Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.

407 replies

thecranberries · 02/09/2021 12:44

AIBU to ask what Pro Life 'supporters' do to actually help living children in need? Sparked by Rachel Maddow Show Podcast on MSNBC - which gives a brilliant coverage on what's going on.

PL seems to want to stop a woman's right to choose, even in instances of rape or incest. That's in Texas, US, but as we know, many of the 'trends' that start in the US migrate over here. And as we know, there are lots of Pro-Life (read anti abortion, anti women) believers over here.

So, my AIBU is to ask - what do these PL do to actually support actual living children in need in this country or the world? How much do they give to UNICEF/Save the Children etc charities? How much do they donate time, money and resources to actual children living in poverty, bad housing, experiencing harm or bad schooling to ensure that these actual living children get the best life possible?

Do these PL, who cite religious grounds, actually enable women to obtain proper contraception when they need it? And speaking about religion, how many religious PL turn a blind eye to religious organisations history of child abuse?

I don't understand anyone, especially men, who does not accept a woman's right to chose what happens to her own body.

So, AIBU to ask Pro Life supporters to tell me in detail what they do - as actively as supporting their 'cause' - when it comes to helping living children in need?

OP posts:
mumwon · 02/09/2021 23:36

decrease family planning & banned abortions & as for "Christian Families adopting" presumably white Christians predominately & the number of women affected are non white or in some cases women whose babies could be disabled & who will adopt them, especially with the cost of medical care in the USA? These women are as pp said being punished & if they keep these babies how will they afford them & they are likely to be doomed to poverty poor education etc
Every child should be wanted -not resented - & how in God's name can they force underaged children or women who have been forced into sex into having a baby under these circumstances?& They talk of the Taliban's treatment of women

Spanglybangles · 02/09/2021 23:01

I am heartened by Joe Biden’s response to this dreadful development in Texas. I hope he can sort this madness out, perhaps making abortion laws federal rather than up to individual states is the answer. I fear for women and girls in Texas right now who are in the heartbreaking situation where they find themselves pregnant, but don’t want to be.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-58424249

EKGEMS · 02/09/2021 22:38

Sorry I hit post too soon-of Americans who absolutely are more progressive than TX? I could use stereotypes to describe the UK and it would only showcase my ignorance like you do @TableFlowerss

EKGEMS · 02/09/2021 22:36

@TableFlowerss Do you realize there are 50 states in the USA and there's millions of citizens who don't agree with this new TX law including many, many Texans? You are smearing a lot

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 02/09/2021 22:24

I hope that women who are forced to proceed with a pregnancy against their wishes sue the state for the cost of the medical care they have to have during pregnancy and birth.

Tevin · 02/09/2021 20:41

I'm assuming this means any woman (or girl) who finds out she is pregnant after 6 weeks, is unable to access abortion in another state and then has complications during her pregnancy requiring extra medical care will have to not only continue a pregnancy she doesn't want, birth a child she doesn't want but also pay for the medical bills during the pregnancy and labour she didn't want?

thecranberries · 02/09/2021 20:34

@Hereslookingatyoukid

Apologies of this has already been covered - I did read through but might have missed it. Would women in Texas who travel out of state either for an abortion or to discuss their options also be at risk of prosecution? I'm thinking of the women from Ireland who would travel to London/other parts of England to have abortions when abortion was not available legally there.
This is a grey area, and very concerning. The law as it stands now is that anyone - anywhere - who 'aides and abets' any Texan woman/girl to have an abortion can be sued for $10,000 plus legal costs.

So, vigilante law has been enacted.

The scenario is that any taxi driver / family member / friend / medical professional who 'aides and abets' a Texan woman to have an abortion can be sued. So, does that mean anyone who helps the woman leave Texas for the abortion? The woman would have to leave somehow.

That's why there are loads of anonymous donations / donors coming forward to help these women - so there is no trace of them.

