Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving in to DP's mortgaged house... who should pay?

291 replies

hollsmoi · 02/09/2021 20:36

I'm shortly due to leave my rental property to move in with DP who already owns a property. The plan is to live together there for a while and if all goes well, we will rent out his place and purchase somewhere together which is more suitable. We are in central London so DP currently rents out one of his bedrooms to a lodger (he makes a lot of profit from this), who will be moving out when I move in.

DP has implied that he expects us to split all outgoings for the house 50/50. Having never moved in to a partner's home, I'm not sure this is right. Without question I will be contributing 50/50 to all of the household bills, council tax, food shop etc. but part of me feels uncomfortable about essentially paying half of his mortgage as 'rent'. AIBU?

Also, when I move in we are needing to covert the spare bedroom to an office space and storage area for me e.g. desks, built in wardrobes and drawers for my things. DP has mentioned when "we" buy these things which again implies 50/50. WIBU to expecting DP to fund this since it's his property and in the event that things didn't work out, he would benefit from them i.e. they'd remain in his property. Thoughts welcome as I'm new to this!

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 03/09/2021 11:36

@CarrotTops

If the mortgage is 1000 and the interest is 200 (these are total bs figures btw)

Op pays 100 a month which is half the interest. She can then save 900 a month

Ops DP pays 900 a month, 800 of which is going towards his assets 100 towards the interest. He has a spare 100 a month he can save

After 10 months OP will have saved 9000

After 10 months DP will have 8000 additional assets and 1000 savings- 9000

If OP pays half the mortgage 500. Then at the end of the relationship OP has saved 5000, whilst the DP has increased his assets by 8000 plus the 5000 that he has then saved on mortgage payments so a total of 13000. He walks away much better off

Anything that isn't interest on the mortgage is essentially going into the DPs savings because it is going towards his assets i.e. the house. That's why its not fair. Even if DPs worse off paying his mortgage it's still building his assets, his money si still going back to him in the future.

A reduced rate or amount to cover about 50% of the interest (which obviously is unlikely to be as low as 200) is reasonable. Half the mortgage is not

That's my logic too. She should ring fence her savings so if they do split she has money for a deposit or if they buy together she can contribute at that point. But she needs to be building her savings via a Standing order into a savings account.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 03/09/2021 11:35

@beingsunny

I would consider paying half the interest payment on the mortgage plus half utilities.

That way you aren't paying down the mortgage.

This.

Perfect solution imo.

Lorw · 03/09/2021 11:32

I reckon you should just rent somewhere else together (if you both don’t want to buy just yet) and he can just rent his house out. This would make me uncomfortable with it being ‘his’ house, he could kick you out at a seconds notice and you wouldn’t have a say, so no security and it will never feel like your home OP.

LittleMysSister · 03/09/2021 10:47

@CarrotTops

I don't think living in someone's house is being subsidised by them.

It's their house, they chose to buy based on their earnings. They aren't paying more money than the house they chose to buy or paying more money because a partner moves in (this case is slightly different). Like anything else it's the houseowners possession which they are paying for. Its not OPs possession, it's her DPs.

Everyone gets so het up on living rent free, but as long as the partner pays their fair share of bills, does their fair share of housework etc I don't really understand why someone you love living rent free is such a horrific thought. As I said my mortgage doesn't increase because I move a partner in and I'm getting a house out of it. (The lodger complicates the situation)

It should never be a long term thing, that would be freeloading. If you've lived together longer than say 6 months or a year you should be looking to buy together, ideally with the money saved from not renting. But if at the end of the relationship one partner walks away with a house and the other savings equivalent of a house it sounds reasonable

Na I just can't get on board with one person paying so much more than the other when both are living in the same property. It's just not fair.

My partner lived with me rent free for over a year because he was paying off debt and couldn't afford to contribute. I was not horrified by it, definitely not. But as soon as he finished his debt, he took over paying all the bills as he wasn't comfortable with me paying for everything and him nothing (except shopping). He would never have felt it alright for me to continue paying loads while he just paid half the bills and tucked the rest away in savings for himself.

