Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are expensive clothes worth it?

115 replies

strawberrydonuts · 03/09/2021 06:18

On the back of another thread, I've been browsing some online clothes stores.

I tend to like places like FatFace, Weird Fish, Sea Salt, Boden occasionally... just decent quality, casual stuff. I usually buy stuff in the sale but I might splurge £40-50 for a really good quality top or shirt which will last me years. I have some clothes from these places that have lasted me 10 years.

But looking at some of the online stores people suggested on another thread, I am seeing cotton tops/ shirts costing £100+ that look no different in quality to what you can get at FatFace for half the price.

Things like:
www.toa.st/collections/womens-tops-tees/products/seed-check-boxy-shirt-french-blue

AIBU to ask what's the difference? Are they really worth it? If you would pay £100+ for a casual top/ shirt, why? (Not in a judgemental way... I'm just genuinely wondering if I'm missing something!)

It can't be just about quality because the clothes I buy are good quality. Is it design/ fit? Is it about the materials and where they are sourced?

OP posts:
Enko · 04/09/2021 09:10

Oddly that was not the concensus I got from reading this thread.

To me the consensus seems to be it is about what qualities you are looking for. If ethically sourced environmentally kind cut and fit are important for you then you go that both higher. However this does not mean ALL brands of 100+is worth it.

Ita about knowing the brand and their ethos.

Personally I dislike the shops you mention as their styles are not mine at all my dd loves fat face so has a fair bit of their clothing
For me I am happy paying the money shops like peopletree want because I feel I support the planet that way. I like their cut and their sizing. So I am willing to pay a bit more for this hence to me it is worth it.

The best pieces of clothing I have had were homemade.

BabyLeaf · 04/09/2021 09:10

@nordica

I assure you, not one of the cheap tops/t shirts I’ve bought for £15 or less have unravelled after two washes (or any number of washes tbh!) and they feel very soft against my skin. You seem to have a really inaccurate view of what affordable clothes are actually like.

I lolled at a PP comparing an £80 coat with a £250 one as if the former was a cheap option. £80 for a coat is an awful lot for the majority of people. I have a decent household income and comfortable live but there’s absolutely no way I’d ever consider spending that much on a coat!

Cabbagewhites · 04/09/2021 09:06

If I buy more expensive stuff, it’s because it looks nicer - better colours, fabric sits well, etc.
in my experience they don’t last longer. White stuff in particular don’t last well. Neither do Barbour tops and jumpers - mine are all shapeless after a year.

If I want something that will last I get it from Matalan or M&S.

strawberrydonuts · 04/09/2021 08:58

@girlmom21

The clothes you're talking about are expensive to most people. Are they worth it? Is the quality much better than say Matalan or New Look?
A few people made this point and yes this is very true - FatFace and Boden etc. are quite expensive to me as well, hence I usually will buy stuff in the sale if I can.

I absolutely do find the quality worth it compared to the brands you mention, yes. I don't like Matalan and New Look and have found things I've had from there have not lasted. Some supermarket stuff is surprisingly good but I am very dubious about how they make it so cheap so I try to avoid that too.

As others have said, it's all about the way you look at clothing I guess. I try to limit my purchases (even though I love clothes) for ethical/ environmental reasons and it also saves me money in the long run. This means I can afford a decent quality item from a shop I feel is worth giving money to.

Consensus seems to be that once you get to a certain price point you are paying more for the brand... so probably the £100+ shirts aren't worth it... and it's more about looking at material, cut and the company ethos.

Thanks for your input everyone, it's been an interesting read.

OP posts:
roses2 · 04/09/2021 08:53

When people say you get what you pay for I cringe

Totally agree. Some things you are paying for quality and others you are paying for the brand.

I buy good quality on ebay and in charity shops. I can't justify paying $150 for a new Tommy Bahama swimsuit which has great reviews so I found it on ebay for £18 Inc postage brand new with tags.

If you're willing to put in effort and shop around you can buy great quality for similar prices to Primark.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 04/09/2021 08:49

There is a complete disconnect between quality and price in many areas. I have Somerset and Whistles pieces that have cost over £100 and they are made poorly, with crap finishing. My Uniqlo and M&S knitwear costs less than £40 and item and is going strong after years of good service. My £16 Sainsbury jeans are lasting as well as my more expensive, high end jeans; colours being the only thing I find high end denim does better.

