Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you wanted 3 but stuck with 2 did you make peace with it?

107 replies

gruffaloo · 01/09/2021 17:37

Not really sure where to post this but decided to do it here for traffic.

We're deliberating the prospect of a third. I've gone back and read as many of the "should we have a third?" threads.

What I'd love to know is if you were keen on a third child but for whatever reason didn't go ahead with it, did you make peace with that decision?

I'd like a third but it's not an easy child to justify. There are lots of rational reasons for two but I feel I may regret not having three? But perhaps this is something I can over come? Something that is just short-lived?

I have a 3 year old, and a 1 year old.

OP posts:
MinimumChips · 03/09/2021 09:58

I would have really liked to have 3 at one point, but dh wasn’t keen. I accepted that but wasn’t totally happy that I’d never have a third. Then I had a surprise pregnancy when dc2 was 3. We would have gone ahead, I was happy about it, but it turned out to be ectopic and ruptured. I didn’t feel particularly sad to be honest after I got out of hospital as I was just very glad to be alive, so we decided to leave it there. Dh had a vasectomy which I was super happy about and have never really looked back.

Just recently my period was a few days late and I thought, “what if the vasectomy failed and I’m pregnant?” My overriding feeing was that it would be like getting a prison sentence!! I am just starting to see the point at which we’ll be able to go out for dinner without a babysitter now, just a few years away, and really don’t want to go back to babies. And we now have so much more money than we’d have if we’d had a third, partly due to me now being ahead in my career, but also because we haven’t had a third lot of maternity leave, a third lot of childcare costs etc. Our families live abroad and we can afford to see them semi-regularly which would have been difficult with three children. I can also see that it wouldn’t have been the best decision to have another child from an environmental perspective and for my two living dcs’ futures, something that I think about a lot more now than I did 10 years ago when ds1 was a baby.

Row1n · 03/09/2021 09:51

I wanted 3 or 4, but financially it would have been a struggle and we made the decision to move on to a different phase in life (away from nappies etc) and really enjoy the 2 ds we have. I did cry a few times as I thought about never having another baby of my own again, but I knew it made sense. And now my dc are older I am so so pleased we stuck with it. We have a lovely life (far from perfect, but enjoyable) and never felt we had more going on than we could cope with. My closest friend however went for 3 and cannot cope. She gave up work but even so is always flustered, she isnt enjoying their childhoods and is always snapping at them - this isnt me making judgements btw, she has told me this outright. She has never said she regrets the 3rd, but she has told me she cannot wait for them to grow up and move out.
Obviously this isnt everybody's experience, some are more organised and patient and can cope. Others just arent cut out for it
Some make peace with having fewer children, others dont.
I think you just need to play it by ear and see how it goes, dont put pressure on yourself to decide right now

nervousseacreature · 03/09/2021 09:50

@Highflyingadored

I would love a 3rd and still trying to come to terms that it wont happen.

My head is being logical, extra expense, being tired, the noise, the general logistics and the strain on my body.

My heart... I want to carry another little person, I want the birth experience, the smell, the way they develop.... but it's what I want and not what we want.

What I want and what I should do for the good of my family are 2 different things.
. Doesnt mean it's not hard and DH doesnt understand that I need to grieve he thinks I should just get over it

I feel exactly the same. Have a 4yo ds and 3yo ds. Sensibly I know i should stick at two. They are 12m apart so we had a hectic few years. Husband definitely doesn’t want any more and after an emcs and an elcs I don’t know how my body would cope. Plus I’m 39.

BUT I’m just really sad I won’t experience the baby years again. I feel like I didn’t enjoy it properly as it was so hectic. With 1st ds I was pregnant for most of his 1st year. With 2nd ds I had a newborn and a 1yo.
It’s definitely heart vs head

Mamatotwinsplusone · 03/09/2021 09:44

*any other way and anyone. Had about 3 hours sleep last night!

Mamatotwinsplusone · 03/09/2021 09:42

I’ve had twins the second time, and honestly I adore them and wouldn’t have it anyway. They are perfect. I can’t understand for the life of me though why anyway would have 3!

Also imagine if you had a third pregnancy and it was twins!

Hadenoughcrap2 · 03/09/2021 09:40

In a lot of ways 2 is probably a more practical number, as it gave us more choice with cars, and there was always 1 parent for each child when swimming, on rides, etc.

Hadenoughcrap2 · 03/09/2021 09:38

I always wanted 4, dh 2, so we compromised on 3.
As soon as the 1st 2 came along he reneged on the 3rd, which I might not have minded, except I always wanted a boy (& a girl) and my 1st 2 were girls (as seems to run in my family).
I didn't get pregnant that easily...about a year trying for no.1 and 6-7 months for no.2.

I'm late 40s now and my dc are pretty much grown up. I still get really broody, but I realised once they were past the ages of 9/10 that I wouldn't practically be able to go back to nappies, etc, as it would probably be too much physically for me as I've had RA since my late 20s.

I still get broody though and I do regret not pushing for 3 when the oldest was around 6. I guess I was also worried about having yet another girl too, which I know sounds awful, but I always wanted one of each. If I could've guaranteed having a boy I would've definitely not let it go so easily.

GirlInterruptedOftenByKids · 03/09/2021 09:30

Also, I had fairly uneventful pregnancies and births but TTC was stressful and borderline traumatic both times. I don't think I can go through that again...and the PCOS that makes TTC hard also increase the risk of complications in pregnancy. It's just easier not to open myself up to All That again

GirlInterruptedOftenByKids · 03/09/2021 09:27

Yes, totally at peace with it. I always imagined having three but Child#2 turned out to be quite high needs and I've not had the emotional capacity to seriously consider any more since she was born.

I grew up in a family of 4 kids and I always thought only 2 kids would be a bit lonely. But we fit well into our house and our car and it's easy for each kid to have one-on-one time at the weekends because we can take a kid each. Also, been doing parenting for 12 years now and the youngest one is halfway to 18....I can't imagine adding another few years onto that stretch

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2021 08:31

Actually @zeddybrek there was a thread on here a few months ago where a lot of people said they regretted having their third child. I'm sorry for your sadness but it is pretty irresponsible to tell anyone to have a child on the basis that "you never regret a child". It's just not true.

ReallyNeedToPrioritiseMe · 03/09/2021 07:21

@gruffaloo
We felt that with three, one always seemed to be left out. Not always the same one - but it just didn’t feel right.
So we had 4 because then there might be two left out- but at least they’d have someone to be left out with! We did find they played in different pairs - the oldest and youngest are still close (7.5 year age gap)

My husband is one of two, and I’m one of six.
I feel with two children there’s too much parental attention- it’s can be too intense for them to grow as an individual. My husband and his sister still fight a lot more than my siblings and I did. That’s probably going to be controversial on this thread.

It might depend on your age gaps - whether you feel three works or not. Or personalities of children… who knows?

Overall - two would have been too quiet for me - and if you’re interested in how parents feel at the end of childhood, with two children they are suddenly both away at Uni and it’s all over too quick. I’m glad we have our youngest a few years longer (but he can be very grumpy).

However, two is a very sensible number and works in the modern world. Also these days there’s anxiety about environmental concerns - which wasn’t so apparent twenty odd years ago.

No idea if that helps - trying to be balanced.

jillandhersprite · 02/09/2021 20:34

Yes wanted more but not too sure of the right terminology to describe the feelings. Am completely happy with the decision we made to stick with 2 but that doesn't mean I'm completely comfortable with it either. It doesn't keep me awake at night or negatively impact my life but I'm able to be open about the fact that if things were different I would have had more...
I love a cuddle with my friends subsequent babies but I also have an internal sigh of relief that I don't have more at the same time!

zeddybrek · 02/09/2021 20:13

I always wanted 3 and have 2 now aged 7 and 5. It's one of my biggest regrets. I should have had another when my youngest was 2 but was back at work and got promoted and then life just happened and then it was too late for me. I have so much of my life back but deep down there is a void and it is the child I never had. I cannot discuss this with anyone in RL and I carry these feelings with great sadness in my heart. OP if you want 3 then go for it. Yes it'll be hard but having them close in age would be lovely and you don't regret having a child.

hollyivysaurus · 02/09/2021 20:07

I have two, and DH had a vasectomy as he was done at two (which we agreed we wanted before we even started TTC our first child). I would have liked a third, but now that my youngest is 3 and we’re out of the baby stage and getting to do more trips out and about, I’m glad we stuck at two. I think I’d have lost too much of myself if I had a third, I’m frazzled enough with my two! And I enjoy them getting a little more independent and us starting to be able to do more together without considering naps / feeding / nappies etc. Feels like we’ve moved to a new phase!

Ilovechocolatetoomuch · 02/09/2021 19:26

My oldest dc is suspected to have ASC he is very hard work. When they where small and easy I was desperate for another now they are older they fight and argue every single day.
On top of that food, holidays, days out etc put me off.

gruffaloo · 02/09/2021 19:11

@ReallyNeedToPrioritiseMe great to hear from someone who's been there, done that, and now has 4 adult children to tell the tale. Out of curiosity why did you feel 3 didn't work? Why was 4 better?

OP posts:
ElspethFlashman · 02/09/2021 09:47

If I had been younger I'd have gone for a 3rd. But I had kids very late and was lucky to get 2 in tbh.

But in fact that's what most of my friends did - they turned 38 and suddenly they got madly broody. I think it was a "time is running out" thing. So they all had a 3rd at 38/39.

Tbh they pretty much cured me. I still think we had enough love for a 3rd, but so did my friends and having a 3rd half killed them! They all have enormous cars and have to do self catering everywhere and there's a lot of bringing the mother in law along on holiday for childcare. And going on holiday with other families, again for more eyes on the kids.

My cousin told me that #3 spent the first year of his life in a car seat. She had to do drop offs and pick ups at 2 locations every day and then there was football practise afterwards and at the weekends.

She didn't breastfeed the 3rd because she literally didn't have the time (no big deal but just gives you an idea of how little time you have to sit down with the baby).

It has to be said that once your second child goes to school, life does become enormously more chill.

And I do really like that when you're on the sofa, you can have one under each armpit and nobody is left out. 🥰

OrangeTortoise · 02/09/2021 09:20

Not quite the same as you OP, but I have 3 and wanted 4, but stuck with 3 because DH didn't another. Now my youngest is 11 and I have definitely made my peace with it - in fact, I'm not sure what I was thinking! 3 is more than enough.

ReallyNeedToPrioritiseMe · 02/09/2021 07:25

Our third child was actually an accident - we had decided to stop at 2. Then we really felt three didn’t work - so we had another 🤣
It was really hard work, and financially I don’t recommend it, but it was wonderful to have 4.

But now they are nearly adults - one of my children has become psychiatrically seriously unwell- and I am so very glad that my other three have each other to turn to. Nobody understands this pain like immediate family.

I think - thinking longer term - you are not just having children for yourself - but for them. Two makes a lot of sense, but as adults if one child moves far away they become only children - which is also fine - but it’s just a thought.

I liked the chaos of a big family - but it’s not that compatible with the mum managing to keep working/ modern cars and hotels.

I’m aware this is a bit of a contradictory post - but it’s a long term decision - and probably not as simple as one might think.

Ricepops · 01/09/2021 23:05

We have a 7 and (almost) 4 year old and are currently deliberating over a third DC. I have only ever wanted 2, but recently started to have thoughts about a third. It probably is partly because my eldest is really growing up now and i keep going over memories of when he was little in my mind.

If money was no object, I think I would definitely go for a third. We are comfortably off, but a third mat leave/ nursery fees etc etc would have an impact. I'm late 30s now, so likely another baby would push back when we could pay off our mortgage and retire.

On the other hand, a family of four does seem small and possibly a bit boring. It's noisy and busy and fun now, but probably won't be when they are tweens/teens. I am one of four, and DH is one of 3. On the other hand, the age gap would mean the youngest would end up spending their teen years in a quiet house once the other had left for uni etc. I was in this position as the youngest child. I remember my primary school years being in a very busy, fun and exciting house, but a few years later it was just me and my mum.

EncroachingLoaf · 01/09/2021 22:44

I'm in a similar situation. I'm desperate for a third, DH was less enthusiastic but did agree and even get excited about the prospect after taking time to consider it.

Then I had an ectopic pregnancy which was devastating. DH has now changed his mind back again and says no. I am left mourning both the recent loss and the third child that could have been part of our future.

I am so angry and bitter and sad right now. I feel like I've had the choice taken away from me but the longing for a third is even stronger since my loss. I don't know how to get over it. I'm pretty sure it is going to destroy our marriage also at this point.

RAINSh0wers · 01/09/2021 22:43

I have a 7 and almost 4 year old. Straight after having my youngest I really wanted a third and the feeling lingered. DH is pretty against it, and I completely see his view-money, car, holidays etc. Now my 4 year old is starting hobbies and her own play dates etc I do see how we’d (personally) be stretched with a third.

On Friday we went to London for the day and stayed overnight with the children. And it was lovely. I think for me it may have been a turning point. The next day we were around babies and all I could think is what hard work they still have to come…!

waitingpatientlyforspring · 01/09/2021 22:35

I really wanted a third and was broody for years after my second. Due to money it was just never the right time. Its been more than 6 years since I stopped feeling that way and now I'm so happy we stuck at two and logistically I'm not sure how we would cope now with 3 dc.

Namechange1million · 01/09/2021 22:32

We decided we were done after 2 for practical reasons so my husband has the snip soon after our daughter was born. We had one of each and want a life that having more than 2 would be too expensive and difficult.

Recently I have been broody! Obviously my husband's snip has meant that a 3rd is a no go. And i think I'm broody due to hormones. When I contemplate a 3rd and the reasons why I want a third, the reality is not worth the 3rd. I want a third because I miss having a baby and seeing a baby grow and I reminisce about my 2 being babies and miss it. But thinking of the reality, that part is lovely, but exhausting and the sleepless nights again! I spend most of the baby stage half asleep and couldn't wait for it to be over! Then there is the childcare costs. We were lucky with first two as my parents could babysit for 2/3 days a week over the years. Now they are too old so it wouldn't be fair to get them to babysit. So that's fulltime childcare costs to pay for many years. My two are both now sleeping well and are starting to become more independent. My 3 year old is a few years off being fully independent, but already I long for more free time and child free time! So a third would set that right back! So don't really want to give up the freedom I have started to gain! Holidays are important to us and we chose to only have two as we want nice holidays. With 3 kids this would be very expensive and would push the likelihood of holidays back a few years until 3rd is 3 and gets free nursery hour. So those are the reasons I have accepted a 3rd isn't going to happen. And I did go through a stage where I was thinking about my husband getting a snip reversal! But that's crazy hormones talking 🤣

Blessex · 01/09/2021 22:30

Porcupineintherough

@Blessex wait perimenopause hits. I am far less patient and far more grumpy and generally less maternal. Thankfully my youngest turned teen just as this happened so I'm less in demand anyway but I shudder to think how it would have worked if I'd had a younger child.

Ha you are my head. Love this x

Swipe left for the next trending thread