Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform policy should be enforced?

266 replies

Runoverbyllamas · 02/09/2021 22:55

Otherwise what’s the point?
Why bother to have a uniform, state it in detail online and in welcome packs, and then say nothing when kids aren’t wearing correct uniform?
We’re talking a state school with nothing needing to be logo, supermarket brands are fine and the colours are easily available.

A friend has had enough because she made sure her kids were dressed correctly and then others in the class were wearing leggings, trainers, wrong colours etc, and her kids were getting cross about it. On approaching the Head all she got was ‘be glad you can afford to get the correct uniform’. The kids who hadn’t were in premium brands ffs! Plus my friend actually saved to make sure she had the right things, she doesn’t have a lot of money to spare.
The school PTA also does preloved at very small cost to parents, so there’s just no excuse.
One of the more annoying parents of the kids in trainers told her that ‘PFB doesn’t like school shoes’ as if that’s a good enough reason.
This has been going on for at least a year now, and friend is getting more and more frustrated that nothing is being addressed.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Jemand · 04/09/2021 22:03

@so750

3 children were expelled from our primary school because they took the school logo off the school top. Wearing a logo went against their religious beliefs. The head wasn't prepared to compromise.
I do hope their parents challenged this, as its a direct breach of the official guidance on the part of the school. They could also get sued for discrimination.
FishfingerFlinger · 04/09/2021 12:23

It might be obvious to children who the poorest kids are, but not having a uniform is an extra way in which children can be picked on or feel lesser than their peers. And it extends right through the spectrum of wealth. I don’t think it is helpful for children of any social background to feel pressure at school to have the ‘right’ trainers or latest gear. You’ll never eliminate it of course, but uniform reduces that pressure.

I think the answers are probably:
-simple uniform with minimal/no branded items
-fairly enforced (giving children and parents a chance to remedy if they don’t have the uniform, but not a ‘free for all’ where people are routinely floating the rules so they can show off their trainers)
-options (second hand sales, loans, financial support) for those on lowest incomes
-good pastoral care that recognises signs that children not in uniform may need investigation for the underlying reason, not immediate punishment.

ItsSnowJokes · 04/09/2021 11:13

@Popetthetreehugger

My DC are parents themselves, with 3 DGC starting school this week . I work in a school with a very mixed catchment . My thoughts are uniform makes life in the morning a doddle , it’s a spun line that people can’t afford uniform , it’s going to be the haves who will wear expensive clothes and trainers and the obvious have nots who will be put under pressure to come up with clothes their families can’t afford . So students will have a self made uniform of designer clothes. The punishment for not conforming is ridicule instead of detention. Uniform is a leveller . Our 6form is non uniform, but by this age they are savvy enough to be their own people who aren’t impressed by clothes one way or the other .
I have said before on this thread that uniform is not a leveller in any way shape or form. It is bull that it is. Students still know who is poor and who has money. Students going to school with holes in their shoes while others have brand new shoes as and when needed. Cleaning of uniform (and themselves) is also a big clue to a lot of people.

Other countries manage perfectly well without uniform and if they do have a uniform it is normally a lot more basic than in the UK and they certainly don't have the draconian rules that you will be excluded if you have black instead of white socks on etc.......

Of a uniform is needed it should be a very basic uniform of a plain, non branded tracksuit with a polo shirt available from a variety of supermarkets. Schools should not be allowed to specify branding, they should certainly not be allowed to give contracts to sole suppliers of uniform.

so750 · 04/09/2021 10:44

3 children were expelled from our primary school because they took the school logo off the school top. Wearing a logo went against their religious beliefs. The head wasn't prepared to compromise.

Popetthetreehugger · 04/09/2021 10:23

My DC are parents themselves, with 3 DGC starting school this week . I work in a school with a very mixed catchment . My thoughts are uniform makes life in the morning a doddle , it’s a spun line that people can’t afford uniform , it’s going to be the haves who will wear expensive clothes and trainers and the obvious have nots who will be put under pressure to come up with clothes their families can’t afford . So students will have a self made uniform of designer clothes. The punishment for not conforming is ridicule instead of detention. Uniform is a leveller . Our 6form is non uniform, but by this age they are savvy enough to be their own people who aren’t impressed by clothes one way or the other .

DumplingsAndStew · 04/09/2021 09:58

I must remember to tell my GP she's not professional, maybe she should consider a shirt and tie combo.

Might pop in and speak to my solicitor too.

