Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.

407 replies

thecranberries · 02/09/2021 12:44

AIBU to ask what Pro Life 'supporters' do to actually help living children in need? Sparked by Rachel Maddow Show Podcast on MSNBC - which gives a brilliant coverage on what's going on.

PL seems to want to stop a woman's right to choose, even in instances of rape or incest. That's in Texas, US, but as we know, many of the 'trends' that start in the US migrate over here. And as we know, there are lots of Pro-Life (read anti abortion, anti women) believers over here.

So, my AIBU is to ask - what do these PL do to actually support actual living children in need in this country or the world? How much do they give to UNICEF/Save the Children etc charities? How much do they donate time, money and resources to actual children living in poverty, bad housing, experiencing harm or bad schooling to ensure that these actual living children get the best life possible?

Do these PL, who cite religious grounds, actually enable women to obtain proper contraception when they need it? And speaking about religion, how many religious PL turn a blind eye to religious organisations history of child abuse?

I don't understand anyone, especially men, who does not accept a woman's right to chose what happens to her own body.

So, AIBU to ask Pro Life supporters to tell me in detail what they do - as actively as supporting their 'cause' - when it comes to helping living children in need?

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 09:50

The sex of a fetus cannot be determined until 14 weeks at the earliest, I cannot support abortion at that stage of pregnancy just because you don't like the flavour nature gave you. There are many good reasons why abortions may take place later than this in pregnancy, choosing the sex of your child is not a good reason

Its very easy to say in a safe little westernised bubble that it's wrong. But girls In other countries are maried off as children. Thrown in the trash at birth. Left to die in menstruation huts. They die of treatable diseases because if having no male family member to agree their treatment. There are countries where domestic violence is the norm. They are shunned by their husbands and their families when their under developed immature bodies don't cope with pregnancy and child birth and they suffer complications. They are trafficked and raped repeatedly. Denied education. Rights to bodily autonomy and god knows what else in this world. If I lived somewhere where these things happened. I'm sure I'd think twice about whether i wanted to bring a girl into this world.

FOJN · 03/09/2021 09:37

Someone terminating because they wanted a girl and not a boy, im still ok with because what’s the point in someone having to raise a baby they don’t want? Being born a boy when they wanted a girl leaves that child open for abuse.

I'm very pro choice but I do not support sex selective abortion unless it is for medical reasons. In parts of the world where sex selective abortion is more common it leads to an imbalance in the male/female sex ratio because boys are favoured over girls. Many men in China will never marry because there are not enough women to marry.

The sex of a fetus cannot be determined until 14 weeks at the earliest, I cannot support abortion at that stage of pregnancy just because you don't like the flavour nature gave you. There are many good reasons why abortions may take place later than this in pregnancy, choosing the sex of your child is not a good reason.

boogiewithasuitcase · 03/09/2021 09:15

@Soubriquet

I am horrified that anyone can support forced birthers

If a 16 year old child wanted to adopt a baby, they would be told no. They are too young

Being raped and then forced to have a child is perfectly fine though. Adoption would not take away the trauma of having to carry and birth a child.

So rape and child abuse have now effectively been legalised in Texas. Congratulations

Soubriquet · 03/09/2021 08:36

I had to think long and hard about late term and selective sex abortions and I’m still ok with it

The chance of anyone terminating a pregnancy at 38 weeks is incredibly minute and it won’t be just because she changed her mind.

Someone terminating because they wanted a girl and not a boy, im still ok with because what’s the point in someone having to raise a baby they don’t want? Being born a boy when they wanted a girl leaves that child open for abuse.

Farevalah · 03/09/2021 08:29

I remember reading about the Kermit Gosnell case (very disturbing BTW) which made me think a lot about abortion. It's hard to justify abortion for one thing but not another. Eg are sex selective abortions OK? Are very late term abortions acceptable, if not, why not?
(I've never had an abortion or considered one so maybe I've just been lucky with contraception.)

There's extreme positions on both sides which muddy the waters as I think that a lot of people fall in the middle ground.

Soubriquet · 03/09/2021 08:18

“I don’t want to wear a mask! It’s my body, my choice!!!”

“Oh you want an abortion?! Tough shit. You don’t get a choice”

What happened to my body my choice?

Oh yeah….ones a woman who is forced to go through with a pregnancy she doesn’t want to give birth to a child that no one wants. Got it

CheekyAFAIK · 03/09/2021 08:01

It's really a challenge to Biden to pack the Supreme Court and give conservatives fuel for culture wars, right?

CheekyAFAIK · 03/09/2021 07:58

Actually the best way to reduce the abortion rate would probably be lots of sex education to prevent pregnancy and financial support for those who have unexpected pregnancies. I'm sure a lot of women abort babies they want because their financial situation is not stable enough to raise a child.

Evangelical types usually hate sex ed and welfare though.

Drgnbllx · 03/09/2021 07:54

@Balonzette

Pro life doesn't mean anti-women.

And why should pro-life supporters provide people with birth control and/or support their children?

I don't really understand why this would be the logical next step 🤔

Yes it does.

You want to deny women choice over their own bodies and force them to give birth.

Imnothereforthedrama · 03/09/2021 07:52

@AlternativePerspective

My DP is a Christian and his ire is that these people aren’t pro life at all, they’re pro birth, with little thought to what happens to everyone once that birth has occurred.

Interesting isn’t it that Texas has banned abortion but still supports the death penalty. Hmm

I agree with your husband it really annoys me when it’s well religious reasons but support the death penalty. It’s bullshit , outdated , ignorant and actually bloody stupid . Support the death penalty and pro life hypocrisy IMO .
EishetChayil · 03/09/2021 07:48

A system is being created where poor disenfranchised women become brood mares for the rich and infertile.

