Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument over hand washing

36 replies

undecided2022 · 02/09/2021 22:22

Have just massively freaked out at my husband ( I know I overreacted) and want to get clear on something.

I think it's disgusting not to wash hands with soap after touching raw meat. Husband says it's fine to use just plain water it does the same job.

I take stuff like that seriously- we have a toddler in the house - I don't want raw meat juices everywhere. Anyway I assume i am not being unreasonable?

Things escalated... he then decided after we had googled etc and I argued my point... that he was not talking about meat he just meant general dirt and that I misunderstood him. Am I being unreasonable to say that's gaslighting and trying to play games with my head? He does this shit all the time drags me into a debate about something that is cut and dry and then changes what he had originally said.
I've now ruined our evening because I flipped out as I am fed up of him doing this. We've been through a lot lately and are trying to rebuild our relationship. Now seems like we've taken 50 steps back wards.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
catfunk · 03/09/2021 19:13

Don't understand why it had to turn into an argument - if he changed his tune to say he meant just dirt and not raw meat you can then say 'ok great so you agree I was right' and give him a smug satisfied smile.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 03/09/2021 18:47

Did you throw something at him?

Hercisback · 03/09/2021 18:46

The raw meat thing isn't too bad. I eat raw steak so wouldn't get too upset about that. It does sound like you perhaps over reacted a bit and if you're like this about everything he may have had enough.
HOWEVER the gas lighting isn't cool and he shouldn't be doing that.

Hummingbird1950 · 03/09/2021 18:46

Just realized it's #2 you wanted him to wash his hands properly, he didn't want to. That would be enough to start it. You dared to have an opinion and make a simple, reasonable, non-negotiable request.

Hummingbird1950 · 03/09/2021 18:41

[quote undecided2022]@MadeForThis that's exactly what has driven me completely up the wall. I am absolutely furious. And super annoyed with myself for losing my temper as now I feel like the bad guy even thought I repeatedly asked him to leave it and just stop he just carried on and on as if I'm a fucking idiot who wouldn't remember what he had already said!!!

Now he's acting all wounded being quiet and saying he is 'calm' when actually he's definitely very very pissed off.

Arghhhhhhhhhhhhhh[/quote]
Questions:

  1. has he been drinking alcohol?
  2. did the plans for this evening involve anything at all that he'd prefer to not do, however small and inconsequential it may seem?
  3. were you planning to go out alone?
  4. were you feeling happy and content with life until this "debate"?

I ask because I had this shit all the one with my ex. Often when he'd been drinking. Functional alcoholic so never seemed obviously drunk or even tipsy, eve when he was. Took me years to realise he always picked a fight with me when drunk (took me years to recognise he was drunk, too).

He also liked to pick fights like this if he had to do something he didn't want to eg
a) visit my friends, he'd start a row before hand, I get upset, I go alone or don't go at all. A result as far as he's concerned.
b) I'm going out alone, he starts a row beforehand, I get upset and don't feel like going any more. Just what he wanted.
c) I'm happy, well we can't be having that can we?! He much preferred me sad and low and passive, so would pick a fight like this to out me into that state. Too pissed off to argue with him, more likely to do whatever he says. Job done.

OP I wouldn't be rebuilding this relationship I'd be getting out of it. YANBU, he is. These aren't debates, you questioned him and he started a row to put you back in your place. Anyone will lose their temper if pushed far enough, you've nothing to feel guilty or apologize for. He did this deliberately. He ruined the evening, not you.

DogsandCatsB4u · 03/09/2021 18:27

He’s disgusting

Hydrate · 03/09/2021 18:16

He is gross, spreading bacteria all over the place, wonder if he washes with soap after using to loo, or in the shower?

violetbunny · 03/09/2021 06:32

Ew, I always wash m hands in soap and water after handling meat. I double wash if it's raw chicken!

Another thing that disgusts me is raw meat and chopping boards. We have different coloured boards for chopping red meat, chicken, fish and veg. When I met DP he had one board for everything (🤢) and I have caught him before chopping meat on the veg-only board Angry Makes me cross!

arcof · 03/09/2021 03:44

When all is calm agree that should you reach a flashpoint like this again and you ask him to
Stop, he will stop, or agree that one will walk away to give breathing space and the other is not to follow. Also when calm talk about how annoying it is when he says one thing then changes it to another and it's THAT which is getting you worked up. Ask him not to do that again, ask him why he thinks he does that. Write down an agreement and sign it if needed, refer to it in future.
Do all this if you want to remain in the relationship only, obviously

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 03/09/2021 02:27

He sounds like a twat and he has changed his story because you have proven him wrong. Simple as that. I can understand why you got annoyed.

I wouldn't call it "gaslighting" although it may well be. He is simply lying because he doesn't want to admit he's wrong.

Susannahmoody · 03/09/2021 02:00

Absolutely gross. It's raw meat!

