Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Discovered (by accident) BIL is bankrupt. Do I tell SIL?

487 replies

PoppyWoods · 02/09/2021 20:08

Part of my job is to check the insolvency register. It's a public register, freely accessible to all.

I put in various names, mine, my parents, my sisters and brothers, not expecting to find anything. Anyway to my horror I discovered my BIL was declared bankrupt 3 months ago. It's definitely him as it lists full name, address and dob.

My SIL has never mentioned it. We're fairly close and she's disclosed very personal things to me in the past, so I'm wondering if she even knows. Is it even possible that he could go through the process and her be totally unaware?

My dilemma is, do I tell her or not? What if she doesn't know? What if she does know and she's so mortified she hasn't told anyone? What if she accuses me of snooping and interfering?

I honestly don't know what I do with this information (if anything). Appreciate your thoughts

OP posts:
Waferbiscuit · 03/09/2021 16:20

This thread had taught me that one of the cardinal British values appears to be to ‘mind your own business’ which is followed closely by ‘turn a blind eye.’ Well done.

3scape · 03/09/2021 14:58

You were snooping and I hope that your employer keeps a record of your searches. Isn't it hugely inappropriate for you to be searching family members, presumably on work time? If it was out of work time you were still massively over stepping your boundaries.

phishy · 03/09/2021 14:52

@HyggeTygge

The glee is just pouring out of all your posts, OP

No it isn't.
What a bizarre thing to write.

"No it isn't"

What a riveting response. Not.

Excelthetube · 03/09/2021 14:40

@HeartsAndClubs
Haha so true. 90 % of people on this thread clearly aren’t in the top 5% bracket of earners.

Excelthetube · 03/09/2021 14:39

17 PAGES
AND STILL PEOPLE CANT UNDERSTAND THAT ALL INFO ABOUT BANKRUPTCIES IS AVAILABLE TO ANYONE WHO WANTS TO LOOK.

IT IS PUBLIC.
IT IS NOT ILLEGAL

Lockheart · 03/09/2021 14:05

@HeartsAndClubs

Well if one thing has come out of this thread, it’s that it’s finally dispelled the myth that mumsnet is full of well educated and intelligent women. 😂😂😂
It wasn't always this stupid, it used to have the reputation for a more well educated user base, but now it's devolved.
RincewindsHat · 03/09/2021 14:01

I think I would have a private conversation with her.

Own up, and explain what you were doing and why and that you accidentally found out something which is non of your business.

See how she reacts. If she lets you know she's aware of the bankruptcy, apologise, let her know you will not disclose this to anyone else, and offer to support her in any way you can.

If she doesn't know, break the news to her gently and say you wanted to offer her support and again, you will not share the information with anyone else.

She's unlikely to respond well either way, but at least you will have done the best you could in a sensitive way.

HeartsAndClubs · 03/09/2021 13:48

Well if one thing has come out of this thread, it’s that it’s finally dispelled the myth that mumsnet is full of well educated and intelligent women. 😂😂😂

HyggeTygge · 03/09/2021 13:28

muriel Grin
"No it isn't. What a bizarre thing to write" could pretty much be posted appropriately on any AIBU thread after ~150 posts!

Jemand · 03/09/2021 13:21

@BritWifeInUSA, I've literally cut and pasted what you posted, in which you in turn specifically quoted the reference to the Data Protection Act before claiming that it's irrelevant. This is no more snooping that looking up people you know on Google or Facebook.

MurielSpriggs · 03/09/2021 13:19

@HyggeTygge

The glee is just pouring out of all your posts, OP

No it isn't.
What a bizarre thing to write.

I love this thread, it's the very worst of Mumsnet all in one place!

We've had inability to comprehend, wilful refusal to comprehend, ridiculous misinformation conveyed as settled fact, pearl-clutching judgmentalism, scapegoating projection, legal mumbojumbo from the ignorant, and now complete delusion Grin

Foxmylife · 03/09/2021 13:16

You didnt find out by accident.Hmm Of course don’t tell her.

BritWifeInUSA · 03/09/2021 13:12

@Jemand

No Data Protection issues, public register

That’s irrelevant that it’s a public register. You should only be accessing an individual’s data as and when your job requires it. Not to snoop on people you know

Self-evidently, the fact that it's a pubic register is 100% relevant to the question of whether there are Data Protection issues. Why do you think otherwise, @BritWifeInUSA?

I didn’t mention anything about data protection issues. I don’t know why you misinterpreted my list to assume that I did. I’m talking about ethics and morals. Just because the information is in the public domain, doesn’t mean it’s right to snoop.

She snooped because she wanted to find something, otherwise she wouldn’t have snooped. Now that she’s found something, she should have the decency to tell the people that she looked them up and what she found. If she can’t bear to do that, it shows she knows it was ethically and morally wrong.

user1471457751 · 03/09/2021 12:59

@FleasInMyKnees she doesn't need to ask her employer. It's a public database she checked, one that any of us can access. What possible legal issue do you think arises here?

HyggeTygge · 03/09/2021 12:56

The glee is just pouring out of all your posts, OP

No it isn't.
What a bizarre thing to write.