He still pays less than half of what I pay for the mortgage, but I am OK with this as to me, that is what compensates for the fact that I own the flat and he doesn't.

MrsKrystalStubbs · 03/09/2021 10:45

Of course you should pay half, you would be paying rent so you should pay half of the mortgage bills etc. Unless he earns substantially more than you, then you agree a percentage of what you will pay. If you are doubting the future of the relationship then don’t move in. If you expect him to buy somewhere with you in the future then you need to start sharing costs now. Ive been married twice and both times I moved in to their mortgaged place, paid rent and bills and then eventually got a mortgage together in London. When DH1 and I split, there was no issue over money as we had both contributed to the mortgage bills etc and we split it all 50/50 after 7 years. Don’t expect a man to take care of you. Be independent, earn your own money and pay your own way. My now DH’s first wife lived in his flat rent free for 2 years while she earned more than him and spent her money on business class flights, clothes etc etc. I have no respect for women like that and she was supposedly a feminist. It’s about self respect.

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 10:36

[quote leakymcleakleak]@TractorAndHeadphones Its not always cheaper, but actually I think the issue is more the perception. 'Opportunity cost' rather than real cost. So, you live with your partner for 7 years: yes its 'his' flat but you pay half the bills, you know you're both going to sell and use it for a deposit on a house when you're ready to have kids, you've been involved in the redecoration, you both see it as 'our home'.

If you were both living in a rented flat, still planning those kids, even if rent was higher you would personally be ensuring keeping an eye on savings. Your partner wouldn't say 'oh we can totally afford to go on that holiday abroad, look how much the equity has increased in the last year.' If you were living in a rented flat on your own, and 7 years had passed, you'd be thinking about your own security and not relying on a flat that you don't actually have any legal right to.

I know a LOT of people who made financial decisions in long term relationships based on an assumption they'd always be together that screwed them when they split, ranging from supporting a partner through retraining by picking up bills (it will be alright because when he goes into the higher paying job he'll make up for it) to trusting they lived in a 'shared' house until suddenly they split, weren't married and didn't have names on the deeds. I don't think the OP should be so much better off from moving in, but I do think its right they think about it and think about whats fair now vs in a couple of years.[/quote]
That’s not a financial issue though - it’s a lack of planning. They didn’t agree a budget, didn’t keep their focus on what they wanted. I know a lot of people who would never have been able to get on the ladder as quickly if they’d been living alone. So who’s anecdotal evidence is better - yours or mine?

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 10:32

@CarrotTops

If the mortgage is 1000 and the interest is 200 (these are total bs figures btw)

Op pays 100 a month which is half the interest. She can then save 900 a month

Ops DP pays 900 a month, 800 of which is going towards his assets 100 towards the interest. He has a spare 100 a month he can save

After 10 months OP will have saved 9000

After 10 months DP will have 8000 additional assets and 1000 savings- 9000

If OP pays half the mortgage 500. Then at the end of the relationship OP has saved 5000, whilst the DP has increased his assets by 8000 plus the 5000 that he has then saved on mortgage payments so a total of 13000. He walks away much better off

Anything that isn't interest on the mortgage is essentially going into the DPs savings because it is going towards his assets i.e. the house. That's why its not fair. Even if DPs worse off paying his mortgage it's still building his assets, his money si still going back to him in the future.

A reduced rate or amount to cover about 50% of the interest (which obviously is unlikely to be as low as 200) is reasonable. Half the mortgage is not

This makes sense. I’ve reread the OP and realised that she’s asked about 50/50. My bad. 50/50 is too much but she should pay some money which is what I have been saying. And the bulk of furniture, which she can take with her when leaving .
leakymcleakleak · 03/09/2021 10:31

@TractorAndHeadphones Its not always cheaper, but actually I think the issue is more the perception. 'Opportunity cost' rather than real cost. So, you live with your partner for 7 years: yes its 'his' flat but you pay half the bills, you know you're both going to sell and use it for a deposit on a house when you're ready to have kids, you've been involved in the redecoration, you both see it as 'our home'.

