Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 04/09/2021 15:18

And no, siblings and I don’t use humour due to some suppressed trauma

Well then, maybe you can explain what's inherently funny about beating children until your implement of choice breaks, and the children subsequently being beaten with something else that causes week-long injuries?

Bonnytoon · 04/09/2021 15:05

YANBU

My mum used to chase us around the house and smack us repeatedly for the smallest of things. It was definitely just her unleashing her anger or frustration. Afterwards she would say things like "I never thought I would hit my own child but I never knew a child could be so selfish/disobedient/bla bla bla." Never took any responsibility and never apologised, just always doubled-down on why it was our fault. There was a rhyme she would say before she hit us. She said to me a few years ago grinning and laughing "Remember that rhyme I used to sing when you had been naughty?" I looked at her square in the eye and said "Aren't you ashamed of yourself? I just can't believe you expect me to look back on that fondly." She still just tries to pass it off as a sign of the times. It wasn't. It was the 90s and none of my friends were being hit with wooden spoons and spatulas. I get along with her okay but I know deep down she is a nasty piece of work. f

2389Champ · 04/09/2021 15:04

My mother used to regularly smack me and when I look back as an adult, the ‘crimes’ I had committed to deserve the punishment were pretty standard normal child behaviour. I was supposed to have known what I had done wrong - I genuinely didn’t and if I asked why, I got another smack for answering back or having a bad attitude.

Her particular favourite was shillelagh which was an Irish blackthorn walking stick which was quite knobbly and consequently resulted in some pretty impressive bruising. I’m sure nowadays a school would raise concerns over my injuries but back then, no one even questioned it.

Again, it wasn’t until I grew up that I realised my mother’s form of discipline wasn’t normal and was clearly abuse. She always denied it when I spoke to her woman to woman and said she rarely hit me and I must have imagined all the incidents! Not justifying her in anyway - and I never left my children in her care for this reason - but I think violence was ‘normal’ in her upbringing and most of the times I was hit by her was not because I deserved it but more that SHE had lost control of her own anger.

I was an only child so her focus was entirely on my behaviour. I don’t think she could have coped with more than one child so I rather bore the brunt of her issues. Our adult relationship until her death was bizarre. I never entirely forgave her for my treatment (is that really wicked?) and kept her at arms length although she always told others we had a very strong mother/daughter bond and was believed!

I never grieved over her death last year either. Maybe I’m a heartless bitch, but my childhood memories were always taunted by her cruelty.

MiaAnnabell3 · 04/09/2021 14:52

@HoppingPavlova
You feel how you feel. But take yourself out of the situation. Imagine seeing a child being beaten so hard with a spoon it broke and then beaten with a strap, would you find it funny?

Kanaloa · 04/09/2021 14:38

Obviously you don’t feel traumatised by it and that’s fine, but I would say it is abusive behaviour and certainly wouldn’t be acceptable nowadays when we know better.

Kanaloa · 04/09/2021 14:37

@HoppingPavlova

However, more often than not, people who have been at the end of their parents' anger, feel traumatised.

See, there’s the thing though. Our parents never hit us because they were angry. They never hit us when angry. It more so seemed a chore to hit us, something they believed they had to do as a means of behaviour modification for our own good to make us better people. I truly believe their generation was brought up to believe that if you didn’t do this then children would turn into adult delinquents. No loving parent wanted that for their kids!

Any punishment we were dealt was never at the time out of anger, it was always at another time when household chores/tasks at hand were finished. They were in no way abusive. I believe that’s very different to what certain other posters describe.

And no, siblings and I don’t use humour due to some suppressed traumaHmm. It’s because many of the things we did at the time that involved punishment were genuinely hilarious.

The situation you’re talking about though - one parent hitting a child with a wooden implement until it breaks, followed by another parent hitting them with an implement for laughing at the first one breaking - is objectively really not funny. It’s poor parenting. And if anything, I would say it’s worse that they ‘waited until household chores were done’ so therefore had time to think about what they were going to do and then still hit their child.
HoppingPavlova · 04/09/2021 14:12

Parents were very much judged if children misbehaved.

Exactly, and double edged. Judged that they were not in control of their kids, and judged that they were failing their kids. It was seen as a parental job just like feeding kids nutritious food, clothing them correctly and taking them to Dr when unwell. I know my parents definitely saw it as a parenting chore, it was not something that they enjoyed or excited them, probably pretty much on par with dealing with nits or having to go to soft play in the modern day context.

HoppingPavlova · 04/09/2021 14:03

However, more often than not, people who have been at the end of their parents' anger, feel traumatised.

See, there’s the thing though. Our parents never hit us because they were angry. They never hit us when angry. It more so seemed a chore to hit us, something they believed they had to do as a means of behaviour modification for our own good to make us better people. I truly believe their generation was brought up to believe that if you didn’t do this then children would turn into adult delinquents. No loving parent wanted that for their kids!

Any punishment we were dealt was never at the time out of anger, it was always at another time when household chores/tasks at hand were finished. They were in no way abusive. I believe that’s very different to what certain other posters describe.

And no, siblings and I don’t use humour due to some suppressed traumaHmm. It’s because many of the things we did at the time that involved punishment were genuinely hilarious.

Anon778833 · 04/09/2021 13:52

I actually think that a lot of shit parenting is our parents using us as a dumping ground for their unresolved issues.

My dad was a terrible father. He literally had no idea how to parent at all and would smack me because he didn't want me to ask questions he didn't know how to answer.

Even at school, the 'discipline' was shit. I remember teachers dragging students by the arms, shoving them. I remember the head teacher saying to numerous boys 'your head is going to go that way and your body the other.' I remember children getting smacked.

This was the 80s

LizzieW1969 · 04/09/2021 13:51

I would like to point out that there was a lot of pressure on parents back then to keep their children in line. Particularly in churches, the background I grew up in. It was considered right for parents to maintain discipline within families and corporal punishment was actively encouraged to this end. It wasn’t right, but it’s the way things were. Parents were very much judged if children misbehaved.

I do think my parents took that way too far, even in a church background, and my DM admits that they were wrong, as I’ve said. But at the time my DM considered it part of their role in bringing us up. They were both disciplined that way as children, which also played a part, I think.

I only mention my DM there; obviously my F was a different matter.

sicklycolleague · 04/09/2021 13:51

I wasn’t really smacked, I know it happened a handful of times from parents or grandparents but it was the lightest of taps with a hand and it hasn’t really registered in my consciousness. My mum was occasionally subject to a wooden spoon and in my dad’s family there was a metal spoon which my uncle buried in the garden! It sounds like what you mention is much much more abusive.

Beating children up has never been OK, my great gran almost got herself in harm’s way after she saw someone in a shop hitting their child in the 1980s and at 5’ nothing in stilettos just went up and gave them a piece of her mind. My mum has always been very proud of her for that, she’d take on anyone she thought was being cruel to kids

yname · 04/09/2021 13:18

And, I'm sorry, I don't buy the "we knew no better" as said from my mum. The love I have for my children makes me want to protect them, not hurt them. I have four children, three now who are in their 20s. They drove me absolutely batty, at times. They were sometimes a nightmare. But that never made me want to strike them. I just couldn't. I also realised that I couldn't misplace my anger on to them, if I was having a bad day.

Anon778833 · 04/09/2021 13:02

I remember forcing myself not to cry after being smacked. Which would make my mother hit me again. And again. And again. My father stopped her in the end.

What the F is wrong with these freak parents?

Anon778833 · 04/09/2021 12:57

YANBU - hitting a child is abusive. It was then and it is now.

Maybe you could look into some counselling?

DrSbaitso · 04/09/2021 12:54

Well I'm not going to tell you how you feel, HoppingPavlova, but I am going to tell you that is fucked up. I absolutely understand using humour as a defence against it, definitely when your mother destroyed her preferred tool of assault, but it's not the beating of children that's funny.

Everything that happens to us makes us the people we are today. That's just a neutral fact, not necessarily a good or bad thing. Is it good that someone has grown up to think children deserve to be hit or that it's character building to be beaten so hard that it leaves you injured for a week?

The smacking stopped when I grabbed her hand and threatened to snap her wrist.

Haha. Amazing how many parents who just can't be expected to control themselves or couldn't possibly find any other method of resolution suddenly have alternatives when they face getting bashed right back. Alternatively, I suppose some parents see it through and end up having an actual brawl with their adult or nearly adult children, but it's still not exactly a ringing endorsement of their amazing parenting, is it?

yname · 04/09/2021 12:40

And yet to this day I still feel like I'm a bad person despite not really knowing why

You were the scapegoat; someone to take their anger out on.

You see, their narrative was that you were naughty and needing punishing, although you now know this not to be true.

