Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be pleased with the Ofcam ruling on Piers Morgan

621 replies

TeloMere · 01/09/2021 12:51

Even though I can't stand the bloke?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/09/2021 17:16

Whatever the OFCOM ruling, ITV are still at liberty to decide whose views are welcome (or not) on their own programme.

Worked the other way with Jenni Murray and Jane Garvey. Their views were not being accommodated on R4's 'Women's Hour': they were unable even to articulate them, so they both left.

This works the other way too.

In relation to the point made above, there is no such legal position as a 'common law' or 'de facto' marriage in the UK. Of course anyone can make vows such as handfasting ceremonies with personal meaning to them, but in England, any ceremony outside the CofE is not legal unless it's accompanied by the standard civil ceremony and conducted by a registrar. Even Catholic ceremonies have to accommodate this.

H&M might well have 'exchanged their own vows' ahead of their official ceremony. Personally, I don't see why anyone cares.

PwySyddYma · 01/09/2021 17:15

Why is everyone so hung up on this "marriage" thing. Does it really matter in the grand scheme of things?

I personally can't decide which one is the dimmer lightbulb, her for thinking she got married in a back garden or him for not explaining to her that's not how it works.

I can't say that their dimness has an effect on my life

Theluggage15 · 01/09/2021 17:15

Bloody hell. What’s all this about culture crap? So apparently she thought she was married after a bit of waffle in a garden and no one including her ‘husband’ put her right?! Ok then.

cardibach · 01/09/2021 17:15

What on Earth do you think she needed from him @JudgeJ? She was the star if a multi million dollar show and wealthy in her own right as a result. He is an objectionable grifter who hacked a dead child’s phone for financial benefit. If we are considering who has lied and cheated the most, I submit it isn’t MM.

Quaggars · 01/09/2021 17:14

@StoneofDestiny

The irony. Morgan gets to pass his opinion - no problem with that. When Alex Beresford, the weatherman passed his opinion to Morgan, Morgan stomps off in a hissy fit. You couldn't make it up.
@StoneofDestiny This. I watched him storm off and honestly thought he was joking - after all the times he dishes out his opinions on others, the minute someone says something to him he doesn't like, he storms off? Then I realised he was serious. Utter, utter man baby. I hope he doesn't go back onto GMB, you can actually get to hear other opinions now as well as just hear his voice.
stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:14

Yes marriage needs to be legal if it is to stand for anything.

You can pretend you are married, walk around calling yourself Mrs Freddy, say all the blessed vows in the world but in a court of law in this land it will count for absolutely nothing. Diddly squat.

SlipperyDippery · 01/09/2021 17:14

No, that is YOUR idea of marriage. Marriage is a UNION of two people. The legal paperwork is separate from that

It’s not about my idea of marriage, or yours. Words have meanings. Those meanings are contained in the dictionary. The dictionary definition of a marriage includes it being formally recognised - go and check.

We do not (yet) live in a post truth era where words mean whatever people want them to.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:13

Poor Freddy sucked in good and proper.

FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:12

@stepupandbecounted

Nope you can not, you are either married and legally so, or you are not. It genuinely is as black and white as that.
Wrong, and a very insular and ignorant view. Marriage does not have to be legal.
stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:12

Nope you can not, you are either married and legally so, or you are not. It genuinely is as black and white as that.

FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:11

@SlipperyDippery

You're all stuck on the 'legal' part. You can have a marriage and it not be legal. It's still a marriage. Just not legal. Why are people having such difficulty understanding this?

No, the entire point of a marriage is that it is formal entity with legal standing.

No, that is YOUR idea of marriage. Marriage is a UNION of two people. The legal paperwork is separate from that.
FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:10

@stepupandbecounted

You can't have an illegal marriage and be married. I am worried you can't seem to follow the basics of law. You are either married or unmarried. You can say as many vows as you please, but it doesn't mean you are 'married' in any meaningful or legal sense.
I'm sorry but that is simply ignorant. You CAN. You can exchange vows and consider yourselves married to each other. You may not be married in the eyes of the government, but you have exchanged vows and are married. It's what Common Law Marriage is all about. Or DeFacto relationship. This black and white thinking of the UK is scary and quite worrying.
SlipperyDippery · 01/09/2021 17:10

In her culture she would refer to a vow exchange ceremony as a marriage

What culture do you mean by her culture?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/09/2021 17:09

The ruling is correct. The Windsors already have far too much control over how their image is represented in the media - much as their PR claims things are otherwise - and this needs to be challenged, not reinforced.

A free press is absolutely essential to any society with pretensions to democracy. A monarchy isn't.

