Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
Libraryghost · 02/09/2021 20:34

Just reading some of these stories and I am a bit shocked by the removing underwear and leaving marks on skin. No wonder people are traumatised.

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 20:33

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

To clarify...

My parents never:

  • bruised me or left a mark
  • removed clothing/underwear
  • smacked with anything other than palm of hand

I think going beyond any of those would have put it in a different league for me and probably caused more trauma but everyone's different.

I think this is the difference. Not that I condone any smacking at all. My mum used to tell people a story about me not being able to do PE lesson because I had handprints on my legs so she had to make an excuse, like it was a funny story to tell? Really weird and no one I’ve heard her tell ever laughed
OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/09/2021 20:30

To clarify...

My parents never:

  • bruised me or left a mark
  • removed clothing/underwear
  • smacked with anything other than palm of hand

I think going beyond any of those would have put it in a different league for me and probably caused more trauma but everyone's different.

Libraryghost · 02/09/2021 20:29

@Dizzy1234 I have no memories of sitting on my mums knee or being cuddled either. I was the scapegoat (middle child) Its made me extremely independent and resilient but it’s not a nice feeling is it?

Libraryghost · 02/09/2021 20:25

My mother would always slap first and ask questions later. I think it was wrong but I am not traumatised by it. I grew up in the 70s and 80s and it was an accepted punishment. I once had my head shoved under a tap by a teacher to wash my make up off! Forget about it op, times have changed and you don’t need to be dwelling on it.

LonelySock · 02/09/2021 20:24

Yup 😔 My dad used to "smack" my bum, up until ages 13 or so. The humiliation and the bruising afterwards are so vivid in my memories.

I couldn't get changed easily for PE in late late primary/early secondary as the bruising - that lasted ages - was on my thighs as well as bum.

The last time he did it when I was 13, I brought up in one of those "family meetings" that used to be popular in the 1980s how embarrassed I felt in PE and my parents instantly dismissed me and told me of course they never marked me and I was exaggerating it.

But they never did it again so 🤷🏻‍♀️ hopefully I embarrassed them a bit into realising it was wrong.

I also relate to being forced to cuddle afterwards and told it "hurts me more than it hurts you". Utter crap. It was power and humiliation and pain done in anger.

I wasn't a naughty child at all 😔

I have never hit my children.

Thatsjustwhatithink · 02/09/2021 20:24

Not traumatised at having been smacked, but I would never ever hit a child so more confused that it was considered normal back then.

I'd never hit a child or animal. Or anything that was weaker than me and not a physical threat. It makes me wince to see parents hit children. Such a lack of control.

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 20:24

I’m 30 now so this was in the 90’s, I don’t think a lot of my friends were smacked but one friend in particular was and I remember her saying to me when we were about 10 that she was so happy because she hadn’t been smacked for a whole week and feeling really jealous and wishing I could go a whole week without a smack. We are both NC with our fathers. As are all other children they had.

OP posts:
Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 20:21

I don’t remember what age it stopped for me but I was still scared of it happening way into my teens and think it would have if I got on the wrong side of them. I always avoided going anywhere with him in public for fear of the humiliation of having my trousers pulled down and smacked in front of people. I used to try and draw absolutely no attention to myself if we were out anywhere so that I wouldn’t accidentally do something that would warrant it.

OP posts:
MiaAnnabell3 · 02/09/2021 20:21

My mum and her siblings were really badly hit as children. All of her siblings have gone on to hit their own children although not to the same extent. My mum has never laid a finger on us and I never will with my children.
I can never fathom why an adult thinks they have the right to inflict pain on a defenceless child simply because they birthed them.

worriedatthemoment · 02/09/2021 20:17

No as it never happened often and was what happened to all my friends so see a tap or light smacking as normal back then
One of my friends dAds used fo actually full on hit her hard and I knew that was not the type of smack the rest of us received

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/09/2021 20:16

Not traumatised. Occasional smack on bum, when definitely old enough to know full well I had done something bloody naughty. Haven't done it to my kids as times have changed, but it wasn't really a big deal when I was a child.

Koyto · 02/09/2021 20:16

I'm so sorry OP, please don't try to minimise your feelings about what smacking has done to you, your feelings are valid Flowers
I was smacked with a leather belt up until the age of about 9 I think, always dished out by my father over his knee with my pants pulled down, it always makes me feel disgusting when I think of it now, I'm 45yrs old. My dad would get home from work and I'd hear my mum tell him whatever I had done and then I'd hear the footsteps up the stairs. Begging and pleading, hiding, running away, he was bigger than me so I was always going to get my punishment. It stopped when my sibling was born in the 80s, I have no idea why they decided to parent them differently but they never got a smack for being naughty.
Like other posters, I tend to think of something else if it ever pops in my head. Funnily enough, my dad has apologised on many occasions and says he regrets it, wishes he could go back in time and says that's just how he was bought up. My mum never discusses it but I don't know how she could sit downstairs listening to the crying and screaming above her and not want to stop it.
Unfortunately I think it helped shaped me into what I am today, people pleaser, afraid to speak up for myself, not be able to deal with confrontation, I sometimes feel I go about life apologising to anyone for anything, even existing in some cases Hmm I'm a well behaved adult now though, a model citizen in society so I guess it worked huh?! 🙄😂
I accept my childhood, all I can do is live the best I can and break the chain of "that's how I was bought up" to my children.

5128gap · 02/09/2021 20:14

@RiversideAnne

I don’t feel traumatised exactly but now that I have my own baby I truly, truly can’t understand why my parents smacked me. They didn’t do it often at all - I only recall 2 or 3 occasions. And it was a quick smack with the hand. But it is hard to understand how they could have been ok with it when I feel like I would chew my hand off before I hit my son.

I just remind myself that it was a different time with different standards. It’s not exactly an excuse, but it’s an explanation.

Because many people thought it was being a good parent to discipline their children. My dad told me how his own dad had given him the slipper for deliberately breaking a neighbours window, and afterwards he caught his dad crying it had upset him so much to do it, but he felt it was his duty and he would have been failing my dad in not teaching him a lesson. This was the 1940s, but was the attitude my parents grew up with and which influenced their own parenting. I'm in my 50s and while I didn't smack my children I didn't think it was terrible either as I'd been smacked in a loving household. The change in attitudes has been gradual.
Dizzy1234 · 02/09/2021 20:14

Yes and in my middle age I seem to be focusing on my childhood, a few things have happened lately that have stirred up past memories.
It's a standing joke in our family that I don't like human contact, cuddles, people touching me etc but when I was a child the only time my parents touched me was to hit or smack me, I have no memories or sitting on my mums lap being cuddled, now if people go to touch me a inwardly flinch.
My sibling had a different childhood to me, I always seemed to be the scapegoat, siblings could blame me for anything and I would be hit, they'd deny this ever happened now, embarrassed probably.
I never laid a finger on my own daughter

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 20:12

@Blackopal

Yes , really affected me.

We were smacked and also 'spanked' this meant being put across father's leg, having trousers pulled down and hit repeatedly.
All in front of siblings etc.
My dad's temper was unpredictable and could erupt in a moment out of nowhere. A usual domestic scene could be occurring and my dad could decide he didn't like the way you looked at him and you were being lifted into the air.
The shock and humiliation were awful.

I remember all of us begging him not to.

The other thing which I find awful was that afterwards he would hold you against his chest arms looped around legs so you couldn't move an inch and keep you there until you stopped crying and were 'friends' with him again.
So no power even over your own natural anger/pain or need to get away.

Really wrong and totally unnecessary. I have never touched my children.
Such a shame, all about the broken adult and thier issues being taken out on little people who can't stop it.