With the exception of shoes and coats I don’t tend to agree with investment pieces; lifestyle and clothes style moves on. The poster writing about not wanting to get baby sick on a Burberry trench had it spot on! I’ve moved beyond the baby years, but I cycle to work, so my smart work clothes also have to work on a bicycle. In 5 year’s time there’s no telling what I’ll be doing, so spending thousands on posh work wardrobes wouldn’t be great.

Blossomtoes · 04/09/2021 08:44

I also loathe the word "frumpy". Nasty,judgemental and misogynistic

Absolutely. And completely meaningless.

Hawkins001 · 04/09/2021 08:44

Reading with intrigue

TempleofZoom · 04/09/2021 08:41

Things like a pair of winter boots might only last a season or two if you wear them every day...but twenty or thirty pounds every year is still cheaper than 150 for a good quality "classic" pair that you feel you have to keep wearing forever even though two years into buying them knee high black leather you can only wear with skinny jeans is completely out and everyone else is wearing brightly coloured ankle boots with their mom jeans!

I have a pair of classic black riding boots that I bought 15 years ago for £150.
No amount of cheap £20-30 boots will ever come close to the quality of these.
They are cleaned, reheeled as needed and treasured.
I dont wear them with skinny jeans.
What happens to your cheap boots?-they fall apart and you put them into landfill.
Mom jeans and brightly coloured ankle boots -been there done that in the 80s so its a no from me !

I buy toast.
Im tall and I love the fact that their dresses and skirts are long.
I set a budget and try to buy in the sales.
I probably spend less than someone who buys cheaper.

Cheaper ranges are always made from horrible fabrics and cut really skimpily, particularly in terms of length.

I worked in an office where everyone spent saturdays in Primark, they crackled with static!

My size is pretty steady, through the pregnancy, birth, BF stages.
I love nice fabric, yarns and I get my clothes second hand, knit and sew.

I also loathe the word "frumpy"
Nasty,judgemental and misogynistic.

Pottedpalm · 04/09/2021 08:22

@Tarcietiger

There is a type of jersey made by some high end retailers that is a cut above (literally). It’s a bit heavier in weight and just sits more nicely/ washes better etc. I’m thinking Baukjen/ Pure Collection/DKNY. I wouldn’t spend £100 on a tshirt like this but I would spend up to £50 in a sale for something I’d get a lot of use out of.
I agree; cheap t shirts don’t wash well ( in general), are not square after washing and are often thin ( m&s guilty here). I pay for quality and definitely get more wear from those items. I have a Baukjen coat which makes me feel good every time I wear it. I bought it in 2015 and I still get admiring comments every time I go out in it.
elbea · 04/09/2021 08:12

I think it is if you understand clothing construction and fabrics. Look at cheap, fast fashion clothes carefully and you will see wonky seams etc… They are likely made in an unethical way with cheap fabrics. Fabric is a large percentage of the cost of clothes.

I don’t shop high end because I can’t afford it, I shop mid range like Somerset by Temperley and Ghost because they have decent fabric and are cut in a way that suits my shape. I have clothes from here that 6/7 years old that I wear all the time and look like new.

I think shoes are the best thing to invest in. My fairfax and favor explorer boots at 6 years old and look as good as the day I bought them despite daily wear on the farm. They were £400 but worth every penny.

nordica · 04/09/2021 08:09

For me it's mostly about materials these days, and choosing items that suit my style. I buy mostly organic cotton for day to day wear, and a top can cost around £30-40. Compared to a £5 or £10 t-shirt from a supermarket or New Look, the ones I buy feel soft on the skin, wash well, and tend to be made ethically by people who work in good conditions and the brands generally have higher quality standards so stitching won't just unravel and the cut has been designed so it doesn't go a weird shape after two washes. So it's absolutely worth it for me for those reasons.

Also with things like knitwear, cotton or merino will last and look much better for a long time compared to a cheaper acrylic version that looks awful after a few wears.

On the other hand, I wouldn't spend more on something just because it's a particular brand as in your example in the OP.

I also try to pay attention to ethics because it's absolutely obvious that brands selling £5 dresses can't possibly be paying the people in their supply chains a living wage.

