Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meeting for breakfast - Which of us is being unreasonable.

989 replies

Dandy008 · 02/09/2021 13:17

Im meeting a friend in a few weeks time who lives in a different part of the country to me.

We’ve arranged to have a day out.
It will be her and her husband, myself, my husband and our 18month old son.

As they live some distance, we have decided to book a hotel and stay over night.

My friend has asked me to book a hotel right by her house so that it’s less distance for her to travel to meet us the next day for breakfast.

I’ve agreed to this, even though we could get a cheaper hotel a bit further away.

We were chatting and she said she would come and meet us for breakfast at 10.30am

I explained that DS wakes around 6.30 and is ready for his breakfast at 7am.
I could probably distract him and at a big push take him down for breakfast at 8am

I also explained that it’s a 2 hour drive back home so Ideally we wanted to head home after an early breakfast.
There’s not much for DS to do in the hotel so once we’ve eaten it makes sense to leave.

She told me that 8am is too early for her and her husband (they don’t have kids) and that the best she can do is 10am.

I’ve suggested then that we skip breakfast and I will book a cheaper hotel a bit further away.

She’s since sent me a text telling me I’m being difficult and that my DS will be fine waiting for his breakfast until 10.30am for just one day.

I’m tempted to message back and say her and her husband will be fine having breakfast at 8am for just one day… 🙄

OP posts:
longhours · 03/09/2021 12:13

Again, why post if you don't want to be told what the friend's perspective is? If you want to hear that your friend is awful and you're totally right, just vent to your partner??!

You're not the thread police!

I read the thread as OP posted since her friend called her difficult for saying 'sorry no, can't do a late breakfast the next day as well. Can do an early one only'

OP was trying to compromise- including on the hotel (for a lazy friend who didn't want to drive half hour!) but couldn't meet childfree friends expectations and was shocked at her friends rudeness back. That isn't an unreasonable 'AIBU?'

It's all in the original post

Clymene · 03/09/2021 12:12

You don't seem to understand how hotel breakfasts work @Rozziie. And if you have such disdain for people prioritising their children's needs, perhaps you should find a different forum? The clue is in the name after all.

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 12:10

@Heliachi exactly! How do people not read what they've written and see how utterly self centred it is? Talking about other people being selfish and having no empathy when they expect everyone else to work around their children at all times, as if other people have no responsibilities or restrictions of their own.

It's baffling.

vivainsomnia · 03/09/2021 12:07

So this had nothing to do with seeing your friend. it was always about taking your DS to a fun family event. It happened that you friend likes it and again, it wasn't so much about seeing your friend and spend some quality time with them but about them getting to know your child.

They were fine with that (good friends) but then assume you could have a more adult like get together too and breakfast was a good compromise when your child could be distracted allowing for some catch-up, except that again, you made it about your DS. You don't seem interested at all in having a proper catch-up with her at all, instead, you want to enjoy your family time and to show your pride and joy to them.

I think mixing the two is where it's all gone wrong. If you are not prepared to make that going away a bit of both, then you shouldn't have mentioned going there and then joining you. You could have just said that you'd prefer to arrange a get together just as adults and leave your child behind.

longhours · 03/09/2021 12:06

inappropriateraspberry explains it well, to those going off on a tangent.

MrsMiddleMother · 03/09/2021 11:58

The response on this post is ridiculous! You are not being precious at all, your friend is an asshole. I'd say I've changed my mind, we're not meeting for breakfast. Even prekids 10am for breakfast is ridiculously late. Do whats best for you and your family.

longhours · 03/09/2021 11:54

And then the childed wonder why their childfree friends fade away.

Spending a whole day with someone and saying you can't do a third extra meet up the next day (that only the friend wants to do), but isn't possible because of timing, is not 'fading away'

Anyone self-centred enough to immediately call her friend with young toddler "difficult" when she explained why she couldn't, is not the kindest friend out there. Plenty of childfree friends don't get 'mean' when they don't get their own way. Laying in bed late by all means but that doesn't mean a toddlers world and busy parents lives can then be put on hold for 3 to 4 hours. It's incompatible with what OP said she has to do the next day.

I have many childfree friends who understand my DCs have their own lives, likes, dislikes, and little personalities . The same way I understand their lives have certain flow and responsibilities, (usually around animals, disabled parents or long hours at work) . We fit in with each other where we can and make short meet ups where that's all we can do.

The problem here is that OPs friend wants it all, to have OP at her beck and call all weekend, when "it all" is too much, not easy and timing wise is not possible for Sunday morning . And she is throwing her toys out with the pram when OP said no.

I wonder how the rest of OPs conversation with friend has gone? As friend is in danger of upsetting OP by being mean, if she doesn't back off with demands after being told "no sorry can't do that bit".

inappropriateraspberry · 03/09/2021 11:47

@Rozziie If they we're meeting at an independent place for breakfast/brunch, then yes, you can feed your children at home beforehand if needed. But she is in a hotel and would be going down to breakfast to feed her son, they can't then come back later to meet her friend! There isn't the flexibility afforded if both coming from their homes. It gets complicated and they'd be rushing to get sorted after a late breakfast to check out - child will need cleaning up, changing etc at the bare minimum, let alone the adults wanting to brush teeth etc!

PizzaBreath · 03/09/2021 11:39

Just bin off breakfast, you’ve had your day out for catching off and breakfast doesn’t work for either of you. She is NBU for not wanting to get up early, you are NBU for wanting to get up early and go.

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 11:34

@Tiana4

Rozziie You seem determined to make having a toddler and their having needs (as a human being in their own right) sound unreasonable. When it's not.

It's not for friend to argue with OP that neither her child's needs nor OP's matter.

It could have been a discussion except for the friend calling OP 'difficult' when OP said 'no sorry can't do' and why.

Enough PPs have said same thing to you.

I think you are OPs friend. Or someone else's equivalently single minded friend.

I'm not saying the friend doesn't also sound like a headache - I think they both do.

There's nothing wrong with a toddler having needs, but OP is using them for the reason she can't meet later, as if it should be obvious. It's not obvious. I have friends with young children, we meet for brunch. They feed the kids earlier. I'm sure it is a bit of a faff but they want to keep the friendship going, so make it work. We all compromise here and there. The issue is the OP doesn't really want to meet the friend and considers it a hassle/burden. Fine, but this difference in understanding of the situation is where the problem has arisen.

Again, why post if you don't want to be told what the friend's perspective is? If you want to hear that your friend is awful and you're totally right, just vent to your partner??!

shinynewapple21 · 03/09/2021 11:32

I can see it from both points of view . If I was your friend I would want to do breakfast at 10.30 rather than 8 on a Sunday . However I can see that you have inconvenienced yourself more by paying extra for the hotel near to where your friend lives . Particularly as this was originally a trip you had arranged for your family which she has said she would like to join in with .

It will be nice for you to meet her at the safari park and for the evening meal the day before but I can't see what either of you are getting from the breakfast meet up. It sounds like your friend normally goes there for her own breakfast at 10.30 and doesn't want to put herself out at all to include meeting with you and your family .

If it's not too late I would book the cheaper hotel with the pool, enjoy your day at the safari park with your friend but do your own thing on Sunday morning and head back for your cat .

Tiana4 · 03/09/2021 11:29

Rozziie
You seem determined to make having a toddler and their having needs (as a human being in their own right) sound unreasonable. When it's not.

It's not for friend to argue with OP that neither her child's needs nor OP's matter.

It could have been a discussion except for the friend calling OP 'difficult' when OP said 'no sorry can't do' and why.

Enough PPs have said same thing to you.

I think you are OPs friend. Or someone else's equivalently single minded friend.

thing47 · 03/09/2021 11:25

'Difficult' is a really unpleasant word to use about somebody who is supposed to be a friend. If someone called me 'difficult' they'd probably be told to fuck off.

But semantics apart, OP did say no, it's right there in her first post: I’ve suggested then that we skip breakfast. The correct response to that would have been 'yes, that's a shame, the timing isn't going to work, is it?' not 'you're being difficult'.

And they are meeting up, they're spending Saturday together. Sunday breakfast was an additional idea, one that won't work at a time suitable for both parties.

Heliachi · 03/09/2021 11:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 11:14

Basically if you don't want to do something, say 'no'. Don't say 'I need to feed toddler before 8...' etc. That is NOT a no!

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 11:12

@Tiana4

"No sorry, can't do it, we need to get away really early on the Sunday" - how hard is that?!

Honestly this thread for PP that haven't RTFT or even OPs posts, is like banging your head against a brick wall

OP did say that !

Friend then texted her and called her "difficult" and tried to argue back

I wouldn't fancy paying an extra day for cattery for zero reason. Nor having two breakfasts.

I wouldn't fancy trying to entertain a toddler for 3 hours and negating the whole point of staying in hotel overnight to make our trip away nicer and more rested.

It's hard enough with a toddler without a childfree friend being a princess about her lie in. And trying to tell me how my toddler, husband and I should fit around her wants (because we don't matter Hmm)

I think a whole day on Saturday with a friend like this - who lacks empathy & hasn't realised the world doesn't revolve around her- would be plenty enough time Grin and a long enough meet up.

Tbh I would bet money on friend being late for the Saturday morning meet up time for safari park. As she doesn't "get" young children's needs and is thoughtless about others.

Yes, the friend thought she was being difficult because of the way she worded it! How many bloody times do I need to say the same thing?

"I can't do X because of Y" just invites problem solving/solutions and attempts to compromise. If OP had just said "no, can't do breakfast, sorry", that would be it.

I guarantee the friend is complaining about how OP is the one who thinks the world revolves around her and her toddler.

This is a communication issue but since OP seems determined to think her friend is a selfish, childless monster with no consideration, fine.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 03/09/2021 11:08

go for the cheaper hotel,
if you are driving 2 hours the least they can do is drive half an hour if they want to meet you for coffee
however you want to leave anyway

say to her you will see how it goes!
no point committing

Tiana4 · 03/09/2021 11:08

"No sorry, can't do it, we need to get away really early on the Sunday" - how hard is that?!

