Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving in to DP's mortgaged house... who should pay?

291 replies

hollsmoi · 02/09/2021 20:36

I'm shortly due to leave my rental property to move in with DP who already owns a property. The plan is to live together there for a while and if all goes well, we will rent out his place and purchase somewhere together which is more suitable. We are in central London so DP currently rents out one of his bedrooms to a lodger (he makes a lot of profit from this), who will be moving out when I move in.

DP has implied that he expects us to split all outgoings for the house 50/50. Having never moved in to a partner's home, I'm not sure this is right. Without question I will be contributing 50/50 to all of the household bills, council tax, food shop etc. but part of me feels uncomfortable about essentially paying half of his mortgage as 'rent'. AIBU?

Also, when I move in we are needing to covert the spare bedroom to an office space and storage area for me e.g. desks, built in wardrobes and drawers for my things. DP has mentioned when "we" buy these things which again implies 50/50. WIBU to expecting DP to fund this since it's his property and in the event that things didn't work out, he would benefit from them i.e. they'd remain in his property. Thoughts welcome as I'm new to this!

OP posts:
Hekatestorch · 02/09/2021 23:25

@CarrotTops The problem here is OPS DP has chosen to buy something he actually can't afford to pay for, and has been reliant on a lodger for years. This has left him in a sticky situation when he wants to move his partner in,

Where have you got this from? Where has op said she is moving in because the lodger is moving out?

Op says the mortgage payments are small. In your example if you getting the TV made your dp alot better off and you alot worse off, of course they should help you pay.

Also if you dp decided the TV is the majority for his use (like op is getting more use out if the bedrooms) then he should pay.

If your dp can't watch a TV without paying towards it (like grown adults can't live somewhere without paying for it) and would pay more to watch another TV why wouldn't he pay a smaller amount towards watching your TV

DoubleEx · 02/09/2021 23:25

What difference does it make if you pay rent to a landlord, who in turn will use that money to pay off their mortgage, or rent to your DP?

She has much less legal rights and protections paying rent to her DP than she does as a tenant on a proper lease.

In fact she has hardly any. It’s a legally vulnerable position to be in.

I moved into my DH’s mortgaged house and did loads of research beforehand so that’s how I know. When I realised he could kick me out at any time if things went to shit and I’d have absolutely no rights at all, I told him I wasn’t going to feather his nest for nothing in return. So we came to an arrangement we were both happy with.

FabulousIAm · 02/09/2021 23:23

Why would you move into a partner's house who owns it without being put on the mortgage and paying half of it? They aren't your landlord and your'e not their tenant.That's basically saying that you will eventually spit up. So why bother moving in at all?!

HarrietOh · 02/09/2021 23:22

I’m about to do same but no way am I going to pay my DP’s mortgage. I’m giving up my own to move in with him so I’ll bank the money I was paying on my mortgage into savings, ready for when we do pay together.
I could pay half this mortgage each month then one day he can throw me out on the street if he wanted. It’s his asset not mine.

ManifestDestinee · 02/09/2021 23:20

DP has implied that he expects us to split all outgoings for the house 50/50. Having never moved in to a partner's home, I'm not sure this is right. Without question I will be contributing 50/50 to all of the household bills, council tax, food shop etc. but part of me feels uncomfortable about essentially paying half of his mortgage as 'rent'. AIBU?

So you want to live rent free, while he pays? You're a cocklodger

Also, when I move in we are needing to covert the spare bedroom to an office space and storage area for me e.g. desks, built in wardrobes and drawers for my things. DP has mentioned when "we" buy these things which again implies 50/50. WIBU to expecting DP to fund this since it's his property and in the event that things didn't work out, he would benefit from them i.e. they'd remain in his property. Thoughts welcome as I'm new to this!

So not only do you want him to house you for nothing, you want him to buy you an office to work in and wardrobes for your stuff, while you pay nothing?

He should run, you're covered in red flags.

userxx · 02/09/2021 23:20

You need to pay some sort of rent.

Dee1975 · 02/09/2021 23:17

What difference does it make if you pay rent to a landlord, who in turn will use that money to pay off their mortgage, or rent to your DP? Your last post says you will be saving money pm. So surly that’s a win win?

CarrotTops · 02/09/2021 23:13

Currently me and Dp rent, but I own a lot of the furniture. Lets say I bought my TV on credit

Dp benefits from my TV because he gets to use a nice TV and doesn't have to pay for it (or rent one if he can't afford to buy). I'm happy for DP to use my TV because I love him, I bought a TV I could afford to pay for and ultimately it was my choice to buy the TV. If the relationship ends I will then leave with the TV, because I own it

What I won't do is choose a massive TV, charge DP half the credit and then fuck off with the TV at the end of the relationship. We can all see that would be a massive dick move. But when the assets get bigger suddenly DP is expected to pay half the TV

The problem here is OPS DP has chosen to buy something he actually can't afford to pay for, and has been reliant on a lodger for years. This has left him in a sticky situation when he wants to move his partner in,

DoubleEx · 02/09/2021 23:08

@Charlotte2020

When I moved into my DPs mortgaged place, instead of giving him rent I put the same amount into savings. Eventually we bought our own place and those savings went towards the house purchase. That way it's not like you get a free ride and you aren't paying someone else's mortgage either.
This is exactly what DH and I did too.

OP you need to be aware of where you stand legally if you move in with him. Because he lives in the property too you will only have the legal status of lodger, not tenant. Tenants have a lot of rights and protections in law. Lodgers have far fewer. If your DP decided he wanted you out of his house, he’d only need to give you a week’s notice.

In consideration of you moving from a secure legal position to a much more precarious one, I think it’s fair enough for you to say that you’re happy to cover your share of the bills (or even all the bills, if you’re happy to split it that way) but you’re not helping to pay off the mortgage on a property you have no title to, and no equity in.

Hekatestorch · 02/09/2021 23:06

[quote CarrotTops]@RandomLondoner but it's not the same as renting half a house. You don't have the same rights, you haven't chosen where to live or how much the mortgage costs. The owner of the house has chosen the house based on what they can afford and what they like. Op has no say in that. What if you own a 5 bed detached property and OP rents a studio flat?

Why the fuck should you pay 50% of the rental value if they don't have a mortgage? Do you charge you partner taxi fares if you drive them to tesco? Its a relationship not a business transaction.[/quote]
But then she can chose to not move in. She can choose to keep paying more in her own place. Until they can afford to buy/rent together.

And she will be sharing the main bedroom and having another bedroom to herself.

She can get the same rights by having an agreement signed

BoredZelda · 02/09/2021 23:05

Pay your way. Why should you live for free? Whether you pay a randomer rent, or him half the mortgage, it’s the same thing.

Same with the office furniture. Why should he pay for your office furniture? I wouldn’t even be asking him to go half’s.

Dreamingofbeergardens · 02/09/2021 23:05

I never understand why people suggest a couple should rent together instead. It's his home, doesn't make sense to spend more money on rent instead of living in the home he owns!
OP I think you need to work out an amount of rent to pay your DP or figure out how else you can pay which makes things fair. And I think you should pay for your office furniture.

Hekatestorch · 02/09/2021 23:03

@CarrotTops the dp rented the room out to make money, not because he can't afford it. Op says the mortgage payment is low.

The dp is gaining anything. He is losing money by op moving. Even if she pays half.

CarrotTops · 02/09/2021 23:02

@RandomLondoner but it's not the same as renting half a house. You don't have the same rights, you haven't chosen where to live or how much the mortgage costs. The owner of the house has chosen the house based on what they can afford and what they like. Op has no say in that. What if you own a 5 bed detached property and OP rents a studio flat?

Why the fuck should you pay 50% of the rental value if they don't have a mortgage? Do you charge you partner taxi fares if you drive them to tesco? Its a relationship not a business transaction.

Batshitkerazy · 02/09/2021 23:00

Hmm I’ve been on both sides of this

  • moved into my ex’s mortgaged home, and now my current partner lives in my mortgaged home. I only contributed towards bills with my ex and similarly, my partner only pays half the bills now. There’s just something that doesn’t sit right with me, about charging a partner rent.

I think that the big factor here is the loss of income from the lodger. You want your boyfriend to be better off financially with you moving in (as he’ll be getting money towards the bills) not worse off. I think making up that shortfall would be the decent thing to do, especially if you are already used to renting. The office space should be funded by yourself if you’ll be having sole benefit of it.

Good luck for the move Smile

Proudboomer · 02/09/2021 22:55

My son hopes to buy next year and his partner will move in with him but they won’t be buying jointly.
My son will pay the mortgage and his partner will pay bills and food.. she will be paying less but as my son earns more it will leave them with about the same disposable income.

CarrotTops · 02/09/2021 22:54

Or you could look at it that he clearly has a mortgage that he can't afford and he needs to find someone to pay it. Moves in his girlfriend so she pays half, ultimately the more he pays off on his mortgage the better the house he'll be able to own in the future.

He could just move in a succession of girlfriends to pay his mortgage. It should be a mutually beneficial. What is the mortgage, what is the rent on a room? What can OP afford? These are all questions you need to answer before just a flat out half. What's the difference between the two incomes?

Say mortgage is 1000, room is 500. Op paying 250 means they both save about 250 each. You say 'we will do this for x months, if all good after x months we will get a place together and rent this/sell this'

RandomLondoner · 02/09/2021 22:43

The technically correct thing to do, if you want to pay your own way, is to pay half the rental value of his house. You should pay this same amount regardless of whether it's more or less than half the mortgage payment. You should pay it even if he doesn't have a mortgage, and every penny of your payment is going into his savings.

If you think you are not getting half the benefit of living in the house, then some other fixed fraction of the rental value might be appropriate.

It always irritates me in threads like these when people complain about paying someone else's mortgage. While I agree that "half the mortgage" is the wrong calculation, nine times out of ten it will be less than the "half the rental value" that you should be paying. To act as if you are the one being ripped off when in fact the wrong is in the opposite make people look like sanctimonious idiots.

Lotusmonster · 02/09/2021 22:40

Pretty decent of him to suck up the loss of rent from his lodger tbh…..this whole you moving in with him is definitely going to end up costing him more. Why are you dissatisfied exactly?

CattyMcNips · 02/09/2021 22:40

When I loved in with DH I paid 50% of the mortgage on hit flat. It was about £300 less a month than my rent.

When we bought our house we sold the flat to renovate our new house.

Even if we'd have split up after 6 months he would have saved me a fortune in rent!

Hekatestorch · 02/09/2021 22:37

The more I think about it, the more I can't believe someone thinks they should br able to live rent free. Even when they are already saving loads and it's costing their dp money for them to move in.

And then take over one of the bedrooms, want it entirely kitting out with fitted wardrobes and an office and not think they should pay for any of that room doing on top of not paying rent.

Tbh, if I was him and my dp said any of this to me, I would swiftly decide living together was not going to work.

holidaynearlyover · 02/09/2021 22:37

Should add that the money i saved on rent I put into a savings account and after a couple of years when he put me on the mortgage I paid of a chunk

BeesButterflies · 02/09/2021 22:36

If you were a man people would be calling cocklodger. Pay your fair share- you know what it is. Not really fair for DP to loose out in his lodger meanwhile you feather your own bank account to the tune of £300 per month.
If you were my partner proposing this I’d say ‘no thanks, continue renting’

holidaynearlyover · 02/09/2021 22:35

I always find these threads weird.

I moved in with dh after we'd been seeing each other for a year, I paid groceries and for various things we did to upgrade the house but from early on we thought of it as our money.

Maybe we were lucky that we are still together 23 years on- the money is still very much joint now. I can't imagine having to sort out what to pay and how best to split things but can see that it's sensible to do it!!

HalzTangz · 02/09/2021 22:32

So you don't want to pay for the room he is losing income for and you also want him to fit this out for you.
This is your office you should be solely paying for the refit.

As for the mortgage, I would perhaps argue this, however I would still expect to contribute to rent.

The other alternative is to just rent his place out and rent or buy a property jointly from the outset