It's going to be a minefield to actually get an abortion after 6 weeks, and with the Supreme Court allowing this dystopian law to stand (5-4 voted against upholding the Injunction to stop this law being enacted) and because of the way it's written, there is no certainty of what rights Texan women now have.

Truly sad situation.

OP posts:
Kithic · 02/09/2021 20:21

@PlanDeRaccordement

Texas has banned abortion

Sorry but they haven’t. They’ve restricted abortion, not banned it. A ban is when something is illegal no matter the circumstances.

oh go away - how many women actually know they are pregnant by 6 weeks which is the cut off date!
Kithic · 02/09/2021 20:20

@bananapumpkin

Anti abortion is not anti women. It's clear that many people are both, but many others are pro-life partly because abortion is such a damaging experience for many women.

While it's laudable to help children in need, it's irrelevant to the PL/PC argument - unless you seriously believe that it's better to be dead than living in poverty.

No anti abortion is anti women, anti abortion is anti womans choice and cannot be anything but anti women
DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 02/09/2021 20:18

Its taken 13 hours after these barbaric laws for the first woman in texas to die after attempting her own abortion.

Pro life my arse.

TurquoiseDragon · 02/09/2021 20:14

@HarrietsChariot

A solution of sorts would be to permit a woman to have an abortion, but only if she is sterilised as part of the procedure. This would make people think very hard about whether an abortion is right for them, knowing that they will then no longer to be able to have children in the future. It satisfies the pro-choice argument that a woman should have the ability to decide whether to proceed or not, and from the pro-life point of view there will be no more repeat aborters.

As someone who is very much pro-abortion this would satisfy any qualms over the so-called morality of the decision.

(Personally I'm of the Bill Hicks school of thought, that not only should abortion be legal but in many cases should be mandatory!)

And what if that first pregnancy was the result of rape, for example? Your "solution" is a load of crap.

As early as possible, as late as necessary.

Hereslookingatyoukid · 02/09/2021 20:03

Apologies of this has already been covered - I did read through but might have missed it. Would women in Texas who travel out of state either for an abortion or to discuss their options also be at risk of prosecution? I'm thinking of the women from Ireland who would travel to London/other parts of England to have abortions when abortion was not available legally there.

Pallisers · 02/09/2021 20:01

@mustlovegin

Perhaps more emphasis should be placed on contraception so that these pregnancies don't happen in the first places (with the exception of those resulting from rape and other exceptions, obviously)
rates of abortion in the US have been falling for years and are at an all time low. Ditto birth rates and teen birth rates. Access to contraception is doing its job.

Abortion will still be needed for some women.

SmokeyDevil · 02/09/2021 19:48

@Petardos

I love that you call me judgemental or rude, and come out with tripe like this. Please educate yourself before judging me. I'd rather be rude than stupid. grin

I think you are both rude and stupid and probably never been in America.

You're the one who is claiming that women who have had several abortions shouldn't be allowed them. Your theory then can be expanded to no cancer treatment for smokers or people who didn't use sun cream, no treatment for people who caused a car accident, no treatment for an obese person who ate too much etc. Where do you stop on that kind of thinking?

And I wouldn't want to go to America, too many idiots there quite clearly since they've voted for this stupidity. The stupid are now the majority.

EKGEMS · 02/09/2021 19:36

I don't agree with the Texas abortion law but that's what happens when US presidents are allowed to appoint justices and stack the courts. On the healthcare debate-I've worked minimum wage jobs as a teen and early 20s a long time ago and I had healthcare plans available-I think we should have universal healthcare-I'm a moderate Democrat in my political beliefs and the Covid pandemic and majority of Republican attitudes have converted me to fully Democratic political persuasion. Right now it's a employee job market and stiff competition for the workforce and I hope more people can take advantage of the college tuition payment programs like Amazon and Walmart are offering now. Education really is the gateway to future success and opportunity.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 02/09/2021 19:21

Idk why people are arguing with Plan. Viable foetuses have to be dead before birth otherwise this would no longer be a late stage abortion but a live birth.

To be fair Plan can argue in an empty room.

mustlovegin · 02/09/2021 19:19

'in the first place' I meant

mustlovegin · 02/09/2021 19:19

Perhaps more emphasis should be placed on contraception so that these pregnancies don't happen in the first places (with the exception of those resulting from rape and other exceptions, obviously)

PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 19:13

@thecranberries

Late term abortion discussion arose because we were talking about the line between fetus and baby. And how that line is drawn in different places by prolife Vs prochoice. One poster was fixated on whether a 8mo fetus is a baby or not.

So, I was saying that late term abortion is the ethical minefield where both sides meet in the middle where the drawing of line between fetus and baby becomes most difficult. And given that abortions do sometimes fail, when does feticide become infanticide?

This is what we need to talk about to have real discussion on abortion. This thread way before me turned into a general discussion on abortion.

PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 19:05

@Jaysmith71

But other countries seem to manage second-trimester terminations without this, just like they manage without operating a death penalty by lethal injection or any other method.
Not really. It is world-wide. Do you seriously believe a late term abortion involves the birth of a live fetus?
thecranberries · 02/09/2021 19:04

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@thecranberries

Back on pg 1 of the thread I answered your AIBU as follows. I also voted YANBU for the record.

“all PlanDeRaccordement Thu 02-Sep-21 13:03:31
It’s a good question. No idea if any prolife organisations do support children.

Went to Prolife Action League website and zero mention of helping the women or babies forced to be born.

Went to Human Coalition, and their website says they have a “continuum of care” program where they provide “financial, job training, maternity housing and healthcare, etc.” Support to the women and children.

So evidently some do and some don’t?”[/quote]
I apologise. Responses delay on my device.

Also, just to add, late abortions are extremely rare and there must have been some horrendous implication for mum or foetus's health. So no real reason to bring late abortions in to this issue, surely?

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 19:02

Lidocaine and KCL are also used. There’s even a study on which is better at feticide.

Drugs used to induce fetal demise prior to abortion: a systematic review
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33294839/

Clinicians have used feticidal agents prior to second trimester abortion for many years. Despite the widespread use of various agents to induce fetal demise, a comprehensive or systematic review of the evidence is lacking on the safety, effectiveness, and most effective routes of administration.

Evidence from included cohort studies demonstrates that digoxin, KCL, and lidocaine are all effective in inducing fetal demise. Intra-fetal administration of digoxin is superior to intra-amniotic digoxin administration. Administration of feticide using intracardiac KCL may shorten the abortion experience. Limited data from observational studies also supports an increase in maternal side effects and/or complications related to the administration of digoxin.

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/09/2021 19:01

Idk why people are arguing with Plan. Viable foetuses have to be dead before birth otherwise this would no longer be a late stage abortion but a live birth.

Jaysmith71 · 02/09/2021 19:00

But other countries seem to manage second-trimester terminations without this, just like they manage without operating a death penalty by lethal injection or any other method.

PlanDeRaccordement · 02/09/2021 18:58

[quote Jaysmith71]Digoxin is a heart medicine used by the NHS, "not thought to be harmful during pregnancy:"

www.nhs.uk/medicines/digoxin/[/quote]
Yes but when you inject it in a high enough dose into a fetus, it kills it.

From one of the studies
Intra-amniotic injection of digoxin is a well-known method for feticide before inducing a termination of pregnancy (TOP) at 17-24 weeks of gestation. Information on its effectiveness when administered after 24 weeks of gestation is limited. This study evaluated the efficacy of intra-amniotic digoxin injection for inducing fetal demise within 18-24 hours, at 21-30 weeks of gestation, and its safety.

Intra-amniotic digoxin for feticide between 21 and 30 weeks of gestation: a prospective study
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30703286/