Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.

407 replies

thecranberries · 02/09/2021 12:44

AIBU to ask what Pro Life 'supporters' do to actually help living children in need? Sparked by Rachel Maddow Show Podcast on MSNBC - which gives a brilliant coverage on what's going on.

PL seems to want to stop a woman's right to choose, even in instances of rape or incest. That's in Texas, US, but as we know, many of the 'trends' that start in the US migrate over here. And as we know, there are lots of Pro-Life (read anti abortion, anti women) believers over here.

So, my AIBU is to ask - what do these PL do to actually support actual living children in need in this country or the world? How much do they give to UNICEF/Save the Children etc charities? How much do they donate time, money and resources to actual children living in poverty, bad housing, experiencing harm or bad schooling to ensure that these actual living children get the best life possible?

Do these PL, who cite religious grounds, actually enable women to obtain proper contraception when they need it? And speaking about religion, how many religious PL turn a blind eye to religious organisations history of child abuse?

I don't understand anyone, especially men, who does not accept a woman's right to chose what happens to her own body.

So, AIBU to ask Pro Life supporters to tell me in detail what they do - as actively as supporting their 'cause' - when it comes to helping living children in need?

OP posts:
TableFlowerss · 03/09/2021 11:46

[quote EKGEMS]@TableFlowerss Do you realize there are 50 states in the USA and there's millions of citizens who don't agree with this new TX law including many, many Texans? You are smearing a lot [/quote]
Of course most people don’t agree with, because it absolutely horrific. What’s that get to do with the price of chickens?

The point is, Texas is a state in the US. The land of the free…. So of course it’s astonishing that even one state has passed this ridiculous law….

2kl4skl · 03/09/2021 11:41

You can believe what you want. If you want to believe in fairies and unicorns, you’re free to. Science doesn’t back up your belief though because no life begins at conception. Only a blastocyst, then an embryo and finally a foetus. It isn’t a life, is isn’t alive and before 22 weeks it has no hope in hell of surviving without the human host it lives in. The woman is, however, alive and should have autonomy over her own body

Human life begins at conception and that's ok. It's ok to end that life, but it's still life. I don't get the parasite thing people go on about. Parasitic organisms are still alive.

Also, 20 years ago, a 22 wheeler wouldn't survive. Hell, decades before that, a 35 seeker wouldn't survive. Your comment implies 'life' is dependent on whatever technology we have at present.

(If you were to admit conception were the bar for life would that make abortion wrong for you?)

The only universal marker for human life can be conception. It's ok to end that life, just like euthanasia and assisted suicide are ok, as it's in everyone's best interest.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:37

With any decision, a certain % will always experience regret. There is no decision in life that is ever regret free.

This includes both deciding to have an abortion AND deciding to have the baby. Yes some women do regret having a child.

So basically counselling is just needed no matter what anyone chooses.

pollypokcet · 03/09/2021 11:26

Anti abortion is not anti women. It's clear that many people are both, but many others are pro-life partly because abortion is such a damaging experience for many women.

To pretty much ban abortion on the grounds that some women have a bad time is anti-woman, hiding behind those people as an excuse. Like banning any other healthcare procedure because some people don't take to it well

But there should be more balance, because some women do regret it. Both sides should be allowed to be heard and counselling always encouraged. I hate that anyone who questions anything is labelled anti straight away

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:22

@VulvaTeeth
Snap! I was writing same argument at same time :)

pollypokcet · 03/09/2021 11:22

@Tubbytenbums

Are these pro life supporters not the first to support the death penalty?????
I'm not even pro life but you can't compare abortion to executing a murderer or rapist, necessarily

For people who believe in capital punishment and not abortion, it's because execution is the ultimate punishment. They have their life taken away because they took someone else's whereas a fetus hasn't had a chance to live yet

Pro life doesn't mean pro every single life, I think it's a bit disingenuous to assume that. Most people would say it's acceptable to kill in self defence but most people aren't 'pro-death'. Just means death is acceptable for them in one scenario

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:21

[quote UpstreamSwimmer]@PlanDeRaccordement

Why? Why is the state obligated to pay for someone's choice on whether to keep their baby or not?[/quote]
Apart from the moral argument for the State paying for abortions, there is also a financial argument. It costs the State less money to provide abortions to women who want them, than it does subsidising the raising of all those resultant children if the women are forced to go through with childbirth. For awhile the US was even making welfare benefits dependent for many mothers on the mother having the contraceptive implant put in...to prevent her getting pregnant and having more children on benefits. They did this to save money.

So it follows, they’d actually save money by letting poor women who want an abortion to have it for free. It’s not going to cost tax payers any additional money.

VulvaTeeth · 03/09/2021 11:19

[quote UpstreamSwimmer]@PlanDeRaccordement

Why? Why is the state obligated to pay for someone's choice on whether to keep their baby or not?[/quote]
Alright, so I'm a woman who can't afford an abortion- so am presumably not in a great financial position to have a child. But I have the child. Now, at the very least, the state is paying for 14 years of education for my subsequent child. It's also likely that I will be claiming some form of social security, due to being in a poor financial position. I'm not sure how Medicaid is funded, but I'm going to be pretty dependent on that for giving birth, any antenatal or postnatal care, any illnesses my child might develop...
From an economic standpoint, it makes no sense for the state to refuse to cover abortions for women who can't afford them.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:16

[quote UpstreamSwimmer]@PlanDeRaccordement

Why? Why is the state obligated to pay for someone's choice on whether to keep their baby or not?[/quote]
I view abortion as part of healthcare and family planning and the ability to have an abortion should not be restricted by unaffordability. Every woman should be able to get one for free. If it’s not free, then you create a rich and poor divide where rich can have abortions, but poor de facto cannot have abortions.

We are not talking about buying luxury items or trips abroad, this is healthcare and healthcare should be universal.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:12

@Whatwouldscullydo

The sex of a fetus cannot be determined until 14 weeks at the earliest, I cannot support abortion at that stage of pregnancy just because you don't like the flavour nature gave you. There are many good reasons why abortions may take place later than this in pregnancy, choosing the sex of your child is not a good reason

Its very easy to say in a safe little westernised bubble that it's wrong. But girls In other countries are maried off as children. Thrown in the trash at birth. Left to die in menstruation huts. They die of treatable diseases because if having no male family member to agree their treatment. There are countries where domestic violence is the norm. They are shunned by their husbands and their families when their under developed immature bodies don't cope with pregnancy and child birth and they suffer complications. They are trafficked and raped repeatedly. Denied education. Rights to bodily autonomy and god knows what else in this world. If I lived somewhere where these things happened. I'm sure I'd think twice about whether i wanted to bring a girl into this world.

But if you lived in one of those countries where women are forced into marriage and have no bodily autonomy, then abortions would also be illegal?

So your scenario is highly unlikely to happen. Because it is part of women’s rights is to have reproductive rights to contraception and abortion. And no country without women’s rights has given women reproductive rights. Finally, in every country so far women’s right to equality (voting, Working, politics, etc) come before women gain reproductive rights.

UpstreamSwimmer · 03/09/2021 11:07

@PlanDeRaccordement

Why? Why is the state obligated to pay for someone's choice on whether to keep their baby or not?

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:06

@UpstreamSwimmer

Payment is another point. Even if some people will concede that - at least in certain cases - the woman can abort her fetus/unborn baby (depending on your view of the subject), there is no real argument for having the government pay for it.
What? Of course there should be universal healthcare and it should cover abortions. Otherwise it discriminates against poor women. Access to a legal abortion means absolutely nothing when it is unaffordable to on segment of the population. And abortions can cost several thousand...which is beyond the reach of even many FT working women. No, the universal healthcare system should pay for it for all women. I know US doesn’t have this, but they could expand Medicaid to include abortion and that would be easy enough to do.
OhRene · 03/09/2021 10:55

@MaskingForIt

I think many see adoption as the ideal outcome for “unwanted” children. By preventing abortion is means there is a steady supply of newborn babies available for childless Christian couples to adopt.
For a huge fee that goes to the Christian adoption agency too.

I believe the basic required fee for adoption agencies located in Texas is currently standing at $38,000.

$38K to buy a baby? No wonder they're anti choice, pro adoption.

UpstreamSwimmer · 03/09/2021 10:55

@Soubriquet

“I don’t want to wear a mask! It’s my body, my choice!!!”

“Oh you want an abortion?! Tough shit. You don’t get a choice”

What happened to my body my choice?

Oh yeah….ones a woman who is forced to go through with a pregnancy she doesn’t want to give birth to a child that no one wants. Got it

Because according to pro-lifers it's not just your body but also the one of the unborn child.

Is this really so difficult for some people to grasp?

UpstreamSwimmer · 03/09/2021 10:52

Payment is another point. Even if some people will concede that - at least in certain cases - the woman can abort her fetus/unborn baby (depending on your view of the subject), there is no real argument for having the government pay for it.

UpstreamSwimmer · 03/09/2021 10:49

@Knittingupastorm

Anti abortion is not anti women. It's clear that many people are both, but many others are pro-life partly because abortion is such a damaging experience for many women.

Oh so they’re protecting women from abortion by forcing them to give birth. This makes total sense.

This is a load of nonsense and anyone who pretends that by and large pro-life is at all about the women, is simply not being truthful.

Pro-life is about protecting the baby. Simple as that.

While pro-abortionists choose to confer human rights in the baby at viability or at birth, pro-lifers believe a baby has human rights and deserves the law's protection from when a heartbeat can be detected.

Either position is an arbitrary one, not backed by anything more than 'That's when I choose to consider a fetus a human being.'

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 10:46

@Tevin

I'm assuming this means any woman (or girl) who finds out she is pregnant after 6 weeks, is unable to access abortion in another state and then has complications during her pregnancy requiring extra medical care will have to not only continue a pregnancy she doesn't want, birth a child she doesn't want but also pay for the medical bills during the pregnancy and labour she didn't want?
Yes. And I think average cost of even a uncomplicated childbirth is eyewatering.

Although Texas did keep their judicial bypass for minors who want an abortion. So the 6 week limit applies to adult women, not minor girls.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 10:42

@mustlovegin

Perhaps more emphasis should be placed on contraception so that these pregnancies don't happen in the first places (with the exception of those resulting from rape and other exceptions, obviously)
As I posted before research done by Planned Parenthood discovered that roughly half of abortions are needed due to contraception failure. Think about that 99% effectI’ve at preventing pregnancy rate, sounds good, but it means for 1 in 100 women, 1 will fall pregnant due to contraception failure. When you considered hundreds of millions of women taking contraception, it is easy to see that you will need a millions of abortions just due to contraception failure.
PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 10:38

The law as it stands now is that anyone - anywhere - who 'aides and abets' any Texan woman/girl to have an abortion can be sued for $10,000 plus legal costs.

This is inaccurate. Texas law only applies within the borders of Texas. So it’s not “anyone -anywhere” but “anyone in Texas”. They also have to be knowingly helping her...if she calls a taxi and taxi driver has no idea she is pregnant, can’t be sued.

This means that a woman can legally drive herself or use public transport like a Greyhound bus or an Amtrak train or even an Uber to go to another State and have an abortion.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 10:33

@Hereslookingatyoukid

Apologies of this has already been covered - I did read through but might have missed it. Would women in Texas who travel out of state either for an abortion or to discuss their options also be at risk of prosecution? I'm thinking of the women from Ireland who would travel to London/other parts of England to have abortions when abortion was not available legally there.
No. It is perfectly legal to drive or take a bus to another state for an abortion. Unfortunately, many of the states adjacent to Texas have similarly heavily restricted abortion. The woman would also have to pay for the abortion (most abortions aren’t covered by health insurance anyway), so affordability is a problem even in the liberal States that have abortion laws similar to U.K.
DuncinToffee · 03/09/2021 10:03

'I want an abortion' should be enough reason for one.

Not allowing sex selection will also lead to unsafe backstreet practices and babies being abandoned at birth.

QualityMarguerite · 03/09/2021 09:57

Sex selection isn’t an issue in wealthy and educated societies. Abortion in these cases reflects inequality and if women’s rights and roles are prioritised then the birth rate slows and the sex imbalance equalises.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 03/09/2021 09:56

I'm very pro choice but I do not support sex selective abortion unless it is for medical reasons

Then you are not very pro choice are you? Can you honestly not see why some women would actively avoid bringing a girl into their world?

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 03/09/2021 09:53

@behindhereyes

I'm in America (not Texas) and in my town the PL people do a lot for children and women with unplanned pregnancies. I see drives for nappies and formula and baby clothes all the time that can be dropped off at pro- life centers to be given away for free. The churches really encourage people to foster kids, support groups for women etc. I don't know if I just live in a town that's very charitable but I have to say there seems to be a lot of genuine hands on support from the PL.
That's nice and everything, but free nappies are a drop in the fucking ocean of having to raise your rapist's child, or raise a child while still a child yourself, or not be able to go back to work/school because of a child you didn't want, or just purely go through having to bear and raise a child that you don't want to bear and raise.

If women are genuinely contemplating abortion because they don't know how they'll keep a baby in nappies and formula and otherwise want to keep it and that helps them, great. But a few free nappies and formula are nothing on the scale of what it takes - financially, emotionally, physically, logistically - to have a child, and forced-birthers shouldn't fool themselves that they've made it aaaaaaall better.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 09:53

If men are sad they have no one to marry they should ask themselves why.

Women are not mens property we don't have children just so men have someone to marry Hmm