A similar narrative was used on my sister. She was this evil, manipulative child who needed severely punishing. Truth be told, she was a well behaved, kind child. I, on the other hand, was a bit of a handful. But if they had laid a hand on me, I would have hit them back, in defiance. So, they decided to label me schizophrenic, instead Confused

I reported them to the police for the abuse of my sister. But my sister felt guilty pressing charges, and didn't. She was annoyed with me for pursuing it (which I kind of understand, TBH).

yname · 04/09/2021 12:28

What is wrong is others (not OP) telling everyone who was physically punished how they feel as though it’s a blanket feeling.

If that's directed at me, that was not my intention. I'm looking at the actions of the adult, not the child. You are, of course, well within your rights not to feel fazed.

However, more often than not, people who have been at the end of their parents' anger, feel traumatised.

My trauma comes from watching my sister being beaten. Like you, it doesn't seem to have affected her. That does not make the actions of my parents more palatable.

minatrina · 04/09/2021 12:25

Oh also I'd like to add that throughout my childhood I thoroughly believed I was an evil child and that's why my parents had to hit me. It felt like this horrible secret that I had to live with, that if anyone else knew who I truly was and how I behaved at home then they would hit me too. It stopped me from wanting to be close to other family members.

Looking back and after having frank conversations with my mother about it, I was actually a pretty well behaved child. I did really well in school, and neither me or my mum can name a single notable occasion of bad behaviour from me. The only thing was I was a bit of a sarky mare. But I never got in trouble at school, I never did anything at all remarkable. And yet to this day I still feel like I'm a bad person despite not really knowing why

yname · 04/09/2021 12:21

but it did make siblings and myself the people we are today

How did being hit make you the people you are today. I have never understood that comment?

minatrina · 04/09/2021 12:18

I was smacked a lot by both my parents, probably more viciously than most but certainly it never caused injury or marks or anything. Now I'm in my 20s, I realise how much it's messed me up. I have always had this gut feeling that romantic partners will hit me one day, and that it will be my fault because I pushed them to it by being annoying.

Now luckily I'm married to a wonderful man who I absolutely know would never ever do that, but if I annoy him there's a part of me deep inside that's preparing to be hit. The worst part is that whilst I absolutely know that no one should ever hit someone else and there is never ever an excuse, if I were to be hit by my partner I truly don't think I'd leave him because it's so normalised in my brain that if someone hits me, it's my fault for being rude, for being annoying, for being disrespectful.

It really upsets me to think about. It's silly really because I do know my partner would never, but I feel ashamed about the fact that I would probably just accept the behaviour.

I can say with absolute confidence that I would never lay a finger on my child. It just seems so utterly wrong to me, and it makes me feel sick to think about. I don't think it's right to teach children that there's ever an acceptable scenario where they deserve to be hit or abused.

HoppingPavlova · 04/09/2021 12:17

Should add, the one we laugh about the most is one of us getting hit with the wooden spoon (by mum). The spoon broke which made mum irate as we had broken her good spoon. The rest of us found it funny and laughed so then we all copped it with the strap when dad got home. Several decades later we still crack up remembering the look on mums face when that spoon broke and all agree the belting we all got afterwards was well worth the laughter at the time as was most of the stuff we did in order to be punished.

HoppingPavlova · 04/09/2021 12:10

You are not wrong to feel traumatised as you feel how you feel.

What is wrong is others (not OP) telling everyone who was physically punished how they feel as though it’s a blanket feeling.

I’m old and grew up in the age of corporal punishment, cane at school and the belt/strap at home or if mum the wooden spoon. Some siblings still have physical scars. However, it was just the done thing at the time and patents were not horrid or uncaring. The reverse in fact in that they thought it was their duty to make you a good citizen and if they didn’t then they had failed you. Hurt like fuck at the time and the saying couldn’t sit down for a week was true but it did make siblings and myself the people we are today and often when we are together and taking a trip down memory lane we have a bit of a laugh about it. I appreciate everyone is different though.

yname · 04/09/2021 12:04

dentydown, yes. My sister used to have to cry, when she was smacked, or else it would make my mum really angry. Psychological /emotional abuse is just as damaging. Disgusting behaviour from so called care givers.

dentydown · 04/09/2021 11:56

I remember forcing myself not to cry after being smacked. Which would make my mother hit me again. And again. And again. My father stopped her in the end.

The smacking stopped when I grabbed her hand and threatened to snap her wrist.

N4ish · 04/09/2021 11:33

Smacking is just a nice way of saying hitting. It’s never ok to hit a child, I don’t care if the hitting doesn’t leave marks.

People should challenge the use of the word smacking when they see it being used. It glosses over and minimises the reality of what’s happening to a child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread