Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
MiaAnnabell3 · 03/09/2021 22:23

The posters saying they "deserved it" have also been damaged, they just don't realise it.

DaraTheTeapot · 03/09/2021 22:20

[quote NewFlav]@DaraTheTeapot It's funny you say that. I was severly beaten as a child. My mum would walk into a room and strangle me in a fit of rage until I blacked out for absolutely no reason whatsoever. Any object within reaching distance was used as a weapon to her. But its the emotional abuse that scars me more than anything. It hurts my stomach to think of anyone ever speaking my child the way I was spoken to. Sad[/quote]
I’m sorry you also experienced abuse 😞

The times we were hurt obviously it was awful but it was to me as a child on one level, physical hurt that was always the same unlike as you say emotionally abusing which would feel like my mind was being twisted and my heart ripped up and the fear all the time and living on edge and in a constant state of anxiety humiliation jealousy (of favoured and well treated sibling) and high alert

NewFlav · 03/09/2021 20:53

@DaraTheTeapot It's funny you say that. I was severly beaten as a child. My mum would walk into a room and strangle me in a fit of rage until I blacked out for absolutely no reason whatsoever. Any object within reaching distance was used as a weapon to her. But its the emotional abuse that scars me more than anything. It hurts my stomach to think of anyone ever speaking my child the way I was spoken to. Sad

Moelwynbach · 03/09/2021 20:28

Smacking is assault no matter how you dress it up. Its shit lazy parenting. I can see how parents when pushed to the edge sometimes strike out and while its not okay its sometimes understandable when parents have nothing left.
Its never okay in my opinion.

CatsArePeople · 03/09/2021 20:22

That said, at the time smacking was actually a more preferrable punishment than grounding.

CatsArePeople · 03/09/2021 20:20

I wouldn't say traumatized - given the time and place, it was pretty much "the norm" and parents just didn't know any better.
But I do feel resentful. There were a couple of times where I actually deserved it (stealing, tormenting animals), but most of the time it was for not wanting to eat, not wanting to sleep, not sitting still, doing things too slowly - meaningless shit like that. My mother was quite a cow.

Plumtree391 · 03/09/2021 19:47

Violence, shouting, hateful words to a child are terrible.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 03/09/2021 19:09

@Babyparrotdog

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.
I don’t think it’s dramatic whatsoever. It’s awful being hit as a child, children can’t remove themselves or leave the situation. I think, having my own, made me realise how bad some things were growing up.

Punishing another adult physically would be abuse and I’m all for physical punishments to children being made illegal too.

ballroompink · 03/09/2021 19:05

@cushioncovers

I was smacked as a last resort when my mum who was one of the most patient people I knew had lost her temper. This was because I had ignored her and continued to be a pain in the butt. I'm not scarred by it at all. My father didn't smack but used hurtful words instead. 40 years later I can still remember them and his words deeply affected me. Given the choice I would rather have been smacked.
This, except it was my mum who would say hurtful things and my dad who was more likely to smack. Have no feelings whatsoever about the occasional smack that I received but some of the hurtful words really stuck with me.
DaraTheTeapot · 03/09/2021 19:05

Funnily enough I was talking to db last week and we were saying we would have preferred smacking/consistent physical abuser to the severe emotional abuse we suffered plus odd occasions of physical abuse but few and far between yet often enough for us to be on edge constantly. How said that we fee now all this time later we wished to have been beaten as the better option . Both of us suffere severely with issues now

Liverbird77 · 03/09/2021 19:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

MereDintofPandiculation · 03/09/2021 18:51

Didn’t once lay a finger on any of them- bc he decided not to. Regardless of culture and context it is ALWAYS a choice. It is always a choice - but it's much easier to choose to go with the prevailing culture than against it.

In the 1960s, the idea of bringing up a "spoilt" child was a very big fear, and parents who didn't give a "good slap" when behaviour "merited" it were criticised.

Peppaismyrolemodel · 03/09/2021 18:09

Yes, although it wasn’t as bad as some,-and what I feel is mainly a grey that a child was made to bear the brunt of adult failings.
To those posters who say ‘it was a different time’: my ggd was physically abused by his mum as a child, grew up away from family. He had 4 rowdy boys in the 50s/60s.
Didn’t once lay a finger on any of them- bc he decided not to. Regardless of culture and context it is ALWAYS a choice.

5128gap · 03/09/2021 18:09

[quote LizzieW1969]@CurryLover55

I was smacked in primary school, in the mid 1970s. Only with a hand, not a ruler or any other implement. One teacher smacked children a lot. Late 70s and early 80s, it was just the fact that there was a cane in the headteacher’s office, I think,

Then corporal punishment was banned. I remember hearing that it was, I don’t remember exactly when.[/quote]
In the 70s at primary class teachers would smack children on the bottom in a fairly casual way. Formal smacking by the head teacher was either hand or slipper, at times the slipper was given in assembly in front of everyone. I remember towards the end of my primary school they stopped snacking girls. In secondary school the cane was around until early 80s I think. It was usually on the palm though there were rumours of boys being caned on the legs/bottom, but never girls. Female teachers caned girls on the hands.
PE teachers were a law onto themselves and would hit students with table tennis bats, wet towels, ropes. Male games teachers would often come into the changing room to 'hurry the girls up' out of the showers and would slap us as we passed. We used to call them 'pervs' for it but in a resigned eye rolling way, not traumatised. This would gave been around 1982 I think.
So shocking to look back on.

londonrach · 03/09/2021 17:37

No, I was hurt to leave marks too. I'd never hit DD though and never had but I'm in a different time to my parents....I know they did it as they thought only way to teach right and wrong.... they very anti it now...

Plumtree391 · 03/09/2021 17:37

That's awful, Fatya.

Fatya · 03/09/2021 17:35

Just to add that by most people's standards I was a very well-behaved child. Top grades in school for every subject and very conscientious. Never got into trouble at school and always has glowing reports.

Didn't save me from being smacked about at home, though.

Fatya · 03/09/2021 17:32

I'm still affected by childhood smacking. If people raise their arms near me, I flinch. It's entirely involuntary and has drawn comments from friends and colleagues.

Both of my parents used to smack me. The incidences that stick in my mind are the ones where they'd accuse me of something I hadn't done and hit me across my head until I'd 'confess'.

To give my mother some credit, she recognised it as a problem and sought counselling for her rage issues (I didn't learn this until adulthood).

It definitely continues to affect my relationship with them though.

Kanaloa · 03/09/2021 16:51

And as for the teenager who apparently deserved to be ‘punched round the room’ by her mother, I don’t think that can ever be justified. If violence is unacceptable then it’s unacceptable, it’s not okay when somebody is a certain level of irritating/upsetting to you. Otherwise where does it end?

shouldistop · 03/09/2021 16:51

I think I only remember being smacked once. No it didn't traumatise me.

Kanaloa · 03/09/2021 16:50

Nobody ‘deserves’ to be hit, least of all a child. If your two children were playing together, and one whacked the other one for hogging the toys, would you say no sweetie you deserved that because you were hogging the toys from your sister? No, you would tell the smacker that’s not what we do, we use our words and tell people if they are making us upset.

VicQuin · 03/09/2021 15:49

YANBU. I was smacked as a child but it was worse than just a tap on the back of the legs. I was a little brat at times but I don’t think I deserved to be treated the way I was. My dm was too lenient and mu df was to strict so of course I pushed the boundaries. My dm couldn’t cope with me and my dsis so she used to threaten us with our dad eg just yiu wait until your dad comes home from work. I’d hear my dm tell my df whatever it was I’d done and the next thing my df legged it up the stairs and completely lost it. I was hit over the head repeatedly left sobbing on be floor. A couple of times he even dragged me to the bathroom and shoved soap in my mouth for swearing. Oh and there were spells were he would hit my mum. You wouldn’t think any of this happened now though it’s like my df has amnesia and we are one big happy family. But I’ve finally as an adult taken time to process things and I’m
at the point now we’re I resent both of my parents. They have a good relationship with my dc but I wish they didn’t in a way as I’d like to see less of them. So yeah that’s my take on it.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 15:03

@PumpkinKlNG

Whether or not deserve it I don’t hold any bad feeling and don’t feel upset about it.
Well that's great. Of course it's better when children are not damaged by bad parenting.

But stop spreading the idea that kids deserve it. Especially if what you mean is "parents are angry and frustrated".

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 15:02

Whether or not deserve it I don’t hold any bad feeling and don’t feel upset about it.

ConstanceGracy · 03/09/2021 15:00

No. I was smacked and although I think it was a shitty thing to do, I don’t harbour any ill feelings about it