Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatised by being smacked

389 replies

Babyparrotdog · 02/09/2021 17:58

Sounds dramatic to some maybe but am I the only one who feels they are genuinely traumatised from being ‘smacked’ as a child? I feel so much worse about it since having my own child.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HoppingPavlova · 18/09/2021 16:35

Do you punish your children the same way as your parents punished you?

If you read the thread I’ve already answered that.

Bakingtraypan · 15/09/2021 10:36

@HoppingPavlova

Ironically it's being hit as a child and yelled at unexpectedly by an abusive father that's made me far less resilient than I would like because it taught me that adults are fundamentally unpredictable and you have to walk on eggshells all the time so you don't get hurt or humiliated (I will never know if some of the humiliation aspects of what my father did to me were a sexual thing for him and I suspect I never will). This is taking me years to work through in therapy.

This is a problem and abusive. If there were clear rules and you broke them you expected to be punished. Being yelled at outside of those parameters is abusive. Being hit unexpectedly also lies outside of those parameters and is abusive.

I was never yelled at unexpectedly or hit unexpectedly. If we did something wrong then maybe we did tread on eggshells briefly waiting to find out if we had been caught. If we were we accepted the punishment - definitely not unexpected! If we were not caught we breathed a sigh of relief at getting away with it. There was also a level of predictability at home and school. When you planned your escapade you knew that if you were caught it would be worth roughly 5 hits of the belt or cane, or 3 good ones with the spoon for example. It was never a case of it was normally 5 but someone had a bad day and took that out on you and turned it into 10. That’s what many people do describe on this thread and I agree that’s abusive and like apples compared to oranges, as is telling/hitting kids for no reason and out of the blue.

Do you punish your children the same way as your parents punished you?
HoppingPavlova · 15/09/2021 09:56

Ironically it's being hit as a child and yelled at unexpectedly by an abusive father that's made me far less resilient than I would like because it taught me that adults are fundamentally unpredictable and you have to walk on eggshells all the time so you don't get hurt or humiliated (I will never know if some of the humiliation aspects of what my father did to me were a sexual thing for him and I suspect I never will). This is taking me years to work through in therapy.

This is a problem and abusive. If there were clear rules and you broke them you expected to be punished. Being yelled at outside of those parameters is abusive. Being hit unexpectedly also lies outside of those parameters and is abusive.

I was never yelled at unexpectedly or hit unexpectedly. If we did something wrong then maybe we did tread on eggshells briefly waiting to find out if we had been caught. If we were we accepted the punishment - definitely not unexpected! If we were not caught we breathed a sigh of relief at getting away with it. There was also a level of predictability at home and school. When you planned your escapade you knew that if you were caught it would be worth roughly 5 hits of the belt or cane, or 3 good ones with the spoon for example. It was never a case of it was normally 5 but someone had a bad day and took that out on you and turned it into 10. That’s what many people do describe on this thread and I agree that’s abusive and like apples compared to oranges, as is telling/hitting kids for no reason and out of the blue.

UnsolicitedDickPic · 09/09/2021 21:50

@Bakingtraypan You may be absolutely right, I concede that point. :)

Anon778833 · 09/09/2021 19:51

@DrSbaitso

I ask again: if the purpose of the beating was to build character and resilience rather than to correct and educate over behaviours, should I just bash my daughter up for no reason? That'll teach her how to cope with shit happening, right?

People just cannot accept that their parents were wrong sometimes.

My mum's mother was a dreadful parent who had 6 kids who were pretty much left to fend for themselves and were neglected and malnourished and emotionally abused. Yet she will say that she isn't damaged by her. How she wasn't too bad because she bought her a colouring book every now & then Confused

Whilst this wouldn't bother me ordinarily, I have the distinct feeling that she takes her shitty childhood and dumps it onto me. She should have got counselling. But no, she pretends that all is well whilst having a toxic attitude towards me.

I myself, have sought to examine my own actions as a parent and to try hard not to dump my issues onto my children.

And to accept my anger that my parents weren't great parents, not say how they were fine really then project that anger onto my children.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 09/09/2021 19:43

@DrSbaitso Ironically it's being hit as a child and yelled at unexpectedly by an abusive father that's made me far less resilient than I would like because it taught me that adults are fundamentally unpredictable and you have to walk on eggshells all the time so you don't get hurt or humiliated (I will never know if some of the humiliation aspects of what my father did to me were a sexual thing for him and I suspect I never will). This is taking me years to work through in therapy.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 13:27

I ask again: if the purpose of the beating was to build character and resilience rather than to correct and educate over behaviours, should I just bash my daughter up for no reason? That'll teach her how to cope with shit happening, right?

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 13:14

@HoppingPavlova

May I remind you that it was largely members of this terrible and weak new generation who attended to Covid patients during lockdown before there was a vaccine, and frequently with inadequate PPE?

I have a friend who postponed retirement due to the current environment. They are in ICU (I was in A&E) and while it is great people have stepped up they predict post crisis many will crash and not have the ability to get on with it and will leave. Hopefully they are wrong. Often the best case scenario is being wrong.

And it'll be entirely down to not being strapped and having spoons broken on them as children, will it? Nothing to do with the stress of a pandemic that is unheard of in living memory, the strains on the NHS and the way our wonderful government treats its staff?
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 13:09

@HoppingPavlova

And if you really believe the current working population are entitled soft wingers who get stressed at a little hard graft, I suggest you spend a shift or two in a busy A&E or ICU, especially one where there is a high incidence of Covid. You will find it full of people who have never been beaten who still manage to work bloody hard in incredibly stressful conditions for hours on end.

I spent more than a shift or two in one of those two areas. Try a couple of decades. I’m glad to hear people have stepped up without the whinging and claiming stress. Trust me, we spent years training people coming through who were progressively worse on arrival. Were not used to hard graft, got stressed at the drop of a hanky, zero resilience, limited coping skills. Most could be turned around but it was tiresome that we had to put the effort in as parents and schools had failed them. Not blaming parents as such though as ‘doing that makes me feel sad’ and ‘well, no PlayStation for 30mins for you’ does that. Schools are very limited also, little Johnny who has nothing wrong with him doesn’t want to run cross country, ‘that’s fine Johnny, can we get you to do your favourite activity instead’.

I think you've forgotten what it's like to be young. Nearly all young adults struggle in some way when they first enter the workplace. They learn and they adapt. Whatever they need, it's not a sodding childhood beating.

I'd love to hear what your superiors thought of your generation when you first started out. We know they thought you needed the crap beaten out of you long before you got there.

2389Champ · 09/09/2021 12:51

@HoppingPavlova

And if you really believe the current working population are entitled soft wingers who get stressed at a little hard graft, I suggest you spend a shift or two in a busy A&E or ICU, especially one where there is a high incidence of Covid. You will find it full of people who have never been beaten who still manage to work bloody hard in incredibly stressful conditions for hours on end.

I spent more than a shift or two in one of those two areas. Try a couple of decades. I’m glad to hear people have stepped up without the whinging and claiming stress. Trust me, we spent years training people coming through who were progressively worse on arrival. Were not used to hard graft, got stressed at the drop of a hanky, zero resilience, limited coping skills. Most could be turned around but it was tiresome that we had to put the effort in as parents and schools had failed them. Not blaming parents as such though as ‘doing that makes me feel sad’ and ‘well, no PlayStation for 30mins for you’ does that. Schools are very limited also, little Johnny who has nothing wrong with him doesn’t want to run cross country, ‘that’s fine Johnny, can we get you to do your favourite activity instead’.

It’s perfectly possible to bring children up to understand boundaries and gain resilience without resorting to physical violence to get the message home.

A firm no, followed by consequences of continued misbehaviour gets the message across far more than a slap. I agree you can’t reason with a screaming toddler, but by either removing them, or the trigger of the tantrum, from the scenario doesn’t take long for the child to connect cause and effect. Where we all fall down as parents is inconsistency, we all send mixed messages because we get tired, can’t be bothered etc etc.

The lack of fortitude nowadays, I think you are referring to, is more to do with parents and schools not teaching children to accept failure or that someone will sometimes be better than you rather than not experiencing physical punishment. I think we give our kids unrealistic expectations now and would do them a greater favour by giving them sensible expectations.

“You can be anything you want”
No, sorry, you can’t. You might not be tall enough, fast enough, clever enough, not in the right place at the right time, know the right people.
I can’t see how beating a child into submission makes them a better adult. Clearly, by the snapshot of replies on here it’s done almost irreparable damage to many and hasn’t made them into stronger, more resilient grown ups at all. I’m speaking from experience here too. My punishments destroyed my confidence for years and I made many poor life choices because I was too frightened and anxious to stand up to those I believed were more powerful than me.

HoppingPavlova · 09/09/2021 12:45

May I remind you that it was largely members of this terrible and weak new generation who attended to Covid patients during lockdown before there was a vaccine, and frequently with inadequate PPE?

I have a friend who postponed retirement due to the current environment. They are in ICU (I was in A&E) and while it is great people have stepped up they predict post crisis many will crash and not have the ability to get on with it and will leave. Hopefully they are wrong. Often the best case scenario is being wrong.

HoppingPavlova · 09/09/2021 12:08

And if you really believe the current working population are entitled soft wingers who get stressed at a little hard graft, I suggest you spend a shift or two in a busy A&E or ICU, especially one where there is a high incidence of Covid. You will find it full of people who have never been beaten who still manage to work bloody hard in incredibly stressful conditions for hours on end.

I spent more than a shift or two in one of those two areas. Try a couple of decades. I’m glad to hear people have stepped up without the whinging and claiming stress. Trust me, we spent years training people coming through who were progressively worse on arrival. Were not used to hard graft, got stressed at the drop of a hanky, zero resilience, limited coping skills. Most could be turned around but it was tiresome that we had to put the effort in as parents and schools had failed them. Not blaming parents as such though as ‘doing that makes me feel sad’ and ‘well, no PlayStation for 30mins for you’ does that. Schools are very limited also, little Johnny who has nothing wrong with him doesn’t want to run cross country, ‘that’s fine Johnny, can we get you to do your favourite activity instead’.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 12:06

And you were injured for a week.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 11:58

They didn’t look forward to it.

Your mother got so pissed off with you laughing at her broken spoon that she held on to it the rest of the day to get your father to strap you.

It was not done with gusto.

The spoon broke.

Anon778833 · 09/09/2021 11:43

Again, my parents took no joy from it. They didn’t look forward to it. It was not done with gusto. It was pretty much on par with all the other shitty jobs on the list people had to endure as part of day to day life. If it was not a belief that it was something they had to do for our own good they would have happily left it off and been glad of one less chore.

Abuse isn't more acceptable just because the person inflicting it didn't get sadistic pleasure from it.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 11:42

@HoppingPavlova

If not, why not? If it's so character building and opens up such wonderful employment opportunities?

No, I didn’t. Are my kids the same gen of lazy, entitled soft young adults who learn some very hard lessons pretty quickly in the real world - yep. Why didn’t I ? Because, as you fail to grasp, it’s a different environment. The one my parents grew up in and the one I grew up in had the firm belief that this was required in order to ultimately benefit your kids so they would grow into a decent adult rather than a shit one. It’s exactly the same as asking why my clinical practices were not the same 30 years years later than they were earlierHmm. Because it’s a different environment with different knowledge.

Again, my parents took no joy from it. They didn’t look forward to it. It was not done with gusto. It was pretty much on par with all the other shitty jobs on the list people had to endure as part of day to day life. If it was not a belief that it was something they had to do for our own good they would have happily left it off and been glad of one less chore.

You are so unbelievably damaged by your beatings from your caregivers that I don't know where to start.

Yes, we know it was a different environment. What you fail to grasp is what a shit environment it was, what the true reasons for it were, and that no, even then you do not beat your children with spoons and straps, injuring them for a week or scarring them for life, because you think it benefits THEM. Your mother did not break her spoon on you, nor your father strap you, out of altruism and self sacrifice. Let me guess, it hurt them more than it hurt you?

Have you given any thought to the implications of "being beaten makes people better"?

The environment used to be that it was right for men to rape their wives or deny credit cards and mortgages to unmarried women. Do you seriously think they were truly motivated by ethics and women's wellbeing? Or was that just a cultural fig leaf so people could pretend they weren't actually self-serving and sadistic? What would you think of someone who defends it now, saying it's not a big deal because it was "the environment" and laughs about it?

Medicine moves with the times and better research, and the observation of obviously shit outcomes. It doesn't blame the new patients for being less resilient now that they get better care. May I remind you that it was largely members of this terrible and weak new generation who attended to Covid patients during lockdown before there was a vaccine, and frequently with inadequate PPE?

I could say a lot about how this all fits in with your apparent disapproval of your own kids as well as everyone else who was lucky enough not to be raised the. I'll stick to saying: if being beaten as a child didn't equip you to raise them well in spite of "the environment", perhaps it didn't build as much resilience and character as you think it did.

HoppingPavlova · 09/09/2021 11:11

If not, why not? If it's so character building and opens up such wonderful employment opportunities?

No, I didn’t. Are my kids the same gen of lazy, entitled soft young adults who learn some very hard lessons pretty quickly in the real world - yep. Why didn’t I ? Because, as you fail to grasp, it’s a different environment. The one my parents grew up in and the one I grew up in had the firm belief that this was required in order to ultimately benefit your kids so they would grow into a decent adult rather than a shit one. It’s exactly the same as asking why my clinical practices were not the same 30 years years later than they were earlierHmm. Because it’s a different environment with different knowledge.

Again, my parents took no joy from it. They didn’t look forward to it. It was not done with gusto. It was pretty much on par with all the other shitty jobs on the list people had to endure as part of day to day life. If it was not a belief that it was something they had to do for our own good they would have happily left it off and been glad of one less chore.

Bakingtraypan · 09/09/2021 09:23

@UnsolicitedDickPic

"We had the ability to grin, bear it and just get on with things. Very different these days, generally entitled soft whingers who get stressed at the sniff of hard graft."

I appreciate this comment was mostly about the times in which you lived but honestly, on a thread where a multitude of people are telling you that yes, they lived through these times too and were traumatised by them, it's a bit of a shitty take.

The "shitty take", the undeniable lack of empathy evidenced from those comments, including the comments about laughing at the abuse, might be the result of the trauma the poster experienced at the hands of their parents - we all have coping mechanisms. People are not always aware of the impact and there is no way of knowing what the poster would have been like had their parents not inflicted physical punishment in their formative years.
UnsolicitedDickPic · 08/09/2021 19:32

"We had the ability to grin, bear it and just get on with things. Very different these days, generally entitled soft whingers who get stressed at the sniff of hard graft."

I appreciate this comment was mostly about the times in which you lived but honestly, on a thread where a multitude of people are telling you that yes, they lived through these times too and were traumatised by them, it's a bit of a shitty take.

HarrietsChariot · 08/09/2021 13:45

In my case it's not so much the smacking that has caused me long term trauma and lifelong depression as the unjust punishments I received.

The time I threw a bucket of water over my brother and got smacked and sent straight bed, fine, I can accept that one.

But there were lots of times my brother abused me. Sometimes I physically resisted but eventually I stopped bothering because restisting always led to a fight which led to us both being smacked. It seemed so unfair even as a young child that there was no other choice - put up with the abuse from him or end up getting smacked by my parents.

It's certainly led me to "put up" with bad behaviour and negativity throughout my life. I don't challenge things because will just end up getting into trouble anyway.

Jemand · 08/09/2021 13:13

@HoppingPavlova

I will also say that the age we grew up in did benefit us, if I grew up in this day and age I would never have been able to do my job. We had the ability to grin, bear it and just get on with things. Very different these days, generally entitled soft whingers who get stressed at the sniff of hard graft. Most who stick it out end up alright as real life kicks the shit out of them but they are done no favours by being thrust into adult life ill-prepared with no mettle and suddenly having to try and gain what the rest of us gained naturally over our childhood.
You really believe you wouldn't have been able to do your job had you not been frequently beaten as a child? Do you really think so little of yourself?

And if you really believe the current working population are entitled soft wingers who get stressed at a little hard graft, I suggest you spend a shift or two in a busy A&E or ICU, especially one where there is a high incidence of Covid. You will find it full of people who have never been beaten who still manage to work bloody hard in incredibly stressful conditions for hours on end. And those are just two examples amongst thousands.

I do have to wonder whether what you suffered in your childhood has affected your attitude to other people, otherwise I really don't think you would come out with these wild generalisations that simply have no foundation in fact.

Jemand · 08/09/2021 13:04

See, there’s the thing though. Our parents never hit us because they were angry. They never hit us when angry. It more so seemed a chore to hit us, something they believed they had to do as a means of behaviour modification for our own good to make us better people. I truly believe their generation was brought up to believe that if you didn’t do this then children would turn into adult delinquents. No loving parent wanted that for their kids!

That makes it worse, @HoppingPavlova, because they did it in cold blood. Given that you say you and your siblings still misbehaved, clearly it didn't work as a behaviour modification tool.

Jemand · 08/09/2021 13:00

I can still remember being slapped and deeply resenting it because it was obvious to me from a very young age that it was invariably a matter of my mother taking out her bad temper on me as opposed to my actually deserving anything.

I can also remember vividly another incident when I was around 6. I had done something which I had no idea was wrong, but I received a full-on spanking from my father for it. I certainly was traumatised - from my point of view I had innocently shown them what I had done thinking it was just a bit of fun, and had suddenly out of the blue been painfully attacked for it.

It certainly affected my relationship with both my parents because I just couldn't respect people who thought that was OK. If they had ever said at a later stage that they regretted it, it could have made all the difference, but they didn't. I've never smacked my children and have a much better relationship with them than my parents had with me.

DrSbaitso · 07/09/2021 19:34

Just reread HoppingPavlova's posts and I forgot that she also said some of her siblings "still have physical scars".

But no harm done...

Kanaloa · 07/09/2021 18:37

Although it is common for those who are abused in childhood to end up in abusive relationships in adulthood, so I suppose in that respect childhood abuse would prepare you for some aspects of your adulthood.