IStoppedWatchingTheWalkingDead · 03/09/2021 01:51

Grim. Even if just cooking for myself I wash my hands after handling raw meat because I don't want to contaminate every surface I touch with meat bacteria for husband or dd to then touch the same surfaces and prepping their lunch.

I've once saw my brother rinse a chicken at the sink, chuck it in the oven, faff about flicking through recipe book and tidying bits away and when I said he's just touched all that without washing his hands he dramatically ran his hands under the cold tap for a few seconds, used the same t towel he had just dried his barely wet hands on to mop up the splashed water from rinsing the chicken and smeared that all over Mam's counters, to then touch various cupboards getting cups and milk out to make a cuppa for everyone and called me "a clean freak" when I said I'll make my own cuppa and I'm no longer hungry and why.

Nat6999 · 03/09/2021 01:12

I usually would wash my hands in the hot water & washing up liquid I always have in the washing up bowl when preparing food if I had handled raw meat.

ChevreChase · 03/09/2021 00:38

Yes, my exH used to do this, completely change the terms of an argument when I was able to prove my point through evidence. I have a decent memory for things people say, and would also be able to repeat verbatim the assertions we had both made in the opening stages of the argument, but instead of him acknowledging that he was misrepresenting his stance, would tell me I was dogged and obsessive for recalling things accurately.

Once, to prove a point, he, he insisted I start a MN thread to get opinions on an issue (also a hygiene one!), as he claimed I would be the only person in the world who thought the way I did. However, 95% of posters agreed with me. His response: "you can't go running to MN every time with have a disagreement". Aaaarrrgghh!

You're right about the hand washing too, but people who refuse to argue in productive and fair ways are impossible to live with.

toomuchlaundry · 03/09/2021 00:27

@XenoBitch there is gross and then there is raw meat gross! Why would anyone risk getting ill, just use soap!

XenoBitch · 03/09/2021 00:23

But isn't it not just about cooking but touching other things afterwards that is problematic?

You said you have a toddler. I bet every surface in your house in reach of them is covered in something gross.

HSHorror · 03/09/2021 00:23

This happens to me a lot with dp.
He never listens and when he does he interprets stuff to what he thinks you should saying.
Then i look crazy for getting frustrated.

I wouldnt really want to meat juice kitchen and the next thing he touches could be fruit or salad.
Also if he does even give himself a stomach upset it can still be contagious depending on what it was caused by.
Dp parents are relaxed about higiene so i feel like i have ocd if i say kids should wash hands after touching the dog.

Suzi888 · 03/09/2021 00:22

Raw meat juice? blood you mean. Envynot envy. Of course he should wash his hands with soap!

toomuchlaundry · 03/09/2021 00:20

Why don’t people use soap after handling raw meat if you are only cooking for yourself?

Blueleah · 03/09/2021 00:12

Yes you need to use soap after touching raw meat. I suspect he knows that and the real problem is the way you’ve approached telling him. It sounds like you’ve told him he’s disgusting and have gone off on a rant, and unsurprisingly he hasn’t responded well. A better approach would have been to just say “please can you remember to use soap to make sure the meat juice is washed off”.

BlancheB · 03/09/2021 00:08

Why is he saying he is "calm"? He's the one who doesn't understand basic hygiene principles and as an adult (and parent?) he should know better. Hand washing with soap is hardly onerous. No idea why he thinks he has to be calm? Don't apologise as none of this is your fault.

You have a right to be annoyed. Please eat something. Preferably something that has not been prepared by him.

undecided2022 · 02/09/2021 23:43

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

Water 'does the same job' as soap is clearly stupid.

But the gaslighting would make me very very angry as well to be honest. The 'well you misunderstood what I said in the first place' is a pathetic argument. I couldn't be with someone like that, it means he never accepts being in the wrong, never reflects on what the argument is actually about and his part in it, can never apologise, and cares more about being right than about anything else, like the issue under 'debate' or the other person's feelings. All just horrible and extremely childish

Yes. That's exactly what made me so upset earlier. It's the first time it's happened in a while so it hurt more.
OP posts:
undecided2022 · 02/09/2021 23:39

@wheretoliveplz

It depends, if cooking for myself then it's up to me. But cooking for others then always with soap.
But isn't it not just about cooking but touching other things afterwards that is problematic?
OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/09/2021 23:36

Water 'does the same job' as soap is clearly stupid.

But the gaslighting would make me very very angry as well to be honest. The 'well you misunderstood what I said in the first place' is a pathetic argument. I couldn't be with someone like that, it means he never accepts being in the wrong, never reflects on what the argument is actually about and his part in it, can never apologise, and cares more about being right than about anything else, like the issue under 'debate' or the other person's feelings. All just horrible and extremely childish

wheretoliveplz · 02/09/2021 23:28

It depends, if cooking for myself then it's up to me. But cooking for others then always with soap.