Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:32

@PumpkinKlNG

And who are those better parents as literally no one is queuing up to adopt a 13 year old child who is in a gang who drinks and smokes and refuses to go to school 🤷‍♀️
The halfway decent parents will ask how a 13 year old came to be in that situation to start with, and the answer is most unlikely to be "wasn't hit enough by his wonderful parents".
DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:31

@PumpkinKlNG

All I’m saying is I can see why parents will hit out of anger and frustration and I certainly deserved it a few time’s being rude to my mum (I never stole or joined gangs etc that’s something my brother did)
Yes, anger and frustration!

NOT because the child deserved it! Because the parents failed to be parents!

You started off by saying you deserved it, that kids deserve it, but now with a bit of pushing you come to it. It's the parents' failure. Smacking and hitting is always a parent's failure. It might have a context but it's never right. Your mother failed when she hit you. You didn't deserve it.

So please remember that next time you start to say that children deserve it, which by extension includes many people reading here. Because that's vastly different to what you've said here, which is correct: it's nothing more than a vent for the parents' anger and frustration.

And if you don't want your kids learning that when you're angry and frustrated, you hit, then learn some better coping tactics yourself. And stop the lie that the kids deserve it.

Anger and frustration, you got it. Shit parenting.

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 13:30

What are you talking about @PumpkinKING?
Better parents are the ones who do not resort to hitting their kids!
Are you saying that hitting that abandoned 13 year old would be the way to stop them being drinking / being in a gang & make them go to school? Because if you are, that's REALLY fucked up!

Soyouthought · 03/09/2021 13:29

I was smacked often, I remember one arm being held high and then smacked so hard I was lifted off the floor. Then when too big for that I was pinned to walls by my throat. It has stayed with me and effected me and how I parent. To be honest the shouting and full in face rage was just as bad.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:28

Oh and before you say it it’s not just the “bad” parents whose kids go off the rails, it can happen to anyone.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:26

And who are those better parents as literally no one is queuing up to adopt a 13 year old child who is in a gang who drinks and smokes and refuses to go to school 🤷‍♀️

MrsBertBibby · 03/09/2021 13:23

My mother was a woodenspooner. We would be sent to get it, ordered to take out trousers and knickers down, and then walloped. I still feel the hot blind impotent rage and humiliation, and the fantasies of beating her face to a pulp. That's an awful awful thing for an 8 year old to feel. Awful.

She had two favourite wooden spoons as she said hilariously to other fucking adults in our hearing that they left no mark.

It really troubled me after my son was that age, and I realised I had never laid a finger on him, no matter what, and never would.

I stole her fucking wooden spoon one Christmas, aged 40 and burned it on a friend's fire. Stealing both felt greedy but the next Christmas, I stole the other one, snapped it over my knee, and threw it into the Thames near Canary Wharf.

I am so glad I did it before she lost her marbles. Hearing her wondering querulously where her favourite wooden spoons had gone was so sweet.

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 13:22

I utterly disagree with you @PumpkinKING, no kid deserves to be hit. But those kids do deserve better parents.

Out of interest, those people saying they were not traumatised / think they deserved it - do you have children and did / do you hit them?

Pinkbonbon · 03/09/2021 13:19

Not the smacking necessarily, but the depantsing in public too smack, yes.

I actually think one quick smack to a misbehaving child who has already been warned is perfectly fair. But I think some parents go overboard and that can breed resentment.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:13

All I’m saying is I can see why parents will hit out of anger and frustration and I certainly deserved it a few time’s being rude to my mum (I never stole or joined gangs etc that’s something my brother did)

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:12

@PumpkinKlNG

I’m not saying they would be neither would they if they get sent to their room or get a talking to, all I’m saying is sometimes kids do deserve it 🤷‍♀️ And I hold no hard feelings
No, they do not. Children do not ever deserve to be hit. Adults who think they do don't know how to parent.
Feelingmardy · 03/09/2021 13:07

[quote TracyLords]@Feelingmardy I found the fact that someone pulled your pants down the worst of it all. I don’t remember it being that sore, it was more the humiliation and lack of bodily control. And I was terrified in case it happened in front of anyone[/quote]
I agree. The deliberate humiliation of your children does untold damage. I do remember it being very painful but that is what my parents wanted t achieve. I was sexually assaulted as a teen and I do actually blame my parents for that. Not just because we told my dad and he said 'don't be silly', but also because we have been taught that adults can do anything they want to your body - so neither of us did anything to try and stop it (which I expect the abuser decided to interpret as indicating that we were enjoying it).

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:04

I’m not saying they would be neither would they if they get sent to their room or get a talking to, all I’m saying is sometimes kids do deserve it 🤷‍♀️ And I hold no hard feelings

Mamma635377 · 03/09/2021 13:04

No, you're not the only one. I was smacked with a palm, but also with a light plastic cane that left a big welt. They usually hit in anger, and I vividly remember a couple of times when it was uncontrolled. They were generally good and affectionate parents, but when I was young I feared their anger.

I forgot about it and I even thought that when I became a parent, a little smack to reinforce something was dangerous was something I would do.

I felt completely different when I had my first baby. In the early days I must have had some post partum depression because they memories suddenly came flooding back and I spent hours through the night feeling angry at my parents. Years on I can't forget or forgive saved I have very limited contact. I suspect as grandparents the would not smack my child, but I won't take the risk and will never leave them alone together. I really see the damage that corporal punishment has done to me and I would never inflict that on any child.

I'd say to any parent who smacks their kids that you may think that it is harmless and controlled and doesn't hurt much, it's doing them good and they may still love you after. But you don't know what is really doing to them inside, or whether they will come to hate you for it in time. So at the very least if you can't have empathy for them, be selfish and don't risk your relationship with them.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:01

@PumpkinKlNG

I never said a child deserves a flap for that 🤦‍♀️ You obviously misread, my point was that would be when it was completely uncalled for, we are talking about kids who run away from him, join gangs, steal etc, sorry but even that happens to “good parents” Hmm
And kids who join gangs and steal won't stop if their parents hit them! What planet are you on?
Humblpi · 03/09/2021 13:00

I don't feel at all traumatised by the few smacks i had.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:00

Oh...and in the absence of additional needs etc, positive reinforcement and time out work very well, as long as they are used consistently and with patience. Modelling the behaviours you want your kids to learn is the best thing you can do.

Not something hitters want you to know.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 12:59

Flap=slap! 😑

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 12:58

Him=home*

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 12:58

I never said a child deserves a flap for that 🤦‍♀️ You obviously misread, my point was that would be when it was completely uncalled for, we are talking about kids who run away from him, join gangs, steal etc, sorry but even that happens to “good parents” Hmm

Ellarain · 03/09/2021 12:58

No not traumatised at all.

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 12:56

I was slapped in primary school, in the 80s, with rulers, pieces of wood from the edge of the blackboard, hands etc and I was a really quite, studious child and this was par for the course for wrong answers in homework, being accused of day dreaming etc

At home my mother had a REALLY short fuse and was a stressy, anxious short tempered parent. My dad worked a lot and never really hit me that I can remember, he excelled in the 'guilt' chat - 'you've really disappointed me etc' which I hated with a passion.

My mother hit me a lot, with her hands on bare legs or arms, very stingy & smarty. Or sometimes with the back of a hairbrush. Very hard. She used it as her no 1 go to method of discipline for my whole childhood until I hit my teens. My sister is much younger and she never hit her, which always felt v unfair to me. She took all all her frustrations out on me and it was a wider family 'joke' how quick she was to anger & how impatient with me she was (not that I ever found it funny)

The absolutely infuriating thing is, much like the OP, she totally re-invented herself once she became a grandmother to my dc who were the first grandchildren. She's positively earth mother now and would intervene if I spoke in a firm voice!

I have never once put a hand on my children in anger or frustration and they're now teens. And I never will, neither has dh, despite a very troubled upbringing. I am really proud of that. We were not a shouty family either , my mother was very shouty.

She seems to have whitewashed her own behaviour in her own head and has no recollection. But I have not forgotten. Nor will i.

There is literally no excuse worthy of hitting children imo

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 12:56

@PumpkinKlNG

Where did I say it was funny! On mn obviously everyone’s kids are little angels but not all children respond well to the naughty step or time out, we are talking about teenage tear aways here not a toddler getting a smack for drawing on the wall, I don’t blame my mum one bit.
Haha. Never saw a teenage tearaway whose home was a calm haven where the parent/s consistently modelled self control and good methods of conflict defusement and resolution. The fact that so many of these parents have managed to fail their children three times over - once by modelling shit behaviour, twice by hitting children for imbibing it and three times for making the kids think it was their fault - is absolutely tragic.

And a toddler who draws on the wall was left unsupervised when they shouldn't have been. If anyone deserves a slap for that, it's the parents again. You didn't learn that either?

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 12:42

Where did I say it was funny! On mn obviously everyone’s kids are little angels but not all children respond well to the naughty step or time out, we are talking about teenage tear aways here not a toddler getting a smack for drawing on the wall, I don’t blame my mum one bit.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 12:40

@PumpkinKlNG

I definitely deserved it!
No you didn't.

It's not funny.