Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying money for step child in uni

266 replies

Thinkingannie · 02/09/2021 23:09

I’ll try to put as much info as poss but will probably forget stuff so apologies in advance…

Background DH has a son from a previous relationship he has nit seen for over 11 years, not his fault. Access was stopped many times then resumed just as we went to court resulting in the court not putting a court order in place. We went to court twice. DSS and EX live approx 500 miles away we live in Scotland, them in the south west so husband has never been able to just pop over but has been turned away from weekend visits numerous times (after driving over seven hours to get there) costing a fortune in both petrol and a hotel room that is nit used but can’t be cancelled, more importantly the emotional toll was high on him. So after going to court twice then being at the ex’s beck and call for years eg phone call on a sat morning come and have DSS this weekend or you’ll never see him again or after driving down being told no you’re not having him now etc, when she stopped access the final time my husband just didn’t have it in him to go to court a third time and just left fighting for access for his own MH. Since then we’ve had no access, have been blocked on social media and have no idea where they live etc. So DSS is now 19 and we stopped CM, we then got a message chasing it up and found out that he is starting uni this month. We have confirmed that CM should be stopped at this point but offered to pay DSS some money direct, if he just sent us his bank details. My DH got a ton of abuse back, not sure if it was the ex who wrote it or the son but it was written as if it was the son.

The ex said you can still give me the money though and I’ll pass it on (not convinced this will happen as it didn’t when we had DSS staying with us as we often had to buy him new clothes pay school stuff etc.

Are we being unreasonable to refuse to pay anyone but DSS direct?

Sorry it’s so long..

OP posts:
Oblomov21 · 05/09/2021 05:22

"How was your husband at court twice and still unable to arrange a contact agreement for his child, who presumably, if he hasn’t seen him in 11 years and the boy is now 19) was only 8 years old? From what you’ve said, it sounds like both times contact started again and he just gave up on court. Understandable once, but odd that he did it twice, and then ‘couldn’t face’ it a third time.

It doesn’t sound like they’ll ever have a good relationship, but I don’t think it can be excused as ‘not his fault’ and I don’t think his son will see it that way.

The abuse coming from the ex is unacceptable, but it sounds like this mess started long ago. I don’t know if there’s any point saving money from birthdays and Christmases that have been missed - a lump sum of money won’t make much difference to that. Would it never have been possible to deliver some money/gifts and a card for the boy at his address?"

The above post was by kanaloa.
I agree completely. Why has your husband never taken proper legal advice and fought properly. A really good lawyer would know many of the tricks these bad type of mothers play, and would present a decent savy case. It might not have resulted in much but at least he'd have known he'd tried everything.

Your excuses are quite weak. Repeatedly giving up. I fear these excuses just wouldn't cut it, if I was his son and this was explained to me now.
Are you both emotionally prepared for that sad possibility?

BlackShadowCat · 05/09/2021 03:58

@LoisLane66

Do you have proof that he's going to uni and which course and which uni? I'd want to do a whole lot of digging before handing money over and want to check that he's really been accepted to do the course and get updates as to his attendance.
It feels a bit like Groundhog Day here.
LoisLane66 · 05/09/2021 03:32

Do you have proof that he's going to uni and which course and which uni?
I'd want to do a whole lot of digging before handing money over and want to check that he's really been accepted to do the course and get updates as to his attendance.

Darbysmama · 05/09/2021 02:14

Do not pay that woman. Pay the son directly or not at all. Additionally, if you are so inclined, I would make it conditional upon him having some sort of contact with your partner. Maybe emails or calls, possibly a few visits to start. I would make it clear that you’ve wanted to have a relationship but have been prevented from doing so. Don’t badmouth the mother. Most assuredly he has been brainwashed into believing that your partner is a deadbeat dad who never made an effort with him. That’s what my mother did with me. She had me convinced my dad was the worst person in the world. It wasn’t until I became an adult that I got to know my dad and my dad’s side of the family. We started with snail mail at first. Then emails. Now? He and my stepfather came to our home to spend the weekend and celebrate my birthday. My point is, as he matures he’s going to have to start thinking for himself, not having mother dearest tell him what to think. So there may be hope for a relationship one day.

Owl55 · 05/09/2021 01:53

At 19 years old I think you should make efforts to contact the son in person (perhaps through an investigator) and find out what he thinks and feels about his father, maybe they could have a relationship without the mother’s interference and offer financial support .

