Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should do away with girls/ boys uniforms?

239 replies

MerryMarigold · 02/09/2021 12:51

Can't we just have a gender neutral uniform? Trousers, jumper, shirt, maybe tie
My daughter literally NEVER wears skirts outside of school but obviously ALL the girls wear skirts to school even though trousers are permitted.

A. It would help those struggling with what they identify as wouldn't need to make any massive statements via uniform.

B. The cost of girls uniform (usually) is ridiculous and much higher than boys. My daughter's school has a specific skirt and specific blouse (skirt is 30.00 alone!) where whereas boys have generic grey trousers and generic white shirts.

It seems schools have bought into/ contribute to/ emphasise this very distinct boys/ girls gendered clothing. I hate it!

OP posts:
BiBabbles · 03/09/2021 09:55

I would question the school on the sexed uniforms and cost differences. The former some parents don't mind, but you might find more support on trying to tackle both issues. I agree both are an issue.

You identified a 'gender neutral uniform': Trousers, jumper, shirt, maybe tie which, while times have changed, is traditionally the boy uniform which many are pointing out is an issue to assume male as the ideal neutral standard. There is a lot of discussion in many areas on the issues of 'standard uniform for all' meaning 'we got rid of the more feminine options we don't think guys will/should wear rather than something that considers both sexes'.

While trousers can be feminine, school trousers rarely are and many girls find them not cut well for their body shapes. Skirts can be more forgiving. If there isn't going to be sex differentiation, with culture as it is, the trousers are unlikely to be widely seen as feminine. They'll be neutral at best.

I've no strong opinion on uniforms vs dress code, they both have their pros and cons, but tackling uniform issues based on what people wear outside of it likely isn't going to work. Part of the whole thing with uniforms is to set apart from the rest of life to create a collective identity (and make it easier to spot and make complaints if they cause issues in the community... that seems to be their main use around here).

WeirdCouncil · 03/09/2021 09:51

Does gender neutral mean 'male' then?

Angel2702 · 03/09/2021 09:50

I wouldn’t want to get rid of skirts but certainly the gendered PE kits, why do the girls need a different Polo shirt and shorts for PE?

Sillysuzie · 03/09/2021 09:47

🙄

Keke94LND · 03/09/2021 09:39

Why does gender neutral = traditionally male attire? There's nothing wrong with traditionally female clothes? I wear trousers to work because I feel more comfortable in that at work but I also sometimes wear skirts.. when I was at school, I liked wearing skirts, there's nothing wrong with being a girl/woman and wearing traditionally feminine clothing. The only change I think schools should make is to allow boys to wear shorts in summer. Or, if you really do want gender neutrality then let boys wear skirts

lazylinguist · 03/09/2021 09:35

It should be more reasonably priced, but what positives are there of getting rid of it?

Most kids hate it. Lots find it uncomfortable or unflattering, and it's not the social leveller that people claim it is. Nor does it 'give the students a feeling of belonging and pride in their school', or any such guff which schools peddle. Teachers have to spend an irritating amount of time dealing with uniform infractions. It's old-fashioned and unnecessary.

Most other countries manage perfectly well without it, so I don't understand why so many people in the UK regard it as such a necessary or desirable thing to have. Schools also claim that a formal uniform 'helps prepare students for the workplace', which is also ridiculous considering how many jobs no longer require formal dress, and the fact that kids will go off to college or university and be able to wear whatever the hell they like for a few years!

cricketmum84 · 03/09/2021 09:25

Our high school banned skirts a few years ago. All students must be in trousers and they must be the same style, no skinny fit or slim leg style allowed.

Doesn't really bother us as my DD hates skirts anyway and lives in jeans, leggings or shorts outside school.

lazylockdowner · 03/09/2021 09:21

My dd will only wear skirts/pinafore as that's what she likes, girls can and do wear trousers if they wish.

I wouldn't be impressed if they stopped girls wearing skirts, I also have no issue with a boy wearing a skirt to school if they wish

Booknooks · 03/09/2021 09:20

@DynamoKev

All school uniform can fuck off to the far side of fuck and then fuck off some more.
It should be more reasonably priced, but what positives are there of getting rid of it?
moooshroom · 03/09/2021 09:19

Our local primary school have no uniform, although others in our area do have polo shirts, fleece, jumpers, trousers,culottes,skorts,shorts options. The secondary school has a range of uniform choices: shirt- long or short sleeved, skirt/shorts/trousers and jumper/cardigan/vest. Anyone can choose whatever combination of items they prefer. No boy or girl uniform, just select what combination works for you. It seems to work well. Guess where we are!!!

DynamoKev · 03/09/2021 09:15

All school uniform can fuck off to the far side of fuck and then fuck off some more.

Booknooks · 03/09/2021 09:15

The price discrepancy is an issue, but I don't really see what's wrong personally with having a choice, the wording just means anyone can wear whatever in reality.

WindyWindsor · 03/09/2021 09:15

I would have thought most schools have a standard uniform that both boys and girls wear, with maybe extra options for girls (i.e. skirt). When I was at school all the boys and girls were wearing the exact same thing (shirt, tie, blazer, trousers) but some girls wore skirts instead.

If it's the cost you're thinking of then I see your point, but I don't see gender neutral clothing as the solution, more a reasonable uniform policy. I don't understand why there's specific skirts and blouses required, that's nonsense. As far as I'm concerned a jumper/blazer with the school logo on and maybe a tie should be the only "branded" things required. For black trousers/skirts and white shirts/blouses I see no reason for a school not to allow any as long as they follow a reasonable uniform policy.

sashh · 03/09/2021 09:14

reluctantbrit

I worked in one school where girls could wear a shirt and tie but also had an option of an open necked blouse and scarf. Most girls chose it because they didn't have to tuck it in to their skirt or trousers.

