Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a 3 & 4 year old should sit quietly through a wedding?

264 replies

appleturnovers · 01/09/2021 22:08

I went to a wedding last week and I was pretty embarrassed as there were two children, 3 and 4 years old, who were just walking around wherever they wanted and speaking quite loudly, at points drowning out the vicar and even the bride and groom saying their vows. They were wandering around the altar, walking up the aisle, coming and standing next to the bride and groom, one of them even walked up behind the vicar as they were exchanging the rings.

In fairness, both sets of parents were part of the wedding party so were unable to do much, and the grandmother who was supposed to be minding them both was clearly trying but struggling to keep them in check.

I normally love seeing children at weddings as in my view weddings are a family event, and there were almost a dozen babies, toddlers and young children at my own wedding, but I don't remember a single one of them behaving anything like that. Then again, I don't have kids of that age myself so maybe I have unrealistic expectations about what sort of behaviour children that age are capable of...

So, AIBU to think that children aged 3 and 4 are old enough to sit reasonably still and quietly, (and I don't mean in complete silence, but perhaps whispering if they absolutely have to say something, and not wandering up to the bloody altar) during a 45 minute wedding ceremony?

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 02/09/2021 00:11

@Maskless

Serious question: how come that decades ago, until recently, children DID sit still and shut up throughout weddings, funerals, Sunday morning church services every single week (and more for Catholics). There is not a chance in hell that children would have been allowed to be wandering around by the altar - vicar - marrying couple at any time in the last hundreds of years right up until the last 20 years, when all of a sudden it's deemed acceptable for children to run about, make noise and disrupt everything.

How did parents manage during all those decades/centuries?

Not that it matters, but until relatively recently, people did a lot more moving around during church services. Sure, wandering around the altar, probably not. But people moving around, getting up, sitting back down, breastfeeding a child - yes, definitely. It's relatively recent (like decades or 150 years tops) that people have decided 'church' behaviour means tiny children sitting absolutely motionless for the whole service.

I take DD to church regularly, and she is perfectly capable of getting through a longish service without being hugely disruptive (ie., she might need shushing occasionally and might not sit perfectly still, but she'll stay in our pew and won't talk or anything). But she usually doesn't have to, because the vicar will have her do altar service or help with collection, or someone will beckon her to come sit by them.

If you read accounts of churchgoing in, say, the Victorian period, although there's a lot of emphasis on older children needing to be disciplined (which in itself indicates they were regularly not very well behaved), people don't seem to have expected a three year old wouldn't be moving around a bit.

Phrowzunn · 02/09/2021 00:10

I took my 2 year old and 4 year old to a wedding the other week and they both managed to sit quietly for the duration. The 2 year old with a book and some colouring and the 4 year old just sat quietly on her dad’s knee. The 2 year old I would have taken out if she had started getting tetchy but at 4 years old there’s no excuse for that in my opinion. But then I’m a very strict mum by today’s standards and can’t abide bad behaviour. So I’m with you OP.

Cattenberg · 02/09/2021 00:09

This is a useful thread for me as I’m taking DD (aged 3 1/2) to her first wedding soon. I can’t see her sitting still and quiet for 45 minutes without a book or snack to distract her. I’d like for us to sit right at the back near the exit, but that would be tricky as we’re both part of the bridal party.

Oceanbliss · 02/09/2021 00:06

CattyMcNips
If heavily sedated of course they would.

@CattyMcNips 😂 Brilliant

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 02/09/2021 00:06

Why were you embarrassed? What embarrassed you about it? Or are you using that word incorrectly?

Anordinarymum · 02/09/2021 00:04

@appleturnovers

I went to a wedding last week and I was pretty embarrassed as there were two children, 3 and 4 years old, who were just walking around wherever they wanted and speaking quite loudly, at points drowning out the vicar and even the bride and groom saying their vows. They were wandering around the altar, walking up the aisle, coming and standing next to the bride and groom, one of them even walked up behind the vicar as they were exchanging the rings.

In fairness, both sets of parents were part of the wedding party so were unable to do much, and the grandmother who was supposed to be minding them both was clearly trying but struggling to keep them in check.

I normally love seeing children at weddings as in my view weddings are a family event, and there were almost a dozen babies, toddlers and young children at my own wedding, but I don't remember a single one of them behaving anything like that. Then again, I don't have kids of that age myself so maybe I have unrealistic expectations about what sort of behaviour children that age are capable of...

So, AIBU to think that children aged 3 and 4 are old enough to sit reasonably still and quietly, (and I don't mean in complete silence, but perhaps whispering if they absolutely have to say something, and not wandering up to the bloody altar) during a 45 minute wedding ceremony?

Not a chance in hell :)
TableFlowerss · 02/09/2021 00:00

@Hillary17

If I had my way we’d have no children at our upcoming wedding but my MIL would lose her mind. For this exact reason - some kids will be fine and others running riot. I had hearing a screaming child during the vows!
It’s your wedding, how dare she dictate you must have kids there!
mathanxiety · 01/09/2021 23:58

Also, how many children have had the opportunity to practice needing to sit quietly for any length over this last 18 months?

Mealtime at home?

Even watching tv at home?

I know there are parents who let their children run wild at home though, and mealtimes are not as decorous as they could be.

LittleBearPad · 01/09/2021 23:53

Your expectations are unrealistic.

They were never going to sit quietly that long - especially without 1-to-1 parental supervision and a bag of toys, colouring and sweets to keep them entertained

Lockdownbear · 01/09/2021 23:49

The point is we're the B&G bothered?

I had a couple of LOs at wedding who escaped their parents and ran down the aisle, the minister spoke to them "have you come for a better look?" And carried on.
Certainly didn't ruin my service or anything else nor did I expect them to be taken out.

Hillary17 · 01/09/2021 23:48

If I had my way we’d have no children at our upcoming wedding but my MIL would lose her mind. For this exact reason - some kids will be fine and others running riot. I had hearing a screaming child during the vows!

mathanxiety · 01/09/2021 23:46

YANBU

3 year olds though? Literally toddlers?

I see children this young sitting quietly through an hour of Mass every Sunday, and my own DCs managed it when they were that age.

WhisperedWords · 01/09/2021 23:45

It’s a completely unreasonable expectation that they could sit quietly for 45 minutes but not unreasonable to expect the person in charge of them to keep them quiet/entertained or take them outside.

Summerfun54321 · 01/09/2021 23:42

My bet is that they had to sit quietly and do boring things even before the 45 min wedding started. To have kids at a wedding and for it to work they need to have some time to run around and burn off some steam before and after the ceremony.

Flipthatpancakehighboy · 01/09/2021 23:39

My 3 year old could sit for perhaps 20 minutes with colouring, games etc, but not much longer, I wouldn’t let her run around, we’d go outside quietly

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 01/09/2021 23:37

Yes 3 and 4 year olds totally can but only if they are used to it from a young age. So church every Sunday for example. Daily family mealtimes sitting for an hour or more. It is like anything, training.

If they are not used to it then no they probably wouldn't stay sitting down and quiet.

NannyR · 01/09/2021 23:36

I think a lot of it depends on the parents expectations of their child's behaviour, as a nanny, I'm confident that I can keep a 3/4 year old quiet and engaged through a school assembly or church service, however I've also been in the same situation when the child's parent is "in charge" and she doesn't think it's possible for him to be quiet without loads of snacks and noisy activities and she thinks it's OK for him to walk about the room. His behaviour is totally different with the two different approaches.

I see in church too, that different parenting styles result in children behaving differently. We have a lot of African families at our church and (on the whole) their young children sit quietly, looking at books and drawing throughout the service, whereas other parents just look on adoringly as their kids run up and down the aisles.

My nephew is three and he sat through a funeral Mass a couple of weeks ago (no one to watch him, so he had to attend) and he did brilliantly, just needed the loo once but otherwise sat still and quiet.

BungleandGeorge · 01/09/2021 23:30

@DelphiniumBlue

I’d be wondering why no one was looking after them, it’s a pretty poor show if neither the parents nor the grandparents nor any of the guests were able to control the children and take them outside. OP says the parents were in the wedding party, not that they were the bride and and groom. Of course pre school children are not going to be able to sit quietly for 45 minutes without a lot of support, what were the parents thinking?
Perhaps they didn’t realise? CofE and registry office weddings are usually a fair bit shorter than 45 mins. The only one I’ve been to longer than 30 mins is a catholic ceremony
Gimlisaxe · 01/09/2021 23:28

How did parents manage during all those decades/centuries?

Clip round the ear, with the mutterings of when I get you home, you will see what I can do?

I can't sit through a wedding without wanting to fidget, normally why I get the kids, at least we can all go out for a breather and I can happily blame it on the children why I missed it.

TableFlowerss · 01/09/2021 23:27

And that why I decided against having kids at my wedding. I’m so pleased with my decision for this exact reason.

PullTheWeeds · 01/09/2021 23:26

You are both reasonable and unreasonable I think. I wouldn't let my children walk about or talk so loud that they drown out the vicar, that's rude, but neither could I make them sit quietly for 45 minutes.

It's just not a good environment for most children that age. I'd have to have them engaged with drawing or maybe lego, they could listen for a bit at the beginning but then also probably I'd need to take them out at some point before the 45 minutes was completed. Even as an adult I'd struggle to sit quietly and engaged for such an occasion. I mean I would mange to sit quietly but I'd feel fidgety, id get uncomfortable on my wooden pew, my mind would wander etc.

Goldbar · 01/09/2021 23:25

It would be fantastic to have a cage play area for the under 5s at weddings. I would probably start gatecrashing weddings just to drop mine in the pen with the others if that became the norm. I could then hide my book in the order of service and have a relaxing read while the service was ongoing.

BungleandGeorge · 01/09/2021 23:22

When I was young the little children were scooped out of the church service for Sunday school, which was play based. Likewise at weddings there might be a random adult outside with several kids. I don’t think kids have changed that much but society has and we now expect ofstead inspected premises, DBS checks and the like. Not necessarily a bad thing but it does mean that circumstances are different

godmum56 · 01/09/2021 23:22

Did the wedding party mind? Do any of you know about the "messy church" movement? www.messychurch.org.uk.

DelphiniumBlue · 01/09/2021 23:21

I’d be wondering why no one was looking after them, it’s a pretty poor show if neither the parents nor the grandparents nor any of the guests were able to control the children and take them outside. OP says the parents were in the wedding party, not that they were the bride and and groom. Of course pre school children are not going to be able to sit quietly for 45 minutes without a lot of support, what were the parents thinking?

Swipe left for the next trending thread