Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Muslim mum here, looking for views of of other Muslim mums xx

39 replies

fsl409 · 02/09/2021 21:00

Before the summer holidays started, my sister started sending her son (my little nephew, recently turned 5) to madrassa (mosque school) for 1.5 hours every weekday evening after school, leaving no time of energy for him to pursue any other extra curricular interests, clubs or activites that most of his (non-Muslim) friends attend.
My sons are a little older than their cousin but mine have schedules of things like football, swimming and martial arts. They asked me to let them do these things as they really are passionate about them. At first I thought it might be too much for them after a whole day at school, but they really enjoy so I can't complain.
With my nephew, he's become withdrawn, quiet and looks permanantly exhausted. He doesn't seem to have much zest for life and talks with envy about his school friends who are allowed to spend their evenings after school playing sports, going to the park or just doing relaxing things at home or with their families.
Of course I believe it's important to learn about our religion, but I teach my sons about it in a way that fits around their school life, not in a way that takes over every spare minute outside of school hours.
I know my sister loves her son and wants him to grow up as a good and pious Muslim, but I'm concerned that she might be putting her wish for him to attend madrassa every single night for 1.5 before his right to have other interests and do the kind of "fun" activities that his friends do.
Just to be clear, I'm not suggesting there's anything wrong with attending madrassa or studying our religion, I'm just concerned about the amount of time each week my nephew is expected to attend and how this impacts on his opportunities to have other interests or activities.
I even offered to take him to play football with his cousins one evening per week for an hour but my sister was like... 'no, he has madrassa..". AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mrsweasleysclock · 16/09/2021 11:34

There are a lot of online resources these days whereby madrasa can be done at home in a more manageable way. There are fun you tube videos that teach daily duahs. There are structured online classes that he can join. Even options for 1-1 learning through video lessons which can be done at your own schedule. So many options these days without having to physically attend a madrasa. Ultimately it will depend on what your sister wants for him.

Disneyvillain · 02/09/2021 23:19

My daughter attended Madrassah through primary school and up to year 8. Over the years she also did swimming, netball, horse riding, athletics, ice skating etc etc. Yes, it was a push at times but it is possible. As others have said, in a good madrassah the lessons will be age appropriate.

NatriumChloride · 02/09/2021 22:58

I attended a madrassah for two hours every single evening of the week. I hated it. I had no extra-curricular activities to look forward to and was never around when friends stopped by on their bikes, wanting to cycle. My teacher was horrible and used to call me names and compare me to other children whom she liked better than me. We had a few lessons on stories from the Quran and the prophets and Islamic history. As fascinating as those were it didn’t make up for the misery of the remaining time there. I hated it, OP, and I feel sorry for your nephew.

frazzledasarock · 02/09/2021 22:33

@kinzarose

OP basically because you have decided what is 'healthy' in terms of activities you think your nephew shouldn't go? Madrassahs vary hugely, mine would not be going to one where they are expected to sit and recite whilst rocking back and forth for the duration anyway. At ours (4 hours Sat and Sunday) they do a lot more playing than they do reciting or reading. I wouldn't have an issue sending my dc to it everyday if it was available. It is a very social activity, the dc love it.
Rocking back and forth is not actually a requirement of learning at a madrassa.

We’d get told to stop if we started the rocking back and forth. Teachers used to say it was a waste of energy.

I completed my Quran recitation by age seven. So wasn’t there that long.

Flyingsunflower · 02/09/2021 22:32

Is she wrong to take her son to the madrasa 5days a week? No

Are you wrong to prioritise extra curricular activities? No

Unless she is pressuring you to follow her parenting style, I would quit judging her and mind your own business.

frazzledasarock · 02/09/2021 22:28

I went to madrasah as a kid. I left as soon as I’d completed the Quran, we were also taught Islamic jurisprudence and Hadith though besides recitation and it was very interesting as we got older.

When younger I’d fall asleep in madrassa. We’d be sat there expected to be reading our lesson and it never required that long to learn the readings really.