Volhhg · 05/09/2021 01:29

I think you're husband could have made more effort to contact his son between the age of 12 and now. I have read the whole thread and I think although it is traumatic for him you do have to keep going through the most horrific circumstances sometimes for your kids. I think if your husband can't contact him then the next step is to make himself physically present in the area, speak to people there, possible hire an investigator. No don't send the money but to me the important bit about this scenario isn't the money problem

winnieanddaisy · 05/09/2021 00:37

So many mad ideas! Just contact the son and tell him that you're willing to give money direct to him , tried that and was given abuse and threatened with the police .
Phone or write to your son , have no number or address for the son so can't do that .
Contact son via university, can't as they don't know which one .
Dad has been blocked from contacting mum or son via social media etc so can't contact either .
The best one is... open a savings account for the son and put money away for him , dad did that years ago and has been putting money in for Christmas and birthdays , so I'm sure he will do this with the uni money too Wink

Feedingthebirds1 · 04/09/2021 23:51

The mother is pissed off because her ticket on the gravy train has expired.

Honestly OP I would let it drop. No PI, no solicitor, no response to the mother. You have absolutely no idea about anything to do with their lives because she's blocked all avenues. You have no evidence that he's going to university. You've had no contact for years, until she wants to renew her meal ticket. She's had more than the CSA would award her for however many years.

By all means put money aside and hope that one day you'll be able to give it to DSS on the basis of having created a good relationship. But for now, no more to her regardless of her claims she'll give it to DSS. You're right not to trust her, and any further action on yours and DH's part to try to reinstate contact is just likely to be more heartbreak for DH. So let it go and don't feel bad.

Flufftc · 04/09/2021 23:40

If you have no direct contact with DSS and he is now an adult..why don’t you set up some sort of trust fund that you can pay into and save something on his behalf…when all the s**t has died down or you are in a better position to communicate directly with DSS you can then talk to him about the funds you have saved! ..it seems it’s pretty pointless at the moment trying to talk to either Ex or DSS as clearly they are not willing to communicate on a reasonable level…I would stop all communications and tell them you are paying into a trust fund (you can get proof/evidence if you go through a proper financial advisor) that can be redeemed when they/he is ready to talk properly and sensibly about the future..this way you retain a little control over the situation and are not constantly on the “back foot” to Ex’s demands now DSS is an adult.

jozipozi31 · 04/09/2021 23:27

Make this simple.

DH says to her:

Our son is now an adult, therefore all future dealings and any financial support will be direct with him. Please ask him to give me a call or send a text and I'll take it from there.

And that is it. Not one penny ever again to her. And the son needs to act for himself now.

He might not even be at uni. You know nothing for sure.

Sorry, OP. But just keep it v simple.

justasking111 · 04/09/2021 23:26

If you know what university he's going to it's easy to contact him directly. My friend went to university her real dad was finally able to contact her. It was a shock at first she thought her stepfather was her natural father until then

Are you sure he's going to university, have you proof of this

Strangeways19 · 04/09/2021 23:10

DSS is 19 years old, the ex needs to back off, try to contact DSS again directly, ask him to meet to discuss face-to-face, & refuse any more contact with his mother.

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 04/09/2021 23:10

I don’t get on with my ex, but I can’t fault him re supporting ds. He paid the agreed amount each month, and only just stopped as legally it ends the summer after he turns 19 (I’d only expected it until 16/18). The last year or so I gave ds the money as he was living in halls for uni for most of it, so didn’t feel right keeping it. His dad’s told him he’ll now give him money direct when he can, which is fair enough, and between the two of them. So based on that I’d say YANBU.

Pinkfluff76 · 04/09/2021 22:56

Even if you manage to pay direct to the boy you don’t know that the money is going towards uni or she takes it. Good luck OP

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/09/2021 22:41

Rainbowunicorn

There is simply no excuse. I'm a lawyer and have been through the system on a personal level too.

Damn right I judge. It's not bitchy to call out parents that give up on their kids. There's always some excuse

MidsummerMimi · 04/09/2021 22:36

I would view this as an opportunity for your DH and his DS to start over.
To be deprived of access to your own child must be beyond heartbreaking.
Also for a child to grow up in a home filled with so much hate for his Dad, must be so sad and toxic.
Your DH clearly tried to to have contact and a relationship with his DS, which was constantly obstructed and thwarted by the Mum.
The DS is an adult now and there is still hope that a Father and Son relationship can finally develop.
All the lost years can never be returned, but there could be many many good years ahead.
I think the fact that DS needs help with University costs, is an opportunity to bring Father and Son together.
I think your DH should contact his DS as directly as possible, absolutely bypassing the Mum completely.
Ideally they should have an honest conversation where your DH gets to tell his son how he “lost “ him all those years ago and how much that hurt.
If the DSS harbours resentment and bad feelings towards your DH, that is totally understandable as he will have grown up possibly never hearing a good word about his Dad.
The relationship may be less than perfect and may be bloody difficult at times, but it is their relationship and they are both entitled to that.DSS needs to hear his Dad’s side of the story and learn for himself who his Dad is, instead of accepting someone else’s version.
They have both suffered the loss of each other, because of someone else’s cruel actions.
They both will have work to do to build what has been broken.
DH is being given a second chance here, it may not be easy but it would be so sad to lose his DS all over again.

Pebbledashery · 04/09/2021 21:40

I don't blame your husband for not having the fight left in him. Usually I absolutely, categorically do not respect men who intentionally don't see their children, but having seen from your post the effort he's been to and just had the door slammed in his face, I can imagine he feels brow beaten. Don't give in to her demands, she obviously uses that money on her otherwise she wouldn't be bothered. Your SS is the only person to receive that money.

Queenofeverything44 · 04/09/2021 21:35

I would just put some money in an account so if/when dss contacts you, you have it to give him.
My ex paid me the maintenance through to college but when eldest dd went to uni he took some of her portion and paid directly to her and although she finished uni this may, he still pays it to he until she gets a decent paying job.
In your case it seems the mother is doing whatever she can to prolong the payments. Are you even sure dss has got into uni. She may be spinning a line.
Bank it and tell mummy dearest to bog off!

impatientwatcher · 04/09/2021 20:59

I agree pay the child direct or not at all but, the son may not want the money. Even if he did contact his Dad, as you said the Dad has made no effort to contact his son for 11 years. Why? His Mum is apparently just too unpleasant to deal with. So the Dad left the son with a parent he knew to be a selfish and horrible person, as it was too hard for him?!? You realise exactly how shit that is going to sound to a young adult?

Also for the people saying call the uni etc, a uni will not even confirm someone is on roll without prior consent so you will get absolutely nowhere with that.

Baxterbear · 04/09/2021 20:19

Open a savings account and the absent dad can pay money into that for when/if the son has a relationship with him in the future.

Wally1983 · 04/09/2021 19:47

Direct to him or not at all. Simple message. If either of them are that greedy to persue then they’d be told the same. Disgusting on either part and I’m sorry your going through this! Hope you can get it resolved that you can help contribute to his studies (should he wish the help going forward and you’re willing too!)

Hertsgirl10 · 04/09/2021 19:40

I would set up an account to put what ever money that you want to for him, not that you have to but if it’s what you want to do.

The ex sounds awful it’s obviously the boys mum that sent the msg it’s an awful situation to be in.

ChristmasFluff · 04/09/2021 19:27

V fishy.

If he's going to Uni, the Student finance for England/Wales/wherever will ask for info.

And since he is not resident with you, yourDH income is of no consequence anyway.

Anything DH wants to give or not give, and who he wants to give it to, is up to him.

DonaPatrizia · 04/09/2021 19:13

Sorry this is happening OP. I don’t think you and your DH should pay either his ex or his son as things stand. My suspicion is your DH wants to pay because that’s the only vestige of a relationship he has with his son, but if he doesn’t even know where his son lives, there is no relationship, you are both just being shaken down.
If DSS wants to get in contact with DH then that would be quite easy through social media, but he’s choosing not to. It may be his mind has been poisoned by his mother or it may be he feels no connection. (The mother was definitely behind the abusive message, no student turns down money). Your DH has paid for years, which was the right thing to do, but has been deprived of a relationship with his son. The son is old enough now that if he wants a relationship with your DH, he can do so independently of his mother. Is there a family member who you can ask to say discreetly to DSS that if he wants to connect with his Dad, the door is open, eg an in law or family friend? The best you can attempt at this point is to try to communicate to DSS that you’d like to have a relationship with him.
Sadly, your DH may have to accept his son is not in his life, at least not for the time being. It’s always possible the situation will change in future. It may not, sadly, as his mother may have poisoned his mind irrevocably. But there’s no reason you should pay him directly, let alone the mother, when you are given abuse. Cut both of them off unless and until you are given an apology. It sounds harsh but this is a rabbit hole. No good will come of making concessions. The mother is a manipulator and a scam merchant who is taking advantage of your good nature and DH’s loss of his son.

Good luck.

Mamanyt · 04/09/2021 18:30

Although I would not send the son any money, and if asked why, tell the son that his message to his father was the reason. You'll know pretty quickly if he knew anything about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread