Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying money for step child in uni

266 replies

Thinkingannie · 02/09/2021 23:09

I’ll try to put as much info as poss but will probably forget stuff so apologies in advance…

Background DH has a son from a previous relationship he has nit seen for over 11 years, not his fault. Access was stopped many times then resumed just as we went to court resulting in the court not putting a court order in place. We went to court twice. DSS and EX live approx 500 miles away we live in Scotland, them in the south west so husband has never been able to just pop over but has been turned away from weekend visits numerous times (after driving over seven hours to get there) costing a fortune in both petrol and a hotel room that is nit used but can’t be cancelled, more importantly the emotional toll was high on him. So after going to court twice then being at the ex’s beck and call for years eg phone call on a sat morning come and have DSS this weekend or you’ll never see him again or after driving down being told no you’re not having him now etc, when she stopped access the final time my husband just didn’t have it in him to go to court a third time and just left fighting for access for his own MH. Since then we’ve had no access, have been blocked on social media and have no idea where they live etc. So DSS is now 19 and we stopped CM, we then got a message chasing it up and found out that he is starting uni this month. We have confirmed that CM should be stopped at this point but offered to pay DSS some money direct, if he just sent us his bank details. My DH got a ton of abuse back, not sure if it was the ex who wrote it or the son but it was written as if it was the son.

The ex said you can still give me the money though and I’ll pass it on (not convinced this will happen as it didn’t when we had DSS staying with us as we often had to buy him new clothes pay school stuff etc.

Are we being unreasonable to refuse to pay anyone but DSS direct?

Sorry it’s so long..

OP posts:
Budapestdreams · 03/09/2021 07:52

I'm not sure the son even knows about the abusive messages his mum sent, or he has sent them under duress.
The mum is definitely after the money.
I would do my best to contact him. You say you are still in touch with family, one of them must know his details. However, if his mum is that controlling she won't allow any contact while he is still at home.
Your best bet would be contacting him once he's at uni, assuming that isn't a lie.
Don't give her any money though.

LakieLady · 03/09/2021 07:51

What an awful mess. DSS's mother sounds crazy.

I agree with attempting to contact DSS via a solicitor. And I might be minded to use a solicitor outside of your area, OP, as if any post arrives for him with a Scottish postmark, the batshit mother may intercept it, so that DSS never knows that his dad was prepared to step up.

Actually, if you have friends who live in another part of the country,DH could write a personal letter and send it to them to post, If it was typed and put in a window envelope so that it looked official, and was posted from a long way away from Scotland, it might reach DSS without her intervention.

EmeraldRaine · 03/09/2021 07:51

wouldn't give up on seeing my child, if ops partner had carried on down the court route he may well have got residency as courts take a dim view on a parent who continually obstructs contact.

Obviously you've never been subject to, or threatened with parental alienation have you?

HalzTangz · 03/09/2021 07:50

[quote Thinkingannie]@Medievalist unfortunately, other than setting up fake SM accounts (which does feel a bit stalkerish) we have no way of contacting him, we are all (including our kids) blocked from his social media, the ex only unblocked us today to respond to the money not being in the bank.[/quote]
If your husband knows where family members live he should try make contact with them and ask for son's address explaining he wants to send cheques/bank stuff for his son to access cash at university

EmeraldRaine · 03/09/2021 07:50

What a crazy bitch. Not a single penny more for her. She's obviously upset that the gravy train has stopped.

SW1amp · 03/09/2021 07:49

@RedHelenB

I wouldn't give up on seeing my child, if ops partner had carried on down the court route he may well have got residency as courts take a dim view on a parent who continually obstructs contact.
Nonsense

The OP has already explained the attitude of the judge at hearings - incredibly light touch, assuming things can be resolved amicably

The most likely scenario is that the mother would have strung the legal process along until the son reached 14ish when he was able to make his own decisions about contact and residency

Not a chance in hell would a judge had forced him to move away from his beloved mum to the house of a near stranger 500 miles away as punishment for the mum stopping contact, especially with him groomed to tell the courts he didn’t want to see his dad

I think unless you’ve seen first hand what happens when one parent goes out of their way to block contact and frustrate the legal process, you can’t have the first clue of how it works and how it affects the NRP

ifonly4 · 03/09/2021 07:49

I guess CM maintenance finishes at 16/18, so he doesn't need to pay that to his EX. As DS has chosen to go to uni and will be living mostly away from home, EX shouldn't need any money and it certainly doesn't have to go through her. I reckon she's scared that if you pay DS directly, that'll mean some sort of contact and DS might start wondering more about his DH and starting a relationship with him.

Your DH has tried to do the best he can in the circumstances and supported a DS who he doesn't have contact with. Enough is enough, he pays DS direct or nothing at all.

Damnloginpopup · 03/09/2021 07:47

It'd be a fat fuck off from me. As parent or step parent.

Wiredforsound · 03/09/2021 07:46

I’d put the money directly into an account for him. I’d get in touch with the relatives you’re still in touch with and let them know so that they can tell the DS that his father wants to continue to support him at uni. Hopefully the message will filter through. I’d also see if he was on social media. It is very difficult for someone to be uncontactable these days.

chaosrabbitland · 03/09/2021 07:45

i wouldnt be giving any money and id be well moving on from this stressful situation .

RedHelenB · 03/09/2021 07:44

I wouldn't give up on seeing my child, if ops partner had carried on down the court route he may well have got residency as courts take a dim view on a parent who continually obstructs contact.