If you were both living in a rented flat, still planning those kids, even if rent was higher you would personally be ensuring keeping an eye on savings. Your partner wouldn't say 'oh we can totally afford to go on that holiday abroad, look how much the equity has increased in the last year.' If you were living in a rented flat on your own, and 7 years had passed, you'd be thinking about your own security and not relying on a flat that you don't actually have any legal right to.

I know a LOT of people who made financial decisions in long term relationships based on an assumption they'd always be together that screwed them when they split, ranging from supporting a partner through retraining by picking up bills (it will be alright because when he goes into the higher paying job he'll make up for it) to trusting they lived in a 'shared' house until suddenly they split, weren't married and didn't have names on the deeds. I don't think the OP should be so much better off from moving in, but I do think its right they think about it and think about whats fair now vs in a couple of years.

CarrotTops · 03/09/2021 10:30

But you don't split everything when you move in together

It depends on so many things. Splitting everything straight down the middle a lot of the time just isn't fair. If one is say a cleaner and the other an investment banker going 50/50 is never going to be fair

CarrotTops · 03/09/2021 10:28

If the mortgage is 1000 and the interest is 200 (these are total bs figures btw)

Op pays 100 a month which is half the interest. She can then save 900 a month

Ops DP pays 900 a month, 800 of which is going towards his assets 100 towards the interest. He has a spare 100 a month he can save

After 10 months OP will have saved 9000

After 10 months DP will have 8000 additional assets and 1000 savings- 9000

If OP pays half the mortgage 500. Then at the end of the relationship OP has saved 5000, whilst the DP has increased his assets by 8000 plus the 5000 that he has then saved on mortgage payments so a total of 13000. He walks away much better off

Anything that isn't interest on the mortgage is essentially going into the DPs savings because it is going towards his assets i.e. the house. That's why its not fair. Even if DPs worse off paying his mortgage it's still building his assets, his money si still going back to him in the future.

A reduced rate or amount to cover about 50% of the interest (which obviously is unlikely to be as low as 200) is reasonable. Half the mortgage is not

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 10:26

@CarrotTops

I don't think living in someone's house is being subsidised by them.

It's their house, they chose to buy based on their earnings. They aren't paying more money than the house they chose to buy or paying more money because a partner moves in (this case is slightly different). Like anything else it's the houseowners possession which they are paying for. Its not OPs possession, it's her DPs.

Everyone gets so het up on living rent free, but as long as the partner pays their fair share of bills, does their fair share of housework etc I don't really understand why someone you love living rent free is such a horrific thought. As I said my mortgage doesn't increase because I move a partner in and I'm getting a house out of it. (The lodger complicates the situation)

It should never be a long term thing, that would be freeloading. If you've lived together longer than say 6 months or a year you should be looking to buy together, ideally with the money saved from not renting. But if at the end of the relationship one partner walks away with a house and the other savings equivalent of a house it sounds reasonable

The point isn’t how many savings people have or whether the amount changes. The point is paying an ‘equal share of all costs’ include the costs of living. Which is either rent or mortgage. If someone was renting a flat and their partner moved it - would you expect a share of the rent although it’s the same? If yes then you should expect a payment for living there.

Taking it further you could argue that an extra person adds a minimal amount onto the bill so anyone moving in should only cover this and not half the bills etc etc.

In the end - if you move in together you split everything. For the mortgage it’s fair to not split in half and make a token payment enabling non-owning partner to save, but to expect to pay nothing (either in cash or kind) means that one partner bears the full burden of an expense. That’s not sharing.

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 10:20

@leakymcleakleak

Is there a compromise whereby you don't pay towards the capital repayments?

So, work out what his interest repayments on the mortgage are every month. Pay half that, and half the other bills. The rest of the amount you 'save' and put into an account that is in your name but will count towards a joint deposit in future assuming you stay together. Yes, he'll 'lose out' a bit from not having the lodger but you'll both gain from having the house to yourselves/being able to wander around in a towel/etc etc. Also, if you decide to do some intensive saving after a year or so you could always get a lodger back again.

The thing I think people miss is that living together for the first time is generally a trial. Yes you're committed, but sometimes things don't work out. If you're married, the court tries to work out what's fair, but if your'e not I think you need to treat every stage with consideration given to 'what would be fair if we split up next month? Next year? In 5 years?'

For lots of people contributing to someone else's mortgage means they aren't saving for a deposit for their own which they would do if still single/if with someone who didn't already own a house. With my now DH, when we first lived together I earned more than him, we rented, and the deal was we split all the bills including rent but I bought all the furniture outright and tried to save a chunk of the difference in our income so if we split, that would be mine, if we didn't it would officially become 'ours'. We now have totally joint finances but it was a staggered process: sometimes advise is given here like it doesn't make a difference whether you've been together a decade or are just moving from dating to trying out living together.

Your last paragraph doesn’t make sense. It’s the opposite. People who rent (single or otherwise) are the ones who can’t save for a deposit because high rents eat up all their money. People who stay with a partners save money even when paying towards the mortgage. Because it’s cheaper than rent.

So moving in with a partner also benefits the non-owning one!

CarrotTops · 03/09/2021 10:16

I don't think living in someone's house is being subsidised by them.

It's their house, they chose to buy based on their earnings. They aren't paying more money than the house they chose to buy or paying more money because a partner moves in (this case is slightly different). Like anything else it's the houseowners possession which they are paying for. Its not OPs possession, it's her DPs.

Everyone gets so het up on living rent free, but as long as the partner pays their fair share of bills, does their fair share of housework etc I don't really understand why someone you love living rent free is such a horrific thought. As I said my mortgage doesn't increase because I move a partner in and I'm getting a house out of it. (The lodger complicates the situation)

It should never be a long term thing, that would be freeloading. If you've lived together longer than say 6 months or a year you should be looking to buy together, ideally with the money saved from not renting. But if at the end of the relationship one partner walks away with a house and the other savings equivalent of a house it sounds reasonable

beingsunny · 03/09/2021 10:08

It also sounds as though his spare room will also be yours, so you will actually be having use of more of the space than him?

beingsunny · 03/09/2021 10:03

I would consider paying half the interest payment on the mortgage plus half utilities.

That way you aren't paying down the mortgage.

lunar1 · 03/09/2021 09:59

You need to buy whatever furniture you need, free standing not fitted. Then pay whatever the lodger did plus your contribution to food. Your partner will remain responsible for the repair and maintenance of the house.

LittleMysSister · 03/09/2021 09:48

See I don't understand this - they're not partners yet in the way I understand it. Two independent adults just starting to live together are still trying each other out.

I'd say usually people are pretty solid by the point of moving in together. It might not work out in the long-term, but they have likely still been together a while before even making this move.

Katiebee008 · 03/09/2021 09:43

So you're happy to pay your current landlords mortgage and provide a profit, but not happy to split your partners mortgage cost?

idontlikealdi · 03/09/2021 09:40

He should rent the other room out and you rent somewhere together split 50/50.

Worldgonecrazy · 03/09/2021 09:39

Also ditto to what @FlowerArranger said about not becoming the cleaner. I think there is a biological / evolutionary urge within women to prove what a good potential mate we are by demonstrating our nest / cave/mud hut / house keeping skills by initially taking on all the cleaning and cooking , and before you know it you end up in the role permanently.

leakymcleakleak · 03/09/2021 09:37

@Worldgonecrazy

It should only be 50/50 if you both earn the same. Otherwise ratio it to your earnings, so if one partner earns twice the other, bills and outgoings would be split roughly 66/33 and so on, likewise spare money should also be shared. There are so many threads on the relay boards where the lower earner (usually the woman) is scrimping and going without to provide for the children while the higher earner indulges themselves with what they regard as ‘their money’.

That is the fair way to do it in a relationship, by ratio. You are a partnership not a business and each should give according to means.

If you took a year or two out to raise a family and had little income would he still expect you to pay half? If so, the hills are that way —> start running Grin

See I don't understand this - they're not partners yet in the way I understand it. Two independent adults just starting to live together are still trying each other out. If you've been together for five years, lived together for three, are committed to each other but have agreed you don't want marriage then yes, that's probably a fair way to do it. But early in a relationship, starting to live together to in part see if you're compatible, with no kids.... I think the 'ratio' way of doing it implies a much higher level of commitment than is right to expect from either party.
sbhydrogen · 03/09/2021 09:37

I can never understand why people are happy to pay a landlord's mortgage for years on end but then not be prepared to contribute to a loved one's mortgage even when it means they'll be financially better off.

Hear, hear!

I'd get an Idea PAX wardrobe and make it fitted by adding architraves and decorators caulk. That way you can take it with you if you ever split.

leakymcleakleak · 03/09/2021 09:35

Is there a compromise whereby you don't pay towards the capital repayments?

So, work out what his interest repayments on the mortgage are every month. Pay half that, and half the other bills. The rest of the amount you 'save' and put into an account that is in your name but will count towards a joint deposit in future assuming you stay together. Yes, he'll 'lose out' a bit from not having the lodger but you'll both gain from having the house to yourselves/being able to wander around in a towel/etc etc. Also, if you decide to do some intensive saving after a year or so you could always get a lodger back again.

The thing I think people miss is that living together for the first time is generally a trial. Yes you're committed, but sometimes things don't work out. If you're married, the court tries to work out what's fair, but if your'e not I think you need to treat every stage with consideration given to 'what would be fair if we split up next month? Next year? In 5 years?'

For lots of people contributing to someone else's mortgage means they aren't saving for a deposit for their own which they would do if still single/if with someone who didn't already own a house. With my now DH, when we first lived together I earned more than him, we rented, and the deal was we split all the bills including rent but I bought all the furniture outright and tried to save a chunk of the difference in our income so if we split, that would be mine, if we didn't it would officially become 'ours'. We now have totally joint finances but it was a staggered process: sometimes advise is given here like it doesn't make a difference whether you've been together a decade or are just moving from dating to trying out living together.

Worldgonecrazy · 03/09/2021 09:35

It should only be 50/50 if you both earn the same. Otherwise ratio it to your earnings, so if one partner earns twice the other, bills and outgoings would be split roughly 66/33 and so on, likewise spare money should also be shared. There are so many threads on the relay boards where the lower earner (usually the woman) is scrimping and going without to provide for the children while the higher earner indulges themselves with what they regard as ‘their money’.

That is the fair way to do it in a relationship, by ratio. You are a partnership not a business and each should give according to means.

If you took a year or two out to raise a family and had little income would he still expect you to pay half? If so, the hills are that way —> start running Grin

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 09:32

@CarrotTops

Or you could look at it that he clearly has a mortgage that he can't afford and he needs to find someone to pay it. Moves in his girlfriend so she pays half, ultimately the more he pays off on his mortgage the better the house he'll be able to own in the future.

He could just move in a succession of girlfriends to pay his mortgage. It should be a mutually beneficial. What is the mortgage, what is the rent on a room? What can OP afford? These are all questions you need to answer before just a flat out half. What's the difference between the two incomes?

Say mortgage is 1000, room is 500. Op paying 250 means they both save about 250 each. You say 'we will do this for x months, if all good after x months we will get a place together and rent this/sell this'

That’s why he had a lodger. Did you even read the OP’s post?
Swipe left for the next trending thread