Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers shouldn’t hire on cultural fit

118 replies

Matleave22 · 02/09/2021 19:59

In my opinion, hiring on cultural fit is a really fast way to only hire ‘people like you’.

Surely a range of people with diverse outlooks and differing world views will make for a better and more powerful team! I think this ‘hiring on culture’ ideology inhibits diversity and inclusion.

What do you think? AIBU?

OP posts:
Oblomov21 · 02/09/2021 21:54

Yep. I do. Check it out. All 25 firms signed up to it.
And they prioritise disadvantaged children with free school meals and a parent who didn't go to uni, for their work experience.

They only take disadvantaged children for their work experience. Only. It's their criteria.

Plus for apprenticeships. The same.
I rang pwc and KPMG to check I hadn't misunderstood.

I asked if they had this support programme, which is of course right, to support disadvantaged Children

But was it run . alongside a programme of recruiting any student from .... not disadvantaged families ? say a grammar school (which mine aren't) or from a family who aren't on free school meals. Who have a parent or both parents attending Uni.

They both said no.

I was told by other parents that I should just appreciate that my boys aren't on free school meals, and have parents who are interested. Which I had to agree with. So they are advantaged because I care.

But I couldn't grasp that the top 4 don't / only offer work experience to disadvantaged children.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 21:54

@Hoolihan

I have been involved in an interview process where 'cultural fit' was given as a reason to not hire the only black candidate.
That’s unacceptable- so it was literally only ‘cultural fit’ with no context?
TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 21:54

@Bluntness100

Of course it shouldn’t be done, the issue is people hire people they like and think they will get along with and often that’s people wirh similar personality types to their own.

I’m Corp and we focus on trying not to hire “people like us” but quite frankly we all are very similar in terms of personality. Different backgrounds, ethnicities etc but personality wise yup there is defintely a common thread.

That’s interesting- what sort of personality is that?
Hoolihan · 02/09/2021 21:52

I have been involved in an interview process where 'cultural fit' was given as a reason to not hire the only black candidate.

Hekatestorch · 02/09/2021 21:51

There's no right answer to this.

Companies often need people a little bit different, to keep it moving forward. But also if you think someone just won't fit in with the people there or think in a way that doesn't fit with yeh company at all, it's likely to go tits up.

Taswama · 02/09/2021 21:51

Have you read Rebel Ideas @Matleave22 ? I highly recommend it.
Diversity of thought does lead to more successful organisations.

Bluntness100 · 02/09/2021 21:50

Of course it shouldn’t be done, the issue is people hire people they like and think they will get along with and often that’s people wirh similar personality types to their own.

I’m Corp and we focus on trying not to hire “people like us” but quite frankly we all are very similar in terms of personality. Different backgrounds, ethnicities etc but personality wise yup there is defintely a common thread.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 21:49

@KarlUrbansWife

20 years in recruitment here, across a number of different businesses, both in-house and agency You absolutely should be hiring for people that ADD to your culture - the problem is "cultural fit" can often be code for "someone just like me. I like them because they're very similar to me, and have similar references and experiences." If you have a robust, unbiased process that truly assesses technical skill, potential and the core pillars of how you expect people to behave, you will get it right. You need to have the internal policies to be able to do this. It's the unchecked biases that cause the issues.
That’s the key - ‘cultural fit’ that’s responsable can be defined. With specific values and behaviours.

A vague ‘cultural fit’ reason isn’t acceptable. If rejected on that basis the interviewers should be able to state exactly which cultural aspect is the issue.

Of course this can also be abused… unwilling to attend after work social events for example put down as ‘not being a team player’….

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 21:46

@Oblomov21

Which firms do this?

Accountancy firms only hire disadvantaged children now, which is of course right. But there is no normal recruitment alongside it.
My employment lawyer says white middle class boys are now being disadvantaged, they aren't being hired.

What a deliberately inflammatory, and definitely untrue statement.
christinarossetti19 · 02/09/2021 21:41

"Accountancy firms only hire disadvantaged children now."

Um, do you have anything to back this claim up at all?

Oblomov21 · 02/09/2021 21:36

Which firms do this?

Accountancy firms only hire disadvantaged children now, which is of course right. But there is no normal recruitment alongside it.
My employment lawyer says white middle class boys are now being disadvantaged, they aren't being hired.

KarlUrbansWife · 02/09/2021 21:36

20 years in recruitment here, across a number of different businesses, both in-house and agency
You absolutely should be hiring for people that ADD to your culture - the problem is "cultural fit" can often be code for "someone just like me. I like them because they're very similar to me, and have similar references and experiences."
If you have a robust, unbiased process that truly assesses technical skill, potential and the core pillars of how you expect people to behave, you will get it right. You need to have the internal policies to be able to do this.
It's the unchecked biases that cause the issues.

sjxoxo · 02/09/2021 21:15

Yes totally what @ttcissoboring said.
Which do you mean?

