Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling so upset that my toddler is like this - I need help!

66 replies

Halloumiandtomatosalad · 01/09/2021 11:45

My 2 year old (3 in October) has started pushing and shoving other children when we’re out.
He did it to one of his little friends yesterday, we met up for a play date. This poor little girl was terrified of him and kept asking her mum to pick her up because my DS was throwing things at her and pushing her.
Today at soft play he pushed a smaller child over , before I could get in and intervene, he ran off.
He did it to another child just before we were due to go home, so we took him home early, even though we’d said he could have one more go on the slide, but I’m not sure if these sort of things work. I guess it’s an old school ‘punishment’ we’re going home if you do it again type thing.

Every time he does it, we tell him no and explain we use kind hands. He just laughs and says “I want to push”.

He’s a very clever, affectionate and loving boy. So it’s making me feel rather sad.

He does go to nursery twice a week and they haven’t mentioned anything there about him pushing or being physical with other children…

Any ideas or advice greatly received as I’m starting to feel incredibly anxious about going out with him by myself.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 01/09/2021 13:48

And making him apologise. Every time. If he refuses, you give once more chance woth the consequence that if he dossnt then you will leave. Choice.

MsTSwift · 01/09/2021 13:46

No one sensible thinks badly of small kids doing this but they don’t like it if the parent doesn’t deal with it firmly there and then. Whimpering “Archie please be kind” doesn’t cut it,

RealBecca · 01/09/2021 13:46

Watch closely. Intervene immediately.

Down to his level. "That is not acceptable behaviour. How do you think that child feels. Do not do that again or we are leaving." Then drag out if necessary. None of this running off business. "Come here now or X toy (that is out with you) will be taken away as well." Then remove said toy. No need to shout. Simply set out action/decision and consequence.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 01/09/2021 13:45

This too will pass. DD2 went through a biting phase. I can tell you that she is 12 year old now and definitely doesn't bite her peers Grin

As well as telling him off, praise him highly and reward him when he is nice and doesn't push someone, so it doesn't mean that the naughty behaviour gets more attention than good behaviour.

If he's two and a half a sticker chart might even help. Five smiley faces get a star and a treat, that kind of thing.

Ladypuggerz · 01/09/2021 13:41

Or "wants" to push, even Smile

Ladypuggerz · 01/09/2021 13:40

Definitely set boundaries on the behaviour you expect from him and start to teach empathy like some others have said above.

I like how he communicated with you that he "likes to push" though. Can you offer him opportunities to push safely and appropriately e.g. a toy or friend on a swing, pushing over a large inflatable toy / punch bag, racing with toys he can push (e.g with wheels), to feed the impulse a little?

Aug12 · 01/09/2021 13:33

I just wanted to pop on and let you know you are not alone! My little boy turned 3 in May and does the exact same.. it started when he was about 2 and a half and we are still struggling with it. I use star charts and always have stickers With me in for when do when there are moments when he is playing nicely and gently I can reward it. when we go out, he is told before we leave, you must play nicely and be kind or you will have to leave. If he pushes he gets a stern no that’s hurtful and if he does it a second time we leave and go straight home.. it’s not really working tbh, I’m hoping it is just a phase but it feels like it’s a really long one. We’ve lost little friends over the months as parents don’t want to their child being pushed/shoved which I completely understand.

ReggaetonLente · 01/09/2021 13:25

In a firm voice "I can't let you push other children. If you do it again, we'll have to go home, because I need to keep everybody safe".

And mean it, and do it.

DD has a little mate who hits, pushes and bites and his mum does fuck all about it, just whines his name and apologises weakly. At the last playdate he held a one year old underwater in a paddling pool - we won't be seeing them again. Kids are kids, they all go through phases and some are trickier than others, but fuck. That.

MeredithGreyishblue · 01/09/2021 13:17

Agree with PPs, you need to helicopter. It's not fair to other kids not to.

Its nothing to do with him being clever or loving - he's just little!

And you need to stop it every time and action a consequence every time. You push, we leave. And leave. No pandering to tears or sorry.

Explain the rules when you arrive and repeat them.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/09/2021 13:12

You need to remove him from the situation immediately so he sees the result of his actions. Straight in the buggy for 2 minutes until he stops. If you haven't got the buggy with you then find a quiet area away from the other children. Leaving early won't have the same impact.

I imagine he's doing it for attention. It's a good way to get everyone noticing Wink

Dmacka75 · 01/09/2021 13:07

@Taoneusa
That sounds awful. Surely a 2 year old wont understand why his mum is pushing him

Maray1967 · 01/09/2021 13:07

As PP said, there seemed to be a lot of it before you dealt with it. Where are you when he is doing this? If you have a child like this you need to be a helicopter parent- no sitting down on the bench, but be there right by him and deal with the very first instance. Remove him straightaway and leave him in no doubt that if there is a repeat he will be leaving. I have grabbed mine and hauled him off the steps to the slide when he did this, no messing about, he was straight off there and strapped in the pushchair and off home.

Taoneusa · 01/09/2021 12:59

This is the beginning of teaching empathy. So when you are at home, playing on the sofa, or somewhere soft and comfortable, you push him in a way he won’t like, that disrupts his flow, disrupts the moment.

Then when he’s upset , you explain why we don’t “want to push’ others, once we realise we are creating upset. Pushing creates upset, and we don’t like being upset.

You can ask him “do you like to be pushed?” In a non punitive voice.
It’s the beginning of ‘do unto others as you would have them do unto you”..it’s a vital building block for social and emotional intelligence.

