Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform policy should be enforced?

266 replies

Runoverbyllamas · 02/09/2021 22:55

Otherwise what’s the point?
Why bother to have a uniform, state it in detail online and in welcome packs, and then say nothing when kids aren’t wearing correct uniform?
We’re talking a state school with nothing needing to be logo, supermarket brands are fine and the colours are easily available.

A friend has had enough because she made sure her kids were dressed correctly and then others in the class were wearing leggings, trainers, wrong colours etc, and her kids were getting cross about it. On approaching the Head all she got was ‘be glad you can afford to get the correct uniform’. The kids who hadn’t were in premium brands ffs! Plus my friend actually saved to make sure she had the right things, she doesn’t have a lot of money to spare.
The school PTA also does preloved at very small cost to parents, so there’s just no excuse.
One of the more annoying parents of the kids in trainers told her that ‘PFB doesn’t like school shoes’ as if that’s a good enough reason.
This has been going on for at least a year now, and friend is getting more and more frustrated that nothing is being addressed.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 14:28

@pointythings

Pumperthepumper this. How much time is wasted in British schools policing uniform infringements? What's wrong with extending simple 6th form dress codes across the board? Once the novelty of wearing your own clothes wears off, they'll all just turn up in jeans/leggings/t-shirts/sweatshirts. And if bullying occurs, crack down on that - which schools should be doing anyway.

It's perfectly possible to raise kids who are not obsessed with brands. It's perfectly possible to have high standards and discipline without everyone being dressed identically - as evidenced by other Western European countries. The British love affair with uniform is part of its culture of appearance over merit and it needs to change.

Absolutely! And I think there’s an argument that enforcing stupid pointless rules rather than creating discipline actually does the opposite. Surely if you don’t have the choice, you’re not being disciplined by wearing it?
pointythings · 05/09/2021 14:25

GreenLakes children don't need to follow petty rules about shorts to be able to do things they don't want to do, like homework. Schools, like parents, should pick their battles. Homework done, school attendance and behaviour good = important. What they're wearing, as long as clean, decent and weather appropriate = not important. Substance, not appearance.

Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 14:25

[quote GreenLakes]@Pumperthepumper

But the point is that there are always going to be things in life we have to do that we don’t want to.

I don’t particularly want to go to work every day. I’m sure DS would rather have worn trousers (or jeans and t shirt)- but he wore shorts as rules are rules and the role of a parent is to support the school’s expectations.

I also don’t like this idea that DC need to be protected at all costs from things they don’t want to do. There are things throughout a DC’s life that just need to be done, like brushing teeth and homework/revision.

A few generations ago DC would have been down mines. Having to wear shorts to school is hardly equivalent.[/quote]
But we have reasons for those things: you work for money. Brushing teeth means they don’t fall out. Homework means more consistent learning (although I have thoughts on that too).

What’s the reason for uniform?

pointythings · 05/09/2021 14:23

Pumperthepumper this. How much time is wasted in British schools policing uniform infringements? What's wrong with extending simple 6th form dress codes across the board? Once the novelty of wearing your own clothes wears off, they'll all just turn up in jeans/leggings/t-shirts/sweatshirts. And if bullying occurs, crack down on that - which schools should be doing anyway.

It's perfectly possible to raise kids who are not obsessed with brands. It's perfectly possible to have high standards and discipline without everyone being dressed identically - as evidenced by other Western European countries. The British love affair with uniform is part of its culture of appearance over merit and it needs to change.

GreenLakes · 05/09/2021 14:22

@Pumperthepumper

But the point is that there are always going to be things in life we have to do that we don’t want to.

I don’t particularly want to go to work every day. I’m sure DS would rather have worn trousers (or jeans and t shirt)- but he wore shorts as rules are rules and the role of a parent is to support the school’s expectations.

I also don’t like this idea that DC need to be protected at all costs from things they don’t want to do. There are things throughout a DC’s life that just need to be done, like brushing teeth and homework/revision.

A few generations ago DC would have been down mines. Having to wear shorts to school is hardly equivalent.

Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 14:06

@pointythings

naptime this is what I don't understand. The uniform fans seem to think that British children are so slow to learn that they need to spend 12+ years learning to follow rules and how to dress. Other countries seem to manage to turn out functional adults without all the uniform rigmarole. I don't think British kids are that slow on the uptake at all.
I absolutely agree with this. We spend so much time looking at the needs of the child and learning theories and child-led curriculums - what difference does it make if they do it in leggings and trainers?
Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 14:05

[quote GreenLakes]@pointythings

What my or any patient’s personal views on a particular uniform policy are or aren’t is irrelevant.

The point is that it is a school rule so it needs to be followed.

FWIW, I don’t see being expected to wear shorts or a blazer is some huge hardship. A strict uniform policy ime helps promote a culture of high standards and good discipline.

Having to wear shorts taught DS that sometimes in life you have to do things that you don’t want to do and you just need to get on with it.[/quote]
Well, surely if it taught him anything it’s that people in authority can do whatever they like and there’s nothing he can do about it?

pointythings · 05/09/2021 13:58

naptime this is what I don't understand. The uniform fans seem to think that British children are so slow to learn that they need to spend 12+ years learning to follow rules and how to dress. Other countries seem to manage to turn out functional adults without all the uniform rigmarole. I don't think British kids are that slow on the uptake at all.

Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 13:52

Having to wear shorts taught DS that sometimes in life you have to do things that you don’t want to do and you just need to get on with it. Took him 7 years of wearing shorts to learn that? How did you know that he had finally got the message, did he stop moaning in the final term of Year 6...would you have insisted on shorts through secondary had he continued to moan? Did you try any other methods of explaining this life lesson to him or do you feel the indirect long winded way works best with him. I hope he is picking up on life lessons a bit quicker now, must be hard for him.

GreenLakes · 05/09/2021 11:58

@pointythings

What my or any patient’s personal views on a particular uniform policy are or aren’t is irrelevant.

The point is that it is a school rule so it needs to be followed.

FWIW, I don’t see being expected to wear shorts or a blazer is some huge hardship. A strict uniform policy ime helps promote a culture of high standards and good discipline.

Having to wear shorts taught DS that sometimes in life you have to do things that you don’t want to do and you just need to get on with it.

DancesWithTortoises · 05/09/2021 11:57

School uniforms should be abolished. Problem solved.

Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 11:54

[quote GreenLakes]@Naptimenow

Because the whole point of a uniform is that everyone looks the same.

It ceases to be a uniform if you have some DC in boots, some in grey trousers, some in black, some with blazers off.

Having these rules in place also helps DC to understand how to follow rules that they don’t necessarily like and is good discipline.[/quote]
I think you have massively missed my point

GreenLakes · 05/09/2021 11:51

@Naptimenow

Because the whole point of a uniform is that everyone looks the same.

It ceases to be a uniform if you have some DC in boots, some in grey trousers, some in black, some with blazers off.

Having these rules in place also helps DC to understand how to follow rules that they don’t necessarily like and is good discipline.

Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 11:03

Even if you want to run with the leveller argument - the school uniform rules go well beyond that!

I don't understand how making a child wear a blazer when it's 25C is good for the child.
Why insisting the child wears black shoes rather than black ankle boots or black trainers is good for the child - when they walk a fair distance in all weathers - it we were concerned about poor kids we would not expect them to but special shoes for school.
Why insisting on navy tights rather than black tights is good for the child.
Why insisting the parents spend £15 on school branded sports socks is good for the child and other bits of obscenely priced branded PE uniform is good for the child.
There are countless other stupid rules, that serve no useful purpose.

Schools have lost the plot on uniform - this is not about creating a level experience for poor kids - this is a corporate, vanity project and it's time the Gov put the brakes on this madness.

PurpleOkapi · 05/09/2021 10:46

Kids don’t get to pick and choose which school rules they follow.

The kids aren't the ones choosing which rules will be enforced. The school is. That's often how it works with petty rules in the real world. Those saying that children need to get used to following rules should keep in mind that they'll also need to get used to rules being enforced selectively or not at all, at the whims of whomever made them. Not all jobs require uniforms, but all jobs will have some amount of laxity or selectivity in their rules about something or other.

I still don't understand the "leveller" argument. Making things look level isn't the same thing as actually making things level. Many children aren't the slightest bit interested in designer clothes. And if they are, then so what? Teaching kids that logos don't matter, and that just because they want something doesn't mean they can have it, will serve them far better as adults than teaching them about the importance of uniformity.

MancMum2000 · 05/09/2021 10:23

Your friend sounds like a busybody who can’t manage the behaviour of her own children tbh.

CecilyP · 05/09/2021 10:15

DumplingsAndStew

I must remember to tell my GP she's not professional, maybe she should consider a shirt and tie combo.

Might pop in and speak to my solicitor too.

No Dumplings, you’ve missed the point of the post you were referring to. Doctors and solicitors are professionals environments, therefore you must always wear black shoes when you go to the surgeries/offices to consult them!

pointythings · 05/09/2021 09:11

But GreenLakes making a child wear shorts all year round until they are 11 is ridiculous. There's no rational reason for doing it, it's just the school caring more about their 'image' than about their students' wellbeing. That's the sort of uniform obsessiveness that I have a problem with. I get it, the UK is obsessed with uniform and ascribed mythical qualities of egalitarianism and bullying prevention to it. It's like a religion, and it will take time for the UK to outgrow their childish faith in the power of uniform.
But at least make it comfortable, practical, affordable for all. All these people going on about how 'everywhere' has free uniform and second hand stalls - that is simply not true.

LastToBePicked · 05/09/2021 05:37

@LegendaryReady

For many children it's not about the uniform being available free or cheap or grants being available it's about the household functioning enough to be able to have it available regularly. If mum hasn't got out of bed all week and oldest child has been trying keep little ones fed, it's unlikely laundry has been done.

I've had a situation where a child left their uniform (that school had given him) with a teacher, who took it home to wash because if it went home with him it got sold Sad

But to a greater or lesser extent you’ve got that problem with or without uniform - they need to wear clothes, ultimately!

Uniform has the advantage of being able to disguise the kids who are wearing the same school shirt every day of the week - unless it’s really stained or smelly no-one will notice, you can get away with it. But if you’re not in uniform, people will notice that you’ve been wearing the same T-shirt for days at a time, or that you only have 3 t-shirts that you’ve been wearing all year on rotation.

GreenLakes · 05/09/2021 03:08

@Boomclaps

Clearly there are some DC who are either unable to wear uniform or circumstances make it difficult for them to do so.

However ime the vast majority of DC are perfectly capable of wearing correct uniform- the issue is either parents not bothering/ wanting to appease DC/ DC themselves not complying.

As I said earlier, DS wasn’t exactly thrilled at having to wear shorts to school all year until year 6. However, my role as a parent was to ensure he wore his uniform correctly and so he did with no issue. The vast majority of parents could and should be doing the same.

Boomclaps · 04/09/2021 23:09

@LegendaryReady

For many children it's not about the uniform being available free or cheap or grants being available it's about the household functioning enough to be able to have it available regularly. If mum hasn't got out of bed all week and oldest child has been trying keep little ones fed, it's unlikely laundry has been done.

I've had a situation where a child left their uniform (that school had given him) with a teacher, who took it home to wash because if it went home with him it got sold Sad

Yes this too! 🥺 you’ve just reminded me of a little boy B, who I used to give breakfast every morning. He’d be going into year eleven this week. I do hope he’s ok ♥️💔💔
Boomclaps · 04/09/2021 23:06

Yeah your friend needs to butt out.
I used to work in a school.
Kids who didn’t wear uniform long term (ie we always had a few one or two eaters with mum forgot to dry uniform, left my school shoes at dads and won’t see him til Wednesday etc) were either…

in abject poverty (yeah they had Nike trainers but they were there only pair of shoes for their whole life for a year, for pe for home for school)...

SEN with Sensory issues

Or sick. Like had ehlers danlos, or cancer with dry skin from treatment that meant they needed soft clothes, or had eating disorders that mean regular clothes hung off them, or had a stoma so the stretchy top band of leggings kept it nice and neat.

Your friends being a knob.

Naptimenow · 04/09/2021 22:50

At times it's impossible to know what goes on in people's houses - but punishing and shouting at kids for their parent's decision on school uniform is fucked up bullying shit and it still goes on regularly at primary and secondary and these kids are still scared, embarrassed and humiliated and it still happens regularly - who thinks of these kids - do they not matter?

TeachesOfPeaches · 04/09/2021 22:12

Has anyone considered that some parents just don't care about school uniform?

I can more than afford the proper stuff but my son goes in the supermarket version because it doesn't really matter. It's not all about poverty.

LegendaryReady · 04/09/2021 22:09

For many children it's not about the uniform being available free or cheap or grants being available it's about the household functioning enough to be able to have it available regularly. If mum hasn't got out of bed all week and oldest child has been trying keep little ones fed, it's unlikely laundry has been done.

I've had a situation where a child left their uniform (that school had given him) with a teacher, who took it home to wash because if it went home with him it got sold Sad