In view of that, YANBU. This view has nothing at all to do with my opinion of the aggressive, whining, bellicose, self-pitying Morgan, however. Regardless of the outcome, he's still a weapons-grade bellend.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:09

I could say the sky is bright pink and world is square it doesn't make it true does it! I mean for heavens sake, it is not hard to stick to the facts and not make yourself look like an idiot. Of course if you are going to lie openly like that, people will question your integrity and doubt everything that comes out of your mouth. Stands to reason!

SlipperyDippery · 01/09/2021 17:09

You're all stuck on the 'legal' part. You can have a marriage and it not be legal. It's still a marriage. Just not legal. Why are people having such difficulty understanding this?

No, the entire point of a marriage is that it is formal entity with legal standing.

FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:09

@SlipperyDippery

Sorry freddykruger but I’m not buying it. I don’t know where you are, but I am Middle Eastern and I am aware of differing wedding cultures around the world. She is an American who married in the UK.

In America, where the legal wedding and the wedding celebration are separate, it’s usually that a small legal ceremony happens in advance and then a big wedding party with no legal standing happens (the US wedding forums call it a pretty princess day) thereafter. There is no US culture of being alone in a garden and saying vows with no legal standing at all being the “wedding” rather than the legally binding ceremony with a fuck load of guests a few days later.

It’s just mental gymnastics because you want to be on her side.

No it's not mental gymnastics at all. Often you have the vow exchange ceremony before hand, then the legal one after. In her culture she would refer to a vow exchange ceremony as a marriage.
IntermittentParps · 01/09/2021 17:08

Piers Morgan stomped off his own show and was a knob head. Not illegal, but a knob head in his job and now we are expected to say “oh it’s fine, it isn’t illegal”.
Well, we're not expected to say 'it’s fine'. We can continue, as many on here are and on Twitter and so forth, to say he's a knob. And his erstwhile employers can continue not to employ him.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:06

You can't have an illegal marriage and be married. I am worried you can't seem to follow the basics of law. You are either married or unmarried. You can say as many vows as you please, but it doesn't mean you are 'married' in any meaningful or legal sense.

SlipperyDippery · 01/09/2021 17:06

Sorry freddykruger but I’m not buying it. I don’t know where you are, but I am Middle Eastern and I am aware of differing wedding cultures around the world. She is an American who married in the UK.

In America, where the legal wedding and the wedding celebration are separate, it’s usually that a small legal ceremony happens in advance and then a big wedding party with no legal standing happens (the US wedding forums call it a pretty princess day) thereafter. There is no US culture of being alone in a garden and saying vows with no legal standing at all being the “wedding” rather than the legally binding ceremony with a fuck load of guests a few days later.

It’s just mental gymnastics because you want to be on her side.

FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:05

@stepupandbecounted

It is called a rehearsal freddy
No, a rehearsal and a private ceremony are two entirely different things.
znaika · 01/09/2021 17:04

The UK is not "really weird" about marriage. The UK tax payers funded her multi-million pound wedding. She got caught in a lie.

He is a dick no question, but giving the rich and powerful a free pass to say whatever they like in the public sphere just because you like them helps no-one.

Fairyliz · 01/09/2021 17:04

@PostingForTheFirstTime

To all of you repeating that
     it is not the government

The government is not the only institution we have to worry about in this respect, as Maya Forstater (and Julie Bindell and many another feminist threatened by not-the-government) can tell you.

This man was required by his line manager to apologise for saying he believed Meghan Markle to be a liar. He refused, and was required to resign or be fired.

Like Maya Forstater, he lost his job for stating a belief (that turned out to be the truth).

But because it wasn't the government (in either case) doing this we shouldn't be worried or mention freedom of speech concerns?

@PostingForTheFirstTime

This also applies to a lot of our universities.

Voice an 'unpopular' opinion and you will be managed out. There seems to be 'correct' views to hold and if you disagree your career will be up the spout irrespective of whether or not your view impacts your job.

FreddyKreugersWife · 01/09/2021 17:04

@stepupandbecounted

If you are going to bother to get married in a country that is not your own then at least have the good sense and intelligence to understand what you are doing. I can't believe she would be that stupid that she did not know when she was legally getting married, can anyone possibly be that stupid?

She got married once, and that was in front of millions, as she wanted it to be. The wedding was everything she wanted.

I can't believe she would be that stupid that she did not know when she was legally getting married

You're still not getting it. She knew when she was legally getting married. That doesn't mean that she can't describe the vow ceremony as a marriage, too.

stepupandbecounted · 01/09/2021 17:04

It is called a rehearsal freddy