Some of this is very similar to what I mean. The forced affection was very confusing. I’m sorry that happened to you too
OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 02/09/2021 20:08

YANBU. I was smacked regularly. Usually slaps to the back of the legs or being put over a knee and spanked bare-bottom but sometimes we were hit on the head or other punishments such as having arms twisted behind our backs. My Dad had a stick he kept specifically for threatening and hitting us with and I would also be hit with other objects my parents had to hand such as spoons, chopping board, rolling bin, belt etc. This was in the 90s and I can still get upset about it and I believe the memories have exacerbated or even caused my mental health difficulties.

Brindisi32 · 02/09/2021 20:08

The slap happy culture had a bad effect on me. Some of my school teachers were prone to slapping me for making errors which increased anxiety and shut down the learning process in certain subjects. I also grew up wary of my dad: he was prone to menacing and slapping me at times for very little. He was inconsistent with it and remember thinking why did he slap me for this yesterday but not today? I still remember the last time he shoved me because I refused to accept clothing that was too short for me. By this time I was fairly tall and hit him back for bullying me. He never did it again. He resorted to ridicule and minimising instead. This cemented my thinking that he was a bully and a coward. If you met him, you would never dream he was prone to outbursts. I’m also sure he would deny that he was ever like this with me.

isthisouting · 02/09/2021 20:08

*member

isthisouting · 02/09/2021 20:07

Age 7 I had three wooden spoons broken on me and then the belt. DM is my closest family members but minimalises what my DF would do when provoked.

theruffles · 02/09/2021 20:02

I don't feel traumatised by having been smacked as a child. I think it was more a product of the time I was brought up in (late 80s/early 90s), my parents having been punished in the same way themselves and a bit of a lack of patience with young children. That said, we were very loved and smacking wasn't a regular occurance.

I don't and wouldn't smack my children because I don't think it solves anything. Discipline methods have moved on a lot since I was a child.

OhGiveUp · 02/09/2021 20:01

My father refused to hit me or my sister because he always said that a man who raises his hand to a female, regardless of who she is, doesn't deserve to be called a man.
That said, I dare say there are times when he wanted to punch us into oblivion.
I can't ever remember my mum getting violent with us, she had ' the look ' except for one time when my sister was around 15 and she turned completely feral, wouldn't go to school, started smoking and drinking, not bothering to come home and not contacting our parents to say she wasn't.
After months of my parents trying everything to turn her round, my mum finally snapped and punched her round the room while me and my dad tried to get her off.
My sister underwent a personality transplant and became the fab girl / woman that we all loved.
She absolutely adores our mum and freely admits that, in her words, she was a bitch from hell who deserved it.
Neither of us, or our siblings have ever smacked our own children, though lord knows at times I've wanted to punch them to mars and back.....instead I've made do with slamming the kettle onto the hob.

NoLeafClover · 02/09/2021 20:00

Damaged by it, definitely. My Dad was a big fan of the wooden spoon. As in, he'd make us stand with our hands out, plams up, and smack them, hard, with a wooden spoon. It was horrible. A smack out of fear (child about to run into a busy road, parent grabs them and gives them a smack on the bum) I can understand. I definitely don't condone it, but I can kind of understand it. This was different. Dad would get cross, make us stand with our hands out, go off to the kitchen to get the wooden spoon, then slap us with it. It wasn't done out of rage or fear, it was calm and calculated. And if we dared to cry from the pain he'd say 'stop that crying or I'll really give you something to cry about'.

GoingOutOutNEVER · 02/09/2021 20:00

Depends on you as a person.
I was hit as a child, got the one hit for every word mother said eg don’t you ever do that again = 6 hits, never had a voice as it was deemed to be back chat. Mother hit my child despite me telling her there’s other ways to discipline, her response was well it’s a tap and then it’s over, better than waiting for them to stop screaming …. I cut her out of our lives and never regretted doing so

Cherryana · 02/09/2021 19:59

YANBU I was smacked and shouted at and know I have maladapted response to conflict, shouting and the expression of emotion.

I do not believe smacking is ever acceptable. I have never smacked my children and whilst I am not perfect, try to follow strict rules about taking time out and talking through issues, rather than shouting.

Even when my older son hurts my younger son, I call it out as violence. It is not acceptable in the home or anywhere.