Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone’s mum ever actually stolen their baby?

166 replies

Cabbagewhites · 01/09/2021 18:34

Seen a few threads recently (and lots over the years!) where women fear their mums / MIL want to take over the parenting of their child.
On a thread recently a PP described the overbearing MIL as ‘sinister’.

Just got me wondering, how much of a genuine threat is this? Worst case scenario- how far does it ever actually go?

Has anyone ever been in or heard of a family where grandma did in fact actually succeed in taking over the role of mother, becoming primary care giver in child’s eyes?

(I mean in situations where parents are actively parenting and haven’t actually asked or encouraged GP to step in, and there’s no kinship fostering or anything like that.)

I don’t have children, I’m just curious!

OP posts:
BeckyWithTheAverageHair · 02/09/2021 09:47

One of my friends was raised by her grandparents as her parents split up when she was very young and then her father died. Her mother kept her sister and her grandparents (father's side) took her and stopped her mum from any contact.

The grandparents are now long dead and her mum and sister live in the next suburb but she's not seen them in 40 years and has no interest in meeting them.

justasmalltownmum · 02/09/2021 08:55

There was a story on Reddit once, when the MIL let herself in to her son/DILs house during the night and took their newborn baby, so they could "rest".

AlternativePerspective · 02/09/2021 08:46

Reading through this has just reminded me.

The wife of someone I was at school with left her marriage while she was pregnant with her second child, she already had a daughter. Once she had the baby she moved to find a better life for her and her DD and the baby stayed with her parents until she was settled.

At this point the parents told her that her son was settled with them and that it would be wrong to uproot him to go and live with her, and so he stayed with them and is still there. I think he’s about 11 or 12 now.

LaBellina · 02/09/2021 07:57

Nope but my unhinged narc mother was secretly (in her mind but very obviously to me) VERY jealous of me when I was pregnant. She did some really nasty stuff and the baby stealing threats come I think from the same place. I would advice anyone dealing with this kind of jealousy to keep the contact with jealous mother or MiL to an absolute minimum if at all.

JellyNo15 · 02/09/2021 07:57

Seriously? Your Ofsted registered childminder?

RandomMess · 02/09/2021 07:56

Where it's mothers that trick their daughters into letting their DGC stay then live with them my stealth this will be off the back of a lifetime of emotional abuse/enmeshment where the daughter is unable to go against their mother's wishes.

That sort if dynamic is very difficult for the daughter to even recognise is wrong - it's a codependent abusive one.

JellyNo15 · 02/09/2021 07:54

My MIL and her mother basically stole my DH's cousin. This was over sixty years ago and all dead now including the cousin, who died tragically young. My MIL used to give her version of events but DH's aunt had a more realistic version.
She was concerned that history would repeat itself with MIL and SIL and my children. I think being forewarned helped a lot as they would try to demand time alone with my children. It never happened.

Astraturf · 02/09/2021 07:51

One of my DDs friends stays with paternal grand parents and has had sleep overs from a few weeks old. Her Dad is out of the picture and her Mum has a stepson and a toddler with her new DH. They live in a two bedroom flat while grandparents have a house with big garden and DDs friend has a room and a play room there and goes to activities and has play dates with the grandparents.
If there's a falling out I can see it going through court or it may happen naturally. It's about 50/50 at the moment.

coodawoodashooda · 02/09/2021 07:17

@13579db

My DM used to take my newborn out to do 'messages' in the prism and not tell me when she'd be back. Didn't answer her phone. Told me that she'd wished she never had kids. I could go on. It's a very real thing. A very real negative female to female assassin style behaviour. Jealousy versus ageing and how they've had their chance to birth and parent. But maybe they wish to do it differently witb via their grandchildren. Charming. So so intense and bizarre but definitely a thing. Beware.
Yes. My childminder tried this with mine. I was stuck with her due to my circumstances for a bit. She really thought that i was stupid and that she'd get away with it.
felulageller · 02/09/2021 07:07

To people who ask how this can happen legally, there are 2 main routes:

  1. via the father's PRR- if they have 50/50 or EOW or whatever court ordered or voluntary residence/ contact agreement the Dad can legally hand over the DC to the GPs for all of that contact if he so chooses. I've seen 'dads' go to court for 'contact' when it's actually the GPs paying for the lawyers so they can have the DGCs in that time. Dad's aren't required to actually see or care for their DC's during their contact.

