Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying money for step child in uni

266 replies

Thinkingannie · 02/09/2021 23:09

I’ll try to put as much info as poss but will probably forget stuff so apologies in advance…

Background DH has a son from a previous relationship he has nit seen for over 11 years, not his fault. Access was stopped many times then resumed just as we went to court resulting in the court not putting a court order in place. We went to court twice. DSS and EX live approx 500 miles away we live in Scotland, them in the south west so husband has never been able to just pop over but has been turned away from weekend visits numerous times (after driving over seven hours to get there) costing a fortune in both petrol and a hotel room that is nit used but can’t be cancelled, more importantly the emotional toll was high on him. So after going to court twice then being at the ex’s beck and call for years eg phone call on a sat morning come and have DSS this weekend or you’ll never see him again or after driving down being told no you’re not having him now etc, when she stopped access the final time my husband just didn’t have it in him to go to court a third time and just left fighting for access for his own MH. Since then we’ve had no access, have been blocked on social media and have no idea where they live etc. So DSS is now 19 and we stopped CM, we then got a message chasing it up and found out that he is starting uni this month. We have confirmed that CM should be stopped at this point but offered to pay DSS some money direct, if he just sent us his bank details. My DH got a ton of abuse back, not sure if it was the ex who wrote it or the son but it was written as if it was the son.

The ex said you can still give me the money though and I’ll pass it on (not convinced this will happen as it didn’t when we had DSS staying with us as we often had to buy him new clothes pay school stuff etc.

Are we being unreasonable to refuse to pay anyone but DSS direct?

Sorry it’s so long..

OP posts:
femfemlicious · 03/09/2021 07:24

Just dont send them any money. He is an adult now. Of he eants money from you, he needs to call you and ask for it.

Dashel · 03/09/2021 07:22

I would leave it for 6 months when hopefully the son is away at uni and get a private investigator to track him down and handover a letter saying that he misses him dearly and wants to be part of his life again, even in secret and he would like to meet up in time and reconnect. Don’t mention money and apologise that things are the way they are, and that I’m sure your Mum and I have different versions of what has happened, I love you very much and the door is always open, even if you aren’t ready for it. I would give all your contact details even an email in case he feels more comfortable with that and then I would send another card just before he moves out of the student place at the end of the academic year.

Miniroofbox · 03/09/2021 07:20

Just go to a solicitor and contact the young man that way and (hopefully) reach out.

Jemand · 03/09/2021 07:18

[quote Thinkingannie]@Darker I was hoping my DH would have some contact but we can’t contact him direct and actually the message we received from DSS threatened the police if we carried on asking for his details instead of just paying his mum, it was all a bit weird tbh. But also a bit sad and just generally makes us feel a bit powerless to do anything.[/quote]
Point out that the police will hardly be interested in a father who just wants his son's bank account details so he can give said son some money for university.

louisejxxx · 03/09/2021 07:18

YANBU and I’m really sorry that all this has happened to dh.

Whydidimarryhim · 03/09/2021 07:12

You cannot trust this woman. She is nasty and cruel.
The poor boy having a mother like this and being kept away from his father.
Stop the child maintenance- but put it to one side every month -= you don’t know he’s definitely going to uni but you can save it up.
Can you write to him - can you check electrol role for an address.
Don’t send it to her - she clearly hasn’t got his best interest to heart.

Darker · 03/09/2021 07:11

But how would the son contact the father? If the mother has succeeded in making the boy uncontactable, she’ll have made the same effort to keep the dad’s details from her son.

It’s abuse.

Eralos · 03/09/2021 07:04

If they won’t give you his bank details, I’d save an amount for him each month anyway so if he does get in contact later you can give him a lump sum of what you’ve been saving for him.

MilesOfSand · 03/09/2021 07:04

I don’t think the Private Investigator idea is such a bad one. Your DH could write a letter saying he loves him, wanted contact, still would but no pressure. Also that he’s happy to pay money and for it all to be confidential if his son wishes etc etc.