Like "The Handmaid's Tale". Only non-fiction.

PurpleOkapi · 03/09/2021 07:41

@phishy

So who should support that person?
Their parents, until they're of age. Then they should support themselves, same as everyone else.
Drgnbllx · 03/09/2021 07:34

@frome45

I had an abortion at Christmas and it was my only option. I believe no women should be pregnant if she doesn't want to be. I also believe no women should have an abortion if she doesn't want one. On both sides of the debate no one actually cares about giving women a proper choice. in my experience pro choice are as bad as pro life just in different ways
Who exactly is making women who don't want them get abortions?
Soubriquet · 03/09/2021 07:29

Not your body, not your choice.

as early as possible, as late as necessary

Soubriquet · 03/09/2021 07:28

I am horrified that anyone can support forced birthers

If a 16 year old child wanted to adopt a baby, they would be told no. They are too young

Being raped and then forced to have a child is perfectly fine though. Adoption would not take away the trauma of having to carry and birth a child.

AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.
AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.
phishy · 03/09/2021 07:18

So who should support that person?

PurpleOkapi · 03/09/2021 07:17

I doubt you actually believe that being opposed to killing a person or fetus is the same thing as being morally obligated to support that person or fetus for their entire life. IMHO, it's disingenuous to pretend those are the same thing.

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 03/09/2021 07:15

Does anyone think this will tie in with falling birth-rates and health care providers being able to opt out of providing contraception in the US?

It seems like prequel to handmaidens tale to me. Are there many babies for adoption who aren't from removal by state ie drug use. Is it to slowly start increasing birth rates to offset an ageing population

Have women peaked in their mission to have choice and equal opportunities in work and life? Do men and some women want to try to repress and reinstate us as incubators and primary care givers?

I think this is (fake) nostalgia from a time where women stayed home had babies and cooked.

I am very concerned that it will get worse for women not better. We're not there yet, we are not equal but many want us to go backwards for their own ends. Not progress further with our rights

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 03/09/2021 07:01

@Petardos

The theory that it replaces birth control (because feckless, lazy women can't be bothered with birth control) is one of the many ridiculous fallacies anti-abortion people like to trot out.

I am not anti abortion but I can see there is not room for discussion here. However, Yes, there are women that do not use contraception and get pregnant and then want an abortion and pay by the taxpayer. You can’t proof there are none. However, whatever fits with your agenda.

Hilarious!!!!

I'll put myself 'out' there

I have one daughter, pregnancy was ok, being a mother amazing but hard.
I was married for 8 years to her dad he left and cheated before her 1st birthday she was our first.

Talk about a burden on the tax payer, I am now a single working parent on benefits,!used to be homeowner now rental.

After 2 years single I had a few dates with the same guy, called my doctor to get a coil, she said come after your next period. I had protected sex with a condom during that time but he was pressuring me to use the 'pulling out' method. I became pregnant. I'd know him less than a month, I already knew how hard (and rewarding) being a parent could be. I had an abortion.

Do you know what the burden on the tax payer would have been if I had had that child?? Would you be happy to pay maintenance if you had sex and the woman went through with the pregnancy. I had birth control appointment, I should have not put myself at risk before that appointment. I had gotten to know him before I slept with him, I had condoms in my bag (surprise, men don't really like condoms) I didn't want to make a child and raise it/ co-parent with him. I take responsibility but it was the correct decision for me and him, we did discuss it together. Would you plan to have a baby at the start of a new relationship? No. Would you plan to have sex (safe sex preferably) at the start of a new relationship. Yes.

For information I was 27 when my daughter was born and 31 when I had my abortion. Old enough to know better about contraceptive, also old enough and experienced enough to know what having the baby would have been like.

behindhereyes · 03/09/2021 06:25

I'm in America (not Texas) and in my town the PL people do a lot for children and women with unplanned pregnancies. I see drives for nappies and formula and baby clothes all the time that can be dropped off at pro- life centers to be given away for free. The churches really encourage people to foster kids, support groups for women etc. I don't know if I just live in a town that's very charitable but I have to say there seems to be a lot of genuine hands on support from the PL.

Balonzette · 03/09/2021 06:10

Pro life doesn't mean anti-women.

And why should pro-life supporters provide people with birth control and/or support their children?

I don't really understand why this would be the logical next step 🤔

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 06:04

@frome45

I had an abortion at Christmas and it was my only option. I believe no women should be pregnant if she doesn't want to be. I also believe no women should have an abortion if she doesn't want one. On both sides of the debate no one actually cares about giving women a proper choice. in my experience pro choice are as bad as pro life just in different ways
"In my experience pro choice are as bad as pro life just in different ways"

Could you please elaborate on that?

frome45 · 03/09/2021 00:20

I had an abortion at Christmas and it was my only option. I believe no women should be pregnant if she doesn't want to be. I also believe no women should have an abortion if she doesn't want one. On both sides of the debate no one actually cares about giving women a proper choice. in my experience pro choice are as bad as pro life just in different ways

mustlovegin · 02/09/2021 23:46

a Texan woman

Just out of curiosity, how do you legally define a 'Texan woman' and can you no longer be a Texan woman if you change address permanently, for instance?

mumwon · 02/09/2021 23:41

I had erratic periods & my poor gp (only they could test than!) suggested waiting until I was two weeks over missing when I thought might second period would be. Some women have light shows & no symptoms of pregnancy &what if its a very young girl or someone with LD who has been abused?