Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers shouldn’t hire on cultural fit

118 replies

Matleave22 · 02/09/2021 19:59

In my opinion, hiring on cultural fit is a really fast way to only hire ‘people like you’.

Surely a range of people with diverse outlooks and differing world views will make for a better and more powerful team! I think this ‘hiring on culture’ ideology inhibits diversity and inclusion.

What do you think? AIBU?

OP posts:
NinaGonk · 02/09/2021 22:32

I agree. My work is guilty of it and snaps up extroverts who dont last their probation period. I think it's a license to appoint on gut feelings ie discriminate.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 02/09/2021 22:31

Do you work in HR:-)

In a truly equal world, people should be hired on the basis of their ability to do the job. Not to improve the D&I profile of the hiring company.

Milkbottlelegs · 02/09/2021 22:29

@NameChangeforMoneyThings you’ve put that very well. It’s about widening the pool of available talent at the recruitment stage, by giving people who wouldn’t otherwise think of applying an insight into the opportunities there. I personally think it’s a great idea.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/09/2021 22:29

"cultural fit" is about how the organisation works. If its being used to employ "someone who looks like me" then they are doing it wrong.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/09/2021 22:27

"What a deliberately inflammatory, and definitely untrue statement." What do you mean?

I would guess this comment from your earlier post:
Accountancy firms only hire disadvantaged children now, which is of course right. But there is no normal recruitment alongside it

Which you then modified, without stating it was a correction, to the fact that this is a specific programme for temporary work experience for disadvantaged children. The clue is in the name.

And this one:
My employment lawyer says white middle class boys are now being disadvantaged, they aren't being hired

If your employment lawyer talks equivalent nonsense about the law you might want to find a replacement.

sst1234 · 02/09/2021 22:26

Why would you hire someone who doesn’t share your company’s cultural/behavioral values?

legoriakelne · 02/09/2021 22:26

Accountancy firms only hire disadvantaged children now

Yep. I do. Check it out. All 25 firms signed up to it.
And they prioritise disadvantaged children with free school meals and a parent who didn't go to uni, for their work experience.

Eh?

Are you really claiming there are only 25 accountancy firms in the UK staffed entirely by children ?

If there are only 25 accountancy firms in the country why is there a "top 100" list?

Never mind the fact that work experience programmes for children are not "hires" .

christinarossetti19 · 02/09/2021 22:26

I think kinzarose describes it well.

If a company culture includes an expectation of going to the pub after work, this effectively excludes eg practicing Muslim people and usually women (and some men) with young children.

Milkbottlelegs · 02/09/2021 22:24

But I couldn't grasp that the top 4 don't / only offer work experience to disadvantaged children.

Work experience is not a job offer.

JaceLancs · 02/09/2021 22:22

You’ve all just made me realise that I hire people in the same way I treat relationships
For example shared values are high on my list
Problem solving same - I’m solution focussed and can’t cope with whinging or negativity
I’m also most sympathetic to good all rounders or people who are prepared to challenge or try something new
I’m not great with jobs worth’s or those who work in own silo

GellerYeller · 02/09/2021 22:22

Ought to add that ability and attitude are the only criteria I would consider when assessing applicants.

NameChangeforMoneyThings · 02/09/2021 22:21

@Oblomov21

Yep. I do. Check it out. All 25 firms signed up to it. And they prioritise disadvantaged children with free school meals and a parent who didn't go to uni, for their work experience.

They only take disadvantaged children for their work experience. Only. It's their criteria.

Plus for apprenticeships. The same.
I rang pwc and KPMG to check I hadn't misunderstood.

I asked if they had this support programme, which is of course right, to support disadvantaged Children

But was it run . alongside a programme of recruiting any student from .... not disadvantaged families ? say a grammar school (which mine aren't) or from a family who aren't on free school meals. Who have a parent or both parents attending Uni.

They both said no.

I was told by other parents that I should just appreciate that my boys aren't on free school meals, and have parents who are interested. Which I had to agree with. So they are advantaged because I care.

But I couldn't grasp that the top 4 don't / only offer work experience to disadvantaged children.

To be clear though, work experience and recruitment are not the same thing.

For their work experience they only take young people from less advantaged backgrounds: who might well not be confident enough to know that these schemes are good options for them. They specifically note that this is the "access accountancy" scheme.

www.kpmgcareers.co.uk/apprentice/discovery-work-experience/

That is not the case for e.g. their audit apprenticeship: www.kpmgcareers.co.uk/apprentice/audit-apprenticeship-programmes/audit-apprenticeship/

Or any of the others that I looked at. And you don't need to have done work experience there to get an apprenticeship or a graduate training scheme. They are trying to compensate for some of the disadvantages, not prevent anyone else from applying to actual roles there.

Metabigot · 02/09/2021 22:20

Cultural fit means company culture.

Not what some people seem to think it means

Don't see an issue with it

christinarossetti19 · 02/09/2021 22:19

25 firms prioritising young people from FSM/non-university educated parents backgrounds in certain schemes is hardly all accountancy firms, is it?

And, quite frankly, so what if it was? The white, middle-class boys that you mention will have had plenty of other privileges.

Are you not concerned about the white, middle-class girls btw?

And, no, your children aren't disadvantaged 'because you care.

In fact, they don't sound disadvantaged at all. Not being eligible to apply for a few apprenticeships is not what being disadvantaged means.

GellerYeller · 02/09/2021 22:19

Culture fit has nothing to do with diversity and everything to do with team dynamics. Interviews are a two way street especially more so currently when candidates are more plentiful than jobs. No one moves to somewhere they feel they won't thrive do they? And who hires someone who will upset the apple cart? Unless it's a toxic or stale place that needs fresh ideas and then you're really on a hiding to nothing as decent staff won't stay long. That's hiring 101 surely?

gogohm · 02/09/2021 22:17

I was told to my face that they didn't hire me because I didn't speak Gujarati, there was nothing in the job spec that required it - when I queried it they said it was because I wouldn't fit in because that was the language they all spoke! I wish I had it in written form because its discriminatory

kinzarose · 02/09/2021 22:15

I think there is a distinct but often unwritten differentiation between company values and culture, and I wish recruiters would make that clear. As a very hard working, driven person I can in theory fit into any company. As a practising Muslim woman I have issues fitting into companies where there is a culture (and expectation) of drinking, sexualized 'banter' and constant after work socialising. After graduation I naively assumed I'd do my job and progress, but realized quickly that these 'cultural' elements can be integral to promotion as they are viewed as evidence of dedication to the company.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 22:09

*school leaves, and graduate programmes

lockdownalli · 02/09/2021 22:05

Well I wouldn't deliberately hire someone who I know everyone else in the team would hate - that would be foolish.

However that would be based on issues other than gender/race/sexual orientation/disability etc etc

As PP have said - if an interviewee is an arrogant knobhead with a great CV, they aren't going to get hired.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/09/2021 22:04

@Oblomov21

Yep. I do. Check it out. All 25 firms signed up to it. And they prioritise disadvantaged children with free school meals and a parent who didn't go to uni, for their work experience.

They only take disadvantaged children for their work experience. Only. It's their criteria.

Plus for apprenticeships. The same.
I rang pwc and KPMG to check I hadn't misunderstood.

I asked if they had this support programme, which is of course right, to support disadvantaged Children

But was it run . alongside a programme of recruiting any student from .... not disadvantaged families ? say a grammar school (which mine aren't) or from a family who aren't on free school meals. Who have a parent or both parents attending Uni.

They both said no.

I was told by other parents that I should just appreciate that my boys aren't on free school meals, and have parents who are interested. Which I had to agree with. So they are advantaged because I care.

But I couldn't grasp that the top 4 don't / only offer work experience to disadvantaged children.

I presume you’re referring to programs like the PwC Flying Start - which is restricted to a select few unis and pays for the degree. There are plenty of other apprenticeship and school leaver programmes open to everyone. Worried your boys won’t be up to the competition?
squiddybear · 02/09/2021 22:00

There is no point in hiring someone who you know wouldn't fit in with the team or the company values. It saves training someone and them leaving straight away as they don't enjoy the work or don't like the culture

Doyoumind · 02/09/2021 21:58

I think it depends on the industry and type of role. In my sector, just about every role is recruited on cultural fit. It doesn't mean everyone is the same. It means fitting with the company's values and expected behaviours. People aren't hired based on a point system like they are in so many roles people talk about on here. You provide a CV rather than filling in an application. Recruitment is based on experience and chemistry with the team.

Oblomov21 · 02/09/2021 21:57

@tractorandheadphones ?
"What a deliberately inflammatory, and definitely untrue statement."
What do you mean?

Wickedwaterwitch · 02/09/2021 21:56

@KarlUrbansWife

20 years in recruitment here, across a number of different businesses, both in-house and agency You absolutely should be hiring for people that ADD to your culture - the problem is "cultural fit" can often be code for "someone just like me. I like them because they're very similar to me, and have similar references and experiences." If you have a robust, unbiased process that truly assesses technical skill, potential and the core pillars of how you expect people to behave, you will get it right. You need to have the internal policies to be able to do this. It's the unchecked biases that cause the issues.
Quite. So many bosses end up surrounded by people like them and then there’s no diversity of thought
Ohpulltheotherone · 02/09/2021 21:55

Yes and no.

“Will this person compliment the team and enhance the ethos and culture of the organisation” is a question you should ask when hiring surely?

I do agree that it shouldn’t be a case of recruiting people “Just like me” and that bringing new perspective and experience and diversity is of course a great thing. But surely that person needs to align or gel with the organisation culture. Being at odds with the vibe you’re surrounded by for 40 hours a week isn’t a good thing is it? For anyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread