Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should do away with girls/ boys uniforms?

239 replies

MerryMarigold · 02/09/2021 12:51

Can't we just have a gender neutral uniform? Trousers, jumper, shirt, maybe tie
My daughter literally NEVER wears skirts outside of school but obviously ALL the girls wear skirts to school even though trousers are permitted.

A. It would help those struggling with what they identify as wouldn't need to make any massive statements via uniform.

B. The cost of girls uniform (usually) is ridiculous and much higher than boys. My daughter's school has a specific skirt and specific blouse (skirt is 30.00 alone!) where whereas boys have generic grey trousers and generic white shirts.

It seems schools have bought into/ contribute to/ emphasise this very distinct boys/ girls gendered clothing. I hate it!

OP posts:
Abraxan · 03/09/2021 17:03

@Walkingalot

At my DC's school, the uniform (incl Blazers) is the same for boys and girls (no skirts). They can wear any style of black trouser providing it's not 'skinny'. The girls still manage to look feminine.
But I don't wear a skirt to look feminine. I wear a skirt as I find them far more comfortable than trousers. And for someone who is short having a trouser only uniform would make buying uniform more difficult and often more expensive - fewer brands sell petite in teen ranges, often petite range is much more restricted and can be more expensive. Or you have the issue of needing to pay to have them shortened.
Walkingalot · 03/09/2021 17:01

At my DC's school, the uniform (incl Blazers) is the same for boys and girls (no skirts). They can wear any style of black trouser providing it's not 'skinny'. The girls still manage to look feminine.

CBUK2K2 · 03/09/2021 16:59

We need to stop with the nonsense about confusing kids about sexuality and gender and get them back to being kids again.

Let boys be boys and girls be girls.

Abraxan · 03/09/2021 16:57

@maddening

I agree, trousers for everyone would sort a lot of issues imo (and I am someone who no longer wears trousers)
But cause more issues for others.
Abraxan · 03/09/2021 16:54

So you're idea to end gendered uniform is to reduce the girls' choices. Why not just say that any pupil can wear either a skirt or trousers or shorts?

I rarely wear trousers. I'm not very tall and it's difficult to get trousers that fit me well. I can't just buy standard trousers and there isn't always the option for petite, which would mean me having to pay to have them shortened. For a number of leg styles this then makes the trousers not hang properly and they look quite wrong. This was/has been the same since my teenage years.

So your removal of skirts would end up costing someone like me more money and restricting my choices to wear something I find more comfortable.

DoTheNextRightThing · 03/09/2021 16:49

@BluebellsGreenbells

I appreciate the concerns about uniforms, butt I found them a great leveller.

Are you saying that kids don’t know who the rich kids are and who the poor kids are?

They know who goes skiing every winter and who has the latest backpack and smart watch! They also know who have extra curricular and who’s on free school meals!

Uniform is irrelevant.

Absolutely this. There was a uniform at my school but there was also a huge wealth gap between students as our school had merged with a school in a much poorer area. So we had the kids who's parents were doctors and lawyers and who posted hundreds of photos of their foreign holidays on Facebook and drove Minis to school when they hit 17, and the others whose parents struggled to make ends meet and could barely afford lunch. The uniform didn't prevent us knowing who was rich and who wasn't.
DoTheNextRightThing · 03/09/2021 16:46

@JazzerMcCreary

I think skirts/dresses are fine but there shouldn’t be a ‘boys’ list and a ‘girls’ list of uniform. Just ‘these are the accepted uniform items’.
Exactly this!
DoTheNextRightThing · 03/09/2021 16:44

I don’t think they should do away with skirts, just do away with stupid branded or highly specific school uniform that bleeds parents dry. And I think all children should be able to wear whatever type of clothes they find most comfortable.

In my ideal world we'd scrap uniform all together but that wasn't the question.

I would definitely bin ties though. Hated wearing them. Still can't tie it properly after all these years.

millymollymoomoo · 03/09/2021 16:39

Op, your idea is not gender neutral, it’s making girls wear boys clothes. Why when anyone says gender neutral it’s trousers ? So girls yet again conforming to male ideas

Gender neutral would mean trousers or skirts and girls and boys could chose either …

ExecutiveHodCarrier · 03/09/2021 16:36

@JazzerMcCreary

I think skirts/dresses are fine but there shouldn’t be a ‘boys’ list and a ‘girls’ list of uniform. Just ‘these are the accepted uniform items’.
I agree
Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 16:34

Especially when those people who can't afford expensive clothes cant afford the uniform either and as a result can afford afford less In the way of clothing than before

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 16:12

I appreciate the concerns about uniforms, butt I found them a great leveller.
Some children - driven by parents- strive for the best/ latest label often costing ££££ Shoes or hoodies costing a great deal of money

Thing is you can no longer claim that. Wheb it costs hundreds of pounds to get your kid through the door in clothes that cant be worn anywhere else , nor can they be handed down when it gets to high school becuase of house colours and names being printed/stitched onto the outside.

There's nothing levelling abkut being financially excluded from even.being able to apply.

When you can buy a skirt in asda fir a fiver there's no excuse for the ones that cost 20 plus quid. That's not being a leveller.

And people work bloody hard fir their money this idea they cant enjoy anything or buy something nice incase the other kids are jealous is nuts. I mean I'm.happy for anyone who can afford to have nice things and I'd come down like a ton.of bricks on my lids if they picked on anyone for not having alot of money. But nor do I think its fair those who do have money are meant to send their kids in in cheap crap scruffy polyester shit just because someone else can't afford something. You don't get rich by letting yourself be ripped off by purchasing false economy items.

Surely the key is a sensible dress code and to deal with bullying

BluebellsGreenbells · 03/09/2021 16:04

I appreciate the concerns about uniforms, butt I found them a great leveller.

