Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 14:36

@PumpkinKlNG

Well posters were falling over themselves to defend the op for hitting her child saying she was sleep deprived stressed she’s a Single mum etc, well my mum was a single mum of 6 so if people can justify and understand why a mum would hit a toddler then I can understand why my mum occasionally hit us as teens.
It's irrelevant. That mother failed too. Stop the whataboutery and deflection. Hitting your kids is a parenting fail designed to alleviate your own strong feelings. Stop telling us that kids deserve it.
CorianderBee · 03/09/2021 14:24

My boyfriend says this. Says it really shocked him to his core as a little one.

I was smacked a bit, worse than him, but it didn't really affect me.

So everyone's different and nobody's wrong

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 14:22

Well posters were falling over themselves to defend the op for hitting her child saying she was sleep deprived stressed she’s a Single mum etc, well my mum was a single mum of 6 so if people can justify and understand why a mum would hit a toddler then I can understand why my mum occasionally hit us as teens.

Etulosba · 03/09/2021 14:10

I was smacked as a child. Legs or bum. I’m not aware of any trauma as a result of it. I don’t even think about it unless somebody asks.

Being smacked on the face though seems to be on a different level altogether.

Foreverinthenineties · 03/09/2021 14:06

I was smacked by teachers in Primary, we all were.
I remember once I turned my head to say something to my classmate sitting behind me and teacher run to me and hit me across my head with her big fat hand.
Also teachers threw keys, chalk on us if were were not concentrating..

At home I was very rarely smacked- I would have to do something really bad for my mum smack me, maybe rarely, I can only vaguely remember once..

CyclingIsNotOuting · 03/09/2021 14:02

YANBU. I hate it when people say “It didn’t do me any harm”.
Lucky you.

The absolute worse consequence for me, was that it left me with no skills or parenting techniques to discipline my own children. The way my parents dealt with bad behaviour was punishment. Nothing else. There was no patience, no time, no effort, no understanding.

I got hit when I was bad and hit when I wasn’t.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:57

@Franklyfrost

I was slapped in the face regularly. Now I have kids of my own it just makes it sadder, that someone would do that to their own child. My mother does the same to my children so has to be closely supervised when visiting. It makes no sense to me, I thought maybe once I had kids I’d understand, but no, it seems even stranger.
You'd be well within your rights not to let her see them at all.
Franklyfrost · 03/09/2021 13:54

I was slapped in the face regularly. Now I have kids of my own it just makes it sadder, that someone would do that to their own child. My mother does the same to my children so has to be closely supervised when visiting. It makes no sense to me, I thought maybe once I had kids I’d understand, but no, it seems even stranger.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:50

@DancesWithFelines

My DD12 is pretty traumatised this week as through her bedroom wall she has clearly heard next doors 9 year old getting smacked (the fathers screams of 'bend over' and then smacking over and over).

When she came rushing down to tell me she was visibly shaking. She is also scared that the next door neighbour could do something to our cats. I am in no doubt that the poor smacked child is traumatised. I have reported it of course.

You've absolutely done the right thing.
cushioncovers · 03/09/2021 13:50

Dances that's awful 😞

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:50

@PumpkinKlNG

Well plenty did comment on the thread, in support of the mum so there you go. I don’t smack mine but I understand smacking was more socially acceptable back when I was young and also my culture smacking is normal and most people I know where smacked growing up.
Ah ha, and there's the other one. "Smacking is fine, I deserved it, no harm, no problem...

....but I don't smack mine."

It's good you don't smack yours, but it does suggest that you do know what's wrong with it even as you weirdly try to justify it at every turn.

It's hard to see our parents' faults sometimes.

cushioncovers · 03/09/2021 13:49

I was smacked as a last resort when my mum who was one of the most patient people I knew had lost her temper. This was because I had ignored her and continued to be a pain in the butt. I'm not scarred by it at all. My father didn't smack but used hurtful words instead. 40 years later I can still remember them and his words deeply affected me. Given the choice I would rather have been smacked.

DancesWithFelines · 03/09/2021 13:48

My DD12 is pretty traumatised this week as through her bedroom wall she has clearly heard next doors 9 year old getting smacked (the fathers screams of 'bend over' and then smacking over and over).

When she came rushing down to tell me she was visibly shaking. She is also scared that the next door neighbour could do something to our cats. I am in no doubt that the poor smacked child is traumatised. I have reported it of course.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 13:47

@PumpkinKlNG

It’s funny there was a thread on here a few weeks ago where a mum hit her toddler because the toddler threw something at her and the majority of the posters were telling her it was totally understandable and even a normal reaction! I was one of the lone voices saying Erm actually no it isn’t! But apparently she was a good parent 🤷‍♀️ Mn at it’s finest
I didn't see that thread and I will cop to not following MN obsessively to make sure I'm commenting on every topic to the exact proportions of my feelings about them all. It's just an irrelevant deflection from you anyway.

Have you realised yet that you like to talk about children deserving it when you actually know very well that it's about adults losing control?

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:45

Well plenty did comment on the thread, in support of the mum so there you go. I don’t smack mine but I understand smacking was more socially acceptable back when I was young and also my culture smacking is normal and most people I know where smacked growing up.

Angryfrommanchester1 · 03/09/2021 13:45

As children we were smacked in the legs or bottom, and I remember when I was about 14, my mum threatened to smack me and I said ‘if you do I’ll hit you back’, she seemed very offended saying ‘what you’d hit your own mother? How terrible of you’ etc etc. The irony was completely lost on her but not on me.

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 13:44

*never not ever

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 13:43

I certainly didn't see that thread, and I would have said the same thing on it as I'm saying now - there is ever a reason that would excuse hitting children out of frustration / anger.
Spouses cannot hit each other if they're angry or frustrated and for very good reason so there's no way it's ok for an adult to hit a child. Ever.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:40

It’s funny there was a thread on here a few weeks ago where a mum hit her toddler because the toddler threw something at her and the majority of the posters were telling her it was totally understandable and even a normal reaction! I was one of the lone voices saying Erm actually no it isn’t! But apparently she was a good parent 🤷‍♀️ Mn at it’s finest

N4ish · 03/09/2021 13:39

This thread is really, really sad to read. Also awful to see the posters saying things like 'I was hit but it was fine, I'm sure I deserved it'. No child 'deserves' to be hit ever.

I can't wait for the day so called smacking (ie: abuse) is banned in this country.

Feelingmardy · 03/09/2021 13:39

Hitting out of frustration and anger is not a last resort. It is an adult losing control of themselves and lashing out at a smaller (usually) and more vulnerable person. It will not solve the problem but it will make the relationships in which problems can be solved worse. I think it is dangerous to say that children deserve it as given no evidence of positive impact and plenty of evidence of harmful impact, all this means is "it won't actually change their behaviour but as they've pissed me off, I feel justified in hurting and humiliating them". I guess, by the same token, if the adult child is looking after their parent in their dotage, they would be perfectly justified to hit their parent if they're annoying?

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:38

I never said I hit mine, just because someone understands/doesn’t feel traumatised by
It doesn’t mean they do the same thing. You can’t force me to feel traumatised, I was rarely hit and when I was it was only because my mum had been pushed to her limits.

UniBallEye · 03/09/2021 13:35

PumpkinKING if you have children, do you hit them out of frustration and anger?

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:34

I still think I deserved it so we can agree to disagree!

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 13:33

No one is saying that 🙄 I’m simply saying I can understand why some parents hit out of frustration, anger when you’ve tried every last thing and it’s a last resort etc, I can’t get worked up about it and no I don’t feel traumatised and can understand why/how it happens and I don’t think it makes someone a terrible parent