Naptimenow · 02/09/2021 21:13

We are all about hiring someone with the values that will fit and thrive in our team - we are open about our culture and values and who someone will needs to be to thrive and enjoying working in our team - no surprises really, slackers and big egos not wanted in our team either - it is not about what ethnic group, age etc someone is.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 21:01

@DerAlteMann (can’t quote) I work in tech and there are very specific elements, both technical and personal. For example:

  • Some people throw in any code that works. Others test carefully and ensure it’s easy to read for others.
  • Some people need to run a decision past everyone , other can take high levels of individual responsibility.

When discussing ‘why’ a candidate is marked down we refer to specifics but everything can come under an umbrella of ‘culture fit’ as opposed to , say, lack of technical skill , experience, or fit with company personal values (such as integrity, best effort etc etc).

christinarossetti19 · 02/09/2021 21:01

I don't buy the 'we hire on job ability' line.

Because it would mean that women and people from racialised communities were less able to do senior jobs. given that they are under-represented in these positions.

They may well be less experienced because they haven't had the same opportunities, but that's different from ability and potential.

Having been to many interviews recently, I've realised that organisations hire who they want to, regardless of any objective measures.

I've done the highest scoring interview and not been offered the job for example.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 20:52

‘Diversity and inclusion’ relates to unconscious bias which may hinder the hiring of appropriate people. It’s a social justice concept which has nothing to do with diverse outlooks and world views.

There’s no inherent benefit to having for example a racially/gender balanced team over an all white team. However general prejudice being lower in ‘diverse’ companies are a signal of good staff practices. It’s these that lead to the better performance. Not diversity itself. A different gender or skin colour doesn’t give you a valuable perspective on all jobs.
The ‘culture fit’ mentioned in interviews is work culture. Fast vs slow paced. Level of autonomy. Process orientation , etc.

MrsTerryPratchett · 02/09/2021 20:50

@ttcissoboring

Company culture - YABU

The persons culture (ie - their heritage) - YANBU

This.

It's extremely obvious when someone doesn't fit at my work. Slackers who are there for the money not the work have a very hard time.

DerAlteMann · 02/09/2021 20:45

@orangejuicer

Who hires based on culture?
This. I've done recruiting for over 10 years and I don't even know what "cultural fit" means. We hire on job ability. We'd eventually go bust if we didn't.
FastFood · 02/09/2021 20:44

Well when we talk about culture fit its company culture so yes, it's super important and so YABU.

Let's say that I work in an organisation where we value transparency, team work and thoughtful leadership and we hire someone who believes in micro-managing and competition amongst team members.
That person could be a super expert in their role, still that would be a terrible hire.

I hire people, my team is extremely diverse, in nationalities, ethnicities, background, career path, expertise and style, yet we all uphold the same core values.

I don't care if Piotr loves ballet, if Michelle spends her days at the gym and if Renata's kink is to read books about archeology, what I'm interested in is whether I can provide the environment for Piotr, Michelle, Renata and more to thrive.

ttcissoboring · 02/09/2021 20:44

Though I do agree with OP, people can disguise their biases quite well behind the front is using 'company culture' as an excuse,

For example, a job that employs mainly middle age white guys is kore likely to give the job to a similar middle age white guy in many instances - as that person is likely 'company culture'/ more likely too 'fit in' which I think is wrong.

lightand · 02/09/2021 20:40

Describe what you mean personally by cultural fit.

HermioneWeasley · 02/09/2021 20:36

My company really values diversity of thinking and personality, but people have to be incredibly resilient and fast paced. I know really good people who wouldn’t work out in the place I work. You can be extrovert, introvert, funny, quiet, liberal or conservative- no problem, but if you aren’t determined, adaptable and resilient you won’t survive.

We spend a lot of time in the recruitment process being very up front about this

HerNameIsIncontinentiaButtocks · 02/09/2021 20:35

What Lancelot said. The "cultural fit" phrase doesn't mean "hire the same ethnicity and school as the interviewer" it's "hire someone who'll flourish and augment the existing company culture"

A shit company with shit managers may treat it as the former, but they're shit.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 02/09/2021 20:34

It's more complicated than that. It shouldn't become something that leads to hiring "people like us", whatever that looks like (tech bros being the most notorious one) but yes, part of hiring should be a thoughtful consideration of whether you need a person who fits in the org culture or even a person who disrupts it a bit and how each candidate might fit in that culture. It's no good hiring someone with the right skills and experiences if they just can't operate in the way the company does.

Swipe left for the next trending thread