Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform policy should be enforced?

266 replies

Runoverbyllamas · 02/09/2021 22:55

Otherwise what’s the point?
Why bother to have a uniform, state it in detail online and in welcome packs, and then say nothing when kids aren’t wearing correct uniform?
We’re talking a state school with nothing needing to be logo, supermarket brands are fine and the colours are easily available.

A friend has had enough because she made sure her kids were dressed correctly and then others in the class were wearing leggings, trainers, wrong colours etc, and her kids were getting cross about it. On approaching the Head all she got was ‘be glad you can afford to get the correct uniform’. The kids who hadn’t were in premium brands ffs! Plus my friend actually saved to make sure she had the right things, she doesn’t have a lot of money to spare.
The school PTA also does preloved at very small cost to parents, so there’s just no excuse.
One of the more annoying parents of the kids in trainers told her that ‘PFB doesn’t like school shoes’ as if that’s a good enough reason.
This has been going on for at least a year now, and friend is getting more and more frustrated that nothing is being addressed.

AIBU?

OP posts:
CMZ2018 · 03/09/2021 20:26

Sounds like a great school, I’m sure all the pupils will do well in life

GreenLakes · 03/09/2021 20:18

@trumpisagit

Trainers are certainly not suitable for any school imo.

Schools are professional environments, which means smart black shoes should be worn.

jewel1968 · 03/09/2021 20:17

My DC primary school had an amazing head. She wasn't really interested in a school uniform. Some parents put pressure on and eventually the head relented (a little) and arranged a uniform but it was optional. I would say about 5% wore a uniform. It was a great school with fab teachers. I personally never bothered with the uniform.

trumpisagit · 03/09/2021 20:14

If its primary, I really think it doesn't matter.
DS2 seems to have got away with wearing black trainers throughout primary school.
If school insisted he would have to wear shoes, but tbh I think trainers are more appropriate for primary school.

CheshireChat · 03/09/2021 20:11

My son has sensory issues and simply wouldn't cope with the top button done up or a tie, there's no official diagnosis yet as the assessment period was a min of 18 months prior to Covid.

His school accept this and focus on the things that actually matter rather than push him out Hmm.

He's also gone in his PE joggers as his trousers weren't dry- dryer broke. Is keeping him at home for a day really better?

He also went to school in colourful trainers as his new school shoes gave him blisters.

cansu · 03/09/2021 19:59

Is the school otherwise good?

I do sometimes find that if the school won't enforce simple rules like uniforms it usually means they also won't enforce good behaviour in lessons. In my experience (teacher) it usually denotes a SLT who sweep stuff under the carpet and let things go. It isn't a good sign.

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 03/09/2021 19:52

I was bullied because we couldn't afford the correct uniform at high school.
I had the latest trainers ( on some kind of god awful credit payment plan) but that wasn't an option for uniform

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 18:10

Having a uniform makes everyone equal😂😂😂😂

chocolateorangeinhaler · 03/09/2021 18:04

This again??

Yes they should enforce the uniform. It teaches respect and being in a team. Lots of employers have a uniform or policy on what is acceptable.

It's not a fashion show. Some kids would get bullied for not having the latest whatever because parents couldn't afford it. Having a uniform makes everyone equal.

Jemand · 03/09/2021 17:59

Look we all know that in the vast majority of cases, the school with shit discipline, unenforced rules and parents who don’t give a crap are not exactly producing great results. They’re typically sink schools where children come from deprived backgrounds, but the entire education they get just reinforces that with low expectations, low results and no chance of getting anywhere in life.

Well, no, we don't. Look at, for instance, Finland, widely regarded as one of the most successful education systems around - no uniform. The same is true of numerous schools all over Europe. Look at St Paul's Girl's School (92.4% A and A* in A levels last year) - no uniform. Look at the various examples cited on this thread.

It’s why you have schools like Michaela, with educators who say actually children from deprived backgrounds CAN get top results with a bit of discipline and parental buy-in. The kids they take would have no future in sink schools but see a whole world of opportunity opened to them

I really wouldn't go down the Michaela route if I were you. Practices that really don't bear close scrutiny in relation to SEN and discipline policies, and the jury is very much out on how their products fare out in the big wide world without, shall we say, such a very prescriptive form of education.

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 17:55

my friend actually saved to make sure she had the right things, she doesn’t have a lot of money to spare. That is really sad that have to scrimp and save to buy school uniform - the whole uniform system is crazy. We had a very strict state school uniform anyone stepping out of line with even a hair clip had hell rain down on them - totally disproportionate. Your friend will eventually be bloody glad that her kids go to a school with a human approach to dressing.

Jemand · 03/09/2021 17:51

@pointythings, I'd go along with much of your list except I'd suggest that being able to continue to wear the old uniform shouldn't be limited to those in the final year, it should be possible throughout the school, bearing in mind that some families need to be able to reuse uniform for younger children. The rules should also require schools to allow for a side choice of freely available colours, e.g. not insist on black trousers with no discretion to opt for grey. That way, even if they do have children in a range of uniforms when they move to a new uniform, it won't be that noticeable anyway.

