Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 06/09/2021 22:33

I'd object more strongly to being told it's ok to hit your children. As before, it's just a spectrum of shit. Some incidents fall further to one end of the spectrum than others, but it's always shit and failed parenting.

We've had several people on this thread state that they aren't damaged by it (a low bar for parenting indeed, as someone pointed out), but the more they talk, the clearer it is that they are. The person who knew it was just about a parent failing to control herself in anger and frustration and doesn't do it themselves, yet claimed to deserve it and kept weirdly defending it. The person who insisted that she wasn't laughing about it as a defence, but because being hit until the implement breaks really is just inherently hilarious and implied that being assaulted is character building.

Once you know that at least a fair number of people are traumatised by it, why in the fuck would anyone take the risk?

If someone is not damaged by it, that's wonderful. Of course it's always better if shit parenting didn't come to its worst possible outcome. But it's still shit and disgraceful parenting.

LizzieW1969 · 06/09/2021 22:26

I’m finding this thread quite challenging, actually. I do suffer from cPTSD as a result of what happened to me during my childhood, as do my siblings. But not because of being smacked, though I was smacked a lot and my DM accepts that she got this wrong, as I said earlier.

What I’m wondering now is whether I would have been traumatised by the smacking if the SA hadn’t happened.

I guess I’ll never know. All I do know is that my DM’s role in smacking us made it impossible for me to tell her anything, as I was scared of her. (She thought she was so approachable as well.)

By contrast, my DH wasn’t scared of his parents at all, despite being smacked occasionally. He would object strongly to being told that his parents were abusive because they smacked him, that’s for sure.

Naptimenow · 06/09/2021 21:39

@LizzieW1969

From what I’ve seen during my life and from this thread is that those who are traumatised by having been smacked are mostly those who were beaten rather than just having been tapped on the hand or the butt. (I’m not condoning smacking here btw.)

For example, my DH was smacked as a child, but very rarely, as was my BIL. (Unlike my siblings and me, we were smacked often and hard.) He remained very close to his parents as an adult and we see my MIL regularly (my FIL died in a car accident 17 years ago).

I think that is common sense - the more abuse a child is subjected the more it affects them - there is no line though on what is and is not acceptable and what will and will not leave a mark on someone for life and anyone that thinks this way is deluded. Abusive behaviour will never result in a positive outcome.
UnsolicitedDickPic · 06/09/2021 20:52

@LizzieW1969

From what I’ve seen during my life and from this thread is that those who are traumatised by having been smacked are mostly those who were beaten rather than just having been tapped on the hand or the butt. (I’m not condoning smacking here btw.)

For example, my DH was smacked as a child, but very rarely, as was my BIL. (Unlike my siblings and me, we were smacked often and hard.) He remained very close to his parents as an adult and we see my MIL regularly (my FIL died in a car accident 17 years ago).

For my part, I don't consider that I was beaten - I was slapped with an open palm. But I was slapped continuously, for the most imperceptible of perceived crimes. I was never hit with an object, or punched. It was still traumatic and it has impacted on my adult self in that I became someone who attempted to dodge risk at any cost, and an enormous people pleaser.

My DSis and I were discussing this thread recently (she's not on MN) and she told me she can clearly remember an incident where our DM chased me through the house to slap me. She was traumatised by it all, too.

LizzieW1969 · 06/09/2021 20:10

From what I’ve seen during my life and from this thread is that those who are traumatised by having been smacked are mostly those who were beaten rather than just having been tapped on the hand or the butt. (I’m not condoning smacking here btw.)

For example, my DH was smacked as a child, but very rarely, as was my BIL. (Unlike my siblings and me, we were smacked often and hard.) He remained very close to his parents as an adult and we see my MIL regularly (my FIL died in a car accident 17 years ago).

Naptimenow · 06/09/2021 19:45

@Itsnotover

I was an only child. So I assume that in some families, some children are / were beaten and others were not?
Maybe...favouritism was/is often a thing.
Anon778833 · 06/09/2021 19:33

*I assume from this thread

Anon778833 · 06/09/2021 19:33

I was an only child. So I assume that in some families, some children are / were beaten and others were not?

Naptimenow · 06/09/2021 14:16

@DrSbaitso it's maybe a bit like poverty in the sense that the relative position of your peers matters. A bit like the poster below who seems to bond with her siblings over the beatings they used to get - if only one of them was beaten, there would be nothing to bond over or laugh at - the true horror of a sibling getting beat so hard the spoon broke would have hit home (no pun intended) - just as it did for us the day my younger brother was beat with a belt, makes me want to weep every time I think about it.

DrSbaitso · 06/09/2021 14:03

@Naptimenow

I remember reading a study on the emotional effects of hitting children. The impact was greatest amount cultures where smacking was seen as unacceptable - where children felt the shame of what their parents were doing, knowing that if other people knew the way their parents treated them, their parents would be severely judged. In cultures where smacking was seen as normal the kids who were subjected to it coped better emotionally.
Or they felt less comfortable calling it the shit parenting it is when they know everyone around them is going to tell them they're not traumatised and it was normal and fantastic.
TertiusLydgate · 05/09/2021 16:47

Plus, ‘did me no harm’ is such a low bar for parenting. I don’t want my kids to say my parenting didn’t harm them, I want them to say my parenting elevated them, taught them, shaped them. Just the absence of trauma and harm is a low point to aim for.

This.

Perfectly put.

Starbucksbasic123 · 05/09/2021 11:26

@2389Champ

My mother used to regularly smack me and when I look back as an adult, the ‘crimes’ I had committed to deserve the punishment were pretty standard normal child behaviour. I was supposed to have known what I had done wrong - I genuinely didn’t and if I asked why, I got another smack for answering back or having a bad attitude.

Her particular favourite was shillelagh which was an Irish blackthorn walking stick which was quite knobbly and consequently resulted in some pretty impressive bruising. I’m sure nowadays a school would raise concerns over my injuries but back then, no one even questioned it.

Again, it wasn’t until I grew up that I realised my mother’s form of discipline wasn’t normal and was clearly abuse. She always denied it when I spoke to her woman to woman and said she rarely hit me and I must have imagined all the incidents! Not justifying her in anyway - and I never left my children in her care for this reason - but I think violence was ‘normal’ in her upbringing and most of the times I was hit by her was not because I deserved it but more that SHE had lost control of her own anger.

I was an only child so her focus was entirely on my behaviour. I don’t think she could have coped with more than one child so I rather bore the brunt of her issues. Our adult relationship until her death was bizarre. I never entirely forgave her for my treatment (is that really wicked?) and kept her at arms length although she always told others we had a very strong mother/daughter bond and was believed!

I never grieved over her death last year either. Maybe I’m a heartless bitch, but my childhood memories were always taunted by her cruelty.

I could have written this myself. When you said shillelagh I got a shiver down my spine. Same....16 years on I haven’t grieved properly. My heart goes out to you
Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 11:20

I remember reading a study on the emotional effects of hitting children. The impact was greatest amount cultures where smacking was seen as unacceptable - where children felt the shame of what their parents were doing, knowing that if other people knew the way their parents treated them, their parents would be severely judged. In cultures where smacking was seen as normal the kids who were subjected to it coped better emotionally.

2389Champ · 05/09/2021 10:44

@Naptimenow

I guess it comes down to the definition of smacking and how close that gets to beating! NO! Smacking is abuse it's a spectrum and it is never ok - it is always an failure of the adult's to deal with a situation appropriately. A child who is not behaving in a way you approve of does not deserve to be assaulted.
This exactly.

We have legal system in place that rules it’s unacceptable and a punishable offence to hit others just because you find their behaviour unacceptable or merely because they’ve annoyed you - and that’s to protect adults!

Why should the rules be any different for the striking of children? After all, they’re smaller, more vulnerable and deserve even more protection. Many people that beat children would think twice about doing it to an equally sized adult.

I’m sorry I keep posting on this thread but it’s opened up a huge can of worms from my childhood. My mother had a cupboard full of sayings to justify her punishments, spare the rod, spoil the child, etc etc She loved to tell me when I was a parent, I would feel and do the same. If she saw other parents dealing with tantrums she would offer uninvited advice “that a short hard smack would deal with that”

My kids told me that when they were growing up, my sadness at their behaviour had far more impact on them than if I got cross.

Harpydragon · 05/09/2021 10:03

@naptimenow @DrSbaitso I couldn't agree more. What I was trying to say (badly) is that those who feel traumatised seem to have received more than a tap on the hand or leg.
I was one of those who was beaten, I do feel traumatised by it and I have always talked to my son rather than hit him with the exception of a tap on his leg when he ran out in traffic. I felt and still do guilt because of it, but I did apologise to him at the time and went on to explain why I had reacted how I did. There is no excuse for hitting anyone and I struggled because that was the only thing I knew, but I was determined not to be the same as my mum.

Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 09:14

I guess it comes down to the definition of smacking and how close that gets to beating! NO! Smacking is abuse it's a spectrum and it is never ok - it is always an failure of the adult's to deal with a situation appropriately. A child who is not behaving in a way you approve of does not deserve to be assaulted.

DrSbaitso · 05/09/2021 09:02

I guess it comes down to the definition of smacking and how close that gets to beating!

No, hitting your children is a spectrum of shit. It's always bad parenting. Some forms of it fall further to one end of the spectrum, but it's always shit parenting.

Harpydragon · 05/09/2021 08:55

I commented earlier, but reading back there seems to be a clear divide between those people who received a tap for something they knew was naughty and their don't feel traumatised.
Then there are those people who received far more than that along with verbal abuse, yelling etc etc and no clear reason as to why they were receiving that punishment. These seem to be majoritly the people who feel traumatised.
I guess it comes down to the definition of smacking and how close that gets to beating!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 05/09/2021 08:51

@MiaAnnabell3

My partner's family also all hit their kids. My partner wouldn't dream of it. His sister told us proudly how her toddler had been playing up so she held her hands above her head and smacked her all over Angry And his family laughed. And they wonder why my children have never been alone with any of them.
This sounds revolting.

Please could you/your Oh report her... This is EXACTLY the type of social services would take very seriously

Naptimenow · 05/09/2021 07:48

@notangelinajolie

I remember being smacked but no, it didn't traumatise me. When I was about 8, I was quite rude to my Grandma who had made a dress for my doll. I said it was horrible, refused to put it on her and had quite a tantrum. While I don't think anyone should ever smack a child, I don't think in this case it was undeserved. In actual fact it was a really lovely dress and she had taken weeks to make it. She was a skilled tailoress and I learnt years later that she had used part of my christening gown to make it. I used to talk shit when I was young - I don't know why. My mum used to call me 'Contrary Mary'. I'm still like that today sometimes Hmm. My Grandma was my best friend and we were inseparable. I still feel bad about it 50 years later and I wish I could tell her I'm sorry Sad I do still have the dress up in the loft somewhere.
You think your lovely grandma would feel better that you were physically assaulted because for some inexplicable reason you were rude - the beating didn’t seem to fix that aspect of your behaviour either. Did someone ask you about why you felt the need to be rude - what was driving those emotions, did anyone try to help you understand the warning signs of when you were about to be rude and help you develop coping mechanisms? Did they just thump you and hope the pain they inflicted would be a stronger fear than the other emotions they hadn’t help you explore and that trauma would make you stop. Or did they just lash out in revenge because they were embarrassed?
FreeBritnee · 05/09/2021 07:45

@peoniesandpastels

I was smacked very infrequently as a child, usually in dangerous situations where my parents felt that a sharp shock would teach me not to do that again. I was only ever smacked with the palm of a hand, on the back of the legs or bum, and I dont remember ever having clothing removed. So much milder than many of the experiences recounted in this thread.

