Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think shyness ruins your life?

164 replies

shylady75 · 01/09/2021 23:24

I’ve always been chronically shy. School was a real ordeal for me - I never made many friends and whenever the teacher singled me out I would go bright red and freeze up. This made me an easy target for bullies from a young age.

In adulthood I hoped things would improve as I got older but they never did - I now blush and sweat profusely whenever any sort of attention is directed towards me.

I was a straight A student at school but never achieved much career-wise, and I blame my shyness for this. Let’s face it, no one wants to hire the blushing sweaty awkward person over someone ‘normal’, no matter how good their CV.

I do have a lovely DH and two DC, who are also showing signs of shyness and that worries me a lot - the last thing I want is for them to turn out like me and struggle the way I did.

I see a lot in the media about people being more accepting of mental health issues, but shyness to the extent that you’re blushing and sweating is still a big taboo.

AIBU to think shyness is a terrible condition that ruins lives?

OP posts:
Holskey · 02/09/2021 17:11

@largebouquet, totally agree. @stepupandbecounted, lots of contradictions there and very difficult to grasp the nature of your daughter's shyness, confidence, self-esteem, social skills or anything else.

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 16:33

Okay she is very chatty and confident with family and close friends, but at school she feels put on the spot when asked questions and doesn't enjoy small talk generally with anyone. So she is both. Shy with people she doesn't know, not shy with people she knows well.

I think her shyness hampers her education as she is finds speaking in public hard and keeps quiet when she could be more engaged. She seems to like a low key social life. She is not old enough to know if it will impact her ambitions. I can't think the blushing is comfortable for her, even if she doesn't complain about it.

LargeBouquet · 02/09/2021 15:23

@stepupandbecounted

coriander no she is most definitely shy. She blushes terribly when the teachers speaks to her or other parents, especially the good looking male ones, she dreads social occasions and she is most definitely shy as all of her school reports will testify, much to my anger. She is 100% shy but we don't draw attention to it, and wish the teachers would stop banging on about it to be honest. I refuse to see it in a negative light. I don't want her to think it is inherently wrong and something that needs to be fixed, it is just how she is.
But now you're saying something quite different to your previous post about her, which presents her as speaking frequently, if quietly, having her opinions valued, socially mature in that she knows what she can deal with, turns down stuff she doesn't like, independent-minded and secure in herself -- nothing wrong there. She sounds admirable together for her age.

But in this post, you say she blushes terribly when parents or teachers speak to her, dreads social occasions, and her teachers clearly perceive her shyness as limiting (which I know you are irritated by, but isn't there a point at which you think that if a lot of the adults who see her regularly with her peers think this, that it is genuinely limiting, rather than them being unreasonable?)

Is her shyness hampering her life, education, ambitions etc or not? Does it curtail her sense of herself?

sleepygnome · 02/09/2021 15:17

We live in a world made for extroverts by extroverts. If you are shy or have social phobia it's hell.

shylady75 · 02/09/2021 14:42

When I got on the train to go off to University, I told myself I was not going to be shy any more.
I got off the train not shy. An act of will. I have not been shy since.

I did laugh at this - I've tried it many times. If only it was that simple.

OP posts:
shylady75 · 02/09/2021 14:38

I expect they might be similar to the ones I've employed with my DS (who is prone to shyness) which is to make him to do the things that make him feel uncomfortable, i.e. from an early age, if he wanted an ice-cream he had to go into the shop and ask for one; I refused to ask for him. At restaurants, if he wanted Fish and Chips, he had to order it (or else I'd order him something less appealing). I made him call grandparents on the phone to thank them for gifts (or he didn't get to play with the gift). When we were visiting our friends/family, I brought him into conversation, even though he was squirming with embarrassment and I knew he'd prefer to say nothing (e.g. "Tell Aunt Sue what happened when we went to the farm on Tuesday").

My parents tried this approach with me and I'm sorry to say it made no difference whatsoever - if anything it made me worse, as I felt so desperately self conscious being put on the spot.

I've now got to the point where I won't even walk into a restaurant to ask for a table - I'll ask DH to go in first.

When I'm meeting someone I will feel extremely nervous and anxious beforehand and my mood will get very low.

OP posts:
shylady75 · 02/09/2021 14:18

I would say she is very confident in herself compared to her peers, she doesn't go to places she doesn't like, she is happy to turn down the many invitations she gets, she takes care of herself and her well being because she is not reliant on other people socially, she can take it or leave it.

Your daughter doesn't sound shy to me either! I never got invited to anything at school because I barely had any friends. I'm not confident in myself at all and have very low self esteem, which I think is a big part of my problem. I think I'm very boring, dry company and seem to have a knack of saying the wrong thing, so it's understandable that no one would want to be friends with me.

I'm also very inarticulate around everyone except my DH, partly because I can't relax enough to tell a funny story or be the centre of attention for more than a few seconds. With DH I can chat for ages, but not with anyone else.

OP posts:
shylady75 · 02/09/2021 14:11

I haven't read all the replies yet, I will work my way through now - but to respond to some people's questions:

I've just looked up the signs of autism and don't think I have that. I think my issue is debilitating social anxiety. I was badly bullied at school for the blushing and sweating - that knocked my confidence hugely and made me even more frightened to speak up in class or make friends.

I did go to university but was a complete loner - I avoided all social contact as I was too scared to talk to anyone. I didn't make one friend during my whole time at uni.

Despite doing well academically I was never able to get a decent job because I fluffed every interview I went to. I still remember some of the baffled looks on interviewers' faces when I started clamming up and going bright red. It still gives me shivers.

I wouldn't say my parents are outgoing, but they're not shy either - they're just 'normal' really and have a good social life.

OP posts:
stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 14:11

coriander no she is most definitely shy. She blushes terribly when the teachers speaks to her or other parents, especially the good looking male ones, she dreads social occasions and she is most definitely shy as all of her school reports will testify, much to my anger. She is 100% shy but we don't draw attention to it, and wish the teachers would stop banging on about it to be honest. I refuse to see it in a negative light. I don't want her to think it is inherently wrong and something that needs to be fixed, it is just how she is.

CorianderBee · 02/09/2021 14:07

@stepupandbecounted

My dd is a shy teen, and I am kind of horrified reading the negativity on here. I get that life might be easier if can handle everything the world has to offer, and not feel uncomfortable, but the beauty, kindness and intelligence is what makes my dd a stand out, not the decibels of her voice. When she speaks, which is often, it is considered, thoughtful and interesting to people, her opinions often carry more authority because she isn't delivering them 247. People actually listen to her. Being a brilliant listener herself means she has gained so much wisdom and knowledge, she doesn't 'steal the show' and respect other people's space and personalities. I would say she is very confident in herself compared to her peers, she doesn't go to places she doesn't like, she is happy to turn down the many invitations she gets, she takes care of herself and her well being because she is not reliant on other people socially, she can take it or leave it. Gloriously happy in her own company she never suffers from FOMO and couldn't care less about the dramas in school.

I see her introversion as liberation!!

I on the other hand, as an extrovert am entirely dependent on socialising to feel happy, I get my energy from being out with other people not the other way around, so I am kind of needy in a way my dd will never be. I feel envious of her independence and her ability to be completely herself. It is a super power of sorts. She is entirely self sufficient emotionally, mentally and physically. I admire her, she has many people around her that do, and value the beautiful soul she is.

How you can describe a life with a good job, an excellent education, a happy marriage and two children as a life 'ruined' is beyond me. It sounds a little ungrateful and misguided to say the least. You have achieved what many would love to have. So it can't have held you back that much op.

Start to value your silence, your gentle soul and be who are you, and then maybe it won't feel so painful anymore. Why force yourself to be something you are not. Find a life that suits you and your tastes, you do not need to live a life as an actor.

If your DD is confident, happy to speak when she chooses to, eloquent and able to speak up, and secure in herself then... she is not shy!

Quiet doesn't equal shy.

RantyAunty · 02/09/2021 13:58

Shyness is probably learned behaviour. It doesn't helped being labeled it as then you tend to live up to that label.

There were times as a child I was painfully child but that had more to do with being punished and not really allowed to have friends.

Then I wasn't shy in high school or uni. I was an entertainer for awhile and not shy.

Then I experienced abuse and became painfully shy again. Fear of being punished, shamed, humiliated, rejected. Just now coming out of it.

It really isn't some innate unchangeable trait.

Ireolu · 02/09/2021 13:39

Get your children into extracurricular activities that push them out of their comfort zone. It helps confidence building

LargeBouquet · 02/09/2021 13:16

@stepupandbecounted

My dd is a shy teen, and I am kind of horrified reading the negativity on here. I get that life might be easier if can handle everything the world has to offer, and not feel uncomfortable, but the beauty, kindness and intelligence is what makes my dd a stand out, not the decibels of her voice. When she speaks, which is often, it is considered, thoughtful and interesting to people, her opinions often carry more authority because she isn't delivering them 247. People actually listen to her. Being a brilliant listener herself means she has gained so much wisdom and knowledge, she doesn't 'steal the show' and respect other people's space and personalities. I would say she is very confident in herself compared to her peers, she doesn't go to places she doesn't like, she is happy to turn down the many invitations she gets, she takes care of herself and her well being because she is not reliant on other people socially, she can take it or leave it. Gloriously happy in her own company she never suffers from FOMO and couldn't care less about the dramas in school.

I see her introversion as liberation!!

I on the other hand, as an extrovert am entirely dependent on socialising to feel happy, I get my energy from being out with other people not the other way around, so I am kind of needy in a way my dd will never be. I feel envious of her independence and her ability to be completely herself. It is a super power of sorts. She is entirely self sufficient emotionally, mentally and physically. I admire her, she has many people around her that do, and value the beautiful soul she is.

How you can describe a life with a good job, an excellent education, a happy marriage and two children as a life 'ruined' is beyond me. It sounds a little ungrateful and misguided to say the least. You have achieved what many would love to have. So it can't have held you back that much op.

Start to value your silence, your gentle soul and be who are you, and then maybe it won't feel so painful anymore. Why force yourself to be something you are not. Find a life that suits you and your tastes, you do not need to live a life as an actor.

You seem to be conflating introversion and shyness. Your DD doesn't sound at all shy -- she sounds mature and quietly self-confident.
problembottom · 02/09/2021 13:09

This was me at school OP. Extremely bright but painfully shy. Teenage years were awful. It's just so debilitating isn't it.

By my mid 20s I'd become confident in my own skin and began to really start living. I'm now in my 30s and newer friends just wouldn't recognise me as a kid.

Interesting posters have mentioned ASD, I've often wondered if that's why I was so very shy. I can see traits in my dad.

mewkins · 02/09/2021 13:01

@SimonJT

I’m quite shy, on my first date with my husband I barely spoke at all. Once I know someone I’m quite confident and they have trouble shutting me up, but if we’re in a large group (of people I know), I can still sometimes feel quite shy and feel more comfortable being the observer of the group.

Shyness hasn’t ruined my life at all, I have friends, a husband and a lovely little boy, shyness doesn’t need to have a big negative impact on your life.

I'm similar to you. I like to observe when in large groups and just chip in when others stop talking over each other. I was painfully shy as a kid but now am happy meeting new people. I don't think my shyness was caused by any of these things. My parents were sociable and outgoing and encouraged me. It was just me. I liked to live in my own head and didn't really need others. Also, in the 80s I'm pretty sure people would have thought my parents were crazy to look for help for shyness. It was just a thing that some kids were. It is only an issue if it holds you back. If you feel it does then perhaps developing some techniques to overcome shyness would help.
stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 13:00

SORRY for typos, pressed send before checking :)

stepupandbecounted · 02/09/2021 12:58

My dd is a shy teen, and I am kind of horrified reading the negativity on here. I get that life might be easier if can handle everything the world has to offer, and not feel uncomfortable, but the beauty, kindness and intelligence is what makes my dd a stand out, not the decibels of her voice.
When she speaks, which is often, it is considered, thoughtful and interesting to people, her opinions often carry more authority because she isn't delivering them 247. People actually listen to her.
Being a brilliant listener herself means she has gained so much wisdom and knowledge, she doesn't 'steal the show' and respect other people's space and personalities.
I would say she is very confident in herself compared to her peers, she doesn't go to places she doesn't like, she is happy to turn down the many invitations she gets, she takes care of herself and her well being because she is not reliant on other people socially, she can take it or leave it. Gloriously happy in her own company she never suffers from FOMO and couldn't care less about the dramas in school.

I see her introversion as liberation!!

I on the other hand, as an extrovert am entirely dependent on socialising to feel happy, I get my energy from being out with other people not the other way around, so I am kind of needy in a way my dd will never be. I feel envious of her independence and her ability to be completely herself. It is a super power of sorts. She is entirely self sufficient emotionally, mentally and physically. I admire her, she has many people around her that do, and value the beautiful soul she is.

How you can describe a life with a good job, an excellent education, a happy marriage and two children as a life 'ruined' is beyond me. It sounds a little ungrateful and misguided to say the least. You have achieved what many would love to have. So it can't have held you back that much op.

Start to value your silence, your gentle soul and be who are you, and then maybe it won't feel so painful anymore. Why force yourself to be something you are not. Find a life that suits you and your tastes, you do not need to live a life as an actor.

spartanthehorse · 02/09/2021 12:52

Yes totally. I am also very shy. I actually loved school and had lots of friends but hated speaking in front of the class and it definitely held me back. I was offered interviews at Oxbridge but was too shy to go through with them so accepted the uni where I didn't have to interview I made myself travel the world and go into a job where I have to speak a lot but it still holds me back, everything seems like a battle whereas to others life seems to come more easily.

Jigsawtrain · 02/09/2021 12:43

I also think that if you’re working in a role where you have to speak to people you don’t know, as you become more confident in your role the less shy you become. Get yourself out there @shylady75

MedusasBadHairDay · 02/09/2021 12:27

Jigsawtrain Shop work helped me too, ended up in a role where I had to approach customers to sell them stuff. Which is awful, especially when so many people would really rather you didn't. 😂 But it did mean that the more I did it the less anxious and shy I became.

The other thing I found useful was to alar create a character in my head and approach people as that character. That character was much less self conscious so able to handle social situations better. It sounds daft, but it works.

Karmagoat · 02/09/2021 12:24

I was a painfully shy child, like others have said this was always remarked upon negatively by family and teachers so the shyness became full blown social anxiety.
I'm not as bad as I used to be but I think that's down to age as I'm 46 now and I have learnt almost to 'mirror' more outgoing and social people to appear more 'normal' whatever that means.
I would definitely say it had hindered me career wise though not so much on a personal level as I'm happily married and have 2 dcs and a small circle of good friends.
I do remember one of my teachers in secondary school asking my Mum if I might have autism and had she looked into it, but my Mum actually took offence to that Hmm, probably because back then autism was less known about or diagnosed than it is now, but still.
I do definitely think I'm on the spectrum in some way though, I think it's too late to get diagnosed now, what would be the point?

SirenSays · 02/09/2021 12:21

I'm painfully shy and found faking it only works in short bursts. Fine to have a chat to a cab driver for example, but utterly exhausting and soul destroying to do every day at work.

TreeSmuggler · 02/09/2021 12:21

I didn’t know how respond or start conversation with people. I got lonely so to break the cycle I copied the behaviour of a sociable person I knew. Yes, it’s fakery but it got me friends. It worked very well.

Interesting because I tried this and it didn't work at all. Things that got positive responses, laughter and conversation when said or done by my friend got blank stares and Confused looks when said or done by me.

I have really tried to overcome my shyness and to some extent I have, but unfortunately I'm still boring and awkward as hell. The difference is everyone knows for sure now because I'm talking to everyone (they aren't enjoying it though Blush).

Is there any cure for being awkward?

Jigsawtrain · 02/09/2021 12:20

I disagree. I was awfully shy, even at 15 I used to hide behind my mum if someone spoke to me. Then I got a job in a shop and had to speak. After that I got a job as a carer. I still blush and get flustered if I feel paranoid about too much attention on me but I’ve not let it hold me back at all. I have a successful career and a good group of friends. I also have never told my children they’re shy even when they were because it’s unhelpful.

So yes there are things you can do to combat it.

MedusasBadHairDay · 02/09/2021 12:19

Shy people are introverts aren’t they? There’s nothing wrong with being an introvert.

I don't think they are the same thing, though admittedly they do tend to occur together a fair bit. But it's definitely possible to be an introvert and not shy - introverts are more of a personality trait (that's not changeable IME) whereas shyness is an anxiety thing and can be improved on. It's not easy, and I think you have to take baby steps. I was painfully painfully shy as a child, I'm better as an adult, but I do have to work on it constantly. I have to psyche myself up to talk to people, and do a lot of rehearsing of what I'm going to say (though that can sometimes backfire and make me more anxious).

I wouldn't say it's ruined my life, not at all, it's made some areas more challenging definitely. If I could wave a wand and not be shy at all, I would, but I also know that with effort I can diminish the fear a little.