Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Discovered (by accident) BIL is bankrupt. Do I tell SIL?

487 replies

PoppyWoods · 02/09/2021 20:08

Part of my job is to check the insolvency register. It's a public register, freely accessible to all.

I put in various names, mine, my parents, my sisters and brothers, not expecting to find anything. Anyway to my horror I discovered my BIL was declared bankrupt 3 months ago. It's definitely him as it lists full name, address and dob.

My SIL has never mentioned it. We're fairly close and she's disclosed very personal things to me in the past, so I'm wondering if she even knows. Is it even possible that he could go through the process and her be totally unaware?

My dilemma is, do I tell her or not? What if she doesn't know? What if she does know and she's so mortified she hasn't told anyone? What if she accuses me of snooping and interfering?

I honestly don't know what I do with this information (if anything). Appreciate your thoughts

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/09/2021 11:18

@MurielSpriggs

It worked when I tried it just now putting a random surname on.

It's very odd, I get the message in the picture. (Obviously I'm a nice respectable lady, and would definitely not be using to look at neighbours, colleagues, ex-husbands etc.)

Wrong register perhaps

www.gov.uk/government/organisations/insolvency-service

SeptemberAlexandra · 03/09/2021 11:09

Urghhhhh

SeptemberAlexandra
If I was the SIL I’d be pretty annoyed that someone was snooping on my family, irrespective of whether it was public information or not.
Would you still feel the same if you hadnt known about the bankruptcy? I seriously doubt it.

I would consider neither one of them trustworthy or worthy of my time. They would both have breached my trust. So, yes, I would have felt exactly the same.

LongTimeMammaBear · 03/09/2021 11:03

Just for those who still try to hang on to whether there is GDPR or HR issues, here is one of multiple ways to view the register for insolvency/bankruptcy as well as disqualified directors

Public record.years ago, before I tweet, the gazette would be published similar to a news paper and readily available just like ordering a newspaper or going to the library to read it as well as past publications on microfiche

www.gov.uk/search-bankruptcy-insolvency-register

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:58

Why do you agree that this could break data protection rules, @DoItAfraid? Which section of the Act does looking at information on a public website breach?

FleasInMyKnees · 03/09/2021 10:57

I am sure OP can fess up ask her employer if this was morally and legally ok and if it's a disciplinary offense just to clarify the situation for us all.

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:57

Seems an odd thing to do it wouldn’t cross my mind to access this register and enter people I know details into it

I bet that's only because you didn't know about it. Be honest, if you thought someone you knew might be on the register, would you really go all holier-than-thou and refuse to check? Even if you were thinking of lending money to them?

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 10:52

@Tinkerbellfluffyboots79

You were being nosy and something you discovered something, it’s handy in these situations to think before you act as obs now you’ve found out you can’t unknow and you want to tell your sister. I would too. But will your sister be happy you’re snooping I know mine wouldn’t!! It’s none of my business you should’ve thought about the consequences of your actions in this case. Especially if it’s done in work time on work equipment.

I’m a nurse and I can’t look up anyone I know or my family on work time on computers to even find out the date of an appointment nor can my colleagues do it for me. It’s not allowed for good reason. This may be a public register but it’s also part of your job. Seems an odd thing to do it wouldn’t cross my mind to access this register and enter people I know details into it.

Medical info in a private database is entirely different. OP accessed public data published by the goverment.

15 pages in and this is still not clear to everyone?

DoItAfraid · 03/09/2021 10:48

@justfuckoffthelottayer

I think you may find you are breaking all sorts of data protection and fsa rules and laws by randomly searching people you know, I wouldn't be surprised if that was a sackable offence people have a right to privacy and you have no right to snoop. None of your business they didn't tell you because they don't want or need to discuss it with you so keep your nose out and stop spying on people.
Agree with this.
Tinkerbellfluffyboots79 · 03/09/2021 10:46

You were being nosy and something you discovered something, it’s handy in these situations to think before you act as obs now you’ve found out you can’t unknow and you want to tell your sister. I would too. But will your sister be happy you’re snooping I know mine wouldn’t!! It’s none of my business you should’ve thought about the consequences of your actions in this case. Especially if it’s done in work time on work equipment.

I’m a nurse and I can’t look up anyone I know or my family on work time on computers to even find out the date of an appointment nor can my colleagues do it for me. It’s not allowed for good reason. This may be a public register but it’s also part of your job. Seems an odd thing to do it wouldn’t cross my mind to access this register and enter people I know details into it.

Allfednonedead · 03/09/2021 10:37

I am amazed at all these people who are never curious or bored!

For what to do, I think I would not say directly to SIL, but (assuming you like her and want to be supportive) I'd make an extra effort to stay in touch and give her space to talk about her life.
Even if she doesn't know, there will be repercussions in her life, so she needs a friend.
Think of this as a helpful signal to you to actively be her friend before she is really struggling.

FleasInMyKnees · 03/09/2021 10:36

So just tell her what you found, what's the worse that can happen. She will either say she knows but didnt want anyone else involved or she will say she didnt know. If she asks have you told anyone else just say yes, discussed it with DH and posted it on mn, if she gets upset or angry then deal with it at the time. If her H gets angry that you snooped then deal with that too and apologise for being nosy and bored at work.

LagunaBubbles · 03/09/2021 10:35

This is rapidly turning into cancel the cheque!

Excelthetube · 03/09/2021 10:30

This is the thread that keeps giving.

I can’t believe after 15 pages people still think this is illegal.

It’s public
FML

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:24

What you have done isnt lawful. So no

How exactly is it not lawful, @Newmumatlast?

MyBadHabitsLeadToYou · 03/09/2021 10:24

I honestly love this thread Grin

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:21

[quote luckylavender]@caughtinanet - you have maybe never worked in Financial Services. As I said Employment Contracts are key here. Sneer all you like.[/quote]
No employment contract is going to prohibit employees from using public websites as a data protection/financial services duty issue. It might have rules around using the internet during office hours on the employer's equipment, but that's not the point you're making.

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:17

No Data Protection issues, public register

That’s irrelevant that it’s a public register. You should only be accessing an individual’s data as and when your job requires it. Not to snoop on people you know

Self-evidently, the fact that it's a pubic register is 100% relevant to the question of whether there are Data Protection issues. Why do you think otherwise, @BritWifeInUSA?

Jemand · 03/09/2021 10:14

@bobbeebob

Would you get in trouble at work?

What about their GDPR policy?

Dont get yourself in trouble

How could looking at a public website breach GDPR?
Sunshinealligator · 03/09/2021 09:39

@PoppyWoods

Part of my job is to check the insolvency register. It's a public register, freely accessible to all.

I put in various names, mine, my parents, my sisters and brothers, not expecting to find anything. Anyway to my horror I discovered my BIL was declared bankrupt 3 months ago. It's definitely him as it lists full name, address and dob.

My SIL has never mentioned it. We're fairly close and she's disclosed very personal things to me in the past, so I'm wondering if she even knows. Is it even possible that he could go through the process and her be totally unaware?

My dilemma is, do I tell her or not? What if she doesn't know? What if she does know and she's so mortified she hasn't told anyone? What if she accuses me of snooping and interfering?

I honestly don't know what I do with this information (if anything). Appreciate your thoughts

As someone who's husband was made bankrupt, I would discuss it with her, because if she doesn't know, this will all be earth shattering for her.

When my Husband was made bankrupt, he had "borrowed" from me in the form of taking out credit in my name, and maxed out 5 credit cards in my name. He also took me to a car showroom (I didn't even drive at the time) and explained to me that if I took out the credit for the car, I'd get a better rate on the loan, than he would. So I took out a £12k loan.
I found a letter about his bankruptcy hearing about 3 days before.

Then I realised I'd been duped by him, all of the bills were in arrears, I'd been giving him money to pay, but he was gambling it all away.

I didn't have money to pay off those loans on my own, the credit cards he promised to pay off after he purchased things like car insurance on them, work tools, petrol to get to work-that sort of thing.
I was then saddled with council tax debts, water debts, electric debts and then our late rent

It's turning into a bit of a tangent, but what I'm trying to get accross is if he's secretive enough that she doesn't know he was being made bankrupt, she may find herself with letters from debt collectors quite soon, which she will need to take entire responsibility of.

I'm so sorry that your sister is going through this.

HeartsAndClubs · 03/09/2021 09:24

I know next to nothing about bankruptcy but I find it unlikely that she doesn't know or won't know soon enough. Do you really want to be the one that throws that grenade? She may not want her family to know. That's her choice. And if she doesn't know that's a whole other kettle of fish. but as PP said, what if she then asks that family to lend her money, and they do so while oblivious of the fact that the reason she needs that money is because her husband has made them bankrupt through his gambling debts?

Also, there are ramifications here. If you’ve been declared bankrupt then you can’t have family for instance pay for certain things in your life because that money is considered an income. You can’t be given gifts because those gifts are then considered assets and can be seized.

We had a friend who went bankrupt because his wife was seriously ill and there were major implications to that which I won’t go into, but it wasn’t anything they had any control of.

But when we offered to help them pay for their DD’s drama classes out of school we were told that he wasn’t allowed to accept any kind of payment from us.

When her mum bought her a digital piano the mum had to say that it was actually her’s and that it was being stored in their house.

The reality is that if they are declared bankrupt to the extent their property and assets are seized it’s not something they’re going to be able to keep from family anyway.

DeadButDelicious · 03/09/2021 09:12

I would stay right out of this. You've gone snooping on family members, they may not take that too kindly. I know I wouldn't.

I know next to nothing about bankruptcy but I find it unlikely that she doesn't know or won't know soon enough. Do you really want to be the one that throws that grenade? She may not want her family to know. That's her choice. And if she doesn't know that's a whole other kettle of fish.

Quite the sticky wicket you've got yourself in here.

GnomeDePlume · 03/09/2021 09:06

Never seen a thread with so much pearl clutching and 'outrage'!

(plus lots of nonsense about GDPR, gross misconduct etc)

Lots of information sits in the public domain. Bankruptcy is there so that anyone potentially lending money or trading with someone can check.

One of my concerns in this scenario would be family members being asked to help out and finding that they are effectively throwing good money after bad.

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 09:05

@SeptemberAlexandra

If I was the SIL I’d be pretty annoyed that someone was snooping on my family, irrespective of whether it was public information or not.
Would you still feel the same if you hadnt known about the bankruptcy? I seriously doubt it.
SeptemberAlexandra · 03/09/2021 09:04

If I was the SIL I’d be pretty annoyed that someone was snooping on my family, irrespective of whether it was public information or not.

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 09:01

@PoppyWoods, i'm with you OP.
I would be concerned that she'll be blindsighted and I couldn't stand around and do nothing.

I would drop her the info anonymously. That way if she does know, no harm is done to your relationship. Don't second guess yourself based on all these misinformed and selfrightous comments.