Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how much support Pro-Life believers provide for actual children in need? Texas just banned abortion in the US.

407 replies

thecranberries · 02/09/2021 12:44

AIBU to ask what Pro Life 'supporters' do to actually help living children in need? Sparked by Rachel Maddow Show Podcast on MSNBC - which gives a brilliant coverage on what's going on.

PL seems to want to stop a woman's right to choose, even in instances of rape or incest. That's in Texas, US, but as we know, many of the 'trends' that start in the US migrate over here. And as we know, there are lots of Pro-Life (read anti abortion, anti women) believers over here.

So, my AIBU is to ask - what do these PL do to actually support actual living children in need in this country or the world? How much do they give to UNICEF/Save the Children etc charities? How much do they donate time, money and resources to actual children living in poverty, bad housing, experiencing harm or bad schooling to ensure that these actual living children get the best life possible?

Do these PL, who cite religious grounds, actually enable women to obtain proper contraception when they need it? And speaking about religion, how many religious PL turn a blind eye to religious organisations history of child abuse?

I don't understand anyone, especially men, who does not accept a woman's right to chose what happens to her own body.

So, AIBU to ask Pro Life supporters to tell me in detail what they do - as actively as supporting their 'cause' - when it comes to helping living children in need?

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 19:32

@Whatwouldscullydo

But all that does is punish the women and the girls then born as opposed to out any pressure on the men to change.

If men want to see more if a balance they need timask.themsekves why so many women opt out of giving them a steady stream of girls to abuse. If men want a wife they need to become someone worthy of marrying.

But that wouldn’t work in the countries you are talking about where women have no rights at all. Women there don’t have access to abortions and the are illegal. So there isn’t going to be any sex selection abortions as an act of rebellion to get men to change their ways.

All they can do is what the Tasmanian women did. Kill every child of theirs that is born, understanding that they themselves may be killed for infanticide.

forinborin · 03/09/2021 19:23

To answer the question.

I am mildly pro-life, but also an atheist and not a part of any organisation. I believe that the legal right to abortion should be there (so Texan laws are quite extreme), but ideally would like to see fewer abortions and also access restricted - say, later than the first trimester only in cases of foetal abnormality, or danger to the mother's life. I financially support an orphanage and if someone close to me was considering termination I'd offer more individual support, down to adopting.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 19:16

Again thats something very easy to say. And logically absolutely that makes sense.

But these women aren't in a position to think about some greater good 50 years on the future are they. They only have the here and now.

FOJN · 03/09/2021 19:13

Not to provide " safety in numbers" and absorb mens issues.

Whilst there is safety in numbers for women my point isn't about either of those things. If you support sex selective abortion because men are oppressors then when and how does that change?

I agree with Lizzie that it is not usually women choosing to abort female fetuses, they are being forced/coerced by men, we should challenge that not make it easier for men to justify their oppressive behaviour.

LizzieW1969 · 03/09/2021 19:04

But is it the women choosing for themselves to abort healthy female foetuses? Sometimes yes, no doubt, but there are surely plenty of women forced to abort their babies by their husbands and MILs.

I’ve worked with a project that supports Central Asian women; this really is distressingly common in those countries, women being forced to abort a baby because it’s a girl.

It isn’t necessarily pro choice at all.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 18:47

Babies should be born because they are wanted and loved. Not to provide " safety in numbers" and absorb mens issues.

Whatwouldscullydo · 03/09/2021 18:42

But all that does is punish the women and the girls then born as opposed to out any pressure on the men to change.

If men want to see more if a balance they need timask.themsekves why so many women opt out of giving them a steady stream of girls to abuse. If men want a wife they need to become someone worthy of marrying.

FOJN · 03/09/2021 18:31

Its very easy to say in a safe little westernised bubble that it's wrong. But girls In other countries are maried off as children. Thrown in the trash at birth. Left to die in menstruation huts. They die of treatable diseases because if having no male family member to agree their treatment. There are countries where domestic violence is the norm. They are shunned by their husbands and their families when their under developed immature bodies don't cope with pregnancy and child birth and they suffer complications. They are trafficked and raped repeatedly. Denied education. Rights to bodily autonomy and god knows what else in this world. If I lived somewhere where these things happened. I'm sure I'd think twice about whether i wanted to bring a girl into this world.

I'm struggling to understand how you think women subjected to oppression and abuse would be better off if there were proportionately fewer of them and proportionately more men. Sounds like a way to make Gilead a reality because I don't think the men that make laws and influence culture in those countries are going to have a sudden change of heart about the value of women.

Sex selective abortion is eugenics, opposing it does not change the fact I am pro choice just because some people may think an abortion at anytime for any reason should be a right.

I'm trying to understand if some posters believe that terminating a healthy foetus at near full term just because the mother demands it is OK?

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 17:38

@Mummyford

Yes the law disproportionately affects disadvantaged women. Well off women will have no trouble just buying a plane ticket. Ok off women can drive or take a bus. But poor women are truly stuck.

I was just correcting the prior poster who said anyone anywhere can be prosecuted for helping a Texan woman, which isn’t true. It’s only anyone in Texas who knowingly helps that can be prosecuted. Texas law doesn’t apply to anyone outside Texas.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 16:49

@BiBabbles
Excellent post. You wrote
“I don't think most people who vote for pro-life legislators are part of pro-life groups. I know churches with hundreds of people who vote for these types of politicans and maybe a handful will actively be part of those groups who do these actions. For most, it's just being part of the group - we are X so we believe Y. The work done to make it part of the Evangelical identity has a lot written on it - it didn't used to be that way, it was cultural shift and backlash to the '60s to get them useful for political groups. It's had some nasty ramifications.”

I did post earlier in the thread about this as many were blaming “the Catholics” for the law in Texas, when Catholics as you know are a minority so couldn’t have done all this by themselves. I posted an interview question response from a Professor that studies the rise of prolife amongst evangelical Protestants. It was a fascinating read to see how they began to shift from prochoice to prolife in the 1970s.

I am glad you have corroborated that because it is important to know WHO exactly is behind these laws and WHY they are getting them passed.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 16:43

@dreamingbohemian

Great post.
I agree people don’t arbitrarily draw those lines, they do use both moral and scientific information when making that choice for themselves about the ethics of abortion. I agree can’t impose personal ethics on all women.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 16:40

@Urghhhhh
But we pull the plug on people on life support all the time. That invalidates your argument.

Actually it doesn’t invalidate @Lycanthropology argument at all. They were just saying that having the right to life as a person doesn’t include all that is a human life.

So when it’s a person capable of consent, they consent to maintaining or ending their life (dialysis, transplants, assisted suicide, etc). But when the person cannot consent, there is always next of kin who do have to consent to end that life. Embryonic or Fetal life is also life, but they are not a person, and so the consent always automatically reverts to the pregnant woman carrying that embryo or fetus. She decides to maintain or end that life.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 16:34

@Jaysmith71
A fertilised egg is no different until it reaches some point where it can survive independently of the host mother. Once it reaches this point where it can be said to be a living organism in itself, then it can have rights, which it does not lose until death.

Currently, in most countries, legally you are not person with rights until after you are born. Even a fetus at 24weeks (point where they can survive outside the womb with medical assistance) is not a person and has no rights. It’s ok that this is your personal ethical line as to when a fetus gains personhood.

CaptSkippy · 03/09/2021 15:39

@BiBabbles That is the most sensible post I have seen on this issue so far. Anti-abortionists don't care if women die or end up disabled from giving birth. The "vessel" matters very little to them as long as she is not free to live her life the way she wants.

BiBabbles · 03/09/2021 14:40

Many US states have been trying and had these type of laws repealed for decades. I'm not sure how its surprising to anyone at this point. This has little to do with Texas and all to do with another run at the Supreme Court. It would be laughable if it wasn't so fucked up.

In America a lot of the Christian pro lifers will actually provide and/or find homes for the babies.

It may be a lot, but it is no where near the majority and the efforts described are largely only apply to single women. Married women are treated very differently and while they may get some items, are largely ignored.

A married woman cannot legally adopt out a child on her own -- which may be why married women make up a significant proportion of those who get abortions. More than 1 in 4 abortions in the US last I read, with some places having far higher stats but not everywhere collects that data.

No one would want that. But why is the answer to kill them?

Because abortion has less risks to the pregnant woman or pregnant girl.

It's constantly discussed how pregnancy and childbirth related complication can end up with lifelong consequences that are often ignored. I think that promoting an ideology that speaks against having available a less risky option is to dismiss those risks as unimportant - that those who choose to risk them aren't doing anything really of value because it's just something we should do.

And with no crystal ball, we cannot always determine risk to life and long-term health beforehand to enable legislative exceptions to be used.

Why isn't the answer to ask why women are so disadvantaged in society in so many way?

Women of all backgrounds get abortions. Disadvantaged women are just most likely to be harmed if abortion is hard to obtain legally which is why many focus their concern there. Those well to do will get around the rules.

Almost all pro life groups have an outreach and support group. They are often well funded and do provide practical support eg clothing, baby essentials and in some cases housing etc in the US.

I don't think most people who vote for pro-life legislators are part of pro-life groups. I know churches with hundreds of people who vote for these types of politicans and maybe a handful will actively be part of those groups who do these actions. For most, it's just being part of the group - we are X so we believe Y. The work done to make it part of the Evangelical identity has a lot written on it - it didn't used to be that way, it was cultural shift and backlash to the '60s to get them useful for political groups. It's had some nasty ramifications.

The whole pro-abortion movement is just about choosing an arbitrary point, up to which they allow termination of (at the very least potential) human life. To pretend that anyone disagreeing with that arbitrary point is an oppressor of women is simply disingenuous.

No, the whole point for most of it is that the pregnant woman's or girl's life that actually entirely exists should be what we consider rather than any potential - what are her risks? Is she happy accepting those risks for the potential benefit? If not, how do we lower her risks to an accepted level? In the late-term abortions which are vanishingly small amount and pretty much always involves the news that the desired benefit is not going to be reality, how does she want to handle that? Unwanted pregnancies have a higher risk rates for nearly everything for a whole host of reasons, why would we want anyone to take risks they didn't choose if there is a less risky alternative?

behindhereyes · 03/09/2021 14:31

BuffySummersReportingForSanity

"That's nice and everything, but free nappies are a drop in the fucking ocean of having to raise your rapist's child, or raise a child while still a child yourself, or not be able to go back to work/school because of a child you didn't want, or just purely go through having to bear and raise a child that you don't want to bear and raise.

If women are genuinely contemplating abortion because they don't know how they'll keep a baby in nappies and formula and otherwise want to keep it and that helps them, great. But a few free nappies and formula are nothing on the scale of what it takes - financially, emotionally, physically, logistically - to have a child, and forced-birthers shouldn't fool themselves that they've made it aaaaaaall better."
Sorry I don't know how to tag on the phone app. I was responding to the op's original post of do PL people actually provide any real support. I was never asserting that this would be enough to change someone's mind, simply stating what I have observed the pro lifers in my town doing to provide practical support.

Lycanthropology · 03/09/2021 14:07

But we pull the plug on people on life support all the time. That invalidates your argument

I obviously didn't make my point clear, because it wasn't that all life should be protected. I'm not pro-life at all.
I was asking how those who think that life is defined by its being independent and unsupported view those cases. I gave no opinion of my own.

Jaysmith71 · 03/09/2021 13:46

True, but that is just an arbitrary view.

It is arbitrary. Not in a flip-a-coin way but based on a pragmatic calculation of what we can do.

