Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should do away with girls/ boys uniforms?

239 replies

MerryMarigold · 02/09/2021 12:51

Can't we just have a gender neutral uniform? Trousers, jumper, shirt, maybe tie
My daughter literally NEVER wears skirts outside of school but obviously ALL the girls wear skirts to school even though trousers are permitted.

A. It would help those struggling with what they identify as wouldn't need to make any massive statements via uniform.

B. The cost of girls uniform (usually) is ridiculous and much higher than boys. My daughter's school has a specific skirt and specific blouse (skirt is 30.00 alone!) where whereas boys have generic grey trousers and generic white shirts.

It seems schools have bought into/ contribute to/ emphasise this very distinct boys/ girls gendered clothing. I hate it!

OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 04/09/2021 18:30

@UserStillatLarge

Just asked DD and she says around 25% of the girls in her school wear trousers. So I'm surprised that literally no one (not even any Muslim girls?) wear trousers at OP's school.

I think it would be more interesting for OP to challenge why she's written and seemingly just accepted:
My daughter literally NEVER wears skirts outside of school but obviously ALL the girls wear skirts to school Why is this "obvious"? And why will your DD be assumed to be "trans" if she wears trousers? Sounds like the school has some deep rooted issues, that will lead to more problems than ones surrounding uniform.

I have no idea why no girls wear trousers, OP. There are not many (any I know of, but not seen all the kids due to staggered starts/ finishes) Muslim girls in school, but perhaps they wear the skirt with Asian style trousers under it? I don't know.

I don't know why I said 'obviously'. I meant 'apparently'.

I don't know why the girls don't wear trousers. I was speculating (hence 'perhaps'). I do know there are a few transgender kids, who wear the other uniform, hence the potential association of trousers with being transgender.

Kids only going into Y8 and Y7 wasn't normal so it will be interesting to see what the next year brings. What deeper rooted problems should I be looking out for in the school?

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 04/09/2021 16:23

My daughter wears tunic dresses because she finds them more comfortable as they don't have a waistband. They're also much easier as she is slim and finding trousers that fit is a nightmare.

My son is starting reception and finding school trousers was also a nightmare. I suspect he'd feel more comfortable in a tunic but I wouldn't want him to be picked on so we finally found trousers to fit.

I think it should be all uniform for everyone. I hope over the years boys are able to wear dresses without being picked on, as for some children they are genuinely more comfortable.

Peregrina · 04/09/2021 16:06

So how is adopting a male uniform for both sexes going to help those boys who want to experiment with adopting a female identity? Not at all, I would have thought, but make a lot of girls uncomfortable with what they are forced to wear.

UserStillatLarge · 04/09/2021 15:48

Just asked DD and she says around 25% of the girls in her school wear trousers. So I'm surprised that literally no one (not even any Muslim girls?) wear trousers at OP's school.

I think it would be more interesting for OP to challenge why she's written and seemingly just accepted:
My daughter literally NEVER wears skirts outside of school but obviously ALL the girls wear skirts to school Why is this "obvious"? And why will your DD be assumed to be "trans" if she wears trousers? Sounds like the school has some deep rooted issues, that will lead to more problems than ones surrounding uniform.

MerryMarigold · 04/09/2021 14:13

@CecilyP

Girls Uniform (or those identifying as female) Boys Uniform (or those identifying as male)

Surely, this is where the school has it all wrong. Piecing your posts together, OP, am I right in thinking that boys must identify as female in order to wear open neck shirts? Not sure if girls have to identify as male to wear trousers!?

The girls shirt is different entirely - open necked and striped as opposed to plain white. Girls can wear trousers but my daughter actually thought you weren't allowed as no one does (perhaps because they are going to be considered trans if they do).

This is not just about transgender being made to get comfortable. It's about those who are not yet comfortable with what sex they are. It's that these children, who want to experiment a bit have to make a massive statement ie. 'I identify as male/ female' not 'I'd like to wear a tie or trousers for a change'. NB. THIS IS NOT ABOUT MY KIDS (for those who seem to think it is a personal post) just the concept of such differentiated clothing carrying on from all the pink/ blue in the supermarket into uniforms. I just think the greater the differentiation between the uniform, the more kids feel forced into making decisions rather than just existing as a child that goes to x school.

I think the police is different. These are adults who have decided what they identify as once and for all. I disagree with it in adults but still agree with the theory that there should be a list of acceptable clothes and anyone can wear what they want off that list.

OP posts:
HowToMurderYourLife · 04/09/2021 09:58

I think organisations like the police are well on board with this. They can sound all sensitive and right on by saying it’s so transgender employees feel more comfortable but they also get to save a shed load of cash! All the clothing will be cut to the male body as it’s the default and cheaper. The women wearing uncomfortable clothing and having trousers that struggle to stay up as to fit over the hips the waist will be gaping and even good belts will loosen and slide though the day, well they just need to suck it up and be kind obviously. We can then slag them off for either looking scruffy if they wear a size that fits the hips/breasts properly or looking slutty if they wear something tighter to stop it coming loose. See those women just don’t take pride like proper policemen.

MurielsWedding · 04/09/2021 09:43

@Feelingmardy

Absolutely, as long as it was one that was cut for girls and the buttons were on the left I'd be on board for this.

Totally with you in principle and I agree that we don't want 'unisex' to mean 'girls wear what boys have been wearing'. But boys (esp as they get older) have much wider shoulders (on average of course) so they will need to get a very enormous blazed to fit into a 'girls' one. Should be exactly the same style of course, but perhaps we could live in a world where we acknowledge the biological differences between girls and boys.

So, your proposal is to have school uniforms that look the same to the casual observer but are actually cut and made differently for girls and boys so that their bodies, which are biologically different, can be accommodated?

I reckon this might catch on. In fact lots of schools are doing this already. Grin

CecilyP · 04/09/2021 09:39

Girls Uniform (or those identifying as female)
Boys Uniform (or those identifying as male)

Surely, this is where the school has it all wrong. Piecing your posts together, OP, am I right in thinking that boys must identify as female in order to wear open neck shirts? Not sure if girls have to identify as male to wear trousers!?

Feelingmardy · 04/09/2021 09:32

Absolutely, as long as it was one that was cut for girls and the buttons were on the left I'd be on board for this.

Totally with you in principle and I agree that we don't want 'unisex' to mean 'girls wear what boys have been wearing'. But boys (esp as they get older) have much wider shoulders (on average of course) so they will need to get a very enormous blazed to fit into a 'girls' one. Should be exactly the same style of course, but perhaps we could live in a world where we acknowledge the biological differences between girls and boys.

LittleBrenda · 04/09/2021 09:31

It makes sense that blazers and shirts are all from the traditionally girls section as they will be made for women's chests.

The boys could size down I suppose. The necks might be a bit tight but I think that the boys won't mind feeling uncomfortable for just seven hours a day, five days a week for forty weeks of the year.

GoldieLookingFish · 04/09/2021 09:12

Fine, have a male cut and a female one. Buttons on the left makes absolutely no difference though - it’s a historical hangover that has no practical benefit whatsoever, other than signifying ‘this is a garment cut for females’. It’s not like women and men button things up differently!

No, the boys can just wear the one cut for the girls, it will be much more simple that way. More gender neutral.

We all know the buttons are on different sides because of women having ladies maids but when children learn to dress themselves they learn how to fasten buttons on their own clothes and struggle to fasten them if they are on the other side. It's a learnt behaviour.

So the boys will learn how to fasten the buttons on the other side too on their new gender neutral 'one blazer for all' blazer. It will be fine.

nancypineapple · 04/09/2021 09:01

My youngest dd ( yr 6) and her best mates all wear trousers because they are more comfortable when playing football etc. She actually said yesterday about the silly gingham dresses they have as summer uniform whereas the boys get to wear shorts. They are going to address the head about this as they feel they should have the choice to wear something practical. We have 4 senior schools and their blazers help identify the gangs of kids fighting each other. 2 of the schools have a 40 year history of meeting every Friday for a punch up and pile on which stops the traffic and causes havoc. I feel this is the only useful argument for uniform in senior school!

NoSquirrels · 04/09/2021 08:57

@GoldieLookingFish

One blazer Absolutely, as long as it was one that was cut for girls and the buttons were on the left I'd be on board for this.
Fine, have a male cut and a female one. Buttons on the left makes absolutely no difference though - it’s a historical hangover that has no practical benefit whatsoever, other than signifying ‘this is a garment cut for females’. It’s not like women and men button things up differently!

I think all that any uniform thread shows is how hard it is to get a proper unisex uniform that satisfies everyone. There will always be people who think collared shirts aren’t suitable for girls, ties are archaic, polo shirts are not smart, blah blah blah.

GoldieLookingFish · 04/09/2021 08:12

One blazer
Absolutely, as long as it was one that was cut for girls and the buttons were on the left I'd be on board for this.

habibihabibi · 04/09/2021 08:02

daisypond
Coincidently this is a New Zealand school. I do agree with other posters that such sporty look probably isn't as accepted in British schools but NZ is a much more sporty nation.
Off topic but I think this is what the UK should aspire to, getting children more active.

A uniform that can be worn for both sport and academics is more cost effective.

Peregrina · 03/09/2021 21:00

The same with shirts and ties, we have a co-ed school in our area where girls have to wear a tie. Some of them are "blessed" with a larger bust and it just looks absolutely awful. Having G-cup breast myself I wouldn't be seen dead in anything up to the neck.

I was just going to post something similar. The 'male' item I would get rid of is ties. As you say very few adult women wear ties - unless it's part of a uniform like the Police or Military where they started as male organisations only. Increasingly adult men don't wear ties either.

