Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you wanted 3 but stuck with 2 did you make peace with it?

107 replies

gruffaloo · 01/09/2021 17:37

Not really sure where to post this but decided to do it here for traffic.

We're deliberating the prospect of a third. I've gone back and read as many of the "should we have a third?" threads.

What I'd love to know is if you were keen on a third child but for whatever reason didn't go ahead with it, did you make peace with that decision?

I'd like a third but it's not an easy child to justify. There are lots of rational reasons for two but I feel I may regret not having three? But perhaps this is something I can over come? Something that is just short-lived?

I have a 3 year old, and a 1 year old.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OrangeTortoise · 06/09/2021 19:43

Fair point OP - a fair chunk of that increase was due to immigration. However, births still outnumbered deaths in the UK in 2020 by over 100,000.

FireworkParrot · 06/09/2021 18:41

I wanted three because although I knew it would be tough in the early years, I loved the thought of having three adult DC and big family get togethers etc. DH was dead against it though for all of the usual financial/practical/environmental reasons. Also, DH was one of three children and said one was constantly left out. I kept being incredibly broody though and was often in tears in DD2s first few months as I didn't want to force DH into having another so knew she'd be my last baby. However..... she's now approaching 3 and DD1 is starting school and I'm rapidly realising that I'm going to get some time back, life is becoming easier and childcare costs are going to be decreasing. For the past year and a half we've paid £1k a month in childcare and the end of nursery fees on the horizon means that we're going to have more money for savings and for doing things as a family. I think I liked the idea of having a third but wouldn't have enjoyed the reality.

Confusedandshaken · 06/09/2021 18:21

I did eventually but it took nearly 20 years. I only really got over it after the menopause.

Once we had made the decision not to try for a third DH had a vasectomy so I could come off the pill. It was only after that I realised how desperately I had wanted the third baby but it was too late then. It destroyed our sex life because I would break down and cry every time we had sex. The thought that no baby could come of it broke my heart every time.

NecklessMumster · 06/09/2021 18:18

My friend wanted a third so went ahead and got pregnant but ended up with twins, so now has 4 and is pretty stressed.

Dbank · 06/09/2021 18:06

Is that increase based on births or immigration?

According to the office of National Statistics the majority of the increase was caused by immigration.

sofakingcool · 06/09/2021 17:33

Took a long time Sad

We always planned to have 3, DS1 is mine from a previous relationship. There's already a 5 year age gap between the 2 DS's and he tried for a third when they were 2 and 7 but sadly I MMC twice in quite quick succession. We considered to try again a few months later, but a combination of DH not wanting me to go through a MMC again and there being a 9 year age gap once baby was born, it was decided that we wouldn't.

We've just had the 10 year anniversary of the first MC and I still can't get my head around the fact we won't have anymore Sad

For me, it was because I didn't say goodbye to having a baby, we always assumed we'd have the third, so when DS2 was born there was no "ah this is the last one, saviour it etc ", so I don't think I ever got closure.

gruffaloo · 06/09/2021 17:24

[quote OrangeTortoise]**@gruffaloo* if people on the whole are choosing to have fewer children or increasingly choosing to be child-free does does that off-set my decision to have third?*

The UK population increased by approx 360,000 people last year, so I guess the answer to that is no.[/quote]
Is that increase based on births or immigration?

OP posts:
OrangeTortoise · 06/09/2021 17:10

@gruffaloo if people on the whole are choosing to have fewer children or increasingly choosing to be child-free does does that off-set my decision to have third?

The UK population increased by approx 360,000 people last year, so I guess the answer to that is no.

gruffaloo · 05/09/2021 19:50

@Dbank thanks!

OP posts:
Dbank · 04/09/2021 10:36

@gruffaloo

If two people have three children, who do the same for the three generations, we will have 108 people possibly in less than 100 years. Even if their consumption halved it would be irrelevant.

@Dbank but there is no guarantee that a couple's three children will go on to have three children each. For example, I have 2 kids but my brother and wife have no kids (by choice).

There is sadly too a rise in infertility which takes the choice away from people completely, or they have fewer children than planned.

I agree I don't expect everyone to have three children, some will have more and some will have less or none, but the trend is growth and it's exponential.
gruffaloo · 04/09/2021 08:10

If two people have three children, who do the same for the three generations, we will have 108 people possibly in less than 100 years. Even if their consumption halved it would be irrelevant.

@Dbank but there is no guarantee that a couple's three children will go on to have three children each. For example, I have 2 kids but my brother and wife have no kids (by choice).

There is sadly too a rise in infertility which takes the choice away from people completely, or they have fewer children than planned.

OP posts:
eleanoreleanoreleanor · 03/09/2021 22:23

I always wanted 3. Very strongly, I was convinced we would have 3, DH wanted 2 but more than likely would have had 3 if I'd asked.

Had 2DC. They both had a 50:50 chance of inheriting a debilitating and potentially life limiting genetic condition. We had them genetically tested and while waiting for the results I made a deal with god (I am not a practising religious person so I'm not quite sure where the deal came from) that if both didn't inherit the genetic condition then I would be happy with 2. We got incredibly lucky and they both did not inherit the condition and now I am happy with my 2 healthy DC. To roll the dice a third time would be pushing it I feel

Dbank · 03/09/2021 22:13

[quote gruffaloo]**@Row1n* and @Dbank* I get what you mean.

I googled "does having children ruin the planet?" not very scientific I know, but they point to consumption rather than population, being the issue, though of course population is a huge part of that. And that in time we'll reduce our carbon footprint and that people with children are incentivised to make the changes necessary to protect the planet - including those in government and business.

I found this an interesting listen: Is it OK to have a child? www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v42/n05/meehan-crist/is-it-ok-to-have-a-child

[/quote]
While "per-person" consumption might go down, exponential growth of population, is the problem.

If two people have three children, who do the same for the three generations, we will have 108 people possibly in less than 100 years. Even if their consumption halved it would be irrelevant.

We have to stop thinking about just the current impact of our actions, and realise large families have a long term effect.

nervousseacreature · 03/09/2021 21:53

[quote OrangeTortoise]**@nervousseacreature* I’m just really sad I won’t experience the baby years again. I feel like I didn’t enjoy it properly as it was so hectic. With 1st ds I was pregnant for most of his 1st year. With 2nd ds I had a newborn and a 1yo*

Honestly, though, don't you think that (say you got pregnant now) newborn, a 4yo and a 5yo would be nearly as hectic in a different way? Eg having to get the baby up and fed in time to do the school run, and take your older two to activities and parties with a newborn in tow? To me that sounds just as hard as having a baby and being pregnant![/quote]
Yes you’re probably right! It hadn’t really occurred to me in that way… i was thinking of the lovely newborn cuddles, even with my second we didn’t have to go anywhere on a schedule (except ds1 went to nursery once a week!)

CosmicComfort · 03/09/2021 20:47

I only wanted a third when I was told I had cancer and my womb had to be removed🤷‍♀️ Ds2 was only 15 months when I had the surgery and I did really want to be able to have a 3rd for a few years.

I made my peace and now I am very happy with my 2 wonderful dses. One is off to university this year and the other next so I moved on a very long time ago and I am very content.

gruffaloo · 03/09/2021 20:20

@ReallyNeedToPrioritiseMe thanks for explaining.

I am the same - two does feel too quiet to me too!

We are very organised, and I found going from 1-2 a breeze, and feel like we have capacity - love, space, finance, for another. They would (hopefully) be close in age 4, 2 and newborn if we started trying soon.

OP posts:
gruffaloo · 03/09/2021 20:13

@Row1n and @Dbank I get what you mean.

I googled "does having children ruin the planet?" not very scientific I know, but they point to consumption rather than population, being the issue, though of course population is a huge part of that. And that in time we'll reduce our carbon footprint and that people with children are incentivised to make the changes necessary to protect the planet - including those in government and business.

I found this an interesting listen: Is it OK to have a child? www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v42/n05/meehan-crist/is-it-ok-to-have-a-child

OP posts:
Dbank · 03/09/2021 19:17

Even discussing population control in the UK would guarantee you won't get elected.

If anything we are incentivising population growth with maternity, and child care tax benefits etc.

Row1n · 03/09/2021 18:46

Because if everyone sat around waiting for someone else to do their part or for governments and companies to suddenly step up, it would never happen! They're money lead, and unless people make a stand and force them to do better, they will continue to eat up the earth's resources so long as they can line their pockets - very Dr Seuss' The Lorax, but it's accurate!

gruffaloo · 03/09/2021 17:33

@Dbank the environmental impact is something that has come up in other threads too. And something that is on my conscience.

I guess the thing with that is if people on the whole are choosing to have fewer children or increasingly choosing to be child-free does does that off-set my decision to have third?

Also, if having children is so damaging shouldn't there be some incentives to not have them or have one or max two, or at the more extreme end have something like China's one child policy applied to everyone? Why do I have to self-regulate myself, when others may not? Just posing the question, not saying self regulating is wrong.

OP posts:
RandomDent · 03/09/2021 11:40

I toyed with the idea of a third, but once we were all sick at the same time. I realised that it would be much worse to deal with five of us being ill!
Also we’d have to move house, couldn’t be bothered with that. 😂

OrangeTortoise · 03/09/2021 11:33

@nervousseacreature I’m just really sad I won’t experience the baby years again. I feel like I didn’t enjoy it properly as it was so hectic. With 1st ds I was pregnant for most of his 1st year. With 2nd ds I had a newborn and a 1yo

Honestly, though, don't you think that (say you got pregnant now) newborn, a 4yo and a 5yo would be nearly as hectic in a different way? Eg having to get the baby up and fed in time to do the school run, and take your older two to activities and parties with a newborn in tow? To me that sounds just as hard as having a baby and being pregnant!

Twounderfive83 · 03/09/2021 10:33

So many of the posts on this thread put into words exactly how I feel about it.

My DC are still little (5 and 2) and I'm young enough to wait a couple of years to have another. When DC2 was a little baby I really wanted a third, then again when they turned 1. But now, no.

DC2 is hard work, and actually so is DC1, in a different way - basically I think parenting is just hard work! As they get older, they might play together more, but it inevitably means they fight more, so there is a lot of refereeing.

I would love to go back and re-live a few days of both DC's babyhood, especially DC1 as they were the easiest, loveliest baby, but I didn't appreciate it because I was so shell-shocked at the change to my life. But otherwise I don't miss the baby stage, as a PP has said, when I see friends and family with their babies, even ones who are over 12 months, I just remember how boring and hard work it can be.

Dbank · 03/09/2021 10:20

Long term exponential population growth is really the problem that the planet faces.

Each time two people leave more than two people behind they add to the longterm problem, so there really should be some credit for only having two.

The world won't implode one afternoon, the quality of life will degrade very slowly over multiple generations, until population growth stabilises... it won't be pretty.

Population control is generally considered abhorrent, but ironically China's one child policy has had a greater ecological effect that anything we're currently considering.

The urge to leave a legacy of our DNA outweighs our ability to consider the impact on the future.

Gingersay · 03/09/2021 10:08

I always wanted 3 but I have two dd with two years between them who are so close I didn't want to ruin that dynamic so we are very content with 2. My sister and cousin both had surprise babies at 40 so DH had a vasectomy the week before my 40th as we couldn't imagine going back to nappies and night feeds.

Swipe left for the next trending thread