It is not unlike the evolving concept of what constitutes death. Certainly not an absence of breathing or a heartbeat, both of which can be remedied. Death is an arbitrary point after which the patient cannot be revived, given the availability of assistance wherever they happen to be, and/or how long it would take to bring that assitance to the patient or the patient to the assistance.

Viability is also a moving target. It's the best we can do.

dreamingbohemian · 03/09/2021 12:56

The problem is that the question of when life begins is not a scientific one, it is an ethical question. There is no objectively correct answer. It depends on how you define 'life' and more specifically 'human life'.

I don't think anyone in this debate picks an arbitrary time point. Anti-abortion people say either at conception or at fertilization. Pro-choice people tend to say either after the first trimester or the point of viability.

You can make an ethical argument for any of those time points.

The problem is when you want to enforce your ethical interpretation on everyone else. That is in fact oppressing women because you are taking away their ability to make their own ethical choices.

There is a solid basis for outlawing, say, murder because murder has been taboo in most societies throughout history. There is a consensus that it is bad. But this consensus does not exist for abortion and so it is wrong to impose your own ethics on everyone else.

Urghhhhh · 03/09/2021 12:48

@Lycanthropology

Excellent point *@2kl4skl*

It’s bizarre that some make the case that there is only “life”, or life worth protecting, when it can survive independently and unsupported. Imagine applying this to people in comas, on life support, kidney dialysis etc.?
Do they lose their right to life?

BTW I am not arguing that it is wrong to end embryonic life; I’m totally pro choice, but am puzzled by the life beginning at x stage position.

But we pull the plug on people on life support all the time. That invalidates your argument.
UpstreamSwimmer · 03/09/2021 12:46

@Jaysmith71

An unfertilised egg is alive, but it is not a life. Left to its own devices, it cannot survive. Ditto a sperm.

A fertilised egg is no different until it reaches some point where it can survive independently of the host mother. Once it reaches this point where it can be said to be a living organism in itself, then it can have rights, which it does not lose until death.

This is not holy writ. Just pragmatic ethics.

True, but that is just an arbitrary view. The argument can just as well be made that left to its own devices, a fetus will eventually develop into a 90 year old human. And on the other extreme, why not argue that poor woman who will struggle to raise their child etc should have the right to 'abort' their baby up to a month after birth?

The whole pro-abortion movement is just about choosing an arbitrary point, up to which they allow termination of (at the very least potential) human life. To pretend that anyone disagreeing with that arbitrary point is an oppressor of women is simply disingenuous.

Jaysmith71 · 03/09/2021 12:37

An unfertilised egg is alive, but it is not a life. Left to its own devices, it cannot survive. Ditto a sperm.

A fertilised egg is no different until it reaches some point where it can survive independently of the host mother. Once it reaches this point where it can be said to be a living organism in itself, then it can have rights, which it does not lose until death.

This is not holy writ. Just pragmatic ethics.

Lycanthropology · 03/09/2021 12:10

Excellent point @2kl4skl

It’s bizarre that some make the case that there is only “life”, or life worth protecting, when it can survive independently and unsupported. Imagine applying this to people in comas, on life support, kidney dialysis etc.?
Do they lose their right to life?

BTW I am not arguing that it is wrong to end embryonic life; I’m totally pro choice, but am puzzled by the life beginning at x stage position.

PlanDeRaccordement · 03/09/2021 11:52

@2kl4skl

I agree. Idk why some people insist an embryo or fetus “isn’t alive or a life”. It absolutely is a life and alive, it’s just not a person with rights. The only person with rights is the pregnant woman.

TableFlowerss · 03/09/2021 11:50

@EKGEMS

Sorry I hit post too soon-of Americans who absolutely are more progressive than TX? I could use stereotypes to describe the UK and it would only showcase my ignorance like you do *@TableFlowerss*
What you getting yourself all stressed about?

You’re point about being ignorant makes no sense at all.

The fact a law has been passed is barbaric. The fact it’s been allowed to happen is barbaric.