Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 02/09/2021 21:50

@LizzieW1969

*I don't think that making smacking illegal will stop the abusive smackers.*

Sadly I agree. Also, the abusive smacking described on this thread has always been illegal. The smacking that’s permitted is the type that is with an open hand, on the hand or on the butt, and which doesn’t leave a mark.

And which traumatised me.

Maybe some people have forgotten (or were fortunate enough never to learn) how frightening that is when it's done to you by someone three times your size who is supposed to be your caregiver, but I haven't.

Shit parenting, should be illegal.

DrSbaitso · 02/09/2021 21:48

Yes, I am, and I'm not including the experiences from my teens when it escalated (why wouldn't it, if you lashed out and never learned to control yourself because you're too shit and lazy a parent to work on yourself as well?). Absolutely traumatised by it. Mum has had the decency to apologise. She knows better now but there were plenty of people saying it then.

Harpydragon · 02/09/2021 21:44

My mum "smacked" me. I was not a bad child, but I got good hidings on a regular basis, with hands, hairbrushes, shoes, walking sticks, wooden spoons, belts anything she happened to have in her hands at the time all whilst being screamed at and having verbal abuse shrieked at the top of her voice. I didnt have to have done anything wrong, maybe looked at her in a way she didn't like, it spoken to a friend in a way she didn't like, or failing to ask her permission to have a biscuit offered by one of her friends ,walking too fast, walking too slow. I did well in school and was never in any trouble, but it was never good enough and parents evening always resulted in a good hiding because I got an A- instead of a straight A. Her temper was explosive and she was very loud. I was often covered in bruises but we lived in a farm and there was literally no one around to witness what was happening. I was terrified of getting up in a morning incase she was in a bad mood. She always followed these episodes up with massive hugs and told me she wouldn't do that if she didn't love me

As I got older the physical abuse stopped, but the mental abuse kicked up several notches, I left home as soon as I could.

My mum denies any of this every happened I realised when I was older that she was taking it the frustration of her life on me. My friends from that time have since told me that they knew something was wrong but didn't know what they could do to help. The beatings and shouting was just a part of every thing that went on

My son has got a tap on his bottom precisely twice when he did something dangerous as a scared reaction from me. I am not proud of it and we do most things with discussion although I can get shouty.

I didn't think I was traumatised by the beatings, but I am 52 now and find myself thinking of it a lot, trying to make sense of my childhood. I do not understand how you can do all the things she did in the name of love. I have no memory of a lot of my childhood, I have blocked a lot of it out and I am very scared of bringing that forward. I have never forgiven her or my dad who never once stepped in to protect me

SweetBabyCheeses99 · 02/09/2021 21:41

I actually don’t think that the degree of smacking, whether it’s a “light tap” or frequent whacking makes any difference - if you’re traumatised then of course you’re allowed to feel that way.

Perhaps there is a correlation between the severity and frequency of violence inflicted on children and how likely they are to be traumatised in later life, but you can’t invalidate anyone’s trauma by saying that the cause is not worthy.

Personally I find smacking a very odd behaviour - on anyone else it would be classed as criminal assault but somehow its acceptable on a defenceless child. I think this abuse of power says more about the parents relationship with themselves and their own parents than on the behaviour of their child. I think a big part of the trauma is realising the fear that your primary caregiver took out their own internalised issues on their child.

Unsure33 · 02/09/2021 21:26

Nope. I was smacked occasionally but had a count down warning to stop what I was doing .

Never really think about it to be honest .

LizzieW1969 · 02/09/2021 21:14

I don't think that making smacking illegal will stop the abusive smackers.

Sadly I agree. Also, the abusive smacking described on this thread has always been illegal. The smacking that’s permitted is the type that is with an open hand, on the hand or on the butt, and which doesn’t leave a mark.

HavelockVetinari · 02/09/2021 21:09

I had the odd tap on the bottom or hand if I was doing something really dangerous (like sledging my baby brother down the stairs on a sleeping bag or running across a busy road). It wasn't painful though, just a sharp tap to shock me. I definitely wasn't traumatised but I think most people would be by what you describe Sad

I wouldn't smack DS but I don't hold it against my parents that they smacked me - it never ever left even a temporary red mark. I think the only reason I remember it at all was because of the look of utter fear on my Mum's face when she caught baby DB at the bottom of the stairs, and similar from my Dad when I was nearly hit by a van.

Smacking is wrong and studies have shown it doesn't help discipline anyway.

80Dodgeballs · 02/09/2021 21:06

I don't think that making smacking illegal will stop the abusive smackers.

I think there's a difference between a light tap to stop a kid doing something dangerous and those that get whacked for anything and everything.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 02/09/2021 21:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 02/09/2021 21:02

Yes. Was smacked, hit, scratched and grabbed.

80Dodgeballs · 02/09/2021 21:01

And she wonders why none of us want to see her...

80Dodgeballs · 02/09/2021 21:00

My own kids are horrified when I tell them what she did to us.

80Dodgeballs · 02/09/2021 20:59

As a parent now, I just can't imagine not feeling terrible guilt at ever raising a hand to my child. I would never be able to look them in the face if I did that. Hence, why I've never done it.

I don't understand that kind of parenting. I think my Dad did it once. The threat of being smacked was always there but mostly from my Mum. And, yes, she was vicious. She was the chase you around the house type (I have one fond memory of my brother completely out running her around the garden as we inwardly cheered him on). She hit us multiple times around the head, the legs, the arms. Just lashing out violence. Even my Dad was afraid of her. She denies it all now though!

She once hit me loads while I was naked in the bath because I was unable to use the loo.

I made us kids feel closer as it was us against her. It also made us deceitful as we were bloody petrified of her wrath.

My kids have yet to deceive me because I don't hit them but instead use words.

TrifleCat · 02/09/2021 20:59

I can remember being smacked, across the legs and round the head, and it does colour my opinion of my parents to be honest.

I think smacking is poor parenting - anyone can physically assault someone smaller than them it’s a lazy way to try and establish discipline, and all it teaches is you get your own way by being violent. What a shit lesson.

SukiPook · 02/09/2021 20:58

I got smacked with a ruler twice in school in the 80s and remember how light a tap it was- unlike the discipline in our house, all meted out by my mum with a "sally rod" ... she would purposefully pick the whippiest one out of the hedge. I remember it would leave horrible welts up the legs and was also extremely painful on the hands. We got it a lot. In Ireland, people getting hit with the wooden spoon was a thing too, and I remember being jealous of friends who got hit with the wooden spoon, as I always thought it would be a breeze compared to the sally rod.

Toddlerteaplease · 02/09/2021 20:58

Not at all. We were only smacked if we were really naughty. And I have no doubt we deserved it.

Thebookswereherfriends · 02/09/2021 20:56

I wouldn’t say I was traumatised, but I do vividly remember the incidences when I was smacked and a couple of when my brother was smacked. I don’t have very clear memories of that many things at that age, so they were definitely formative events.

ohdear10 · 02/09/2021 20:53

@SquirryTheSquirrel

His sister told us proudly how her toddler had been playing up so she held her hands above her head and smacked her all over

That's awful. The poor child. That's the sort of thing that makes me want to give the parent a piece of my mind - my dad used to hold me upside down by my ankles to 'slipper' me when I was small enough for him to be able to do that and I instantly remember how terrified and powerless I felt. It shocks me even more that it's still going on in 'modern' times.

I'm not the kind of person who thinks all smacking is abusing but things like this are really hideous. The other thing I hate is children being restrained by adults. It's really distressing, as a child it's like being trapped under a Boulder, you're completely stuck.

A tap on the hand or a swat on the arm is one thing but yeah, things like this go way beyond. Just adults tormenting a kid

RaininSummer · 02/09/2021 20:51

No not at all. I remember being smacked clearly but can't say it was traumatising long term though obviously no fun at the time.

latte101 · 02/09/2021 20:47

I know how you feel, OP. My mum used to hit / smack / kick me. It was called a 'good hiding'. I've never forgiven her and never will. Keep her at arms length. Never laid a finger on mine but feel the urge at times when DS shouts he hates me, and I hate myself for it. I just have to leave the room for 5.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 02/09/2021 20:46

His sister told us proudly how her toddler had been playing up so she held her hands above her head and smacked her all over

That's awful. The poor child. That's the sort of thing that makes me want to give the parent a piece of my mind - my dad used to hold me upside down by my ankles to 'slipper' me when I was small enough for him to be able to do that and I instantly remember how terrified and powerless I felt. It shocks me even more that it's still going on in 'modern' times.

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 20:42

My mum reacts like I’m really harsh for speaking to my child with a firm voice if he does something dangerous! She seems to have forgotten her own behaviour and reinvented herself as a grandma! Or maybe it’s because she’s now married to someone who was and is nice to his children

OP posts:
Pixxie7 · 02/09/2021 20:38

I think it was the norm years ago and it’s the realisation that it was actually abuse that have left a lot of people feeling traumatised.

Marcee · 02/09/2021 20:38

We were smacked, I'm not traumatised.

But it seems you were smacked a lot more and a lot more violently too. Also it stopped a lot earlier, not sure what age, but I think after about 8 years old I wasn't really smacked.

MiaAnnabell3 · 02/09/2021 20:37

My partner's family also all hit their kids. My partner wouldn't dream of it. His sister told us proudly how her toddler had been playing up so she held her hands above her head and smacked her all over Angry And his family laughed. And they wonder why my children have never been alone with any of them.