NerrSnerr · 01/09/2021 12:59

It is normal and many children go through this phase. As PP have said you need to be with them if they're going through this phase- my eldest was often on the receiving end which I didn't mind if the parent was on it and it didn't happen again but I wouldn't have been happy if she was in the scenario you describe where she was scared which suggests it happened repeatedly.

PepsiHoover · 01/09/2021 12:58

Daft question, does he know pushing is hurting another child? So many parents say don't hit, don't hurt etc. But the kids might not realise pushing is hurting.

I agree you need to helicopter over him if you know he will do it, especially if he runs off afterwards. You need to intervene before he does it to stop it instead of punishing afterwards .

CustardyCreams · 01/09/2021 12:52

It’s a phase, but you can help it to end early and not return by explaining clearly the behaviour is not nice, and it hurts the other child and makes them sad so then the other children won’t like playing with him. Remove him from the situation and if needed give a consequence, going home early is absolutely perfect in my opinion.

Be careful about over using the naughty step, my DS has started asking from chocolate and when I say no, he yells, ‘bad mummy, mummy naughty, go on naughty step’ - quite embarrassing in the middle of the supermarket!

Calmdown14 · 01/09/2021 12:49

At that age punishment needs to be clear and immediate. Going home early won't really register by time you have got shoes, got in car, his little mind is away elsewhere!
Take him to a quiet corner, sit him down, and tell him firmly and at his level why you have put him there.
Make him wait there a minute or two and then allow him back.
Or remove him from the area he is enjoying and explain he cannot play there because he has hit x.
Intervention needs to happen straight away for him to link the two

ThePlantsitter · 01/09/2021 12:43

Yes it's completely normal and you don't need to feel upset - he's not like this forever it's just something he's doing.

You do need to tell him off though. Firmly. I never liked formal behaviour schemes for mine but in your case I would get down to his level and say 'do not hit/push other people' very firmly and take him away from the situation, maybe to sit on your knee for a minute or two. Leaving playgroup wasn't a punishment it was a consequence of his not being able to be in a social situation.

You can definitely do 'gentle parenting' and be firm about what they shouldn't do, it's not exactly kind to let someone grow up being a twat. A firm voice doesn't hurt them in an otherwise soft relationship, is all part of it.

nameisnotimportant · 01/09/2021 12:40

I completely agree with @Xmassprout
You can be gentle but very firm with him. At this age they are testing the boundaries to see what they can get away with, so you need to intervene straight away. Block his hands and move him away in a calm manner. Get down to his level and explain firmly in a strong low voice, hands are not for hitting.
I then used to sit down and hold my daughter on my knee for a couple of minutes and say she can't play if she hits. I would then say if you hit/push/bite again then no more playing and we go home. I would then stick to it. Don't threaten anything you don't intend to follow through with.
Remember it is just a phase, it feels embarrassing and like your doing something wrong or your the worst mother in the world when your child starts hitting but lots of children go through this phase and if you are firm and very consistent they soon learn not to do it and the phase passes.
I Hope it doesn't last too long for you. My daughter was rough for about 8 long months but now plays beautifully and it so polite and kind to other children.

BluebellsGreenbells · 01/09/2021 12:38

Strong words before you go anywhere and consequences

You can also offer a reward - if you play nicely today we will go hime and have ice cream or feed to ducks oetc

MeadowHay · 01/09/2021 12:37

@Didiusfalco

My son went through a stage of hurling things at other toddlers and it was mortifying if they got hurt. The key is that unfortunately if you have that sort of child you don’t get to sit and chill whilst they play, you have to helicopter. Also be clued into when they are getting tired or hungry and more likely to act like that and be ready to leave. Never did anything like naughty step, I don’t like it. Mine is in secondary now, and he’s brilliant, so don’t worry, this will pass.
I agree with this as someone whose toddler has always been at the recieving end of this type of behaviour. I feel the onus should be on the parent of the child who is known to hit/push/etc to helicopter parent them and ensure they can't do that rather than on parent of the child who does not do that having to follow around my child everywhere and be the barrier myself to make sure that other kids can't do it to her.
BigSandyBalls2015 · 01/09/2021 12:36

def a phase. One of mine went through this, would scower the room looking for the most vulnerable wobbly 'just started walking' tot and shove them over. I was convinced she was going to turn into some sort of psycho but she soon grew out of it.

As others have said, you need to stick right by him and intervene before he gets a chance to do it.

Anordinarymum · 01/09/2021 12:33

@Didiusfalco

My son went through a stage of hurling things at other toddlers and it was mortifying if they got hurt. The key is that unfortunately if you have that sort of child you don’t get to sit and chill whilst they play, you have to helicopter. Also be clued into when they are getting tired or hungry and more likely to act like that and be ready to leave. Never did anything like naughty step, I don’t like it. Mine is in secondary now, and he’s brilliant, so don’t worry, this will pass.
My grandson thinks the naughty step is a game
Didiusfalco · 01/09/2021 12:31

My son went through a stage of hurling things at other toddlers and it was mortifying if they got hurt. The key is that unfortunately if you have that sort of child you don’t get to sit and chill whilst they play, you have to helicopter. Also be clued into when they are getting tired or hungry and more likely to act like that and be ready to leave.
Never did anything like naughty step, I don’t like it.
Mine is in secondary now, and he’s brilliant, so don’t worry, this will pass.

Anordinarymum · 01/09/2021 12:26

Yes as the poster above says one warning only if he is prone to doing this, and then one action so he knows there is a pattern.
Next week he'll be doing something else, probably far worse.
Toddlers are great aren't they !