Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you wanted 3 but stuck with 2 did you make peace with it?

107 replies

gruffaloo · 01/09/2021 17:37

Not really sure where to post this but decided to do it here for traffic.

We're deliberating the prospect of a third. I've gone back and read as many of the "should we have a third?" threads.

What I'd love to know is if you were keen on a third child but for whatever reason didn't go ahead with it, did you make peace with that decision?

I'd like a third but it's not an easy child to justify. There are lots of rational reasons for two but I feel I may regret not having three? But perhaps this is something I can over come? Something that is just short-lived?

I have a 3 year old, and a 1 year old.

OP posts:
Strokethefurrywall · 01/09/2021 22:28

I definitely made my peace with it, especially by the time DS2 turned 3.
I always wanted 3 (I’m one of 3) and it’s easy to want to maintain the baby phase when you’re totally in it.
Now they’re nearly 10&7 and there’s absolutely nobody missing from our family. Im so glad we stopped at 2, and definitely don’t feel broody for another anymore!

RosesAndHellebores · 01/09/2021 22:26

@Winecurestiredness Flowers
Not dissimilar here. Both wanted three or four and after many miscarriages and a little boy at 27 weeks who lived for just a few hours, between the DC, we stuck at 2 and are thankful for them. They are grown up now.

I didn't have the courage to risk another loss and then I was 40. The older I get the more I regret it and I regret nothing else in my life.

CherryMaple · 01/09/2021 22:15

@Winecurestiredness

I’m so sorry for your loss Flowers

Hyppogriff · 01/09/2021 22:11

Interesting thread I’m in the same boat. Have a boy and a girl 2 years apart. Youngest is now nearly 1 and a part of me wants to go again but I think in my heart of hearts we won’t and that’s the right choice for us. Stressful enough having 2 and trying to give them enough one on one attention around work. Plus environmental reasons I suppose 2 is better! Also the risk that something may go wrong with third pregnancy (feel like
Dodged a bullet after very hairy delivery with second). And practical reasons like money. But still doesn’t take away that yearning !!!

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 01/09/2021 22:09

I wanted a 3rd when my DC were small. DH was dead against it though so it never happened. I was a bit upset for a while, but once dd2 started school my perspective flipped and now I’m really glad we stuck at 2. We don’t have tons of cash and that 3rd child would have made everything so much more expensive, we wouldn’t have been able to give the DC the opportunities they have had.

Also selfishly. I now have teens and I’ve got my life back and I’m glad I don’t have a younger child.

SpidersAreShitheads · 01/09/2021 22:08

I desperately wanted three, but I've stuck with two.

Several reasons - my two DC are twins so I've only had the experience of having babies once. They were very premature and poorly, and it was traumatic. That was amplified by the fact I split up with my partner when I was 8 wks pregnant, and swine flu was rampant. That meant I was in SCBU alone for a couple of months as only partners were allowed in due to flu restrictions. It was a very lonely experience, and there were some very hard days.

I remember when I was pregnant going with my mum to buy her a new sofa and the sales guy was about to have a baby with his wife. He could see I had a big baby bump so we were chatting and he excitedly showed me a 3D scan photo. I've always wanted to have a baby with someone to experience that kind of shared intimacy, and to see them so excited to have a baby.

As it happens, both my DC are autistic and my DS in particular has fairly significant needs. I had to face facts that I can't give them what they need and also have another baby, despite being with a lovely DP for more than a decade now.

It's taken years to get used to (I'm 45 now) and probably only really the last 12 months or so that I've properly accepted it. I think I realised what I wanted was to turn the clock back and experience their baby years ago. It wouldn't actually be the same having a third baby but I just wanted all the things that I never had the first time around. Get out your tiny violins, eh? 😅

Sticking with two DC was the right decision but it took a blunt and emotional debate with my DP to accept it.

Onehotmess · 01/09/2021 22:04

Just read a thread about sugar on weetabix and honestly thought this was about having an extra shredded wheat 🙈
I’ve got older DC than yours and now expecting a 3rd after being convinced we were ‘done’ I just wanted another! I definitely feel like I’d have regretted it if we hadn’t tried.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 01/09/2021 21:53

Sorry for your loss @Winecurestiredness

gruffaloo · 01/09/2021 21:51

@FoxtrotSkarloey that is something I've considered but I don't think it's the think driving me.

For me I think it's being one of two growing up. I found it boring having one sibling and often longed for another, ideally a sister - but maybe lots of kids wish that??

DH is one of three but says it wasn't particularly "party" being one of three and he felt like it was just one too many, none of them are particularly close but carry out their various sibling duties. Much the same as my brother and I.

OP posts:
Singlebutmarried · 01/09/2021 21:48

I wanted three. But had one.

It just didn’t happen. But I can’t regret what didn’t happen.

Holly60 · 01/09/2021 21:47

@felulageller

I've had 3 and in hindsight shouldn't have.

But if I had stuck with 2 I think I would always have been unhappy with that too.

When it's only the older 2 about it's so quiet and doesn't feel like a family the way it does with young DC's.

For me whether they are boys/ girls makes a difference too.

I’m interested in you saying it makes a difference whether they are boys/girls. What do you mean by that? I’m just interested :)
gruffaloo · 01/09/2021 21:46

@Winecurestiredness I'm so sorry this happened to you. Thank you for sharing. It is something that has past through my mind.

OP posts:
Goldenfan · 01/09/2021 21:43

I'm so glad I'm reading this as the urge for me to have another baby is so strongbits primal and hard to ignore. So relieved it eventually fades because practically and financially 3 is too much and I don't want my 2 to have to miss out. But my God the baby fever is like a drug Grin

merryhouse · 01/09/2021 21:42

After about eight years, I realised I no longer felt the same way. It was quite sudden.

A decade later, I occasionally have a "the road not taken" moment, but I'm not generally sad.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 01/09/2021 21:33

Hi OP, I have two the same age as yours and we're having the same debate. I can't answer directly but wonder if you've got some of the same unresolved thoughts I have.

My younger one has just turned one, so thanks to bastard Covid, I barley saw anyone the whole time I was pregnant. No joy of sharing the excitement and expectation. Just fear and solo hospital appointments. Since DC was born, I've also not seen many people except local friends and mostly outdoors. Trying to bf on the depths of winter on a cold park bench because there wasn't even a cafe open. That sort of delightful experience. This will change as people are vaccinated, and I can introduce her to more relatives, but my whole mat leave has been shit compared to what I dreamed of (I became pregnant pre Covid).

Sorry if that's a derail and I certainly wouldn't have another child just to try and have a more 'normal' pregnancy and mat leave. Obviously a child is for life and not just as a newborn! Just curious if it plays any part in your thinking?

SuperCaliFragalistic · 01/09/2021 21:31

I always thought I wanted three. I prefer the dynamic of 3 as I had a pretty rough childhood with just one sibling and we didn't get on. I thought with 3 there would be more opportunities for them to enjoy each others company in different ways. However DC1 was an absolute nightmare for sleeping and general fussiness (still is) and she totally broke me. We had DC2, 4 years later, he was a dream baby and I could happily have a few more like him. I relaxed, got in the zone and became a better mother and was contemplating DC3. However DP then left me for another woman (I wasn't paying him enough attention, poor lamb) and here we are, the decision was taken out of my hands to an extent. I still would have another DC but can't be bothered with another relationship plus the age gap would be much bigger now. My DC also have 2 younger half siblings on their dads side whom they adore so they did OK. I'm completely happy with us being a family of 3 but I do contemplate fostering from time to time - I feel like I have more mothering to give! I don't want to put my DC through the possible difficulties of it though as they already have a lot going on living at 2 houses. Maybe one day.

JalapenoCheeseOnToast · 01/09/2021 21:26

I've literally just decided in the last few weeks to stop at 2. I have always dreamed of having 3 and was very keen up until a month ago. Unfortunately I slipped a disc last year and again this year and it has been a big problem for me ever since. I have now decided that having a third is putting my body at an unnecessary risk of further injury and I really want to be able to walk, run and play with the children I have, rather than have a third and risk further spinal problems. It has been hard to come to terms with and I'm still struggling a little but I know it's the right decision for the family that I already have.

StorminaBcup · 01/09/2021 21:24

We deliberated having a 3rd - same age gaps as yours. Now that they’re 5 and 7 I’m so very very glad we didn’t! Neither slept particularly well (which was the deal breaker), they get on well but are so full on and very energetic, I can’t imagine juggling 3 lots of after school clubs, getting three ready for breakfast club / school drop off etc..

I know plenty of people with 3. And not one of them have ever said they’ve regretted it. But then, you can’t ever say really say you regret having kids can you…Grin

Thunderface · 01/09/2021 21:19

I have two and had times (like a previous poster said particularly from 40-45) where I really wanted a third. I had HG in both pregnancies though and it really took a toll on me mentally and physically and DH was very against having a third. I don't think our marriage would have survived another difficult pregnancy.
My children are teenagers now and I am happy with two but I do have the occasional pang of regret.

speakout · 01/09/2021 21:17

Totally made peace with it.

OH wanted to stick at 2 and I am so glad.
Teenage years are so expensive. one crazy dancer to a high level, gap year to New Zealand, driving lessons, University.
I could not have supported 3 so easily.

Cupoftea53 · 01/09/2021 21:14

I would add though that loads of them have got a puppy instead of a third child. To me that seems harder work than a third child though so not sure I understand the logic!

stopgap · 01/09/2021 21:13

I’m fine with it. I had two boys at 33 and 36.
My autoimmune stuff flared a great deal after my second son, and it took a couple of years to stabilize, by which time I felt too old. (Never yearned for a girl, so never grieved for that.)

Cupoftea53 · 01/09/2021 21:11

We have 3 - have a gap of 4.5 years between 2 and 3. It’s a great gap. I have noticed though that friends who stuck at 2 and now have an 8 and 10 year old have a totally different life to me. They have child free time on holiday, doing loads of exercise, don’t have toys in the lounge anymore etc. But I guess it depends if you are wanting to move on from all that. We quite like the fun of having a little one but I know a lot of my friends are happy those days are behind them.

MiloAndEddie · 01/09/2021 21:10

After having DC2 we felt our family wasn’t complete but now they are getting older that feeling is fading. We’re revisiting the idea next year but I think I know already I don’t want another. Doesn’t help that I’m terrible at being pregnant and giving birth!
As they are getting older, things are getting easier, I don’t have to lug a buggy everywhere, I can take a little bag, they’ll play nicely together. I can’t imagine going back to the baby stage even though we aren’t that far out of it

Porcupineintherough · 01/09/2021 21:07

@Blessex wait perimenopause hits. I am far less patient and far more grumpy and generally less maternal. Thankfully my youngest turned teen just as this happened so I'm less in demand anyway but I shudder to think how it would have worked if I'd had a younger child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread