Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers shouldn’t hire on cultural fit

118 replies

Matleave22 · 02/09/2021 19:59

In my opinion, hiring on cultural fit is a really fast way to only hire ‘people like you’.

Surely a range of people with diverse outlooks and differing world views will make for a better and more powerful team! I think this ‘hiring on culture’ ideology inhibits diversity and inclusion.

What do you think? AIBU?

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 03/09/2021 08:25

My employer has really diverse staff, I think when people talk about cultural fit, they just sort of mean whether you get along comfortably/share values/feel they fit with the team. Eg my team are very supportive & collaborative, if we had someone extremely individualistic & competitive who sort of, stood on others to climb up themselves, that wouldnt really be something we'd value, it would upset the balance and working environment.

ttcissoboring · 03/09/2021 08:21

@OhWhatsTheDifference

In my experience 'hired for cultural fit' means the person isn't qualified for the role but they're either really nice or really hot.

That led to quite the shitshow in my old company when it turns out that most people weren't actually fit for purpose.

Example: three senior men hired the hot 20 year old waitress from their night out and made her a product manager. Apparently they just knew she'd fit right in. Hmm

See this is what I mean - the term cultural fit can sometimes be twisted to suit a creepy or discriminatory narrative and that's when it's not cool.
OhWhatsTheDifference · 03/09/2021 08:20

In my experience 'hired for cultural fit' means the person isn't qualified for the role but they're either really nice or really hot.

That led to quite the shitshow in my old company when it turns out that most people weren't actually fit for purpose.

Example: three senior men hired the hot 20 year old waitress from their night out and made her a product manager. Apparently they just knew she'd fit right in. Hmm

Hoolihan · 03/09/2021 08:17

[quote PegasusReturns]@Hoolihan

I have been involved in an interview process where 'cultural fit' was given as a reason to not hire the only black candidate

And when you queried that what was the response?[/quote]
I'm hugely ashamed to say that I didn't query it. I was in a junior position myself and the statement was made by the CEO. I am not proud of this and if it happened today I would most certainly speak up.

LakieLady · 03/09/2021 08:11

I think cultural fit can be important.

I work for a third sector organisation that has a very distinct ethos. All our clients are vulnerable in some way, most of them are in very challenging circumstances. The organisation is committed to to improving the lives of people in difficulties, to equality and diversity.

It would be really hard for someone who didn't share that commitment to do their job effectively and to be sensitive to the needs of clients and the challenges that they face. I have no issues whatsoever that they tend to employ people who have that "cultural fit".

And they regularly win awards, both for the services they provide and for being a great employer to work for.

MatildaIThink · 03/09/2021 07:55

To often "do not hire based on culture" seems to be code for "only employ minorities". I work in research so people are only employed on ability, my field is around 60% men, but I do not think more women should be employed because they are women, employ the best people for the role, as for cultural fit, that would best be described as slightly odd, which I accept I am.

My husband works in a few sectors but a chunk of his work is with media (film and TV) and they seem to have an obsession with ignoring cultural fit, which largely means a lot of un or under qualified and inexperienced people employed on the basis of not being white or straight. Many of these people seem to lack the right cultural fit, from poor timekeeping, to attitude at work, work rate, arguing with the producers (who on film sets are in overall charge). Note that I am not saying that it is all the people who are not White and straight or are the issue, there are a lot of LGB people in media and there have been for years, but they earned their place on merit. The issue seems to be the fast tracking in of people to expand the "cultural outlook" which involves putting people in roles they are not good at for the sake of a box ticking exercise.

spotcheck · 03/09/2021 07:41

I thought 'cultural fit' meant someone who would fit with the current work force.
Polite speak for ' not an asshole'

C8H10N4O2 · 03/09/2021 07:41

Sorry if I wasn't clear I meant surprised about the pp claim and certain it couldn't be true so looked it up to prove it wasn't true. I was hoping they'd misunderstood but the website was very clear so it looks more like wilful ignorance

My comments were directed at our willful misleader - I could have been clearer!

I know these schemes well, I've been involved in sponsoring them in my own org. Funny how in the days when these 6th form and gap year internships went automatically to the private schools and DC of partners/MDs/friends people like Oblomov were not piping up all over to whinge about fairness.

Naptimenow · 03/09/2021 07:38

@mangowithasqueezeoflime

Hire for values not cultural fit (eg company culture/ team culture). Otherwise the people who get in first dictate said culture and hire more like them.

Example: if a team starts with say tech bros and you hire for culture you get more tech bros. If you hire for values like transparency or collaboration or whatever, you will have a much better and more diverse team.

I don't understand your point - what are tech bros? Doesn't make any sense.

I think culture and values often mean the same thing or at the very least they get confused with each other. We value collaboration - as a team we collaborate, some people don't like to work that way. No way would we just hire for values, we have technical requirements that must also be met - it's not enough to fit the values/culture of the team, you have to be intellectually and technically able too!

