Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying money for step child in uni

266 replies

Thinkingannie · 02/09/2021 23:09

I’ll try to put as much info as poss but will probably forget stuff so apologies in advance…

Background DH has a son from a previous relationship he has nit seen for over 11 years, not his fault. Access was stopped many times then resumed just as we went to court resulting in the court not putting a court order in place. We went to court twice. DSS and EX live approx 500 miles away we live in Scotland, them in the south west so husband has never been able to just pop over but has been turned away from weekend visits numerous times (after driving over seven hours to get there) costing a fortune in both petrol and a hotel room that is nit used but can’t be cancelled, more importantly the emotional toll was high on him. So after going to court twice then being at the ex’s beck and call for years eg phone call on a sat morning come and have DSS this weekend or you’ll never see him again or after driving down being told no you’re not having him now etc, when she stopped access the final time my husband just didn’t have it in him to go to court a third time and just left fighting for access for his own MH. Since then we’ve had no access, have been blocked on social media and have no idea where they live etc. So DSS is now 19 and we stopped CM, we then got a message chasing it up and found out that he is starting uni this month. We have confirmed that CM should be stopped at this point but offered to pay DSS some money direct, if he just sent us his bank details. My DH got a ton of abuse back, not sure if it was the ex who wrote it or the son but it was written as if it was the son.

The ex said you can still give me the money though and I’ll pass it on (not convinced this will happen as it didn’t when we had DSS staying with us as we often had to buy him new clothes pay school stuff etc.

Are we being unreasonable to refuse to pay anyone but DSS direct?

Sorry it’s so long..

OP posts:
Cerebelle · 03/09/2021 12:05

If you use incognito mode on Chrome, you may have more luck finding DSS social media. TBH if he is going to uni, you might be better off waiting until the middle of term to contact him since he will be less likely to be in close contact with his mother, giving him time to think.

Garriet · 03/09/2021 11:58

@Sparechange that’s so sad, I’m sorry that happened to you. What’s your relationship like now with your parents?

I wonder if OP’s husband might hear from his son once he is at university and away from mum.

LittleMysSister · 03/09/2021 11:36

There is no way the message was from SS - why would he be angry about money being sent to him direct instead of his mum, when if he wanted to he could then transfer any amount of it to her?

Sparechange · 03/09/2021 11:36

To give some perspective on what it’s like as a child of a mother who wants to prevent contact with the other parent, me and my siblings went through this after my parents got divorced.

My dad repeatedly went to court to try and see us. My mother knew every tactic in the book
Some times she just wouldn’t turn up to court - judge would throw it out and dad would have to start the whole process again
Sometimes she would turn up, nod along to the dressing down and then just totally disregard it

When he was awarded weekends, she would get us up and out of bed at 6am and drive us to a random friend or relative for us to spend the day
Other days we would literally sit in the car in a car park for hours listening to stories on the stereo until she thought he would have given up waiting at her house

We were told she was a victim of DV, that we were the product of rape, we were told my dad wanted to put us up for adoption
Horrific, constant lies

This went on for years. My dad nearly bankrupted himself with the legal costs but it got him nowhere
She remarried and changed my brothers names to her husband’s new surname when they started at a new school to make it harder for my dad to track them down, she moved house a lot to make it harder for him

Every part of her, and therefore our lives were governed by how she could keep us from seeing him

So all these posters with their bullshit ‘oh he didn’t try hard enough to see his son’
You have absolutely no idea what it’s like when a parent makes it their mission to stop their ex seeing their kids
You have no idea what it’s like as a child being poisoned against your parent. What it’s like to have memories of them being a loving parent and partner and to be gaslit and told it didn’t happen and they hated you
To be told you are unwanted and unloved m

It’s hell, for the child and for the parent

So think before you judge a situation you know very little about

LittleMysSister · 03/09/2021 11:34

Does SS not have a facebook or instagram account his dad can get a message to him through?

SW1amp · 03/09/2021 11:29

@dworky

And driving 7 hours to see him knowing he may or may not be turned away at the door wasn’t making an effort?

I’m sure half the posters on this thread aren’t actually reading the OPs posts before jumping in with their ridiculous comments

MelbourneTerrace · 03/09/2021 11:26

@BungleandGeorge - oh no, I didn't know that...wonder if it can be applied retrospectively?
My DC's father completely refused and then turned up at the graduation ceremony..CF.

I don't think I could have afforded the cost and certainly the stress of going to court. Dealing with the CSA was far too traumatic!

Thinkingannie · 03/09/2021 11:11

I have no idea if he still lives with mum or if he’s going to uni or if it’s a uni close by, no idea at all I have searched but can’t find any info online

OP posts:
cooldarkroom · 03/09/2021 10:44

You don't really know if SS is going to Uni, or if this is a ploy for money.
There is no other logical reason for not allowing money to go directly to SS.

Can you look for son's address on the electoral role?
You have her bank details, She may live in the same town as her branch? You might get lucky. (shot in the dark)
If you could find her address you could go & visit & try & speak to SS, or send him a registered letter (anonymous) that hopefully she wouldn't open.

SunshineCake · 03/09/2021 10:40

Are you sure he's going to uni?

frumpety · 03/09/2021 10:37

How sure are you that DSS still lives with his Mum ?

BungleandGeorge · 03/09/2021 09:57

@MelbourneTerrace

There is no onus on any adult to support any child, even their own through uni so if your DH decided not to do this, it is fine. ( my ex didn't support his son financially).

Good on your DH for the support he has given and wants to continue with especially given how he has been treat.