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 12:43

@SeptemberAlexandra

Urghhhhh

SeptemberAlexandra
If I was the SIL I’d be pretty annoyed that someone was snooping on my family, irrespective of whether it was public information or not.
Would you still feel the same if you hadnt known about the bankruptcy? I seriously doubt it.

I would consider neither one of them trustworthy or worthy of my time. They would both have breached my trust. So, yes, I would have felt exactly the same.

Oh wow...
phishy · 03/09/2021 12:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

safariboot · 03/09/2021 12:22

I'm going with the minority view YANBU. It wasn't my first instinct, but as you say it is public information, and it's also something that could hurt SIL if he somehow manages to cover up.

Isn't it not uncommon for a man to have a financial screwup and the first the wife knows is when the bailiffs knock on the door to evict her and the children?

HyggeTygge · 03/09/2021 12:09

Anonymous tipoffs are rarely a good idea because then she will be preoccupied with "who is the mystery sender? " (and it's likely to all come out anyway)

MattHancocksSexTape · 03/09/2021 12:07

@PoppyWoods if you want to make sure your SIL knows but without the fallout of your snooping, then print a copy of the order and post it to her.

blueshoes · 03/09/2021 12:05

[quote luckylavender]@blueshoes - how am I scare mongering? If the OP has nothing to hide she'll be fine. [/quote]
You are are scare mongering because OP has nothing to hide. She will be fine. I am afraid your advice is misleading.

OP does not work in Financial Services. OP is not accessing a company confidential database - for the nth time, it is a public database meant for public to check.

At most, it is a breach of her company's IT Acceptable Use Policy if she accesses the internet during work hours (we do not know that) or if she is skivving during work hours (hey, tell me you have never done that). I can assure you that managers have bigger fish to fry than to monitor internet usage and if they wanted to enforce the 'employment contract' to the letter, then be prepared for the manager and almost all the workforce to be fired for these peccadillos.

Under data protection rules employers are also not always entitled to monitor employee internet activity. Employers have to balance the employees' expectation of privacy and the employer must have a legitimate interest to monitor and have clear policies around it, particularly if the employer wishes to discipline or sack for such breaches.

Yes, you are scare mongering in the OP's case.

HarrietsChariot · 03/09/2021 11:57

It's fine to tell her, it's public information after all. No different to telling her that a house on her street sold for 230K last month or that the director of a company has a registered address down the road. It's just mundane everyday information, it's not harmful information because otherwise it wouldn't be publicly available. Even if he hasn't told her, he should have been aware that she could find out.

You just need to be a little cautious as to how you've done it, you don't want to come across as being bitchy or point scoring (not "Guess what I've found out about your husband!"). Try to be sensitive and aware that she might not react well.

Ultimately if he is hiding the truth from her, she needs to know. Not necessarily because him being bankrupt is anything to be ashamed of (depending on how he got into that position) but because of the deceit.

ClareBlue · 03/09/2021 11:47

This is the real crux of the matter, not accessing a public website.
If he is a compulsive gambler there will be lies, deceit and almost definitely loans and credit she knows nothing about. It's the nature of the beast.
So it is entirely feasible she knows nothing about this. Will she eventually, yes probably.

But if you read the OPs posts and can get past the fact she is going to lose her job for accessing public information (not) and is probably the worst person ever for putting family names into a public data base (like loads of people do), you see that she states she has a close relationship with SIL and have discussed personal things before AND the BIL has a history of secretive gambling debts.
So it is reasonable to think the SIL might not know. As PP have very clearly said, there can be situations when the first a spouse knows is when the house is taken or the bailiffs arrive.
Don't assume all communication has got to the SIL from creditors or the Courts.
Just read the threads on living with a pathological gambler to see what they will do to facilitate their addiction.

It's a really tough one but I would say something. I would say you came across it on the public register and just wondered if there was anything you could do to offer support in getting through it. No judgement but just supportive.

Pugdogmom · 03/09/2021 11:37

No it isn't a Data breach for looking up someone on a public register!
Yes, your SIL will know as she would probably have to provide her information for the OR ( our rules are different North of the Border, but unlikely that a spouse wouldn't know due to the information to be provided). I work in the Advice sector.
Your SIL didn't tell you for a reason, because most people are embarrassed about money issues. Oh and because of the fact that it is none of your damn business.
And I would keep quiet! Even on the slim chance she doesn't know , she won't thank you for your deliberate snooping, ditto ig she does.
What do you think will be gained by this, apart from a " I know something you don't know"

HyggeTygge · 03/09/2021 11:18

Never ceases to amaze me, the onslaught of idiocy, projection and not RTFT on mumsnet.
The very few articulate voices of sanity just about make it worthwhile posting, but ffs, the inability to think past one's knee-jerk reaction Hmm

I've worked in many a job where looking up people on various databases/ paperwork for non-work related reasons would get you fired.
None of these were public registers, designed to be accessed by the public, to find out about other members of the public. Because that is a key difference.

Op can you see if there is a notice in the paper and tell BIL you saw it?