HalzTangz · 03/09/2021 07:42

@Getawaywithit

Agree with PPs, if you are going to give him some money, do it directly.

when we had DSS staying with us as we often had to buy him new clothes pay school stuff etc

So child maintenance is only to pay for clothes and school stuff? There wouldn’t possibly be other ways the child has benefitted from this money?

OP in your original post you said dad literally had no contact, drove down to be turned away etc, but in the next breath you say you had son over regularly/often. So I'm confused did your husband have contact or not. As for CM stop paying it, open a savings account for the son and put the money in their. If son wants the money he personally can come collect the bank details/card or meet your husband at a half way point to collect. Don't give or meet the mother
Jumpingintosummer · 03/09/2021 07:41

@FlipFlops4Me

We paid for my Scottish dsd's through their degrees at Uni, and the older dsd said she'd not use our money through her masters and doctorate and got herself a job. The younger one demanded we fund her masters but we pointed out that her sister had taken a job and funded her own, so we wouldn't contribute any further to her education.

We got an absolute torrent of abuse from her and her mother but we held firm and in the end she got a job. Turned out she was pissed off because she'd had a job all along but had used our money for life's luxuries. They lived in Scotland so Uni was free.....

Understandable stance, however a masters and doctorate can carry fees in Scotland too. We were over 8k for DH’s masters at Glasgow.
SW1amp · 03/09/2021 07:41

@gogohm

But unfortunately there's no excuses for no contact, your dh is amiss for not going to court 11 years ago. It took my exh 20 years to get over the fact his father didn't pursue contact (his mother was a difficult woman and threatened him to make up abuse to the courts) and his relationship now is ok but he missed out on having a proper dad.

Distance isn't an excuse, your dh took the easy option and just paid money to alleviate guilt

Have you actually read the thread? Confused

How can several court processes, countless trips to see the son, etc be construed by you as ‘not pursuing contact’?

Jumpingintosummer · 03/09/2021 07:38

Do you still have access to any extended family?

I would write a letter and pass it to them.

Miniroofbox · 03/09/2021 07:37

Also the electoral role. The bank sort code will hopefully give a branch in a town and the solicitor could go from there.

gogohm · 03/09/2021 07:35

But unfortunately there's no excuses for no contact, your dh is amiss for not going to court 11 years ago. It took my exh 20 years to get over the fact his father didn't pursue contact (his mother was a difficult woman and threatened him to make up abuse to the courts) and his relationship now is ok but he missed out on having a proper dad.

Distance isn't an excuse, your dh took the easy option and just paid money to alleviate guilt

Miniroofbox · 03/09/2021 07:35

The solicitor can write to the solicitor the mother used to use? Or use a tracing agent?

daisypond · 03/09/2021 07:33

@Miniroofbox

Just go to a solicitor and contact the young man that way and (hopefully) reach out.
How would a solicitor contact him? There’s no known address or phone number or any contact details at all.
FlipFlops4Me · 03/09/2021 07:30

We paid for my Scottish dsd's through their degrees at Uni, and the older dsd said she'd not use our money through her masters and doctorate and got herself a job. The younger one demanded we fund her masters but we pointed out that her sister had taken a job and funded her own, so we wouldn't contribute any further to her education.

We got an absolute torrent of abuse from her and her mother but we held firm and in the end she got a job. Turned out she was pissed off because she'd had a job all along but had used our money for life's luxuries. They lived in Scotland so Uni was free.....

CutePanda · 03/09/2021 07:28

This is so sad. I would stop ALL money to dss and ex. He will be getting full whack student maintenance loan so won’t be in great need of financial support. If you want to help (despite years of abuse) then maybe you could arrange to buy his compulsory reading list (just send the books, not money)?

He is an adult and he will get full whack student maintenance loan and maybe a grant. If he still needs money then he can work part-time. Don’t give him money.

gogohm · 03/09/2021 07:27

If things were amicable it's fine to pay the mother - my exh gives me spousal maintenance to cover university costs for my two, plus the cost of feeding the one who lives with me holidays etc. But in these circumstances it's trickier - I would establish who the tirade was from, if it's the son then I'm not sure I would pay with talking directly with him without his mother in earshot. Yes it's long distance but he could have made the effort to visit himself in the last couple of years too! (Yes I know covid but 2019 perhaps???)

MeanderingGently · 03/09/2021 07:24

Do not pay anything. The son is an adult, and your DH has had no contact or ever seen him recently.
I wouldn't be sending anything over, even directly to a random bank account (details could be anyone's).....son needs to be seen in person, given some money personally or not at all.

When I was divorced, my ex paid a small amount for each child, as soon as they were adults, no payments. Perfectly acceptable. My children have their own relationship with their father and if he wants to support them or give them anything it goes to them, I am no longer involved and out of the loop these days. As it should be.

Whinginadeville · 03/09/2021 07:24

Walk away he is an adult now allow him to be an adult he will come to you if he wants money/relationship or not if he doesn't. You can't change what has happened you can only change your behaviour block her and try to move on.

DontBeAHaterDear · 03/09/2021 07:24

I wouldn’t be giving the ex anything now but it’s not uncommon for RP and NRP to help their children out at least in the first year of university. It’s your call though, and no one should be sending anyone abusive messages.

I noticed in your OP there’s a lot “we” when actually this is down to your husband, the child’s father. It’s great you’re so supportive but I’m wondering why it’s “are we being unreasonable to stop paying child support” when it’s only your husband paying it. Also, whether he pays it or not, the CMS amount is the minimum (legal) amount to be paid so the child’s father taking the child clothes shopping while he has him is certainly not some terrible affliction or at all unreasonable. Child maintenance payments are expected to go towards the child’s general upkeep, not just clothing and school supplies.