Absolutely no money should go to DSS's mum. It probably won't be passed on.

In this situation about contact/addresses etc i would be tempted to set up an account, pay the money in and keep it until a time when/if DSS is in touch. It may happen in the future. At that point he would have a small lump some for a house deposit or similar whilst knowing his DF has thought about and planned for him.

That’s not actually the case, it needs to go to court unlike child maintenance and I suspect that puts people off from applying www.family-lawfirm.co.uk/blog/parents-university-fees-and-child-maintenance/
Cuck00soup · 03/09/2021 09:55

Can you find the DSS through other social media? FB isn't the preferred contact of 19 year olds.

Even an Instagram photo of the uni would be a start.

theemmadilemma · 03/09/2021 09:49

For a start it sounds like the mother has completely alienated the child from his father. Which is awful.

However, I still wouldn't trust that the message came from the child. You have no way of knowing for sure.

I think you're right to not pay the mother, not at this point. Try to gain direct contact and see what happens from there. Leave it open for his son to contact him if he wants to, the offer is there.

BungleandGeorge · 03/09/2021 09:45

@aSofaNearYou yes the child can take the parent to court to request the money

However as the father is happy to pay directly that shouldn’t be necessary. With a name, DOB and previous (or current if he’s still there) address an adult should be relatively easy to trace. So they can just get in touch with the son

MelbourneTerrace · 03/09/2021 09:43

There is no onus on any adult to support any child, even their own through uni so if your DH decided not to do this, it is fine. ( my ex didn't support his son financially).

Good on your DH for the support he has given and wants to continue with especially given how he has been treat.

Absolutely no money should go to DSS's mum. It probably won't be passed on.

In this situation about contact/addresses etc i would be tempted to set up an account, pay the money in and keep it until a time when/if DSS is in touch. It may happen in the future. At that point he would have a small lump some for a house deposit or similar whilst knowing his DF has thought about and planned for him.

MrKlaw · 03/09/2021 09:41

Its tricky - while they are adults at 19, the household income is also taken into account when calculating student loans etc.

Its possible that if you send X amount directly to the DSS, the mother may reduce any contribution they make. So the DSS isn' tlosing out but isn't getting the full benefit either. So effectively the mother is getting the benefit of that.

Id' still prefer like OP to transfer directly to the DSS and potentialy (if desired) try and contact directly now they are 'independent' of the parent.

MzHz · 03/09/2021 09:38

@Willyoujustbequiet

You lost me at no contact for 11 years.

There is simply no excuse.

Guessing you didn’t actually read the whole op…

🙄

Bollindger · 03/09/2021 09:37

Your DSS has grandparents and in laws find them on Facebook maybe. Or via home address.

aSofaNearYou · 03/09/2021 09:36

I always doubt 'not his fault'. Unless the child is moved to another country, it is the father's responsibilty to make the effort to see his child on a regular basis.

That's probably because you've never had to spend your life fighting for something that is never going to happen because it is entirely at the mercy of somebody else who is not reasonable.

DancesWithTortoises · 03/09/2021 09:35

Just stop paying OP.

In the fullness of time DSS will see exactly what his mother is. Not one penny more in her greedy little purse.

Goingdriving · 03/09/2021 09:32

I watched a friend go through a similar scenario of extreme Parental alienation. It was very, very painful. Now the boy is older (19) he is slowly coming round, meeting his father, and getting an inkling of the lies and manipulations he’s been fed. he has seen a paper trail of proof of his fathers attempts at contact (ignored like yours), court appearances (emotional and financial drain), correspondence with an abusive mother (flat out lies) and it has really helped him realise that he was not abandoned (as his mother told him).

You need never have anything to do with this woman again. Definitely don’t give her any money. He’s not a child anymore and she does not sound reliable or honest. He may not even be going to university. If he doesn’t want to speak you at this age he can meet and tell you that himself. And if you’re going to pay for him towards university you most definitely have a right to know what university and what course.
I also think that you should feel free to snoop as it’s not for ill ends and I don’t think you can be sure that the son doesn’t want contact or knows the full truth.

dworky · 03/09/2021 09:31

@Medievalist

Did your DH try to initiate contact when his son became old enough for his mother to not be able to block him?
I always doubt 'not his fault'. Unless the child is moved to another country, it is the father's responsibilty to make the effort to see his child on a regular basis.
Neverquitesure1 · 03/09/2021 09:27

@Thinkingannie p.s. under no circumstances should your decisions be affected by allegations of being controlling. Keep full control and explain that you’re doing so unashamedly to ensure that the stepson gets the full benefit. Simply make clear that he’s an adult and as an adult it’s appropriate that any sums are paid to him.

Neverquitesure1 · 03/09/2021 09:24

@Thinkingannie I think it’s unlikely that your stepson is going to university. If that were the case I think that you’d have proactively heard about it from her to sort out money. I think that it’s a lie made up as a knee jerk reaction to the money being stopped.

You and your partner have been caught in this storm unable to think straight for years,

Stand your ground on this one re proof that he’s at university. I suspect he isn’t but even if he is, and you eventually get bank details, ex will likely want to take some or all of the money from him.

What about instead offering to cover rent and pay direct? That would make it easier for him to move out of this toxic home. Or alternatively pay something else direct.

But as I say, I think that your stepson isn’t going to university.

Don’t be guilted or manipulated. Stand your ground.

Finally, his dad did the right thing in stopping the battle. Sometimes, there comes a time (from professional experience) when the ongoing battle is worse for the child than the lack of contact. Your situation is one of them. Your partner did what was best for all involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread