Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
memberofthewedding · 03/09/2021 03:21

When I was a kid (1950s) it was a good day when if did not get a whalloping from my father. My sister was never touched. I grew up hating my father for his brutality and my mother for her weakness in allowing it.

TravelDreamLife · 03/09/2021 02:51

I wouldn't say I'm traumatised, but I resent being smacked. I see it as lazy parenting & to exert anger, show power. I was never asked my side or had anything explained, just whack! I have never felt close to my parents or felt safe confiding in them or asking for advice. I felt completely alone with no direction & made some horrendous mistakes I wouldn't have if I'd had support. They had no other tools so I ran wild as teen. Having said that, my mother once said she didn't care what I did, but what would other people think of her as a parent?

My MIL harped on & on about how we should smack DS, who's ASD, for toilet issues & how DH & SIL towed the line because she was so strict & smacked, belt etc. I told her off, but REALLY wanted to point out SIL ran away at 16 & DH is unable to manage any disagreement because all he knows is self preservation by shutting down.

So I guess that clears up my position. My kids will never get smacked.

LunaTheCat · 03/09/2021 02:46

I was smacked. I hated it. Never hard enough to leave marks that lasted more than 5 minutes but I found it hurt and humiliating.
Once my mother banged my sisters and I ‘s heads together - that hurt like hell and I saw stars. My mother was emotionally needy and selfish about her needs. I never felt properly mothered - it has had a big effect on my, and my late sisters lives.

LunaTheCat · 03/09/2021 02:40

@WhateverHappenedToFayWray

Yes, I was smacked as child and a teenager and I still think about it. The kind of smack I would get varied. Sometimes it was round the head and other times it was round the face.

My dad punched me in the face because I got drunk when I was 15 and it was so hard that my braces went through my top lip. When I mentioned it to my mum a few years ago she said it wasn't a punch it was a back hand, like that made it ok.

That is awful 💐
KeepPortlandWeird · 03/09/2021 02:34

Userxx yeah my mother used to fly after me and hit me with anything to hand, lock me in the garden at night, slap me across the face, humiliate me verbally, and I would wet myself with fear. It was called ‘getting a good hiding’ in the 70s.

I also used to think in was normal until recently, when I learnt that actually no, not every kid growing up in the 70s was hit by their parents.

My mother came from an unusually large abusive family, more than 16 siblings. She confided in me that her father sexually abused both her and the youngest sibs (twins). Considering his wife was pregnant every year no surprise there. I don’t know if my mother is a barefaced liar, she has a knack for turning things around to suit her story, It wouldn’t surprise me if it were true, the drama in this family is heinous -sociopaths, child abusers, adultery, paedophiles, so, it’s probably true.

But as an adult she blamed her behaviour with me on what she called her hormonal imbalance. Her ‘redhead temper’ dad used to say almost with pride. To my knowledge she never hit my siblings (we are steps, I had a different dad). My brother used to stand in front of her sometimes to prevent her hitting me.

I’ve no idea why. I was a quiet almost mute child, never said boo to a goose. I was happy in myself, but suspicious of physical affection so shunned it. Maybe she couldn’t stand my silence around her, I’ll never know, and don’t want to.
She gives me the creeps. Something must have gone very wrong early on for someone to say that about their own mother I suppose.

Anyway, smacking to any degree reinforces a message that violence is a tool to control someone. If you smack your kid, ‘light pat on the back of the legs’ or slapping your teen across his chops, it’s an act of violence. As evidenced on threads like this, we remember for the rest of our lives what you did to us, no matter how much you deny or try to justify it.

GrandTheftWalrus · 03/09/2021 01:56

Also when I was about 8 I was slapped by a teacher in full view of the whole classroom. But nothing was ever said about it. It was the "norm" then apparently

GrandTheftWalrus · 03/09/2021 01:53

My mum used to batter me with either a stick or her hard soled slipper when I was a child.

My dad used to punch me etc. I remember lying infront of the washing machine while my dad kicked me.

I was terrified as a child if I was bad.

Now however they are the most loving grandparents ever and when I got to about 10/11 they never hit me again. And if I ever thought they would raise their hands to my children they would never see them again

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 01:45

My mum use to smack us occasionally, doesn’t bother me at all!

Nat6999 · 03/09/2021 01:39

I can only ever remember getting slapped twice in my whole childhood. My best friend's mum used to slap both her kids for the slightest thing & it wasn't just a single slap, I can remember the youngest getting slapped really hard & she could only have been maybe 2 or 3, then left to cry & fall asleep where she was. A boy who was in the same form as me was battered by a teacher at school for being cheeky, he was dragged in to the corridor & the teacher punched him in the stomach & then repeatedly punched in the head & face, nothing was done about it, now the teacher would have at least lost his job & probably have been charged with GBH.. while I don't agree with parents smacking children I do think that since corporal punishment was banned in school behaviour has got worse, now the worst thing pupils get is isolation or detention, corporal punishment was a deterrent to bad behaviour.

IceLace100 · 03/09/2021 00:26

My parent smacked my hand very gently. I do remember it well actually as being upsetting.

I don't think that it traumatised me but I do t think I'd do it now. It was a different time.

ozymandiusking · 03/09/2021 00:21

I remember being hit by a teacher when I was about 9. She used a wooden ruler on the inside of my arm above my wrist about 5 times.
I've never forgotten it, and bloody hurt.
Mrs Stansfield, she's dead now.

Recessed · 03/09/2021 00:21

It's the living in fear, the heightened anxiety knowing what's coming. The constant threat is what I most remember. That can't be good for a child. I would hate for my DC to live like that, a horrible, damaging environment to grow up in.

It all came flooding back once I had my DC so YANBU, you look at them so tiny and vulnerable and you think how could your parents have done it? My dad in my case. It wasn't often as far as I remember but it definitely had a long term impact. I went NC with him when I was expecting my second child, he's never met her. No regrets. It's quite empowering cutting abusive people out of your life, frees up that headspace.

Feelingmardy · 03/09/2021 00:13

All smacks left marks BTW, so none of them were 'little slaps'. They were meant to inflict significant pain. I have never, ever hit my kids and they are very well behaved. Unlike me when I was a child, they also respect and (I hope) feel safe with me. I never asked for help with problems as a teenager as my parents had shown themselves to be dangerous people.

Feelingmardy · 03/09/2021 00:11

My parents were quite violent. Frequent slaps around the face, occasional spankings with hands or shoes, always on the bare bottom. Lots of threats of humiliation too (I'll do that in front of your friends) and lots of anger at normal reactions to being assaulted (stop crying or I'll give you something to cry about). My parents do not see this as abusive. I do not have a close relationship with my father. I do see these things as connected and I do think I was abused.

WTF0ver · 02/09/2021 23:39

Funny I was just thinking about smacking recently.

I had a loving family growing up but I did get smacked. Dad and mum did it, but mum seemed to have more anger in hers. Her own dad smacked her, her mum didn't, she never got angry and was the peacekeeper so it seems to have filtered down from her dad. Mostly it was smacking on the bum or legs but on one awful occasion she chased me and caught me on the stairs and grabbed and whacked my head off the stairs :( Funny enough she doesn't remember that now.

I did flinch a bit later on for a while when she was reaching behind me etc, like I was expecting to be hit. And as another poster said I'm also a people pleaser.

My parents' friends used the slipper on their kids, even when we were over visiting! I used to get stressed out listening to it, the threat issued and then them being taken into another room and slippered.

Kanaloa · 02/09/2021 23:24

It doesn’t necessarily make them a shit parent or an awful person, but striking a child in any form (light ‘tap’ or hard smack) is bad parenting. It’s lazy and aggressive, and it is never ever necessary. It is also not good teaching from parent to child.

AmyDudley · 02/09/2021 23:21

I wasn't smacked as a child, (although it was the 60's so quite common - all my friends were smacked) but there was corporal punishment at school.
I remember one male teacher we had - he was retired but used to come in a couple of mornings a week to teach the top class (10/11 year olds).
One boy in the class was going through a very turbulent time at home, and some times he used to be uncooperative in class - mainly just lying his head on his desk and refusing to engage.
I remember once when this happened with the retired teacher he grabbed the boy dragged him to his feet and proceeded to slap him repeatedly round the head, punch him all over his body, and he was pushing him all round the class room hitting him, he just totally lost it, In the end the boy was cowering in a corner sobbing.

I can still remember now how terribly upsetting I found it, I was almost sick having to witness that level of violence,. i can clearly remember everything about that incident - the boys name, the teachers name, the layout of the classroom where I was sitting, the horrified faces of the other children and my own fear and distress. God knows how that poor child felt.
I wish now that I or one of us other children had run to another classroom and got another teacher - but we were all too afraid, and we were growing up in an era when adults could hit children. And assault them in ways that would put them in prison now.

I have never hit my children and never ever had even the slightest inclination to hit them, however they might be acting up. It is sick and disturbing. I'm very sorry for all of you who have been through this.

Hillary17 · 02/09/2021 22:58

Yes, being smacked or even threatened with violence has ruined my life in someways. I’m terrified of my husband one day hitting me - although no reason he would or any real logical fears of it happening. I panic at the first sign of confrontation. Have flashbacks. If anybody ever laid a hand on my child I’d immediately report them to the police. It is abuse regardless of what people want to tell themselves.

PattyPan · 02/09/2021 22:31

I was smacked a few times but looking back I’m not traumatised at all, in fact I agree that I was being a little shit on those occasions and deserved it!

comedycentral · 02/09/2021 22:15

Yes we had the belt, the threat of the belt was just as bad too. I wouldn't raise a finger to my child, I can't understand people that smack their children.

2kl4skl · 02/09/2021 22:15

@worriedatthemoment

I think accusing all parents who smacked with a light tap etc of being shit parents is a step too far , this was how they were taught and led to believe what worked Im now reading how some are saying the naughty step or corner is abusive and many will of used that as its what we believe works and is correct looking at all the behaviour programmes , so we could be accused of shitty parenting I think its more about the whole package of how your parent parented rather than the odd smack you may of received. We had the odd smack and I mean odd but in general my parents were loving , fair and treated us well so that odd smack means nothing to me , but for others who never had that it could be different

Totally. Both my parents, long time divorced, smacked me as a child but I'm very different ways

•My dad did it sparingly. Maybe once a year. One smack to get the seriousness of the offence across. A hug afterwards. He was a and attentive parent and he never abused his power

•with my mum it would be a beating, with me in the cowering corner crying for someone else to help. Shouting and locked out of the living room where the family was, and crying to the point I can't even speak^^ and then getting smacked again for crying and not speaking properly. She was a shit and abusive parent on every front.

Definitely need to take into account all aspects of parenting before judging. Not all smacks are the same.

Loopylobes · 02/09/2021 22:12

Yes I'm traumatised from regular smacking 50 years ago. There were never any bruises and no objects were ever used.

I was smacked quite often by both parents. Sometimes it was because my sister lied about me and sometimes it was because my mother lied to my father about me.

He would spank me through my clothes so I would sometimes put on extra pants and tights when I knew it was coming to try to reduce the impact.

My mother stopped slapping me round the face when I was 16 and I hit her back.

My father stopped hitting me when I was 18 and threatened to call the police.

I mentioned it about five years ago and was told that none of it had ever happened and that my father was dreadfully upset that I would suggest he had ever hit me.

I'm now NC with my sister, which is a great relief. My father is dead and I was surprised how little I grieved him and, although I support my widowed mother, I'm not emotionally close to her and I don't feel guilty when I don't see much of her.

Physical violence against children is shit, whether you call it a tap, a hit or a smack. There's no need for it, it doesn't work and it just causes trauma. If you hit a child hard enough to shock them, you have hurt them and you are in the wrong.

worriedatthemoment · 02/09/2021 22:04

I think accusing all parents who smacked with a light tap etc of being shit parents is a step too far , this was how they were taught and led to believe what worked
Im now reading how some are saying the naughty step or corner is abusive and many will of used that as its what we believe works and is correct looking at all the behaviour programmes , so we could be accused of shitty parenting
I think its more about the whole package of how your parent parented rather than the odd smack you may of received.
We had the odd smack and I mean odd but in general my parents were loving , fair and treated us well so that odd smack means nothing to me , but for others who never had that it could be different

HappyMeal564 · 02/09/2021 21:57

You can report them anonymously to social services, please do, that poor child

baroqueandblue · 02/09/2021 21:55

When they say they did it out of love, that's psychological and emotional abuse which leads to deep confusion about ourselves and relationships. When they deny it even happened (or the severity of it) years later, that's also abusive, as it invalidates the integrity of the formerly beaten self.

Monstrous. And realising one had monsters for parents is heartbreaking.