I think at secondary there should be more options, but they should be options.

My school had summer and winter uniforms and a 'formal' option.

Summer uniform year 7-9 (first to third year in old money) was a pink gingham dress and navy blazer

10-11 open necked short sleeve blouse with skirt from winter uniform.

Winter uniform navy skirt, jumper and coat. Hats and scarves in navy, white or red. Long sleeved shirt type blouse with a tie, different tie for 'senior years' ie years 10-11

Formal was navy skirt, long sleeved shirt and tie, no jumper.

I was lucky they had abandoned the school hats a couple of years before.

MerryMarigold · 03/09/2021 09:13

@Balonzette

Ugh WHY is everytbing traditionally feminine so looked down upon? It's SO sexist! Why does everything have to be gender neutral? Why not let children choose what they wear? Why is society trying to stamp out anything feminine and claiming it's gender neutral when really it's just saying traditionally feminine stuff is inferior to traditionally male stuff. So bloody sexist.

Just because your daughter doesn't wear a skirt doesnt mean nobody chooses to wear the skirt Hmm

Interestingly, my SIL just posted a pic of her daughter going back to school - in trousers! She looks extremely feminine and quite glamorous. Why can't trousers be feminine?
OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 03/09/2021 09:06

@Fluffypastelslippers

Some misunderstanding on my OP I think. This was sparked by a message sent by school.

Girls Uniform (or those identifying as female)
Boys Uniform (or those identifying as male)
*

Well that's quite the drip feed isn't it.

Sorry if it was a drip feed, it's what sparked my thought, along with realising my son's uniform (generic shirts and trousers) is about a tenth the cost of my daughter's uniform. Now if that's not sexist, I don't know what is.
OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 03/09/2021 09:04

Sorry, it's what got my back up and made me think gender neutral was better for all kids.

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 03/09/2021 08:38

@daisypond

That primary school uniform photo posted above looks ideal to me. And the choices in the New Zealand school too. Add a set of tracksuit bottoms and fleece top/hoody for winter, that would be perfect for me. No blazers, ties, shirts, blouses, formal trousers or formal shoes. Sportswear for all.
I disagree. I think sportswear is for well, sport. I think there are enough comfortable clothes around which aren't jogging bottoms.

DD never wears them outside sport and still manages to be active, climbing trees, running around, doing organised outdoor activities.

I hate the fact that people think joggers/loungewear is the only alternative to formal wear.

daisypond · 03/09/2021 08:19

That primary school uniform photo posted above looks ideal to me. And the choices in the New Zealand school too. Add a set of tracksuit bottoms and fleece top/hoody for winter, that would be perfect for me. No blazers, ties, shirts, blouses, formal trousers or formal shoes. Sportswear for all.

reluctantbrit · 03/09/2021 08:09

Most trouser based uniforms (teen but also for adult females) are really badly cut and don't take the vast differences in shape into account. I remember a huge discussion at one German police force about this, it took years to change the uniform.

Wearing jeans or other casual trousers means a girl can wear something suitable for her figure. A skirt is often more forgiving than a formal pair of trousers.

The same with shirts and ties, we have a co-ed school in our area where girls have to wear a tie. Some of them are "blessed" with a larger bust and it just looks absolutely awful. Having G-cup breast myself I wouldn't be seen dead in anything up to the neck.

I also want to know how large the percentage of working women is who wear a tie for work. The only ones I know are the ladies in our office at the reception/security desk and obviously uniformed police/armed forces.

HoppSuisse · 03/09/2021 07:56

The point about the trousers was that many/ most 11+ girls will wear trousers/ leggings outside school but not to school because 'everyone else wears skirts'.
Around here, many/most girls and boys wear jeans, not uniform-style trousers. And its pretty much the same where I work. I have no idea why they cant be worn at school too.
I agree with getting rid of uniforms.

Fluffypastelslippers · 03/09/2021 07:45

Some misunderstanding on my OP I think. This was sparked by a message sent by school.

Girls Uniform (or those identifying as female)
Boys Uniform (or those identifying as male)
*

Well that's quite the drip feed isn't it.

Phyllis321 · 03/09/2021 07:26

Our school just lists ‘skirt uniform’ and ‘trouser uniform’. No mention of the sexes.

Booknooks · 03/09/2021 07:21

@Balonzette

Ugh WHY is everytbing traditionally feminine so looked down upon? It's SO sexist! Why does everything have to be gender neutral? Why not let children choose what they wear? Why is society trying to stamp out anything feminine and claiming it's gender neutral when really it's just saying traditionally feminine stuff is inferior to traditionally male stuff. So bloody sexist.

Just because your daughter doesn't wear a skirt doesnt mean nobody chooses to wear the skirt Hmm

Because men are the default, always.
liveforsummer · 03/09/2021 07:11

@EmeraldShamrock

Surely the choice of a skirt or trousers is better if a uniform is required. I hated school trousers DD only wears a skirt or skort it is her choice of uniform. Abolishing uniforms would be a better idea not making it trousers only.
Noooo. Dc did not have to wear uniform during covid in the hub. Was like a fashion show each morning and good clothes got stained. Far prefer a practical uniform. Takes the decision making out of it.