Tinpotspectator · 03/09/2021 07:34

Also the fact that cultural fit is a word that has different meanings is not helpful.

Tinpotspectator · 03/09/2021 07:31

It's definitely true and research proven hat diverse workplaces are more creative and therefore productive.I'm all in favour of your statement, OP.

PegasusReturns · 03/09/2021 07:23

@Hoolihan

I have been involved in an interview process where 'cultural fit' was given as a reason to not hire the only black candidate

And when you queried that what was the response?

PegasusReturns · 03/09/2021 07:20

Cultural fit doesn’t apply to the candidates ethnicity, race or background it’s about the company culture: values and priorities.

I work for a listed MNC. Everyone who joins goes through a detailed personality assessment because we understand that cultural fit is the number one driver for success in our organisation.

RedEagles15 · 03/09/2021 00:52

@C8H10N4O2

I don't work for KPMG but was so surprised I looked it up

This kind of scheme exists in all the big accounting/consulting firms. They are regularly misrepresented by people whining about "poor middle class boys being discriminated against".

Of course their existence is the reason there are so few white middle class men in the upper levels of the firms in question. Hmm

Sorry if I wasn't clear I meant surprised about the pp claim and certain it couldn't be true so looked it up to prove it wasn't true. I was hoping they'd misunderstood but the website was very clear so it looks more like wilful ignorance
mangowithasqueezeoflime · 03/09/2021 00:14

Hire for values not cultural fit (eg company culture/ team culture). Otherwise the people who get in first dictate said culture and hire more like them.

Example: if a team starts with say tech bros and you hire for culture you get more tech bros. If you hire for values like transparency or collaboration or whatever, you will have a much better and more diverse team.

GellerYeller · 03/09/2021 00:05

@JesusIsAnyNameFree could not agree more.

ChaneySays · 02/09/2021 23:12

Whilst I agree in principle that diversity of view/insights can help, in reality a hardcore lefty wouldn't be a good fit in a team of Trump supporters for example.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 02/09/2021 23:09

Are you sure you've not misunderstood this? We hire based on "fit", as in "fits in with the way we as company do things and hasn't worked in a completely different way during their career".

C8H10N4O2 · 02/09/2021 23:09

I don't work for KPMG but was so surprised I looked it up

This kind of scheme exists in all the big accounting/consulting firms. They are regularly misrepresented by people whining about "poor middle class boys being discriminated against".

Of course their existence is the reason there are so few white middle class men in the upper levels of the firms in question. Hmm

mustlovegin · 02/09/2021 23:06

Surely a range of people with diverse outlooks and differing world views will make for a better and more powerful team

It's not clear what you mean by 'culture' OP. But your statement is not true in every scenario. Filling diversity quotas for the sake of it does not always result in stronger teams. And sometimes there is a valid need (or desire, even?) to recruit 'people like you'.

Would you hire someone who gives off 'hipster' vibes for an agricultural estate agent role?

Or someone from Extinction Rebellion to work at Coutts or for the Royals? Don't think so

Would you hire a nanny to look after your children if she wasn't 'like you' in certain aspects?

blacksax · 02/09/2021 22:59

YABU for starting a potentially controversial thread with over 70 replies so far, and then not coming back to it after what, three hours and counting.

RedEagles15 · 02/09/2021 22:50

@mustlovegin

They only take disadvantaged children for their work experience. Only. It's their criteria Plus for apprenticeships. The same. I rang pwc and KPMG to check I hadn't misunderstood

Oblomov21 Assuming this is accurate and you haven't misunderstood, this situation needs to be given more publicity and challenged, surely?

It isn't accurate the poster is referring to a 2 day work experience programme KPMG offer www.kpmgcareers.co.uk/vacancies/work-experience-discovery-insight-programme-london-tbc-2021/990cbe78-9957-d9e3-4105-2d3c420d957c . That is only to children eligible for FSM or if neither of their parents went to university. They then can skip to stage 2 of the apprentice hiring process if it went well but the apprentice and graduate schemes are open to all who meet the academic requirements. I don't work for KPMG but was so surprised I looked it up.
mustlovegin · 02/09/2021 22:42

They only take disadvantaged children for their work experience. Only. It's their criteria
Plus for apprenticeships. The same. I rang pwc and KPMG to check I hadn't misunderstood

Oblomov21 Assuming this is accurate and you haven't misunderstood, this situation needs to be given more publicity and challenged, surely?

Milkbottlelegs · 02/09/2021 22:35

@TheyWentToSeaInASieve

Do you work in HR:-)

In a truly equal world, people should be hired on the basis of their ability to do the job. Not to improve the D&I profile of the hiring company.

They usually are. What the D&I focus does is force people to search further and harder to ensure they are recruiting the best person for the job, not just hiring the first white male that comes along, who often happens to be a mate of someone in the team.
Cactu · 02/09/2021 22:35

I’ve heard of it in the tech sector.

It basically means hiring a person who can communicate and not necessarily the most technically able person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread