Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
Imasoulman · 03/09/2021 12:38

YANBU
This type of thing definitely has an impact on some people.

We lived in fear of my dad being in a bad mood because we knew if he smacked us he would lose control.

I hardly give it any thought now but my sister is still traumatised by it, she even has counselling.
Same experience totally different outcome.

LizzieW1969 · 03/09/2021 12:28

@CurryLover55

I was smacked in primary school, in the mid 1970s. Only with a hand, not a ruler or any other implement. One teacher smacked children a lot. Late 70s and early 80s, it was just the fact that there was a cane in the headteacher’s office, I think,

Then corporal punishment was banned. I remember hearing that it was, I don’t remember exactly when.

Plumtree391 · 03/09/2021 12:27

I look back and remember being smacked/hit. Not often. I think it is achieves nothing and didn't do it myself, nor did I shout except once which still makes me feel a bit ashamed.

Disneycharacter · 03/09/2021 12:23

I think traumatised is a bit extreme. I remember to 2 occasions I was smacked with discomfort, but not trauma. I think if it's a regular thing in a child's life or done with violence and screaming it would be more upsetting

CurryLover55 · 03/09/2021 12:23

I’m shocked at the amount of posts mentioning physical punishment in schools. When was corporal punishment outlawed? I was never hit by any of my teachers.

LizzieW1969 · 03/09/2021 12:21

@Marshmallow91

I get what you’re saying. But those posters who have defended their parents have one thing in common. They love their parents and believe that they parented in the way that they thought best, and the way that they themselves were brought up.

Basically, if you love your parents, it’s an instinctive thing to ways to explain their actions to yourself. This is why they say that they ‘deserved’ to be smacked, I think.

That’s where I’m at. I know that my DM made mistakes when bringing us up. She smacked us herself more than she has been willing to admit, and she wasn’t approachable to her children. Which is why she never saw what else was going on under her nose. (I accept her word that she didn’t know about it, though at times that’s been quite hard.)

Ultimately, it’s easier to put all the blame on the parent who is dead and was at the end of the day the one who really was guilty of abusing us.

PumpkinKlNG · 03/09/2021 12:21

I definitely deserved it!

OneTC · 03/09/2021 12:06

I grew up somewhere that getting the ruler/cane/slipper as punishment was normal and my parents would hit me quite often as well. Never really given it much thought if I'm honest

TertiusLydgate · 03/09/2021 12:00

I was never hit, but my sister was and has definitely been affected by it.

My husband’s dad hit him on rare occasions and my husband still refers to it with a mix of sadness and incredulity.

I definitely think it’s abusive, no matter what anyone says. Either way, it’s crappy parenting.

Marshmallow91 · 03/09/2021 11:56

The amount of people saying "but I deserved it" in this thread is horrible to read.

Noone deserves to be assaulted by anyone, especially not as a defenceless child.

If anyone even threatened to hit my child, I have no idea what I would do because even seeing strangers shouting at their children makes me see red.

I was hit a lot, and I distinctly remember hiding from my mum behind the sofa because I hadn't tidied my room. She hit me, dragged me upstairs by my hair and threw a wooden jewellery box at my head. Luckily I moved in time, or I'd probably have received quite an injury.

I didn't deserve that. I can understand why my mum was upset, but I'd never condone her behaviour.

bluecampbell · 03/09/2021 10:51

YANBU. My parents both smacked when I was a child. My mother smacked both my brothers and me but my father only used to slap me, and used to boast about "never having to hit the boys" except for one sole occasion. Like it was something to be proud of.
For me, he would slap round the face and I still remember the initial pain and shock, the ringing in my ear and the hot feeling on my cheek. Then that hateful "let's make friends" moment afterwards. The last time he did it I was nineteen. It's definitely affected me. I told my middle brother about it and he confronted Dad who denied it.

YouMeandtheSpew · 03/09/2021 10:39

YANBU. I’m definitely traumatised by being ‘smacked’ (well, hit) by my father when I was a kid.

He never removed any of my clothes though and frankly I think anyone who does that is a pervert as well as violent.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 03/09/2021 10:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 03/09/2021 10:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Planty13 · 03/09/2021 10:05

I don’t think anyone can tell you that you are being unreasonable to feel how you feel.