Love the Ofsted sanction. In fact, I think Ofsted should build this into the inspection framework anyway, because a school that excludes lower income children and children with disabilities by rigid draconian uniform rules requiring expensive clothes is by definition failing.

Sprogonthetyne · 03/09/2021 17:42

@maverickess

Totally agree, anyone saying supermarket uniform is "inexpensive" or "easily available" has never had to balance a budget to the penny just to get by.

I went all the way through primary school only owned 3 school jumpers (1 at a time, lasting 2/3 years). If I split beans down in on Monday it was going to be a cold week, despite having other warm clothes at home. Because aparently freezing in a polo in December made me more "level" then wereing a different coloured jumper.Hmm

Maverickess · 03/09/2021 17:20

@Sprogonthetyne

No offence taken, sorry if my post came across like I was, I totally agree with what you said because my DD had friends in some of those situations, and although we didn't have a lot, one of them took to staying here on a Friday night because she got her uniform washed alongside my DDs and a meal, which I'm not at all sure she got at home all the time.
I just wanted to point out to some of the others on this thread that have decided that people who struggle to provide uniform consistently aren't feckless and buying £100 trainers or just want to buck the system, but as ever, having little money gives less options that others people take for granted. And punishing kids for any of those things, which more than my DDs old school do, makes a mockery of this 'uniform is a great leveller' argument.
💐🍷

Bookworm20 · 03/09/2021 17:07

@IWantT0BreakFree

I work in a school. I think uniform is extremely important. It's a leveller and helps to disguise the huge disparity between the haves and the have-nots. Our school is shite at enforcing uniform and it's heartbreaking to see the social struggles that some of the kids have as a result. On the one hand, it's a symptom and not the root of the problem I.e. those children who are excluding others on the basis of how "uncool" they are need to actually learn to be less shallow, less judgemental, less materialistic and more accepting and kind. On the other hand, having a uniform policy (which is upheld) is one easy way for schools to help reduce the impact of the wealth gap during the school day. It's the low hanging fruit. I appreciate that there's an argument that uniform stifles creativity, but I see little creativity from the families who flout the uniform rules. Those children are generally identikit copies with the same expensive branded leggings, sportswear, trainers etc. It's not the kids with hand-me-downs and Asda trainers for PE who are desperate to wear their own clothes.
Biggest load of tripe I've read today.

And for what its worth, I can afford to buy uniform and my dc go to school in uniform.

But I note one of them does currently have asda trainers and all have had hand me downs from cousins (and each other) before now! (Isn't that normal?)

But thanks for judging them as probably having social struggles and neglected, based on those things.

Bookworm20 · 03/09/2021 16:58

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

But it doesn't work like that when the rules you are enforcing are stupid

Plenty of people don't think uniform rules are stupid. Millions upon millions of adult jobs have uniforms or clothing rules - offices, retail, cafes, armed forces, emergency services, medical, fitness/gyms. Much of what childhood is all about is preparation for adulthood. In the past children didnt spend every minute of their time playing, they would have been with adults learning important skills & social rules in preparation for adulthood. This is the modern day equivalent.

Yes, ADULT jobs. Adult. This is mainly to identify the personnel of that company.

Some of the rules for uniform in schools are just ridiculous. Children should be able to learn without the stress of worrying they haven't got the right trousers on today because they got dirty and mum wasn't able to get them washed and dried in time.
As long as the kids turn up for school and ready to learn, that's the main point of it. Not preventing that exact thing because of what brand of shoe they are wearing.

Sprogonthetyne · 03/09/2021 16:57

@Maverickess

Apologies if I have offended, I was only really giving one example, but you are right to point out that there could be several reasons why a child genuinely can't to come to school in uniform. Non non of which are the child’s 'fault', so totally inappropriate to punish for.

severelysound · 03/09/2021 16:53

Some people live on a parallel universe.

£100 Nike trainers Confused?

I think the most expensive ones you can buy in JD are £65, my DDs are £45. And they actually last. Unlike the Clarks I used to get sucked into buying for my eldest before I wised up and realised it's a complete false economy. They're £45 for the buckle type ones which are no good in winter so need to be replaced with £60 boots.

You can go to Asda etc and spend £20 on those ones, but quality is always more important with shoes (and coats) since it's the one thing they wear every day. And they still need trainers anyway?

So £45 for "designer brands" or £20 + £20 for supermarket brands or £45 + £45 + £60 for higher quality shoes.

It makes zero sense.

Look we all know that in the vast majority of cases, the school with shit discipline, unenforced rules and parents who don’t give a crap are not exactly producing great results. They’re typically sink schools where children come from deprived backgrounds, but the entire education they get just reinforces that with low expectations, low results and no chance of getting anywhere in life.

This is BS ime. I'm in one of those mixed deprivation areas and for years people have fought tooth and nail to get their kids into the stricter Catholic school (in Scotland, it's local school or local Catholic school).
They have homework while ours have none.
They have logo'd bookbags while ours have none.
They have an enforced uniform policy of logos and no leggings or polos or trainers while ours have none.

This year the shit discipline primary scored better than the disciplined one, scoring almost double for "listening and talking".

I wonder why that is?

Could it be that the school providing the better nurturing environment for primary school children is perhaps better at producing children who can analyse, understand, critique, debate, participate in group discussions confidently, listen, evaluate, present reasoned and logical arguments etc than the school churning out the next generation of worker bees who don't question the authority of The Rules?

I'd rather have a child who questioned the premise and thought about the logic than a child who followed along blindly because someone decided that was the way it is.

We need to get away from this thinking that school is to mould you into the exact type of employee big business wants, and that's the only definition of "getting somewhere in life".

pointythings · 03/09/2021 16:49

If we're going to have uniform, and I would far rather we did not, then it should be:

100% available from high street/supermarket suppliers. Abolish single suppliers completely.

Logos to be made available in sew on or iron on form and at cost.

28 working day grace period for things that involve parents needing to replace worn out/outgrown items to allow for working parents and those who cannot afford to buy until next pay day.

6 month lead time for any uniform changes, and all pupils to be allowed to wear previous uniform if in final year of school.

Breach of the above rules to result in immediate OFSTED with inevitable outcome of Requires Improvement status at least.

Expensive uniform is essentially selection by wealth via the back door and is absolutely unethical.

Nsky · 03/09/2021 16:42

Logos need to banned, unless can be sewn one

Maverickess · 03/09/2021 16:31

@Sprogonthetyne

Agree with what you've said, but I'd add these into your list too, because not all children in these situations have parents who can't/won't care for them -

  1. Got themselves up alone (because all adults are passed out or are out at work because they can't afford not to be)
  1. Got dressed in whatever smells least (because there's no one doing their washing, and even if there was the electric's been cut off again) or put on what's available because their parent(s) can't afford to, or don't have the time to, replace something broken, on demand, just like that
  1. Choose to go to school (because there's no one who cares enough to make them or the parent who cares very much, again, is out at work because they don't have an option not to)

My DD was punished for having a parent who couldn't drop everything at a moment's notice to appease school uniform rules.

Sprogonthetyne · 03/09/2021 16:14

You think they should give detention to a kid who's:

  1. Got themselves up alone (because all adults are passed out)
  1. Got dressed in whatever smells least (because there's no one doing their washing, and even if there was the electric's been cut off again)
  1. Choose to go to school (because there's no one who cares enough to make them)

Ok, that won't be the situation for all the kids, but it most likely will be for some of them. You can't enforce rules for some and not others without causing resentment, and effectively painting a poor sign on the kids who don't get pulled up for uniform.

Good for the school, prioritising the kids education and well-being over the schools image. Your friend sounds like a dick.

PhoboPhobia · 03/09/2021 15:57

@GreenLakes

The DC’s school have a very strict uniform and are also very strict about how it is worn.

Top buttons done up, tie covering top button, shirt tucked in, shoes polished and blazers and jumpers on at all times unless a teacher gives permission is the expectation.

Things like coats and bags all have to have the school logo.

Detentions are given for non-compliance. It think it’s great- everyone looks smart and there are clear standards.

The DC do sometimes get annoyed- DS1 wasn’t even allowed long trousers at his prep until year 6. But I do think a strictly enforced uniform policy is beneficial overall.

But what if you can’t afford to buy all that school branded stuff?
Jemand · 03/09/2021 15:53

[quote inappropriateraspberry]@Jemand I'm not saying all uniform policies are right, and I don't agree with expensive logos on all items, but basic uniform of correct coloured trouser/skirts, white shirt, correct coloured jumper and black shoes isn't hard to do. Schools shouldn't be draconian and as long as all pupils have clean, smart uniform there is leeway in having expensive logoed stuff. My children's school is happy for you to wear a plain blue jumper and that's fine. But I'm not happy that they say black trousers etc, and half the school wear grey. Black is sold ina ok the local supermarkets/shops. [/quote]
You get relatively little argument from me here, @inappropriateraspberry. My view is that we should abolish uniform, but if we must have some then it should be more or less along the lines you envisage, provided of course that the "correct coloured jumper" is something that parents can pick up easily in supermarkets, M&S etc - and provided that schools allow quite a hefty degree of leeway. And NO school logos. But it seems to me that rather than making a fuss about allowing only black trousers, it would be much better to say black/dark blue/grey. Similarly shoes should offer a similar choice with small manufacturers' logos allowed.

Fifthtimelucky · 03/09/2021 15:51

Personally I'm in favour of uniform but that's not the point.

If a school isn't going to enforce a uniform policy they shouldn't have one.