Blossomtoes · 04/09/2021 08:04

Something that’s always stuck with me is “Only rich people can afford cheap shoes”. I guess it’s the Terry Pratchett principle.

I have a Toast dress I bought five years ago, I’ve worn it a lot and it still looks like it did when it left the shop. The cotton is beautiful, it’s very soft yet not limp. The seams are taped and the pattern’s matched.

I think cost per wear is a good indication of value for money and on that basis my Toast dress is one of the cheapest things in my wardrobe.

ActonSquirrel · 04/09/2021 07:48

*bone dry

ActonSquirrel · 04/09/2021 07:48

Some times you do get you pay for

Gap leggings for the gym kept falling down although the correct size, they bobbled in less than a year and looked awful and show sweat patches to the extent it looked as if I had wet myself after a gym class.

Sweaty Betty's stayed put, fit great, had a compression factor that was flattering and stayed been dry even after a HIIT class. A pair I have had for 3 years and worn and washed several times a week still looks good as new. Money well spent there

ActonSquirrel · 04/09/2021 07:35

Things like a pair of winter boots might only last a season or two if you wear them every day...but twenty or thirty pounds every year is still cheaper than 150 for a good quality "classic" pair that you feel you have to keep wearing forever even though two years into buying them knee high black leather you can only wear with skinny jeans is completely out and everyone else is wearing brightly coloured ankle boots with their mom jeans!

That depends if you care what the latest trends are. Or like them.

I don't care what everyone else is wearing, I wouldn't be found dead in bright coloured ankle boots and mom jeans. Deeply unflattering

Givemethatknife · 04/09/2021 07:34

@EmeraldRaine

£40-50 for a top is very expensive already. Confused

And no. Generally the clothes are made in the same factory from the same fabric as other brands. You're paying for the name, in most cases. You could probably get your same quality top that you'll pay £50 for, for £20 elsewhere. Or, shock horror, secondhand.

Well this is not true - there is a price point below which clothes are going to be badly made, won’t last, and are a waste of resources. I don’t think (for example) seasalt shirts are made in the same factory as primark, or if they are, they are made to a different spec.

Of course also there is a high point beyond which you are paying for design rather than quality. In which case you need to make sure the quality and design are such that it will last.

Dreamstate · 04/09/2021 07:21

I really loved the quality of Karen Miller clothes before it got taken over by boohoo. Yes they were expensive so always waited for the sale but I got a number of jumpers that are still looking new after 7 years of wearing them. Colour hasn't faded, no bobbling etc. Tshirts still looking new too. On the other hand I've had Tshirts from primark that don't even last a year before you seen colour fading.

OldTinHat · 04/09/2021 07:06

Charity shops are your friend here. I have loads of designer tops that cost a fiver max in a charity shop. You can tell they are good quality because they don't lose their shape or go bobbly.

EmeraldRaine · 04/09/2021 07:01

£40-50 for a top is very expensive already. Confused

And no. Generally the clothes are made in the same factory from the same fabric as other brands. You're paying for the name, in most cases. You could probably get your same quality top that you'll pay £50 for, for £20 elsewhere. Or, shock horror, secondhand.

Grapeuk · 04/09/2021 06:57

@DappledThings

All the shops you mention are expensive to me. I have plenty of items from Primark and supermarkets that have lasted 10 years+ as well.
I agree with this. I've never been one to spend loads on clothes but that's more due to not having the money too. I'm in a better situation now financially but have no desire now to change where I shop. I dont mind cheap and cheerful. My OH who has recently moved in with me has more expensive taste but again that's due to different financial situations.

In my office some of my colleagues are 8-10 years younger then me and it amazes me how much they spend on bags etc but maybe I am just getting old! 🙃

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/09/2021 06:56

Oh I forgot about shoes and boots. Definitely worth paying extra. Far better quality than Clark’s.

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/09/2021 06:54

Boden prints on t-shirt jersey do not wash well, most disappointing. Monsoon prints have worn far better. Tailored dresses and jackets are of better quality fabrics and finish than ones from primark for example. Knitted winter dresses wear the same as something from M&S. Perhaps the quality of material and cut is often superior. I now only buy boden in the sales.