This seems to be an area where secondary schools have gone backwards over the years. My DD never had to wear a tie, at any stage - now the Secondary she went to has ties for girls also. Except strangely enough, they have introduced a polo shirt option for the summer, (which is unisex and popular.)

As for sixth formers having to wear smart business wear - no, some people aspire to other things that working in an estate agents or bank.

HungryHippo11 · 03/09/2021 17:57

See with this my issues still remains that the uniform is very different but is for

Boys (or those who identify as male) or
Girls (or those who identify as female)

Why can it's be girl - who prefers trousers shirt and tie but still identifies as female?

Thats awful. If my daughter wants to wear trousers it doesn't make her transgender!

HungryHippo11 · 03/09/2021 17:55

Our uniform just says a list of the possible options, it doesn't say "girls" and "boys" just blue jumper, grey trousers, grey skirt, white shirt. So you can choose. I'm putting my daughter in trousers because its far more practical for a 4YO

Yogsgirl · 03/09/2021 17:51

YABU! because gender neutral is not when traditional feminine clothes are replaced with traditional male items.

DDs school has removed the gender specified uniform policy and all children can now choose from skirt or trousers. Some of the boys think it's hilarious to rock up to school in a skirt but teachers can't put a stop to the joke because of the policy- just hope the novelty soon wears off!

coffeepleeease · 03/09/2021 17:51

100% yes. This is the school uniform list...jumper/shirt/skirt/trousers/dress/shorts, etc, and you can wherever you like from it. My little girl starts school on Monday and she'll be wearing trousers as she hates skirts. I wouldn't be very happy if she "had" to wear a skirt or dress.

Elkey · 03/09/2021 17:43

@SirenSays

I get rid of all uniforms if it were up to me.
Me too. I'm a teacher and I feel petty policing uniform tbh. Feels like a waste of my time and a stupid battle to have. Trivial compared to more pressing matters.
UserStillatLarge · 03/09/2021 17:38

@Angel2702

I wouldn’t want to get rid of skirts but certainly the gendered PE kits, why do the girls need a different Polo shirt and shorts for PE?
Girls and boys have totally different body shapes. Generic PE kit would mean the boys' was adopted and the girls would have to wear clothes that didn't fit properly.
NoSquirrels · 03/09/2021 17:24

I do think it should be gender neutral.

One shirt colour/style
One tie
One blazer
One jumper
Range of bottom-half options in same colour

That’s all. Differentiating what the boys and girls can choose is mad.

itsgettingwierd · 03/09/2021 17:19

@MerryMarigold

Some misunderstanding on my OP I think. This was sparked by a message sent by school.

Girls Uniform (or those identifying as female)
Boys Uniform (or those identifying as male)

It made me think about why does a child need to choose to make such a strong statement as the boys and girls uniforms are very different? The shirt is different. Girls have no tie etc.

For those of you with kids still in Primary, it is done much better there, I agree. For those of you who don't need to buy school branded differentiated uniform, that's great for you.

Not suggesting it so my daughter can wear trousers! She's perfectly happy in her very girly, very differentiated uniform. It's me that has the issue with it being so differentiated. The point about the trousers was that many/ most 11+ girls will wear trousers/ leggings outside school but not to school because 'everyone else wears skirts'. To me trousers are gender neutral, not boys clothing, but each to their own.

And yes, ideally there would be no uniform at all let alone such strict rules (no knee socks at my daughter's Secondary school. This is a comp in quite a deprived area!).

I like the New Zealand gender neutral uniform ideas. I think that's what I was getting at. Why does it need to be so segregated?

See with this my issues still remains that the uniform is very different but is for

Boys (or those who identify as male) or
Girls (or those who identify as female)

Why can it's be girl - who prefers trousers shirt and tie but still identifies as female?

We are to totally confusing children but reinforcing gender stereotypes or needing to label themselves as a gender or as identifying as a gender due to their personal clothing preferences.

Me and my son actually had a giggle one day this summer after looking at some photos of a day out.

He loves purple and we spent ages finding a suitable purple t shirt for him (he's autistic and very specific). It's a polo t shirt from Tesco. They also had pink ones and I love pink and being tall prefer male t shirts as they fit better.

Without even noticing we both went out wearing black chino shirts and each in our polos. I then had on a pullover pink fleece and ds had his green one on that's slightly different style but they are both very similar.

And I'm pretty girly in many ways and he's a very masculine and a performance athlete.

But it did open a fantastic conversation about how clothing actually doesn't define gender at all and how gender or gender identification shouldn't define clothing.

AllTheSingleLadiess · 03/09/2021 17:04

The cost difference is a major drip feed OP.
10 times more for your dd is scandalous
Are they at the same school ?
My teens went to the same school and the cost was similar. A pair of trousers equalled a skirt/tights and there was no difference in shirt, tie, blazer. They wore school shoes that cost similar.