Honestly this thread for PP that haven't RTFT or even OPs posts, is like banging your head against a brick wall

OP did say that !

Friend then texted her and called her "difficult" and tried to argue back

I wouldn't fancy paying an extra day for cattery for zero reason. Nor having two breakfasts.

I wouldn't fancy trying to entertain a toddler for 3 hours and negating the whole point of staying in hotel overnight to make our trip away nicer and more rested.

It's hard enough with a toddler without a childfree friend being a princess about her lie in. And trying to tell me how my toddler, husband and I should fit around her wants (because we don't matter Hmm)

I think a whole day on Saturday with a friend like this - who lacks empathy & hasn't realised the world doesn't revolve around her- would be plenty enough time Grin and a long enough meet up.

Tbh I would bet money on friend being late for the Saturday morning meet up time for safari park. As she doesn't "get" young children's needs and is thoughtless about others.

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 11:04

@thing47

I don't understand why OP is getting any grief here. Of course an 18-month-old isn't going to wait 4 hours between waking up and eating breakfast!

I can see that 8am on a Sunday morning might be too early for a couple who don't have to get up, but then breakfast doesn't work. The requirements of the two couples aren't compatible so OP's suggestion that they skip the breakfast meeting is the sensible way forward.

Anyone who described a sensible solution as me being 'difficult' would get pretty short shrift. At that point, I would just say bluntly 'yeah, we're not doing that, we'll be on the road home by 10am'

But it does sound difficult for someone who wants to meet up and thinks their friend wants the same.

OP's friend isn't hearing 'sorry, I don't want to'. She is hearing 'you have to meet me by 8am because my toddler can't possibly eat later and I can't possibly feed him earlier and meet you later'.

letsmakethishappen · 03/09/2021 11:00

Friends come and go. This friendship is hanging by a thread

thing47 · 03/09/2021 10:59

I don't understand why OP is getting any grief here. Of course an 18-month-old isn't going to wait 4 hours between waking up and eating breakfast!

I can see that 8am on a Sunday morning might be too early for a couple who don't have to get up, but then breakfast doesn't work. The requirements of the two couples aren't compatible so OP's suggestion that they skip the breakfast meeting is the sensible way forward.

Anyone who described a sensible solution as me being 'difficult' would get pretty short shrift. At that point, I would just say bluntly 'yeah, we're not doing that, we'll be on the road home by 10am'

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 10:52

Where the OP went wrong here is giving a long and detailed explanation of why she couldn't meet later, which to someone who is keen to meet up, just seems like problems that can easily be solved.

OP didn't actually want to meet her friend for breakfast and should have just said she couldn't do it, full stop. Questions about whether her friend is unreasonable or not are irrelevant - they're not on the same page.

The things OP listed CAN easily be solved by someone who actually wants to spend time with their friend. Do you think nobody in the history of the universe has ever been able to meet a friend at 10.30am because of a toddler and a cat? This is the true source of the misunderstanding between the two women. OP doesn't really want to meet up in the morning, the friend does.

"No sorry, can't do it, we need to get away really early on the Sunday" - how hard is that?!

Dangermouse5 · 03/09/2021 10:51

[quote Rozziie]@Dangermouse5 right, so end of discussion, "sorry, can't do breakfast, we're off early in the morning."

Not that hard, is it? Instead of doing that, she came here and started a discussion about whether her friend was unreasonable to want to meet later, to which the answer is no.[/quote]
Hallelujah

OP did say that. Friend was then difficult. OP said what she could and couldn't do.

She posted as friend didn't accept her no and called her difficult.

Dangermouse5 · 03/09/2021 10:49

There's this theme of self centred ness from PPs showing.

To be a good friend OP doesn't have to make her life difficult and her DS miserable. She is already seeing friend all day on Saturday. She doesn't want to see her Sunday as well, since the timings don't match. That's not being "difficult" that's being honest and not letting adult friends wants override what is best for child (& my finances & cat), and what we need to do. OP knows her toddler and her own responsibilities . Friend doesn't.

If any of my childfree friends behaved like this over my saying ' sorry we can't do that' , I'd be concerned about their lack of consideration.

Rozziie · 03/09/2021 10:46

@Dangermouse5

Rozziie who said If she doesn't want to meet her friend for breakfast, she should have said 'oh I can't, we're going really early in the morning, sorry' and that would be that

You haven't RTFT as OP did tell her friend she has to set off early on Sunday and couldn't do a late brunch/breakfast 3rd meet up as well on Sunday that weekend. And it was friend who then called her difficult for saying no. That's the passive aggressiveness there from friend! That's the point of OPs post - That friend didn't listen to her "no, sorry can't do that".

If you select the funnel icon at top and select just OPs posts in green, you'll see this and that's what everyone else is responding to. (Except those who didn't RTFT or even just OPs posts)

No, the friend called her difficult for saying she could only do pre-8am. She didn't say no to her friend. She gave her a very early time, while still giving the impression she was up for meeting. It's not her friend's fault that the OP lacks assertiveness and didn't just say no.