I was smacked as a child and really don’t care, I was a right sod at times and I have no bad feelings about it but everyone is different

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 09:51

@Powerof4

My dad told me recently that when I was on the nappy table and rolling away from him, he decided he needed to show me who was boss by slapping me. I don’t remember that incident of course, but it gave me chills now I have my own. I’m amazed he still feels no remorse.
As sinister as that is, it's the exact logic of smacking. If you can reason with a child or implement a natural consequence to explain why they shouldn't do what they've done, then hitting them to make the point isn't necessary. If you can't communicate why it shouldn't be done, smacking is pointless; they either understand it or they don't, but hitting them doesn't explain the situation. The most they can learn is "because otherwise I'll hit you" and often not even that. And it's almost always just to alleviate the parents' frustration and to "show who's boss" anyway.

A great many times it's the parent's fault anyway. Running into the road comes up a lot in this discussion (hitters are shit at road safety). If a child is too young not to know better than to run into the road, or to roll off a changing table, then it's on the parents to keep control, not hit the child if they fail to do so.

So it makes just as much sense to hit a baby on the changing table for rolling away, which your father should have been preventing anyway.

lunar1 · 03/09/2021 09:49

I was hit as a child, it's definitely had a long-standing effect. I don't like to be touched at all unless it's my husband or children. Covid stopping people hugging as a greeting was a blessing.

I flinch if someone touches me when I haven't braced myself for it. When my children were toddlers I had intrusive thoughts about hitting them-I had therapy to get through it. I have never so much as tapped them on the hand, but I was terrified of hurting them.

Liverbird77 · 03/09/2021 09:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Powerof4 · 03/09/2021 09:42

My dad told me recently that when I was on the nappy table and rolling away from him, he decided he needed to show me who was boss by slapping me. I don’t remember that incident of course, but it gave me chills now I have my own. I’m amazed he still feels no remorse.

babybythesea · 03/09/2021 09:34

No. But smacking was extremely rare in our house.
I can remember being smacked twice and both times I knew I was pushing every button I could - being deliberately as naughty as I dared. The smacks didn’t come out of nowhere and both times I remember being more shocked that they’d done it, than hurt. And also slightly shocked by how rude I’d been to push them to that level. I was under 10 both times. I also know that after that “Do you want a smack?” was enough to stop me in my tracks and let me know I was stepping over the line!

TracyLords · 03/09/2021 09:31

@Feelingmardy I found the fact that someone pulled your pants down the worst of it all. I don’t remember it being that sore, it was more the humiliation and lack of bodily control. And I was terrified in case it happened in front of anyone

3scape · 03/09/2021 09:26

I remember my mum going over to a wooden spoon as one time she smacked my brother her ring caught on something so.her hand got bruised. She didn't have the intelligence to wonder what it was doing to us. We were supposed to have been glad she'd never used it before I think. I also remember every moment of being hit with my dad's belt once. Now I had done something fairly bad then. But I acted like a shit because I'd long since stopped having any respect or care for my parents at all. That's what smacking does. It just builds a wall of distrust and hate.

3scape · 03/09/2021 09:20

I remember being beaten. Being scared to drop things so I was nervous doing jobs around the house. It was the uncertainty obviously there's be smacks for doing something like not finishing a meal (A big deal in the 70s) but as I grew up it was harder to.predict, like clothes I guess had become too tight or too short so were slutty to my parents eyes but I didn't know what that really was at first, constantly new hoops of behaviour. Like a lot of people I was smacked if I wet the bed but also for get to.g out of bed to use the toilet! People who need to smack people are very damaged themselves so of course there's no reason and it leaves you in a state of confusion and fear.

DrSbaitso · 03/09/2021 09:17

It is shit parenting, no question.

Maybe, maybe, the rest of your parenting is good enough that it mitigates the damage and potential damage (although there'll be no way to offset your message that pain and humiliation by the power holder are valid forms of communication, and that you don't need to learn to control or better yourself), but it's still an independently bad parenting technique that has been thoroughly discredited, and you will make yourself a better parent if you stop doing it.

Yes, screaming and swearing at your kids is also terrible and damaging. But nobody denies that, or says it's ok because they do it the right way.

Just stop hitting your kids. If you expect them to grow up resolving things by other methods, lead by example like the parent you are supposed to be.

caravanman · 03/09/2021 09:10

I grew up in the sixties and seventies. I was smacked at home, smacked at school and even smacked in (psychiatric) hospital by nurses. Most of the smacks are hardly remembered. Yet I remember the ones that resulted in too much force or violence being used, for example a male teacher smacking me so hard (in front of the class) for being involved in a fight, that I crashed into a fireguard (I was 10). I think he used more force with me because I was the only girl involved in the fight. I also remember those which breached boundaries of trust and care, e.g, a nurse slapping me across the face because I had left my room without permission in hospital.