I know my sister hired an Islamic tutor to teach her kids. Don’t think he did the Hadith and jurisprudence (he wasn’t qualified to) just Quran recitation.

MsHedgehog · 02/09/2021 22:22

Muslim mum, but to an infant so this isn’t something we’ve considered yet. But I agree that 5 days a week is too much for a 5 year old. Other kids I know who go to a madrassa only go for a few hours on a Saturday, although not sure if it makes a difference that I come from an Arabic speaking country so the children I know are already more familiar with Arabic.

Children need to be children, and that includes extra curricular activities that keep them entertained. It isn’t fair to deprive him of that.

Ghkkl · 02/09/2021 22:10

Ours also do lots of activities, colouring, watching videos, making cards, stories etc. My son loves going. It’s not 3 hours of strict learning. I don’t think you understand what actually happens in madrassa and are very quick to judge.

Girlmum2020 · 02/09/2021 22:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request due to concerns.

Kneesaregood · 02/09/2021 22:02

Not Muslim sorry, I do work with a number of Muslim families in my role. I don't think I've known any to go every night from 5yrs, the ones I've known who go more frequently when that age are the younger siblings of older ones who want to go to 'join in'. However most if not all of the madrassa that I know in our area have a mix of activities - obviously study is very important but they include cricket or other activities as well, in the sense they function a bit more like after school childcare not only as study (I don't mean that to suggest it's not taken seriously by parents, just that it is routine for many to go five evenings a week but not necessarily for study every night)
Thinking about it as well, I don't think the sessions around here are 1.5hrs, I'm sure they're shorter.

I can see if he's at a mixed school where friends are doing different things after school that would be quite hard, and would be isolating over the long term. It'd be different if he was at a school where majority of the children were Muslim and lots of his classmates were going.

Mistyplanet · 02/09/2021 22:02

Isn't there even a hadith about kids learning through play up until the age of 7? Hopefully someone knows here. This could help you convince her its too much for him.

Darbs76 · 02/09/2021 21:57

I’m not a Muslim but my children’s dad is. His brother has 5 kids and they have all done this. 1.5-2hrs a day. It doesn’t leave anytime for any hobbies, none of them ever had any hobbies so not sure if that wasn’t encouraged anyway or just time meant they could fit it in. I feel sorry for my SIL as she’s the one doing the running around, and in London a couple of miles can take forever. I think it’s too much, but not my kids and I don’t understand it at all as I’m not overly religious

Mistyplanet · 02/09/2021 21:57

Muslim mum here. We felt the same for our kids that every evening as some madrassas seem to run would be far too much. Our kids go for 3 hours on a Saturday instead and theres alot of play based /fun activities within that. Maybe you could suggest an alternative for them x

kinzarose · 02/09/2021 21:54

OP basically because you have decided what is 'healthy' in terms of activities you think your nephew shouldn't go?
Madrassahs vary hugely, mine would not be going to one where they are expected to sit and recite whilst rocking back and forth for the duration anyway. At ours (4 hours Sat and Sunday) they do a lot more playing than they do reciting or reading. I wouldn't have an issue sending my dc to it everyday if it was available. It is a very social activity, the dc love it.

Sh05 · 02/09/2021 21:52

@gogohm
Ours is similar, at 5 my dd does a lot of learning through play not sitting in a classroom and parroting verses as many on here seem to think.
They have different activities planned on different days through which they learn the alphabet, some basic etiquite and Islamic manners, they do crafts and colouring, and alot more fun stuff throughout ages 5-11. It's only after 10 that things get intense and that is only for those children who want to memorise the Qur'an and not everyone does

Faffandahalf · 02/09/2021 21:48

Muslim here.
Not sure how much of a Muslim response you expected on MN tbh. It’s not exactly full of vocal Muslim parents. And threads about Islam tend to go very badly on here.
But anyway….
My 6 year old does an hour 3 days a week and then ‘Sunday school’ for 3 hours.
Every day can be a bit much but plenty of kids do it.
You start early because obviously no one can just suddenly be able to read the Quran.
You have to learn the alphabet and the the way sounds are formed and then be able to say words etc. This takes at least a year, then a couple of years to become fluent in reading. Kids retain much more the earlier they start esp learning to read a new language.

In Sunday school they learn much more about the meaning and stories of the Quran so they have an understanding of what they are learning to read. They also do fun engaging activities as groups about how to be good citizens and contribute positively to society. So they learn about charity and doing good deeds for others, how to show kindness, and help people. Etc.

My kids do swimming on Saturdays and a school based after school club one day. That’s it.
Not everyone is rushing to extra curricular activities every day esp when parents are working and lives are busy.

You clearly have an issue. I agree 1.5 hours 5 days a week is a lot. But you clearly have a problem with the madrasah issue overall. Some madrasahs don’t allow part time attendance. We were lucky that we could do 3 days.

You can raise it again I guess and suggest other madrasah options if you can find them.

Sh05 · 02/09/2021 21:48

I doubt he's memorising anything at 5. He's only just learning to recognise the letters of the Arabic alphabet unless he's been attending since he was 2 which I doubt. No one can force a child to memorise the Qur'an, it's a skill that very few have at such a young age and unless she's been reciting to him at home I doubt he knows more than the shortest 3 lined surahs by heart.

Pleasegodgotosleep · 02/09/2021 21:45

Thinking from a totally different perspective...if the little boys dad is rarely around is the mum looking for respite child care for 1.5 hours after school without having to drop off/pick up at loads of clubs??

gogohm · 02/09/2021 21:42

I rented space to a madrasah - they do vary a lot. Yes they go nightly but the one at ours did games, activities (similar to those in scouts) as well as religious activities. Koran studies only get intense at secondary age. The guy that set this one up did so to offer a different kind of madrasah and it doubles up as after school care

PeonyTime · 02/09/2021 21:41

I would tend towards your style of parenting, but your sister obviously has different views.
Not madrassa, but the kids used to go to school on a Saturday. That has different impacts on social life - miss class or go to a party.... We have moved to DH teaching at home. It is clearly not as effective, and progress is slower (slowed further by covid restricting time with the PiL when the majority language switches), but it opens up other opportunities.

Rather than focusing on just madrassa, can you talk about struggling with work load/commitments/priorities, or talk about how tired he is without assigning cause, and see where things go? But be gentle. The school wouldnt offer every night if it didnt work for some families.

StoneofDestiny · 02/09/2021 21:37

At 5 a child doesn't have the intellectual/comprehension skills to understand the Quran - all that can be going on is parrot fashion repetition. 1.5 hours every night of religious study after a day at school is quite shocking.
A child at that age needs to play.

1990b · 02/09/2021 21:35

Muslim here. That's too much at his age as he is still too young. If your sister does want him to learn and then finish Qaran as soon as possible then this is not the way to go about it.

He will probably be too tired to give it as much focus as it needs. Also, he is only 5 so his attention span is probably quite limited.

Learning about and implementing our beautiful religion takes time, patience and dedication.

I think your sister needs to scale back and let him also be a little boy, who does Cotherstone things as well otherwise he might resent her later on

BrilliantBetty · 02/09/2021 21:26

It sounds like it's too much for the kid and he's struggling. Poor thing.
Not a lot you can do though.

Notmoresugar · 02/09/2021 21:25

Poor little lad :-(

cochineal7 · 02/09/2021 21:24

Not muslim but worked for long time in muslim country. None of my muslim friends kids at that age would have that much religious schooling after school hours (and to be clear, not even during school hours). I mean seriously how much will he even retain and how much will he resent at one point. Working through the Quran is not supposed to be a race who can do it fastest; what lessons is he having? Does he speak Arabic or is he also memorising a language he doesn’t even understand? Being pious in any religion is best taught by parents who practice what they preach and lead by example in my view.