Are you saying that kids don’t know who the rich kids are and who the poor kids are?

They know who goes skiing every winter and who has the latest backpack and smart watch! They also know who have extra curricular and who’s on free school meals!

Uniform is irrelevant.

speakout · 03/09/2021 16:02

I appreciate the concerns about uniforms, butt I found them a great leveller.
Some children - driven by parents- strive for the best/ latest label often costing ££££ Shoes or hoodies costing a great deal of money. I think fashion and clothing is a great distraction for teenagers and can make for competition to see who has the latest and best gear.
Implimenting uniform takes away all that competition and bad feeling, at least while the children are in school time.

shiningcuckoo · 03/09/2021 14:28

At primary my children had no uniform. It all worked pretty well and the kids wore practical inexpensive clothes. There was lots of handing clothes down between families.
At secondary the kids choose from a number of items and they can wear these in a combination of their choosing. So there are trousers to fit girls and boys, same with shorts and logoed polo shirts, a jumper, a cardi. A hoody with the name of the school across the front, a skirt and checked shirts for girls snd boys. They can wear black trainers and socks and any jacket. The kids universally choose black down jackets. So my daughter chooses a skirt, shirt with a long sleeved black T-shirt underneath and a black jacket. My son always wears shorts and a polo shirt with a hoody. Other kids have other combinations and my friends son wears a skirt. The other kids don't bat an eyelid. The school is pretty liberal as far as hair colours and piercings are concerned but on the whole the kids look fine and seem comfortable. No one has to look like a blast from the past anymore.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/09/2021 10:35

Mine are long grown up, but I’m largely in favour of uniform, since it means a) no (or at least fewer) arguments about what to wear in the morning, and b) less chance of kids of less well off parents feeling crap, and maybe being ostracised or bullied, because they haven’t got X brand top or trainers.
But it should always be reasonably affordable, with a 2nd hand shop available.

GintyMcGinty · 03/09/2021 10:34

The cost issue would be sorted if schools would stop insisting on specific items and let people buy uniforms out of supermarkets.

My eldest's school does this. Uniform is white shirt, black jumper, black trousers or skirt and black shoes. Excluding shoes I can dress him for less than £10.

My youngest's school still insists on logo polo shirts, sweatshirts and blazers. As a result that adds £60 to the price of her uniform.

I wouldn't have an issue with skirts and dresses being dropped from the uniform but I also don't mind them being there.

My daughter, however, would chose to continue to wear trousers.

Stormyequine · 03/09/2021 10:32

I think schools should have a list off acceptable items that anyone can wear. No reason it can't include a skirt or dress for boys or girls if they want. It would make life so much easier and fairer.

purpleme12 · 03/09/2021 10:26

Agree that skirts last years here too

Dixiechickonhols · 03/09/2021 10:24

My teen could wear trousers but virtually no girls do. Trousers are far trickier and more expensive than a skirt if you are growing and gaining or losing weight. Lots of girls have yr 7 skirt for years and it just gets shorter - waist is adjustable. Trousers need replacement a lot if you grow, I stopped wearing trousers to work when I was losing weight as they never fitted properly.
PE kits should be unisex. Been a campaign at daughters school as boys can wear own tracksuit bottoms, girls have to wear leggings with a skort over (looks ridiculous). Not sure if anyone has identified as male for hour Games lesson a week but seems like solution to me.

purpleme12 · 03/09/2021 10:24

@Angel2702

I wouldn’t want to get rid of skirts but certainly the gendered PE kits, why do the girls need a different Polo shirt and shorts for PE?
Ours don't need different things for PE if they don't want different things They could wear the same as boys

What's different about your PE kit for boys and girls? I don't understand that

CounsellorTroi · 03/09/2021 10:17

I think the idea has some merit, it would certainly do away with all the issues about skirt length/rolling up skirts etc.

GreenWhiteViolet · 03/09/2021 10:15

Everyone should have the choice of trousers, shorts or skirt. No gendering necessary.

Making everyone wear trousers is a bad idea. I've had a curvy figure since age 12 and used to be very embarrassed about it. Trousers would gape massively at the waist and cling to the bottom and thighs that I was very anxious to hide. As an adult if I want trousers I buy a large size (2 or 3 sizes bigger than my skirt size) and have them altered. There would have been no spare money for this kind of thing when I was young. I'm very glad that I was able to wear a skirt to school, even though I complained about it being ugly at the time.

I think it's very tiresome when a poster says that they or their DD personally likes trousers or thinks they're more practical and therefore everyone should be made to wear them. It's as if they can't see beyond their own situation and preferences.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/09/2021 10:10

In theory I’d agree, but why does such ‘equality’ invariably mean girls wearing trousers?

randomsabreuse · 03/09/2021 10:06

Trousers that fit look feminine and elegant, trousers that don't fit look crap. The only "trousers" that fit me are treggings which would be too tight fitting for school rules. I have tried on all the trouser styles in my 40 years of life and had worse issues as a teen as my waist/hip ratio was more extreme not less!

I also have the issue that my DD has no trousers that fit - she has some leggings that are acceptable (but quite baggy) and some Primark skinny jeans that are just about ok for length and not too baggy, except on her calf muscles. However, she has a (fairly reasonable) objection to the 3 inch long loops of elastic on the inside of the waistband. I haven't found any other trousers (formal or jeans) that come close to fitting other than sports leggings. There are also not many slim fit options for school trousers that I've come across!

Fair enough DD is unusually tall and narrow hipped for a 6 year old - most of the taller kids her age are more in proportion but she's got a small chest measurement than her 3 year old brother and is still fine in age 4-5 shirts if she's wearing a pinafore! However she's not an unhealthy weight/BMI so can't be that outside the norm, just unusual enough that clothing does not cater well.