  2. residence by default- sometimes the Mum will be going through a temp crisis eg fleeing domestic abuse/ in a hostel, moving house, having a temp job abroad, studying, being sectioned, rehab, prison, staying with a sick relative/ providing care, etc so they agree to the DC staying with Gran for a few weeks.
    Then when the mum returns they fall out and GPs go to court and say the DC is settled and moving them would be traumatic. Courts are very reluctant to move DC's from where they are- even if this was only a temp plan. If dad sides with Gran, mum has no chance.

So women should be mindful of this when leaving a relationship- never agree to DC's temp staying with anyone else as you may never get them back.

And don't co register the birth.

Crikeycroc · 02/09/2021 01:03

I lived with my maternal grandmother to attend the good primary school near her for almost a year after she applied a fair amount of pressure to my mum. Allegedly, grandma threatened to report my mum to social services because I was homeschooled at the time. I’m unsure exactly what was said.

mathanxiety · 02/09/2021 00:07

Not in the same league as some of these at all, but exMIL decided my DS should go to a particular private school, and of course exH went along with it. ExMIL never said a word to me about it.

Very dominant and quite aggressively proprietorial.
This is a good description of exMIL. Thank you.

Bagamoyo1 · 02/09/2021 00:05

Vulnerable teen mums aside, I don’t understand how anyone can just have their baby stolen. If my Mum had taken one of mine when they were babies, I would simply have picked them up and walked out.

Phobiaphobic · 02/09/2021 00:04

Christ, having spent 20 years bringing up my kids it's beyond me why anyone would willingly go through all that again.

NoNotYou · 01/09/2021 23:35

@GeorgiaGirl52. God bless you for giving up your freedom for the good of your grandchild. I'm glad your daughter is well now 😍

Ozanj · 01/09/2021 23:20

It’s more likely to be parents stealing children of daughters, not pils, as daughters are more likely to overlook severe mh problems in their families. This is why women shouldn’t rush into giving their family the ‘keys’ in terms of childcare.

KeyboardWorriers · 01/09/2021 23:00

Oh and my ex grandmother in law has form for encouraging her son's/grandsons to make spurious allergations about the mothers mental health if they split and then funds their protracted legal battles. I was "lucky" as I had family and medical support to fight it. But some children in that ("respectable" middle class) family were separated from loving mothers for long stretches. (I only found this out after it happened to me and they got in touch)

KeyboardWorriers · 01/09/2021 22:57

My SIL went really weird one day when my son was about 8 weeks old. Only the second time she had met him (we lived in different countries). She took him out of pram where he was sleeping when I nipped to the loo and went and hid in another room and refused to give him back even though he was screaming and desperate for milk. Really weird and DH and his family just all stood around and wouldn't confront her.

milveycrohn · 01/09/2021 22:55

There was a case on TV; the kind of super nanny problem solving one.
The couple (or it may have been a single mother) lived with the mother's parents. I think the mother may also have worked, but when she was home she felt tired, and so the 'parenting' was done by the grandmother.
I cannot remember why there was a problem which involved them being on the program, but I well remember it being pointed out that the mother had sort of 'opted' out of parenting leaving it to the grandmother, but there was resentment all round.
The mother felt usurped, and the grandmother also felt put upon.
I remember that part of the solution was for the grandmother to step back, and the mother to step up.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 01/09/2021 22:52

I've worked with someone who didn't react well when her daughter and grandchild had got their own place and were moving out after a teenage pregnancy. She barricaded herself in the house with her grandchild. The police had to be called. SS had been involved and supported the teenage mother completely, despite the grandparent claiming the teenage mother wasn't looking after the baby properly.

After a while she began to provide childcare for her grandchild but was caught trying to get the child to call them mummy and the mother by her christian name. The childcare ended.

She has refused to return the child after being allowed to spend time with her grandchild. The police have been involved a few times. She's now no longer allowed to spend time alone with that grandchild. Her daughter has had more children and is very strict about not ever allowing them to be alone with her.

jozipozi31 · 01/09/2021 22:49

yes those mad buggers can do it. It is real.

Luckily my mum is not like that. Not 100% certain of MIL though - she has form. Especially when our daughter was a baby. Very dominant and quite aggressively proprietorial.

I am a woman but some women. ....

GobbleHobble · 01/09/2021 22:36

Yes, I've had first hand experience of this, my older sibling being taken away from my mother when I arrived in the guise of "helping" a struggling new mum, my grandmother wouldn't return my older sibling and for the first few years of my life didn't live with us!

Second, I've seen it happen with my in laws where"gran" insisted on being called mum by grandkids, demanded access on specific days during maternity leave, then threatened to go to court for access when the relationship failed (their son, the dad, was a serial cheat) because they could prove the pattern of care. Really fucked up. It only ended when fake mum died. Not joking, it was awful watching the situation from afar and clearly the kids cared for her, but she put their mother through hell with demands and legal threats.

CoastalWave · 01/09/2021 22:36

My MIL stole SIL's baby. It absolutely CAN happen.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 01/09/2021 22:31

My friend lost her oldest child to her parents when she split from her first husband. Her dad really wanted a son and all his children and grandchildren were girls apart from my friend's son.

She had a bit of a breakdown when her marriage ended and her parents stepped in to help and then apparently took advantage of the situation. They had space in their house for her baby but not for her and she ended up in a dodgy B&B for a few months. Once she got a decent place sorted out they just refused to hand the baby over. They eventually claimed she was an unfit mother and everyone, including her ex-husband, sided against her.

Years later they tried the same with her next son. They intervened when her second marriage failed. They ended up housing their SIL and other grandson (funnily enough their house was big enough for them both!). This time her second son was much older and he insisted on returning to his mum's new house as soon as it was ready. The grandad has since died and the SIL is still living at his ex MILs house.

Her oldest son calls his grandmother and grandfather mum and dad and my friend by her name. He doesn't like her because she tried to take him away from his mum and dad and she upset them. He has no relationship with his father.

One thing that my friend seems to get wrong is the lack of stability in her life. She is constantly moving houses, losing possessions due to lack of storage options or transportation or having to sell everything. She has been involved with several high risk businesses and has been burnt. She is now investing her savings in another friend's business. I've never met this new friend and it all seems to be happening too quickly and I'm dubious. Her money was supposed to be going on a mortgage as she's been in rented housing for the last few years and wanted her own place again.

Pallisers · 01/09/2021 22:28

I know someone who had a baby young but not terribly young - around 18 - with her boyfriend. She had younger siblings at home too. She stayed at home to go to college and her parents were really supportive - but supportive in a way that didn't prioritise the mother/child bond but their bond with their grandson so she was sidelined from the start. He stayed with them when she moved out and got married and I know it was a real tragedy in her life that she didn't get to rear her own son. She agreed to leave him because by then it seemed the right thing to do for her son.

One of the things I loved most about my mil was how she was more concerned about my bond with my baby than she was with hers. She came to stay immediately after the birth because I was so sick I needed help. Instead of taking over she would do things like make me breakfast or offer to watch him while he slept so I could go back to sleep or wait till I had finished the night feed and then appear and say "I can put him back to sleep for you if you'd like to go back to bed or sit with you if you'd prefer that" She constantly told me how great a mother I was.