UndertheCedartree · 04/09/2021 01:17

@inappropriateraspberry

All those saying they may not be able to afford uniform - there are grants/free uniform available for those that are struggling. It is not a surprise - all parents know if there is uniform in the local schools, so can prepare. I always see inform for sale or free on Facebook - it's not expensive for the basics in the right colours.
That is not universal! It depends on the school what they spend their pupil premium on.

When my DD started Primary I was very unwell and in hospital so money was very tight. The school were great and let us go in the school 2nd hand shop where we could get items for 50p. This undoubtedly saved me a lot of money. I managed to get 2 pinafores, a polo, a fleece, a P.E t-shirt and shorts in her size. They also gave her a free water bottle and said not to worry with black shoes/trainers - she could just wear the pink sparkly trainers she had! I still had to buy a pinafore, a pack of polos, tights/socks, plimsolls, book bag, cardigan, P.E bag, joggers and hoodie. Also got her some school hair accessories which while not essential I wanted her to look nice. Cost around £100 which was a fortune to me at the time.

CheshireChat · 03/09/2021 23:29

As far as I know, none of those places offer uniform for free in my son's school. Best I know is a little fair where each item will 50p, but have no idea if my son's school is amongst that.

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 23:10

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Sirfredfredgeorge

Uniform is given away free:

  • at stalls by school
  • on the local facebook page
  • on the class list app
  • on local whatsapp groups

This is communicated in letters and emails from school, widely by word of mouth, with adverts on the notice board by the local shops etc. Honestly you have to put effort in to not be able to manage to get some.

Effort that you are required to put in because you are poor. Because if you are poor you are clearly feckless and lazy and have loads of free time? Ever heard of the working poor - who do several jobs just to exist? You live under a bloody stone. None of this is easily available where I live.
CheshireChat · 03/09/2021 23:06

Debate about uniform aside, the best option for your friend would've been to have been told clearly what the uniform actually is. And what they actually expect.

And if their policy didn't include logoed items from the beginning, that would have been ideal.

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 23:06

@TheReluctantPhoenix

Schools will never win.

Some parents think uniform is vitally important whereas others don’t want it at all.

Schools are, however, package deals. They are not a la carte.

Of course it is reasonable to complain if you feel that you have been treated unfairly or you think a school has failed to follow its own policy. However, ultimately, only the school sees the whole picture of the needs of individual children. And, ultimately, if you and the school are totally opposed, it is time to move schools.

This response pisses me off! Move schools? Have you tried? There is no choice! All our local schools have banded together on the superficial uniform thing - so tell me where to move my kids - there is no fucking choice from the madness that insists that people need to dress the same to succeed.
Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 22:43

that a whole profession can't cope with kids wearing comfortable shoes

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 22:26

[quote GreenLakes]@trumpisagit

Trainers are certainly not suitable for any school imo.

Schools are professional environments, which means smart black shoes should be worn.[/quote]
Every post about uniform reveal weird opinions - children have to dress in formal black shoes because it's a professional environment - do trainers offend the professionals because children are not professionals - don't think that's too radical? - Don't you find that uncomfortable, that a whole profession can cope with kids wearing comfortable shoes - school uniform is a really weird fetish, the Brits just can't let go of.

CecilyP · 03/09/2021 22:19

The website and school paperwork stated very clearly what uniform was required, and that they expected it to be worn correctly as it was all widely available from a range of shops, secondhand was available too, and should it not be correct the kids would face sanctions (unspecified).

I can understand why your friend is annoyed, but it’s possible the website hasn’t been changed for years. Often things are more flexible than websites, or formerly uniform lists, would imply, which parents don’t know unless they know the school. Often the Y7s will have the uniform to the last button, so the whole cohort is the same, while the older children have more variation. If pupils start higher up a in a new school, the will differ more from the rest of their classmates. They’ll just have to wear what they have for now (and they won’t be the only pupils wearing the correct uniform whatever they tell their mum) and she can think twice how to replace things when outgrown/outworn.

UndertheCedartree · 03/09/2021 22:04

Just concentrate on your own kids, I'd say! Not sure what is so bad about trainers. My DD wears trainers everyday - much more practical for school. This is allowed by her school, by the way. Lots of the girls wear leggings on P.E days too, tbf not on normal uniform days. But honestly I couldn't get worked up about a DC wearing leggings and trainers. As long as they are comfortable, who cares?

CoffeeWithCheese · 03/09/2021 21:54

Friend's about to have to move (military family being moved posting) and she's got into a heck of a lot of debt to try to sort out the new school's ridiculously strict uniform.

I hear your friend on the school move thing - mine switched schools right near the end of last year - but I did ring and ask the Head (tiny school so he quite often answers the school phone) if they were OK to swerve logged uniform and just come in in supermarket stuff in the right colour for the tiny remaining bit of the term - which was fine. Ours seem to all start in September in the fancy logo and coloured stuff and then by the end of the year people are just in plain unlogoed supermarket top up stuff.

I like the fact the kids' school HAS a uniform in that it reduces the amount I've got to think on a morning - but I do like the fact that it still allows supermarket clothing and leeway for sensory/motor skills type issues (DD2 can't manage some clothing still - especially post-lockdown after not needing to wear school shirts - she doesn't have the finger strength to do it properly at present and her list of sensory "things" gets longer by the week at the moment)

CatsArePeople · 03/09/2021 21:53

Schools are professional environments, which means smart black shoes should be worn.

There is no logical need for kids to look like office rats.

CecilyP · 03/09/2021 21:52

GreenLakes
@trumpisagit
Trainers are certainly not suitable for any school imo.

Of course they are. Especially suitable for boys who play football at break.

Schools are professional environments, which means smart black shoes should be worn.

Small children are professionals? Who knew! Would you care to say what profession they are following?

BigWhooper · 03/09/2021 21:49

Surely it's really sensible for children to wear trainers? They're pretty active people who do best with a rough and tumble approach to life.

Even schools know children need to be active. Eg my dd's school had a big initiative to get everyone walk there and run a mile around the playground in laps at breaktime. But they were all wearing dress shoes! Like wtaf?

pointythings · 03/09/2021 21:40

[quote GreenLakes]@trumpisagit

Trainers are certainly not suitable for any school imo.

Schools are professional environments, which means smart black shoes should be worn.[/quote]
I have no words.

I am a professional, and until lockdown was working in a professional environment. Nobody, but nobody wore 'smart black shoes'. We were all great at our jobs. Uniforms have their place - in healthcare, the police and possibly supermarkets. In many other work environments, dress codes are being relaxed and culture is changing towards one where it matters less what you wear and more how competent you are. And about time too.

Runoverbyllamas · 03/09/2021 20:55

£300 for 2 kids isn’t especially massive, but it was money she didn’t easily have and that the school seemed to insist she spend. She and the kids didn’t even get inside the place before they started due to covid restrictions so could only go by policy. I find that incredibly unfair.

They should just ditch the policy. That’s my view. She can’t afford the pricey gear anyway but now they have the uniform they need to wear it. She would just like a bit of back up on that. I don’t think that’s too much to ask tbh.

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 03/09/2021 20:46

So your friend massively overpaid for uniform, and as a result her kids don't have other important stuff. And kids are now resentful.
The point is that the school uniform isn't that important at the end of the day.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 03/09/2021 20:42

Far from enforcing it, I think it should be gone. It's an unnecessary custom, especially when policed to the nth degree as it is in so many secondary school, and many nations with higher literacy and numeracy achievement than the UK manage perfectly well without it.

If parents are too wet to tell their kids they'll have to get weekend jobs if they want expensive, branded gear - which was the condition my parents handed down to me - it's their own lookout.

Runoverbyllamas · 03/09/2021 20:37

Ok, this got more fraught than I expected.
To answer some questions, the school is a secondary.
And yes it is my friend and not me. She moved away during the lockdown. Kids moved school. The website and school paperwork stated very clearly what uniform was required, and that they expected it to be worn correctly as it was all widely available from a range of shops, secondhand was available too, and should it not be correct the kids would face sanctions (unspecified).

She went to a huge amount of effort to get it all given they were moving mid year and had a lot of other expenses in moving. The colours were not the same as anyone local so without knowing people and not wanting the kids to stick out when they were new, she bought it all new. Then it turns out that a huge number of kids are wearing whatever without any consequence. She ignored initially as covid made things hard for many, but then the school stated that proper uniform was needed for the new school year. And the same kids are back in, with apparently brand new expensive trainers and clothing, and the Head doesn’t seem to care. I find it hard to believe that many have sensory issues if I’m honest. They’re just chancing their arm.

It’s the lack of care, the lack of backing her up as a parent, and the blatant rule breaking that’s the concern. Kids don’t get to pick and choose which school rules they follow.
I don’t know the kids, the school, the Head. My own experience is that rules are enforced. I just wondered what the point in having the rules is in the first place if that’s how they want to play it. She spent over £300 on uniform for 2 kids that they are now getting cross about wearing, and she doesn’t buy fancy brands that would be acceptable to these other kids. At least if there is a policy it should be followed. That’s the point.

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 03/09/2021 20:33

YABU.
Not your circus, not your monkeys.
Your friend is welcome to find another school where uniforms would be more up to her taste.