I have a Burberry Mac it is beautiful but proportionately far more expensive than it would justifiably be worth. Ditto my other designer clothes. Yes, they were well tailored and lasted a long time. The stitching didn’t come undone, that’s for sure! But I haven’t bought anything recently to compare.

Take my MaxMara (now far too small) evening gown, this cost 600 Euros years ago at an outlet shop. At the time that sort of fabric and finish was not available on the high street. It’s far better quality than something from Monsoon for example - I don’t think it is like comparing a £300 wedding dress to a £3k one though. There is a lot of work in a fully boned, hand sewn on beaded 3k wedding dress - or do they cost far more than that?

Dh has had suits from Givenchy, YSL, Boss etc. Boss definitely the lower end in quality of the 3. But a Givenchy suit is 2k now. Do I think they’re worth it? Boss and M&S Saville row inspired range are not that far apart in terms of quality.

IamEarthymama · 04/09/2021 06:42

In Men at Arms, Terry Pratchett presented Captain Samuel Vimes ‘Boots’ theory of socioeconomic unfairness.

“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.
Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.
But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that’d still be keeping his feet dry in ten years’ time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.”.

Pratchett presents another economic theory in Men At Arms.

“The very very rich could afford to be poor. Sybil Ramkin lived in the kind of poverty that was only available to the very rich, a poverty approached from the other side. Women who were merely well-off saved up and bought dresses made of silk edged with lace and pearls, but Lady Ramkin was so rich she could afford to stomp around the place in rubber boots and a tweed skirt that had belonged to her mother. She was so rich she could afford to live on biscuits and cheese sandwiches.”

I worked in a tiny boutique in Welsh Valleys community when I was 13 years old, (weekend job, it was legal, honest.) The wholesalers would send round copies of clothes that had been seen on Top of the Pops the week before. Fridays, payday, the girls from local shops and factories picked up the things they had chosen and put away during the week. They would look fabulous for their weekend evenings. 😊

I love clothes and for many years I followed fashion trends, though I always wore ‘good’ shoes, Bally stilettos were a favourite.

In the last 20 odd years my thinking and my way of life have changed. I now shop less impulsively, I try to buy second hand, I choose material that will wear well, I dye my clothes to extend the length of time they look good. I also wear clothes that aren’t fashionable, they suit me in my middle age.
However, I know if my income rose I would buy clothes that are out of my budget at present. I like to visit a wonderful shop and dream!

Capitalism depends on creating wants, of creating a dream that we can buy our way into. I am fully aware of this and also self-aware enough to know that part of me will always be that 13 year old who knew that a fringed suede jacket and a pair of hot pants were the pathway to my perfect life! 😊

torquewench · 04/09/2021 06:30

The day to day stuff I wear most regularly is from places like White Stuff and Monsoon, and I've only recently discovered and got a few bits from Oliver Bonas. I love Gabor shoes as I find the fit good for me and they're really comfy. I've a couple of pairs of Spanx jeggings, gym stuff is mostly Sweaty Betty (some of thats v old tho). I do find that Primark type things just don't look great on me (5'6", booby and need to lose about 2-3 stone). I'm also not keen on polyester for various reasons 🥵.

However, where I really don't mind spending quite a bit of my money is on my biking kit - my boots were £359, I've had them about 6 years and they're still like new, 100% waterproof and comfy to walk about in as well as when riding. Another £250 for some Knox kevlar jeans - the construction, fit and rise (and colour, as there's no fake fading etc on them) is better than my everyday ones, they're so comfy and even the hip armour in them doesn't add bulk to my frame. I've also spent about £300 on a Knox jacket, and it's the only one I've ever had that's been fully waterproof. It's a waterproof top layer, optional quilted mid layer and a close fitting stretchy layer which has armour. Biking kit isn't necessarily the best if you're worried about looking stylish but this is the best stuff I've ever had with the added bonus for me of not having naff floral embroidery that a lot of female biking kit has. So around £900 for one "everyday" outfit (plus another £400 for the helmet and £75 for gloves) may seem a bit pricey, but it'll last me many years worn in all weathers (and regularly be covered in dead bugs 🤢).

Also, if there's anyone out there that can recommend riding gloves that are actually waterproof and don't soak up water like a sponge, please do share 😁