Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone’s mum ever actually stolen their baby?

166 replies

Cabbagewhites · 01/09/2021 18:34

Seen a few threads recently (and lots over the years!) where women fear their mums / MIL want to take over the parenting of their child.
On a thread recently a PP described the overbearing MIL as ‘sinister’.

Just got me wondering, how much of a genuine threat is this? Worst case scenario- how far does it ever actually go?

Has anyone ever been in or heard of a family where grandma did in fact actually succeed in taking over the role of mother, becoming primary care giver in child’s eyes?

(I mean in situations where parents are actively parenting and haven’t actually asked or encouraged GP to step in, and there’s no kinship fostering or anything like that.)

I don’t have children, I’m just curious!

OP posts:
PhoboPhobia · 02/09/2021 19:51

A friend was manipulated by her MIL in a very cruel and calculated way. It resulted in her small DC becoming terrified of her because he had been told awful things. She fought so hard but ultimately she wasn’t in his life in any meaningful way. She went on to have 2 more DCs in a much healthier relationship but sadly died when they were 10 and 13. Her first DS is a very troubled young man and I feel so terribly sad for him.

JustLyra · 02/09/2021 19:36

I was talking to MIL about this thread last night and it turned out her and her sister spent three days in a children’s home when her younger brother was born because her Mum felt that was a safer option than her Granny or (in particular) one of her Aunts. Her mum felt sure she wouldn’t get them back if they took them!

PinkPanther27 · 02/09/2021 19:29

Yes, this happened in my family.

cricketmum84 · 02/09/2021 19:25

An old school friend of mine had a very abusive mother. It was actually really distressing if I was ever round at her house how her mother treated her and spoke to her, if I had been older and more mature I probably would have reported it but in all honesty her mother was terrifying! She ended up falling pregnant at 15 and a couple of years later her mother tried to tell everyone she was an unfit mother and actually tried snatching the pram from her in the middle of the street a number of times.

20 years later she has been NC for a long time and has a police protection order against the mum due to the severity of the abuse she received.

She is a loving and happy mum now and I couldn't be prouder of her for coming through all that crap!

Toomuchtrouble4me · 02/09/2021 19:21

Yes, I know a young mother who had a bit of post natal depression, she was talked in to moving in with her lovely but weak father and his new and overbearing wife. They’d only been married for 8 months, kids all grown and here was a baby in the house. The stepmom was so overpowering and critical that the pnd got worse, she called on social services, got guardianship of baby and kicked young mum out, no drink, drug issues, just depressed and in need of help and support. They convinced her that she was worthless.
The child is now 6 living with grandpa and step grandma - calls them mama and papa, she doesn’t see her mum who is bitter and angry and disappointed in her dad, with whom she used to be close. She was a single mom, her own mother had passed so she was alone and she was played by ‘wicked stepmom’ who took her child to complete her new family. Shocking. True story.

Mommabear20 · 02/09/2021 19:02

Not to the extend you mentioned but my mum is definitely trying to push her way in as a third parent. Messages daily to ask to take DD out and visit friends, calls her 'my Girl' when introducing her to people etc. Frequently brings her back later than agreed and doesn't see that our boundaries as parents need to be respected.

Linnette49 · 02/09/2021 19:00

I think my MIL was aiming to take my son under her control. She used to have him on a Saturday whilst I did my shopping until I caught her giving him a bath because he was ‘dirty’ and then told was an unfit mother who didn’t know what she was doing. Luckily my Hubbie took my son off her, we dressed him put him in his pram and he told her that until she apologised she wouldn’t see him again. His Sister who was helping her told me afterwards that she was told I had agreed to it. She was a very religious woman who caused me a lot of upset and used to call me out when hubbie wasn’t there. I stayed away as much as I could.

Schooldilemma2345 · 02/09/2021 18:56

I’m on a ‘adult children of narcissistic parents and in-laws’ Facebook group and there are many posts from mothers who have had to take out retraining orders against grandparents. It usually starts with lots of toxic behaviour from a grandparent leading to the parents going low or no contact and limiting the the grandparents access to the GC. Then in retaliation the GC file bogus child protect allegations against the parents and fight for custody (this group has a lot of US members so don’t know if the laws there maybe this more feasible). Or they side with the spouse-in-law when a marriage ends and cut their son or daughter out of the loop so they can spend time with the GC on the ex’s time. Or they abuse the contact they do have; bring kids home much later than planned, take them out for the day much further from home and need to stay over at a hotel etc. Red flag behaviour that they won’t accept not seeing their GC on their terms. Obviously, I’m only seeing one side of the story in these cases but some of it is truly horrific.

Idontknowhowtodothis · 02/09/2021 18:29

I'm fairly sure my MIL would try to steal my partner back Grin #apronstrings

Morgysmum · 02/09/2021 18:27

I don't know if she stole her, but my mum was raised by her Nana, not by her mum.
Her mum (my gran was only 19, but this was in 1951,) not sure why this happened. My mum didn't know either, she was 8 when she went back to live with her mum, who by then had 2 other kids, a girl of 4 and a baby girl. My mum didn't get on with her middle sister (the 4 year old) she didn't get on with her mum either.
Realtionship didn't get better, when my mums Nana, who raised her died, my mum got told she shouldn't be so upset, but to her Nana was her mum, not her real mum. Complicated family dimensions. My mum still doesn't get on that well with her mum.

boatgirl81 · 02/09/2021 18:16

I was brought up by Nan and she was the most amazing person. She welcomed me when I ran away from home having been abused by my step dad and my mum allowing it to happen. There is always another side to a story and my mum would act the aggrieved party but if she has been a proper parent I would not have runaway

Frankie20018 · 02/09/2021 18:05

Yes it has happened to me. My mother has always wanted my eldest DD to go and live with her. When my DD was a teenager we had a normal falling out and my mother invited my DD to her home and wouldn’t let her leave. She changed my DDs bank account, phone number and last name. All the while telling me my DD didn't want to speak to me. DD was terrified of her. In the end the police removed my DD and brought her home. We now obviously have no contact with my mother and she is not legally allowed to contact us

Mollymoostoo · 02/09/2021 18:01

@Mollymoostoo

My mother used to undermine me and make plans with my children that went against what I had said. We have no contact now as she was so toxic. My MIL was not like that, apart from forcing biscuits and sweets down DD she was fine. My SIL and my BIL's wife however feel they can say/do what they like with my SD, thankfully she is not mine so I just ignore it but my DH gets angry. They are so bad they specialise with my DH's ex girlfriend and mother of his daughter despite us having been married for 11 years. They have never liked me but apparently don't like her either and just want to pee me off.
Socialise...not specialise Blush
Mollymoostoo · 02/09/2021 18:00

My mother used to undermine me and make plans with my children that went against what I had said. We have no contact now as she was so toxic.
My MIL was not like that, apart from forcing biscuits and sweets down DD she was fine. My SIL and my BIL's wife however feel they can say/do what they like with my SD, thankfully she is not mine so I just ignore it but my DH gets angry. They are so bad they specialise with my DH's ex girlfriend and mother of his daughter despite us having been married for 11 years. They have never liked me but apparently don't like her either and just want to pee me off.

Wills · 02/09/2021 17:43

Me. My mum even managed to hold my fb before I did. Eventually we had to go NC for a few years. We moved from ‘down the road’ to 90 minutes away and she had solicitors/lawyers chasing us. We now have a good relationship but it was touch and go for a long time. She threatened to call social services the first time I had my first born’s hair cut and accused me of making her (my daughter) a latch key kid when I enrolled her into nursery at 3.5

Iwantcauliflowercheese · 02/09/2021 17:41

My best friend lived with her grandmother all her life. Her parents and older sister lived in the next street. She has no idea why. She did inherit the house though, so maybe that's what her parents were hoping.

coodawoodashooda · 02/09/2021 16:36

@JellyNo15

Seriously? Your Ofsted registered childminder?
Yes.
2389Champ · 02/09/2021 13:44

I knew a family where the grandparents were raising the child and they used to actively tell people they had custody because their DS and DIL had been sexually abusing it! I often wondered if that had have actually been the case whether the authorities would have removed the child completely from the family dynamic? It was never clear if there had been a formal arrangement or if they had just taken over.

The GPs were both batshit crazy, were religious nuts and had a history of making wild accusations against third parties - particularly in the organisation I worked in that had dealings with them. They formally complained that the boss was gay with the assumption that if they were, they shouldn’t be working with children! I was accused by them of making an SEN child clean up its own mess! A complete lie - I had asked it to help me with some tidying up. The child wasn’t even SEN although that didn’t stop them working hard everywhere to get a diagnosis. They wanted a peg to hang all their issues on plus any benefits going. They used to dress the child in the most inappropriate clothing too which drew a lot of unwelcome attention.

When the child finally left, we had a file nearly 15cm thick of unfounded complaints and the related paperwork. The amount of time that was put into responding to their allegations could have been so better spent in other more beneficial areas. After seeking legal advice, we were told that these sort of people are vexatious complainants and get their kicks from this sort of behaviour. It made me wonder how true the allegations against the DS and DIL actually were and how sick someone has to be to fabricate facts like that in order to take over control of their GC.

I found out years later the GC cut them out of its life completely and was probably a lot healthier for it too.

Tunnocks34 · 02/09/2021 12:50

No. I do remember my own MIL telling me ‘when I developed PND she’d take my son, and my husband in and take on the role of mother’

In a weird way I think she was trying to be kind - like tell me she’d be there to support etc, but it just came across weird and overbearing

coodawoodashooda · 02/09/2021 12:30

[quote Worldwide2]@coodawoodashooda

Oh god knows why, I think a previous poster said jealousy ect it's not the norm but it is strange how so many women do this to their own daughters ect[/quote]
I suppose. The childminder i used had a huge family, including 8 grandchildren. I thought that meant she wouldnt have any inclination for the weird psychotic relationship she tried to gain with my kids.

RamblingJenny · 02/09/2021 11:40

My own mum had a really weird reaction with our first child.

When baby would pull a face at my mum or be unsettled, (just through being tired or normal unpredictable baby behaviour!) she would really huff and go off in an awful mood shouting at me that the baby ‘doesn’t want me IT WANTS YOU!!!’. Waving arms around, the lot.
I’d be stood there feeling very uncomfortable and there would be an atmosphere. This happened very often.

I look back at it now and it’s like a rejection to their own ego as a female. It’s warped. Well, what baby wouldn’t want their own mother? It really shattered my idea of how I thought our relationship would blossom which really felt quite heavy, unpredictable and sinister at times.

I think something like this is why the awful twisting behaviour of GP is aimed at a babies and children at young age as that’s when they can ‘get their claws in’ without the child being fully aware of the manipulation.

k1233 · 02/09/2021 11:25

A single mum I know fell out with her parents and went reduced / no contact. They took her to court and have some sort of custody agreement whereby their grandson (her child) has to see them on specified days. I was shocked when she told me.

Worldwide2 · 02/09/2021 11:14

@coodawoodashooda

Oh god knows why, I think a previous poster said jealousy ect it's not the norm but it is strange how so many women do this to their own daughters ect

coodawoodashooda · 02/09/2021 10:56

@Worldwide2

I dont think it's necessary a case of actually stealing the baby. More often it's the grandma trying to get in between baby and mums bond. Being that person that the baby wants ect it does happen. My mum tried to do similar with my dd. Wanted to be the person my dd wanted the most. It's horrible and overbearing. If you don't nip it in the bud it can definitely spiral and you can be pushed out.
Yeah but does anyone understand why they would think theyd get away with it or want that in the first place?
Worldwide2 · 02/09/2021 10:15

I dont think it's necessary a case of actually stealing the baby. More often it's the grandma trying to get in between baby and mums bond. Being that person that the baby wants ect it does happen. My mum tried to do similar with my dd. Wanted to be the person my dd wanted the most. It's horrible and overbearing. If you don't nip it in the bud it can definitely spiral and you can be pushed out.