 04/09/2021 00:16

No!!!

Hop27 · 04/09/2021 00:16

Anything you love wearing, makes you feel
fabulous or really suits you is worth it. It's no relevance on cost in my opinion. Some cheap clothes can last years, expensive ones only last a season. Wear what you love, regardless of price tag.

stepupandbecounted · 03/09/2021 13:34

I do buy expensive clothes and classics, and they last decades. So for me they are worth it. I invest in special one off dresses, and coats that last forever with some dry cleaning once a year. It is sustainable shopping in my view. I only shop three times a year.

Snoozer11 · 03/09/2021 12:49

You need to shop around for quality but more expensive doesn't necessarily mean better.

I find the quality of ASOS clothes absolutely terrible. They don't last one wash and is just a complete waste of £6. Similarly with Primark, I don't like the fit but I admit it's useful for swimwear and the like.

Somewhere like Uniqlo, which is inexpensive uses great materials and their simple £10 t-shirts last years.

You then have Ralph Lauren, which charges £50 for a t shirt which I don't feel fits particularly well or retains its shape or colour after a few washes.

It's all about knowing where to go and which brands to trust.

Though in my experience, you can't compromise with good coats, jackets and footwear. A £250 North Face jacket will always be worth it over a £80 high street coat.

FangsForTheMemory · 03/09/2021 12:35

Designer labels are a waste of money. Good quality brands are worth it IME

GreenBiro · 03/09/2021 12:34

You need to learn how to really understand quality in clothing.

Are things lined, and interfaced?
How are the seams constructed? Lots of interlocking, french seams, taped seams?
What is the cut like? Not just whether it flatters - but where does it sit in terms of pattern match and the how the grain of the fabric falls?
How are the pockets and closures constructed? Is there any lining? If so, is it generously cut and well installed?
Are there spare buttons / threads?
When you look at the garment, is it perfectly symmetrical?
When you try the garment on, does it pull or twist at all?
What is the fabric composed of? A bit of synthetic material can go a long way in something which is otherwise cotton / lined. Likewise a bit of natural material such as wool or cotton can really improve something that is synthetic.
How will you launder the item? Are you OK with this?

TIP: I spend a lot of time in shops turning garments inside out! ;-)

Any then other things...

Does it fit?
Do you like it?
Does it go with other things in your wardrobe?
Are you comfortable with the potential cost-per-wear?
How will you store it when you aren't wearing it?
Are you comfortable with how you might dispose of the garment when you have finished with it?

All of these things make for a much more interesting / complex decision than simply price / quality.

BlairWaldorfLovesShopping · 03/09/2021 12:31

The answer is of course "sometimes", like with any expensive item. (Expensive is also subjective.)

There are many reasons an "expensive" item of clothing may be "worth it" to a person, quality is just one of them but like you say not the only one.
Quality is subjective - I'd disagree that just because something lasts then it is better quality. It might look like a dishrag but just hasn't fallen apart and can still be worn. Quality is also in the fabric, the construction, the comfort/ease of wearing, and the level of design.

As pp have pointed out, there are several other factors such as:
Ethical considerations
Branding (yes a £300 t-shirt won't be 10 times higher quality than a £30 one, but it definitely will be a lot better, designers don't literally get away with slapping a logo on a £30 quality t-shirt and selling it for £300!)
Materials (a silk dress as opposed to a polyester one)
Pattern matching
Design
Fit (being measured on several bodies rather than just an average size 8 or 10 or whatever and scaled up/down)
Production quantities

To answer your question, I would pay £100 for a casual top if I liked it and thought it was worth it, because I can afford it.

If you are really interested why not order the Toast top on a credit card (if you actually like it) and compare it to one of your Boden tops? Could be a good experiment.

cestunestilo · 03/09/2021 12:12

Footwear probably . And water proofs . Other than that I just buy what I like for the look or how it makes me feel.

BabyLeaf · 03/09/2021 12:07

@thevassal

I think people exaggerate how long cheap items don't last for. I've got shoes from primark, tesco etc I've had for years and are going fine. Things like a pair of winter boots might only last a season or two if you wear them every day...but twenty or thirty pounds every year is still cheaper than 150 for a good quality "classic" pair that you feel you have to keep wearing forever even though two years into buying them knee high black leather you can only wear with skinny jeans is completely out and everyone else is wearing brightly coloured ankle boots with their mom jeans!

Basically the ethos of buying something to last years assumes fashions, tastes, lifestyles and your weight all stay the same for a decade or more. But how many people does that really apply to? You could buy an expensive going out black dress, £300 boots, perfectly fitting work trousers, a burberry trench as a pp posted upthread, etc in your late twenties - all great quality 'classic' items....then 3 years later you're working from home so never wear smart workwear, lovely heeled boots have been replaced by wellies for walks in the countryside, the classic lbd no longer fits and you're too scared to get babysick on the trenchcoat!

