Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that soup is a meal?

196 replies

AlrightThereSkippy · 02/09/2021 16:52

Light-hearted disagreement between DH and me!

He says soup is not a meal; it's a starter. I think it can be either and definitely a meal when you include a sandwich.

OP posts:
SkinnyMirror · 03/09/2021 11:40

@NotMyCat

It's a meal. I had tomato soup with a bit of cheese last night and garlic naan
Soup with garlic naan is THE best!
HeronLanyon · 03/09/2021 09:49

A ton of tomato soup with cheese on with nothing else has very unusually been my dinner twice in the last week. Mix of really wanting it (eat it maybe once a year and had a craving) plus heavy heavy workload just made it a sensible and v good option. Filled me as think my lunches had been more varied/substantial.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 03/09/2021 09:43

@BarbaraofSeville

On what basis is it failing the 'meal' test bearing in mind that there's no universally set definition and many are nutritionally indistiguishable from stew?
yeah! I think the issue is that everyone thinks of different soup. Like for example a can of tomato soup (i actually don't even like tomato soup🙈) would absolutely not be a main meal for me even with a slice of bread. But! A big bowl of broth, noodles, meat, veg, egg absolutely is. And no bread in sight. Some of my soups are basically like a stirfry, rather than a stew, with liquid on top of it. So a meal
BarbaraofSeville · 03/09/2021 09:22

On what basis is it failing the 'meal' test bearing in mind that there's no universally set definition and many are nutritionally indistiguishable from stew?

NotMyCat · 03/09/2021 09:17

It's a meal. I had tomato soup with a bit of cheese last night and garlic naan

knittingaddict · 03/09/2021 09:04

It's a meal, but not a main meal. Even as a light meal it needs bread too.

drwitch · 03/09/2021 09:00

I made tomato and lentil soup for the four of us last night. It had 4 tins of tomato's, big handful of lentils, half a head of celery, 3 enormous carrots, 6 cloves of garlic, glug of red wine, pint of stock (from chicken natc). We had it with cheese and garlic bread and bacon bits to scatter over the top. If you made a stew out if this lot it would be clearly a meal why should the addition of more liquid make it less so? We are all really greedy and we're stuffed (only one bowl left).

Annoyedanddissapointed · 03/09/2021 08:51

Its filling in the sense that it's a high volume, so you feel full after a big bowl. But it can be high water content and depending on the ingredients may continue little fat or protein and have a low calorie content, so for many people they will feel hungry again only a couple of hours later as it's not enough calories for their body. It's not rocket science, soup is mainly water, root veg and leek have high water content.

Most of this, except the water bit, can apply easily to many normal meals.
Equally though soup can absolutely be loaded wwith protein and have good amount of fat and carbs to take person through a day. Mine are. My soups are between 450-550 calories. 'Cause I know how to soup😂 (is my theory)

spotcheck · 03/09/2021 07:27

It IS a meal.

But only if there is a ton of veg/ potatoes/ possibly chicken or meatballs. Bread on the side.
Just use a bigger bowl than you'd have for lunch 😀

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 03/09/2021 07:15

Mumsnet eating is so weird. I can quite easily eat an 18 inch pizza that this site says should feed a family of 6, but I would still be reasonably full after a decent bowl of soup. We had soup for dinner tons when I was growing up, lentil soup, leek and potato soup especially. Soup is filling?

Its filling in the sense that it's a high volume, so you feel full after a big bowl. But it can be high water content and depending on the ingredients may continue little fat or protein and have a low calorie content, so for many people they will feel hungry again only a couple of hours later as it's not enough calories for their body. It's not rocket science, soup is mainly water, root veg and leek have high water content.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 03/09/2021 07:12

It really depends on the calorie content of the meal as a whole. 400 calories - meal. 200 or under, not really a proper meal. 2-400 = light meal.

bunny85 · 02/09/2021 20:20

Oh yes it can be a meal, including dinner, and very often it is in my house! If it's a chunky soup made with pieces of chicken/meat, potatoes, veggies etc, something between a soup and a stew, with a nice buttered toast or two, of course it's a meal and a very filling one. Actually even nice thick lentil or bean soup is just the same.

SkinnyMirror · 02/09/2021 20:09

@User135644

This was a big debate in the 90s.

Yes!! I totally clicked on the thread hoping for a Seinfeld inspired discussion!!
PartyPotato · 02/09/2021 20:07

Soup absolutely can be a dinner! I make a lovely thick butternut squash soup, a big portion with a baguette is certainly filling enough for dinner (and I eat like a horse).

LemonFantaGin · 02/09/2021 20:06

Im about to have a soup for my dinner.

TheHoundsofLove · 02/09/2021 20:05

@cultkid

I used to cry when I had soup for dinner 🤣🤣
I think homemade soup with sandwiches/cheese scones/cheese on toast is a perfectly acceptable main meal. Lovely even. But, I've stopped ever serving it as my husband land son look totally depressed when I say it's what we've got for dinner.
RiversideAnne · 02/09/2021 19:42

With a sandwich, yes. Otherwise probably not. Ah really heart soup could be a lunch, but not dinner imo.

Pedalpushers · 02/09/2021 19:39

Mumsnet eating is so weird. I can quite easily eat an 18 inch pizza that this site says should feed a family of 6, but I would still be reasonably full after a decent bowl of soup. We had soup for dinner tons when I was growing up, lentil soup, leek and potato soup especially. Soup is filling?

YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 02/09/2021 19:21

Genuinely, with no snide, I am full after a normal bowl full of lentil soup with grated Parmesan on top.

No rage / hunger / competitive under eating here.

crivit · 02/09/2021 19:12

@LoveFall

We make soups for dinner quite often, especially in winter.

I had my sister and nephew here to visit and I made a roasted butternut squash and cauliflower soup with lentils in it. Served with fresh bread and a salad. It was delicious and filling. Great option for my vegetarian nephew. It was actually vegan.

That soup sounds bloody lovely. Do you have a recipe?

Also, soup is definitely a meal and absolutely a dinner. A good, hearty soup in autumn / winter is for me one of the best dinners. Fortunately there isn't a disagreement about this in my household Grin

Coffeemakesmehappy · 02/09/2021 18:58

As an evening meal (especially if I know I’m going to be working late) I often opt for soup with root veg mash (batch cooked, always have lots of portions in the freezer) - my sister thinks it’s vile, but it’s quick, filling and I love it!

NoWordForFluffy · 02/09/2021 18:58

@Bimblybomeyelash

A soup and a sandwich is a different offering than just a soup! But whatever the bonus additions, I would never really fancy soup for dinner.
Yes. This is how I feel about soup too.
Snowpatrolling · 02/09/2021 18:53

My daughter often has chunky chicken soup for her tea! It’s enough for her!!

chaosrabbitland · 02/09/2021 18:52

a bowl of soup is a meal to me , i feel full after just eating a bowl of it , just the 1 can and i dont have bread and stuff with it , mind you i havent got the greatest appetite , frequently go all day no eating and it not bothering me much , so i think im not quite the same as everyone else where they would not count it as a meal or it would have to have something extra with it , , dinner for me sometimes is toast , its all i can face sometimes

BarbaraofSeville · 02/09/2021 18:40

[quote 3kidsinacar]@barbaraofseville gets combative again

What do you agree with barbs 🤔[/quote]
Logic and rational thought Smile. Sadly lacking from a few on this thread.

I remember my DP saying to me that I couldn’t have a baked potato for dinner or soup for lunch and then just cheese on toast or whatever for tea because his thinking that you should have a proper cooked meal

Those things are cooked, you'd hope. Is he concerned about the lack of vegetables? The soup could have loads of veg in, you could have some with breakfast, eg mushrooms and tomatoes on toast, or have fruit or veg as a snack. No danger of not getting his five a day.