Then he’ll know his son at least knows (as he doesn’t now) and the ball is in his court.

44PumpLane · 03/09/2021 07:00

Honestly, as hard as this is for your DH I wpiod stop all monies.

If his adult son wants money from his father he can work for it this time. Yes it's absolutely not the sons fault, it sounds as if his mother has done a number on him, however it doesn't give him a lifetime free pass...... If the son has been filled with hatred he can't expect to also receive a load of cash monthly.

As an adult we make choices, those choices impact our lives, as an adult now the son needs to decide if the money is important enough to him to be a grown up and reach out to his father to ask for the cash.

Put the money you would give him into his christmas/birthday account monthly so that if he ever does reach out and meaningfully engage he can see you hadnt forgotten about him.

But if he ever does come back to you I wouldn't be throwing this money at him, I'd want to see a meaningful relationship develop before giving him access to the money to protect yourselves. If it never does, perhaps consider donating that money to NSPCC or similar.

Iwonder08 · 03/09/2021 06:58

I voted YABU only because I think it is unreasonable to even contemplate givigg either of them any money for uni. I strongly believe 19 year old going to unI is adult enough to be responsible for his own actions and if he chose not to contact his dad and try to talk it through he shouldnt ask for money either

anon12345678901 · 03/09/2021 06:53

He's not a child anymore, he's a young adult apparently going off to uni. I'm sorry but you have supported him as you should have done, you are right to stop it now going to the mother. Reading all the posts, it honestly sounds like you have tried so hard to see him but the ex has destroyed any chance of a relationship. If he's blocked you and the kids on everything, that will be him. He doesn't want contact then that's fine, he cannot and she cannot expect money to continue. I would leave it, for both you and your husbands mental health.

TidyDancer · 03/09/2021 06:47

I think all you can do (if it's viable) is keep putting money away for him in a suitable amount and way, and make this clear to him. Approaching via a solicitor is a good idea as someone suggested up thread. It may be that the blinkers fall off DSS as he gets older and he sees his mother for what she is. He may be so controlled and manipulated by her that he's never able to see it. But either way, given that he's an adult, there's little you can do to compel him to be in contact.

Whatever the case though, I would absolutely not be giving any additional money to his horrible mother, regardless of what she says it's for.

Thinkingannie · 03/09/2021 06:46

@autummvibes thank you, it was a really hard time and the decision not to chase contact again was not taken lightly, I suppose I’m defending it because until I’d lived through it I would probably been saying but you keep trying. In reality it’s just not that black and white, like everything there comes a time when you just have say enough now… I think the sobbing call from his son was that limit for DH.

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 03/09/2021 06:43

Honestly, I would just ignore them and keep the money. If ds is off to uni, he will have applied for finance based on his mother's income.
There is no financial obligation once school is finished. At thar point it is down to the relationship with the child and there is none.

Thinkingannie · 03/09/2021 06:38

@MayorGoodwaysChicken she moved away to be with her new boyfriend. My DH and mum were together for two years until she left….

OP posts:
autummvibes · 03/09/2021 06:30

No need to explain yourself, from your posts his mother is clearly a controlling nasty bitch. Whether MN want to admit it or not there are parents like this. She sounds vile. Nothing excuses that.
He's an adult and you have no details for him. I'd leave it now. If she unblocks again then you block her so she can't pop up when she feels like it.
You said you have the documents from court. You'll also have these messages which I have no doubt was from her not him.
He's an adult now, if he ever wants to contact his dad he can trance him. You can show him whatever you have to show you tried. Beyond that I'd leave it all be. She sounds like hell. He's a legal adult, don't tie yourselfs up in knots over it.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 03/09/2021 06:27

Why the distance-did she move away or your DH or were they never together as a couple?

Thinkingannie · 03/09/2021 05:30

@Kanaloa I’m lying here now awake thinking of some of the stuff she made us do and actually can’t believe we did it looking back eg I had to move out of our house when DSS came up to visit as I wasn’t allowed to be around him. She threatened to go to social services saying I had hit him (which I obvs hadn’t) if we disobeyed her. That only changed as I was mentioned as needing access as part of the first court agreement so she allowed access to me too just before we went to court.

I wasn’t allowed to refer to myself as his Sm as she as the mum had revoked that right. She as the mum had also revoked the parental responsibility given by the courts the first time as she could (all nonsense but we didn’t argue as she would stop access).

Looking back it was mental the hoops we jumped through…i imagine some of you are thinking I’m exaggerating (I would) but I’m honestly not and there are many more similar events I’m recalling now…

OP posts:
Thinkingannie · 03/09/2021 04:47

@kanaloa so how it happened each time, a week or two before the court date she would call up allowing access, then when we got to court she would say to the judge that access had resumed, judge would declare a court order was not required as access had resumed but leave the case open for x months to revisit (I can’t remember what x was) once that time had expired there would be access issues again and we had to start the whole thing from scratch.

The 2nd time we mentioned the pattern but we’re told yes but it’s sorted now….

The last time my DH spoke to his DS (except for the abusive text when he was 12) DSS called crying to say don’t call or phone me anymore I’m not allowed to see you again and if you call me I’ll get shouted at.he was eight or nine at the time). It broke my husbands heart and he said maybe this constant battling is causing him more trauma than it would be to not fight again.

We have all the court papers should he ever want to see them as I’ve kept them too.

We had no address to send anything to, in the short period I had known them the moved six times and we received a letter my husband had sent as no longer at this address. Same with contact details we have none, even the correspondence today was done via messenger so still have no tel no for the mum.

OP posts:
Lotusmonster · 03/09/2021 03:43

What about setting up a managed trust for the DS and putting money into that?? I think your DH is right to stop payment by the way as painful as it must feel for him. The story and messages sound extremely fishy to me. I’ve got kids at Uni….this business about the money to go via their mum sounds like a load of bollocks.
Are there any third parties …ex family or relatives that a letter directly to the son could be sent to to exclude the ex wife, just offering payment?

Kanaloa · 03/09/2021 03:05

Also, at 19 why is all the information coming via his mother? Can your husband not phone his son and speak to him direct instead of all this ‘his mother told us x, we’re not sure if it was him or his mother blah blah.’

Kanaloa · 03/09/2021 03:04

How was your husband at court twice and still unable to arrange a contact agreement for his child, who presumably, if he hasn’t seen him in 11 years and the boy is now 19) was only 8 years old? From what you’ve said, it sounds like both times contact started again and he just gave up on court. Understandable once, but odd that he did it twice, and then ‘couldn’t face’ it a third time.

It doesn’t sound like they’ll ever have a good relationship, but I don’t think it can be excused as ‘not his fault’ and I don’t think his son will see it that way.

The abuse coming from the ex is unacceptable, but it sounds like this mess started long ago. I don’t know if there’s any point saving money from birthdays and Christmases that have been missed - a lump sum of money won’t make much difference to that. Would it never have been possible to deliver some money/gifts and a card for the boy at his address?

Gumbojumbo · 03/09/2021 02:41

Yes I think it is important your husband support his child. But as his child is over 18, it should be paid directly to his child. At this point in time, his ex partner shouldn't really have any influence.

BreadInCaptivity · 03/09/2021 02:02

[quote Thinkingannie]@AcrossthePond55 no idea where, other than the mother saying he’s going to uni we have no further info, as a PP pointed out that may not even be true… although I’m not sure why they would lie about it… the son has specifically said to his mum (apparently) not yo tell us as he didn’t want us to know which uni or what he’s studying.[/quote]

Then it's incumbent on them to provide proof of that.

Keep stating simply that you agree to pay but direct to the child.

If you get no response then pay the money into an account for the child in question so if/when they do get in contact they understand the situation and state that's what you will do.