Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Discovered (by accident) BIL is bankrupt. Do I tell SIL?

487 replies

PoppyWoods · 02/09/2021 20:08

Part of my job is to check the insolvency register. It's a public register, freely accessible to all.

I put in various names, mine, my parents, my sisters and brothers, not expecting to find anything. Anyway to my horror I discovered my BIL was declared bankrupt 3 months ago. It's definitely him as it lists full name, address and dob.

My SIL has never mentioned it. We're fairly close and she's disclosed very personal things to me in the past, so I'm wondering if she even knows. Is it even possible that he could go through the process and her be totally unaware?

My dilemma is, do I tell her or not? What if she doesn't know? What if she does know and she's so mortified she hasn't told anyone? What if she accuses me of snooping and interfering?

I honestly don't know what I do with this information (if anything). Appreciate your thoughts

OP posts:
ericaandfamily · 02/09/2021 22:30

Do you know how much impact it can have mentally to become bankrupt? Not just financially.

You sound like a nasty piece of work on your replies, keep your nose out of others business.

FinallyFluid · 02/09/2021 22:30

@SummaLuvin

What if she accuses me of snooping and interfering?

well...you were snooping

This.
Chloemol · 02/09/2021 22:30

@justfuckoffthelottayer

Here you go, search away

www.gov.uk/search-bankruptcy-insolvency-register

And for everyone else it’s a public register that anyone can search, no data protection or GDPR rules broken

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 02/09/2021 22:29

The thing is, the OP didn't ask for or require opinions on the morality or legality of checking the register. Presumably she knows her workplace policies better than anyone else on this thread.

She asked fir opinions on what to do with the information now the genie is out of the bottle.

Tyredofallthis1 · 02/09/2021 22:28

Sorry to ask, but which is YABU and which is YANBU? I get confused.

HeartsAndClubs · 02/09/2021 22:27

@ thecognoscenti I suspect that many of the posters here have been in debt etc which they didn’t want their partners to know about. Or feel that it could so easily happen to anyone, whereas most people here seem to think that affairs are black and white and somehow an affair to some on here is like admitting to murdering puppies or kittens.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 02/09/2021 22:26

@PoppyWoods I missed the post about secret gambling debts. That's a massive great red flag. I think that makes it far less likely SIL knows tbh.

jimmyhill · 02/09/2021 22:24

This is a great thread for showing that people haven't a clue what "data protection" is or means

thecognoscenti · 02/09/2021 22:24

@FizzyLizzie

OP, I think you’ve got a hell of a cheek saying “oh the hysteria”. It’s NONE of your business. If you worked in a hospital or healthcare setting, would you look up family and friends there too?
Do you understand the difference between confidential medical details and public information?
NumberTheory · 02/09/2021 22:23

OP I think you're in an awkward situation. But you are right to be concerned about your SiL, especially since BiL has form for hidden gambling debt.

Since this is BiL and Sil, presumably one of them is your husband's sibling? Would it be better to talk to him so he can broach it? Or do you have a closer relationship with SiL?

If you can't face sitting SiL down to tell her because it will require admitting you were looking (and I can see that not going down well), you could try an anonymous letter with a pointer to the register, or a print out of the entry. That's a bit of crappy way to do it though and leaves her really unsupported. It would be better to admit to looking while bored not really expecting to find anything and now feeling a chagrined(? perhaps?). Letting her know you're sorry and won't mention it to anyone if she's trying to keep it a secret but having found out, since she hadn't mentioned it, didn't feel you could sleep well without be sure she wasn't in the dark. And offer her support if she needs it.

Butterflyfluff · 02/09/2021 22:22

Part of my job is to check the insolvency register. It's a public register, freely accessible to all.
I put in various names

I do hope your employer sees this

Part of your job is snooping on your family is it?

Regardless of data protection - it’s a nasty sneaky thing to do

thecognoscenti · 02/09/2021 22:20

@HeartsAndClubs

I wonder how many of the people expressing their outrage here would tel someone or would want to know if the same BIL was having an affair.

Because to my mind your partner being declared bankrupt potentially without your knowledge is far, far worse.

And moral outrage here aside, if your partner had been declared bankrupt without your knowledge, wouldn’t you want to know?

Bankruptcy has huge, huge ramifications. If she doesn’t know and they are married, she is suddenly liable for half their debts. They could lose their home, he will no longer be allowed to have access to a debit card other than to withdraw cash, the list goes on.

What if she is a SAHM and he deals with all the finances and she has no idea about any of them?

What if they don’t have a joint account so she only looks at what money is in her own account?

Clearly in order for him to have been declared bankrupt he is in significant debt already, and there’s a real chance she didn’t know about that either.

People here need to get down off their bloody high horses and think about the fact that a family could lose everything before they even know about it.

No, the OP shouldn’t have found out in the way she did, but now that she has, do people really think that the SIL shouldn’t be made aware in case she doesn’t know?

And again, if this was an affair, the majority of people here would say that they would want to know and that the person who knew had no right to keep the information to themselves.

So why not this?

Totally agree with you. If she'd seen her BIL carrying on with another woman few people would be saying to ignore it.
EmbarrassingMama · 02/09/2021 22:20

Can you get all your friends and family together and reveal it as part of a surprise west-end style single woman show? It could be like a gender reveal party - you could have a cake made up to look like a £50 note but when you cut into it the sponge is coloured red to represent his financial failings.

If that sounds a bit much you could do nothing and say nothing like an ordinary human.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 02/09/2021 22:19

Amen @HeartsAndClubs. Glad to see someone else sees the bigger picture

GnomeDePlume · 02/09/2021 22:18

I wouldn't say anything at the moment. My only concern would be if other family members were being asked to lend them money to sort out a 'temporary' cash flow problem.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 02/09/2021 22:18

Op, was your BIL a sole trader ? So he could file for bankruptcy in his name if he was in a failed business as he would have been personally liable fir any debts (at least that's my understanding) which would be a very different kettle of fish to filing for personal bankruptcy due to reckless spending/gambling/whatever. There have been enough threads on MN over the years from women whose husbands have racked up massive debts without their knowledge to show it's very common. My BIL nearly got declared bankrupt simply because he was ridiculously bad with money despite living at home at the time.

HeartsAndClubs · 02/09/2021 22:17

I wonder how many of the people expressing their outrage here would tel someone or would want to know if the same BIL was having an affair.

Because to my mind your partner being declared bankrupt potentially without your knowledge is far, far worse.

And moral outrage here aside, if your partner had been declared bankrupt without your knowledge, wouldn’t you want to know?

Bankruptcy has huge, huge ramifications. If she doesn’t know and they are married, she is suddenly liable for half their debts. They could lose their home, he will no longer be allowed to have access to a debit card other than to withdraw cash, the list goes on.

What if she is a SAHM and he deals with all the finances and she has no idea about any of them?

What if they don’t have a joint account so she only looks at what money is in her own account?

Clearly in order for him to have been declared bankrupt he is in significant debt already, and there’s a real chance she didn’t know about that either.

People here need to get down off their bloody high horses and think about the fact that a family could lose everything before they even know about it.

No, the OP shouldn’t have found out in the way she did, but now that she has, do people really think that the SIL shouldn’t be made aware in case she doesn’t know?

And again, if this was an affair, the majority of people here would say that they would want to know and that the person who knew had no right to keep the information to themselves.

So why not this?

CambsAlways · 02/09/2021 22:16

None of your business

MyBadHabitsLeadToYou · 02/09/2021 22:11

you may find yourself with a severe sanction at a disciplinary hearing

I would very much like to hear your reasoning here, catlover

On what grounds would she face such a serious disciplinary sanction? Smile

Jigsawtrain · 02/09/2021 22:10

Haven’t RTFT but what about talking to BIL, offering support and asking if SIL knows?

Catlover77 · 02/09/2021 22:09

@iamyourequal

It may well be a freely available public database, but that’s not all that’s relevant here. If the OP was discovered to have used her work time and work computer to search for someone’s personal information irrelevant to her work, she could possibly get in real trouble. I have worked in a local authority before and it was part of our contract of employment that we were strictly forbidden from doing any such searches. We were told that if we were to have looked up, say the council tax band of a property we had no business reason to be looking up (including anything to do with ourselves/ own homes etc) it would lead to disciplinary action. If the OP did all this in her own time fair enough (still very nosy though), but she gives the strong impression she did it whilst working.
This! You need to keep quiet for two reasons - (a) it’s none of your business and (b) you may find yourself with a severe sanction at a disciplinary hearing
NumberTheory · 02/09/2021 22:09

@MrsLargeEmbodied

confidential information. keep out, what a nosey parker
The very opposite of confidential information. It is intentionally public information and deliberately made available for anyone to look up.
cakewitch · 02/09/2021 22:07

What the actual fuck does it even matter anyway.. butt out. None of your business.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 02/09/2021 22:05

confidential information.
keep out, what a nosey parker

Mydogmylife · 02/09/2021 22:03

@PoppyWoods

I'm not worried about any legal ramifications, there aren't any. Icould literally look up the whole street, it's a publicly accessible register.

Also not worried about how appalled you all are, just genuinely curious as to whether this could happen without her knowledge. Would appreciate anyone in the know to advise

This update really doesn't show you in a good light at all - it's totally the sum total of fuck to do with you - keep your big neb OUT!