This is such a good point. Not everyone wants to or will be able to fit into long lasting expensive clothes year after year!

I also get frustrated with people criticising shoppers for ‘fast fashion’ if they shop at places like primark. I love primark but I don’t recognise this idea of buying a top to wear on a couple of nights out and then discarding it. I buy things that will last a long time and wear them until they no longer look alright (which tbf has never happened yet with cheap clothes I buy anyway).

MistySkiesAfterRain · 03/09/2021 11:14

Budget is defo the deciding factor and I think there is a skill to getting the quality and look at a snip.

Ebay, sales, outlets etc.
Key investment pieces

To me, a tshirt could be something you wear every day if it fits amazingly I'd pay more.

But I'd be more likely to pay more for an outer jacket, quality shoes etc.

Otherpeoplesteens · 03/09/2021 11:08

I tend to think it's worth paying for quality if it's something that one would wear a lot and over a long period of time and of course if one is in a position to do so. I've been very lucky that at certain points of my life I've been in a position to buy expensive things and these are keeping me going through periods like right now when we're living hand-to-mouth and I've not bought a single item in about five years.

But I am far from convinced there is a linear causal relationship between price and quality. If the price is high because the material and construction are good quality, that's one thing. If the price is high because of trends or labels but the underlying quality is poor, that's something else, and learning how to evaluate intrinsic quality is something which in my experience Brits are not particularly good at.

I read somewhere a while ago that the average French or Italian person spends slightly more on clothing than Brits, but buys less than half as much. That tells me quite a lot.

sHREDDIES19 · 03/09/2021 10:37

I probably could afford more expensive pieces but I'm rather frugal and don't want to spend a fortune on clothes. I generally shop in Primark, supermarkets as well as selecting some second hand pieces from ebay. I choose wisely based on the quality of each piece and my wardrobe has lasted surprisingly well. I don't buy clothes that often as I hate the throwaway culture. What I buy I want it to last. I also think it's easier to buy clothes if you have a small frame as things tend to sit better so you don't need expensive tailored items.

Blendabrethin · 03/09/2021 10:37

Some are, some aren"t.

I had a velvet boden jacket for about 10 years that still looked as good as the day I bought it (I got rid post children as there is.no way I'll ever fit into it again). I also splashed out on a lovely down filles coat last winter (not canada goose, I'm not that flush!) and I've never been so cosy in my life.

On the other hand, I bought myself a £70 pair of dungarees from seasalt and they broke after 8 wears. I wasn't impressed with their dresses either.

The most comfortable pair of shoes I have ever bought were from Primark.

I don't think price is always linked to quality. You really need to see.clothes in person to get a feel for how well made they are. Internet shopping is a no until you find.a few trusted brands.

Darkchocolateandcoffee · 03/09/2021 10:30

OMG I hate Toast! Their clothes are frumpy, unflattering, and badly cut.

But Mumsnet loves them! I wonder if it's because their prices are high that they have to justify it.

I think sometimes expensive clothes are worth it (eg lovely cashmere that doesn't bobble, well cut jeans) but sometimes definitely not (Toast). It totally depends on the brand.

user1469544430 · 03/09/2021 10:27

I have been thinking about this a lot and decided to focus on ethical brands. If you look on Good On You directory.goodonyou.eco/ it's quite surprising how some brands are rated. Toast for example, isn't rated well: this tells me it's aesthetic of sustainability is just green washing. M&S on the other hand are more highly rated. Some higher end stuff is ethical, some isn't - I'm now building a wardrobe from brands like M&S, Thought but also one-off items from Birdsong and Frank.

frumpety · 03/09/2021 10:15

Sorry mean't to add if you bung everything on a hot wash and then fling it in the tumble dryer, both expensive and cheaper clothes will struggle to look good for long.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/09/2021 10:15

Really want to buy fewer good quality things and not buy cheap crap. I always find I get more wear out of the more expensive things.

Champersandchocolate · 03/09/2021 10:15

@strawberrydonuts honestly, I am skeptical about expensive clothes. I have designer handbags, shoes, belts, clothes etc - for no other reason than the fact I could.

But, take note, Alexander McQueen wore the most cheapest of clothes, he dressed his models in bin bags and began his career with dole money - I find the only meaning behind expensive clothes is lining the pockets of a business, like most things expensive.

I only ever buy jeans or jeggins from primark as my thighs are bigger than my waist/hips and they allow the stretch on my thighs and the tightness on my hips, cannot find it anywhere else.

I tend to shop for what style I'd like to wear - not the designer, not the shop, not the price.

Usually jeans or workout leggings and a crop top from ASOS that £6-£8.

All I wear 😂