I don't feel especially traumatised by it, or resentful of my parents for doing it. It is definitely not something I would ever do with my own children, however. I think it models behaviour that you are trying to teach children is unacceptable, and there are more effective ways to communicate with them that don't involve a dynamic of fear and pain.

I feel exactly the same. I wouldn’t snack my children as they attack each other regularly and I’ll look bloody ridiculous reprimanding them for hitting, whilst hitting them.
peoniesandpastels · 05/09/2021 07:43

I was smacked very infrequently as a child, usually in dangerous situations where my parents felt that a sharp shock would teach me not to do that again. I was only ever smacked with the palm of a hand, on the back of the legs or bum, and I dont remember ever having clothing removed. So much milder than many of the experiences recounted in this thread.

I don't feel especially traumatised by it, or resentful of my parents for doing it. It is definitely not something I would ever do with my own children, however. I think it models behaviour that you are trying to teach children is unacceptable, and there are more effective ways to communicate with them that don't involve a dynamic of fear and pain.

DrSbaitso · 05/09/2021 07:36

@notangelinajolie

I remember being smacked but no, it didn't traumatise me. When I was about 8, I was quite rude to my Grandma who had made a dress for my doll. I said it was horrible, refused to put it on her and had quite a tantrum. While I don't think anyone should ever smack a child, I don't think in this case it was undeserved. In actual fact it was a really lovely dress and she had taken weeks to make it. She was a skilled tailoress and I learnt years later that she had used part of my christening gown to make it. I used to talk shit when I was young - I don't know why. My mum used to call me 'Contrary Mary'. I'm still like that today sometimes Hmm. My Grandma was my best friend and we were inseparable. I still feel bad about it 50 years later and I wish I could tell her I'm sorry Sad I do still have the dress up in the loft somewhere.
You deserved to be corrected, not hit! What was hitting you going to teach you that a serious explanation didn't?

All these posters who think they deserved to be hit for being children and not adults!

VicQuin · 05/09/2021 05:24

Hi. I’ve already commented on this thread but I thought I’d just add a bit more. I’m 40 years old, I have 2dc, one of whom is autistic. I was diagnosed with adhd myself last year and going through the process of assessment basically forced me to reflect on my life especially my childhood. I found it sole destroying as all of these memories, that I’d pushed to the back of my mind for years came flooding back. The psychiatrist agreed that I ticked all the boxes for adhd although a milder form (his words) but I know that a lot of my difficulties don’t just stem from going undiagnosed all these years, they stem from my childhood. Then all of a sudden these feelings of anger and resentment for my parents crept in and I found myself having to work really hard to not just blurt it all out to them. There is absolutely no point, no point at all in speaking to them about my childhood as it’s like it never happened, at least to them. My df hit my dm on and off for years and hearing that, plus being “smacked” myself has caused me damaged mentally.

Like I said, my dc is autistic. He at times, has explosive behaviour, and although I deal with it and we have strategies in place to help him cope with feelings of frustration, the fact I was hit as a child means that when my ds acts out it kind of triggers me and get incredibly anxious. But I have never, and would never lay a finger on him. I might be feeling frustrated and anxious inside when my ds has meltdowns but it’s my responsibility to remain as calm (outwardly) as I can and not lose my temper. I admit I was a difficult child. I had odd behaviours, I was impulsive, did stupid things, had a right potty mouth etc but I didn’t deserve to be treated the way I was. I like to think I’ve grown up to be a decent person but that isn’t because my parents kept me in line, it’s because I wanted to be a good person and a good mum. I’m far from a perfect parent,I’ve made mistakes, but I try my best and my dc are good kids so I can’t be doing that bad.

Pantaloony · 05/09/2021 05:24

I was regularly smacked as a child and while I don’t remember it, my mum admitted to losing it with me when I pooed myself as a toddler and really smacking me. I suspect I surpressed the memory but I actually had issues with constipation and fear of going to the toilet for years to the point I had to have counselling and hypnotherapy as an adult. So yes I was traumatised from being smacked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread