Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving in to DP's mortgaged house... who should pay?

291 replies

hollsmoi · 02/09/2021 20:36

I'm shortly due to leave my rental property to move in with DP who already owns a property. The plan is to live together there for a while and if all goes well, we will rent out his place and purchase somewhere together which is more suitable. We are in central London so DP currently rents out one of his bedrooms to a lodger (he makes a lot of profit from this), who will be moving out when I move in.

DP has implied that he expects us to split all outgoings for the house 50/50. Having never moved in to a partner's home, I'm not sure this is right. Without question I will be contributing 50/50 to all of the household bills, council tax, food shop etc. but part of me feels uncomfortable about essentially paying half of his mortgage as 'rent'. AIBU?

Also, when I move in we are needing to covert the spare bedroom to an office space and storage area for me e.g. desks, built in wardrobes and drawers for my things. DP has mentioned when "we" buy these things which again implies 50/50. WIBU to expecting DP to fund this since it's his property and in the event that things didn't work out, he would benefit from them i.e. they'd remain in his property. Thoughts welcome as I'm new to this!

OP posts:
Thisisworsethananticpated · 03/09/2021 16:54

I’d say a fair deal would be shared bills
And a contribution to mortgage
Not 50% that’s a tad high

callmeadoctor · 03/09/2021 16:47

Continue to pay the same as lodger, and move your own desk etc in (I assume you have one?)

Hekatestorch · 03/09/2021 16:21

He shouldn't be trying to profit out his gf.

He isn't.

cupofdecaf · 03/09/2021 15:55

How is this any different from when a man moves into a woman's house and she loses benefits because she's no longer living as a single parent? No one would tell her the man shouldn't contribute.
In OPs situation her OH is losing the income from the lodger.
In my view you should pay him a reasonable rent but that isn't automatically half of the mortgage. Not only are you living there, his lodger is moving out and you're taking over and working from the spare room. You can't expect that for free.
I also would say you should pay all the cost of setting up your office. If you're worried about his assets/ property then could he rent it again if it's fitted out as an office? If not you're not increasing its value. Buy furniture you can take with you or sell if you want but I think you're being cheeky expecting him to fund any of it.

When my DH moved into my house he paid rent and 1/2 of the shared bills. We also wrote an agreement that meant if something happened to me he wouldn't lose his home straight away. Now we're married it's all immaterial and frankly he's done rather well out of it given how much it's gone up in value. His reasoning was he'd be paying rent elsewhere and didn't expect to live somewhere for free. I equally didn't take the mick and paid for all maintenance/ repairs etc.

Lockdownbear · 03/09/2021 15:47

Then the argument stretches to ‘why should she pay any of the bills or expenses - it’s not a business deal’.

Because presumably she's using sharing the heating and other living expenses. He shouldn't be trying to profit out his gf.

Hekatestorch · 03/09/2021 15:46

@Lockdownbear

He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal.

So she can financially benefit. Which she is, even paying half.

He is losing out even if she pays half. So is she just doing it as a money saving exercise instead of seeing it as a relationship.

And actually, tying your finances together in anyway needs to looked at removing the emotion from the situation. It's not an emotional decision to make.

Its a financial one. Op is benefitting, even without having an interest in the property. He is not. And was better off with his lodger.

Lockdownbear · 03/09/2021 15:40

So the day after the wedding its ok to demand she starts paying half? Should he expect back pay too?

The day after the wedding she'd be able to put claim on the house.
I don't know English laws but in Scotland he wouldn't be able to sell without her signature. And she'd be able to claim on any increase in value from the point of the wedding. But not on what he owned at the point of the wedding.

So definitely no she shouldn't back-pay and actually I think she should seek legal advice before putting anything into it even if she was married.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 03/09/2021 15:37

@KingdomScrolls

I owned my flat when DH moved in, everything was 50/50 including mortgage and it was costing him significantly less than his previous rental. When i sold it the profit went into our joint property, and even then he wanted me to ringfence my equity, I said no because we were about to get married anyway. Frankly I think he is being generous paying for half of a home office he has no need for when he's already losing money by losing his lodger.
Did you add him to the mortgage deeds?
KingdomScrolls · 03/09/2021 15:33

I owned my flat when DH moved in, everything was 50/50 including mortgage and it was costing him significantly less than his previous rental. When i sold it the profit went into our joint property, and even then he wanted me to ringfence my equity, I said no because we were about to get married anyway. Frankly I think he is being generous paying for half of a home office he has no need for when he's already losing money by losing his lodger.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/09/2021 15:22

@Lockdownbear

He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal.

So the day after the wedding its ok to demand she starts paying half? Should he expect back pay too?

My ex charged his new gf half the rent but saved it up on the understanding that if they split he'd give it back and if they married it would be a lump sum off the mortgage / towards the wedding etc

SleepingStandingUp · 03/09/2021 15:20

@Lockdownbear

He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal.

Why should it cost him money but save her hundreds? And if the sexes were reversed she'd be told he's a cocklodger who's just using her to save up for his own deposit.
Makhiaman · 03/09/2021 15:13

What’s the female equivalent of a cocklodger?

Of course you should pay half of everything.

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 15:09

@Lockdownbear

He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal.

Then the argument stretches to ‘why should she pay any of the bills or expenses - it’s not a business deal’.

The difference is that you (and several posters) view it as a capital expense, contributing to the assets.
Others like myself view it as a normal expense like gas, water, and electricity.
Again though I don’t think half is fair - the interest and a bit on top yes, but not nothing . I don’t suppose you mean nothing either .
Anyway OP is going to discuss it so there’s no point in the thread anymore

ManifestDestinee · 03/09/2021 15:07

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal

And why should she live rent free? It's a relationship not a freeloading, money saving enterprise

Lockdownbear · 03/09/2021 15:05

He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset

That's my logic why should she pay toward his asset. Its a relationship not a business deal.

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/09/2021 15:01

Lodgers still have rights
www.tenancyagreementservice.co.uk/lodger-legal-rights

Horehound · 03/09/2021 14:59

I think it should be looked at separately than comparing to a lodger renting.
I initially posted saying she should pay half but after a discussion with my husband he was shocked when I read out the op.
He made me see that it is a bit weird to be expecting your gf/bf to pay half towards what is their asset
It's a relationship not a business deal. So if the guy sees it as a negative that he is losing a lodger but can't see the fun/moving forward with a relationship then that's not a great sign imo.

FoxesAtDawn · 03/09/2021 14:57

It's the exact same as being a lodger. And lodgers pay money to lodge. They don't lodge for free and take another bedroom as an office and expert free office equipment as well.

Nor do lodgers pay exactly 50/50 of all household related costs and mortgage. The pay a set amount which includes rent + bills.

LittleMysSister · 03/09/2021 14:55

@ManifestDestinee

OP’s situation is nothing like renting from a LL. She will have no tenancy agreement, no protections and nothing to stop her being thrown out with immediate effect so I don’t think it’s a reasonable comparison

It's the exact same as being a lodger. And lodgers pay money to lodge. They don't lodge for free and take another bedroom as an office and expert free office equipment as well.

Also the eventual plan is to buy somewhere together so in the long-term OP will benefit as they will presumably be able to afford a better property by using the deposit raised by this house.
BatshitCrazyWoman · 03/09/2021 14:52

@Mayorquimby2

Seems he's trading one type of lodger for another
I agree. A lodger or a tenant has rights, protected by law. A landlord also is not in relationship and having sex with his tenant/lodger. He could just chuck the OP out with no notice and she'd have to find someone else.

OP I'd not build anything in to the property. And save so if it all goes tits up you can rent again.

ManifestDestinee · 03/09/2021 14:44

OP’s situation is nothing like renting from a LL. She will have no tenancy agreement, no protections and nothing to stop her being thrown out with immediate effect so I don’t think it’s a reasonable comparison

It's the exact same as being a lodger. And lodgers pay money to lodge. They don't lodge for free and take another bedroom as an office and expert free office equipment as well.

Maskless · 03/09/2021 14:16

Why don't you simply pay exactly what the lodger used to pay? Your DP was happy with that. And if you went into any other house share that is what you would pay.

Plus of course half the food, which would not have been part of the lodger's rent.

What's wrong with that?

Movingsoon21 · 03/09/2021 14:16

You were paying rent to live in your previous flat so why wouldn’t you pay rent to DP? How come you get to live for free and his home outgoings double as he’s lost his lodger? That makes no sense and would make you a cheeky freeloader!

Why not just pay him whatever you paid for rent at your last place. You won’t be any worse off and although he will be as his lodger was paying a lot, hopefully it will be worth it for him to have you live there!

FoxesAtDawn · 03/09/2021 14:12

OP’s situation is nothing like renting from a LL. She will have no tenancy agreement, no protections and nothing to stop her being thrown out with immediate effect so I don’t think it’s a reasonable comparison.

It’s tricky because I do think a contribution is fair but 50/50 for none of the normal protections from renting doesn’t sound fair. Plus think about it this way - OP continues to pay rent whilst damaging her saving capacity. When they buy together partner has only been paying half the mortgage but gets to put the 100% of equity into his share and OP can only contribute what’s she’s been able to save so they’ll never end up being on equal footing.

I don’t think there’s one right answer to this, but I do think there needs to be some consideration for safeguarding OP’s future.

Kithic · 03/09/2021 13:53

@Lockdownbear

He's not loosing money, he's investing in his house that she has no claim over. He will always have the money that he pays into the capital of the mortgage.

The interest is a cost that I view differently.

he has a lodger who will be moving out when OP moves in, We are in central London so DP currently rents out one of his bedrooms to a lodger (he makes a lot of profit from this), who will be moving out when I move in. if thats not losing money, then i dont know what is
Swipe left for the next trending thread